tk-421Original postDagobah · Mar 23, 2014#1I've been wondering about this question for a long time. The lack of admin engagement leads me to believe that they have no incentive to keep this site running indefinitely, especially since the vendor payment system -- basically the only known way to send money to the admins -- has been broken for a long time.
Lack of admin engagement has brought a lot of drawbacks to YW. For example:
- we have no idea how frequently backups are being performed on our data
- we have no access to those backups anyway, so if admins close shop we will likely still lose everything
- mods have almost no admin privileges, and can't be of much help when there are software or user account issues
- forum software hasn't been upgraded in a while and it's showing its age
- there is no mobile version of the forums and they are barely usable at their current state
- ever-growing amounts of spam and limited ways to deal with it are a big concern
Considering that many members here have invested a long time and effort to bring great content to YW, it would be a big loss for all of us if said content were suddenly lost for some reason or another. We have already gone through a big attack a few years ago in which the admins were caught unprepared and a big chunk of data was lost as a result.
My proposal
With that in mind, I propose a clean break from the current platform in which:
- admins are active members of the community
- said admins have complete access to our community-generated data and have the tools to maintain it
- there are democratically-elected trusted members with special privileges
- there are premium features for paid members and sponsors
- current data is not lost
- made from the ground up to work on mobile and desktop environments
Of course, all of this would have to come at a price. There are costs associated with hosting a high-traffic site, as well as installation and maintenance. Having said that, the costs to do this have actually gone down considerably since YW opened its doors in '06.
I would therefore like to gauge interest with YW members to see if this is a service that you guys would consider supporting. I am completely open to suggestions and feature requests, so please feel free to post them here.
The nerdy stuff
I would really like to give
Discourse a try. It's a community platform that is built around threads instead of forums. Threads can then be tagged and searched just like in gmail, making everything much clearer and efficient to use.
Hosting and backups are of course both extremely important issues. I have dealt with both of these professionally for years and would personally recommend a distributed virtualized solution such as
DigitalOcean which provides redundancy on many servers transparently. This takes care of server load issues and should guarantee smooth sailing all year long. The best part of this is, if we don't like the service, we can export our virtual server and move it someplace else very quickly.
For more information on the forum platform and their philosophy be sure to read
http://www.discourse.org/about/ and try out a live demo here:
http://try.discourse.org/ New features
A new home should also bring in new community features and guidelines. A few ideas:
- A way for trusted members to gain notoriety in the community
- A way for trusted members to democratically elect new moderators
- Donation and/or premium options in which members can show their support for the community and receive nice swag in return
- A way to channel donations to admins and moderators
- an official store with special rates for premium and trusted members
Feedback
I'm really curious as to what you guys think about this, so please post your thoughts and contribute as many details as you can. I think we can come up with a pretty great platform if we put our heads together…
Thanks for reading and much 🙌.
Replies 75
AstromanWenatchee, WA · Mar 23, 2014#2Hey I'm down as I'll have a yaris for many many years to come and love the community. I know ctscott looked into buying the yw domain bit the admins wanted way to much. Anyway just wanted to pipe in I'll do whatever I can to help keep the community alive.
tk-421Thread starterDagobah · Mar 23, 2014#3Thanks, Astro! 👍
Hopefully enough members are interested. There's lots of things that we could do to improve our situation and it wouldn't take much to get started.
CrankyOldManWest Michigan · Mar 23, 2014#4Weird--I clicked on "vote now" and went to a thread about someone's sedan...
CTScottUSA, CT · Mar 23, 2014#5 Originally Posted by
CrankyOldMan ↑ Weird--I clicked on "vote now" and went to a thread about someone's sedan...
^ Same thing happened to me.
I did contact the owners last year and actually never got a definite price from them. I recently tried to contact them again, and received no response.
tk-421Thread starterDagobah · Mar 23, 2014#6Weird… Looks like the votes are going through, though.
This bug also kind of drives my point home regarding my concerns with the software.
ExiwolfmanWasaga beach · Mar 23, 2014#7Im in,.... out with the old in with the new...also mobile would be awesome too and maybe i wont have to re size all my pics lol when posting. I work on Toyotas gone be with my 07 Yaris for some time then i would love the new shape 2012 up so ill be here.
I m all for little donation , free and payed members etc..so definitely count me in :)
cali yarisCanoga Park, CA · Mar 23, 2014#8 current data is not lost
How is that accomplished?
tk-421Thread starterDagobah · Mar 24, 2014#9without going into much detail, I can write a script that can clone any particular thread or export its information in a way that can be imported somewhere else (all I need is a template and a list of desired links). 🙂
tk-421Thread starterDagobah · Mar 24, 2014#10 Originally Posted by
Exiwolfman ↑ maybe i wont have to re size all my pics lol when posting.
I can fix images for you (among other things) if you have stylish installed:
http://userstyles.org/styles/78697/tk-421-s-tweaks Im all for little donation , free and payed members etc..so definitely count me in :)
🎉
bronsinnj · Mar 24, 2014#11I would rather have YW than the dealer.
Sign me up!
MyzticZ3r0Las Vegas, NV · Mar 24, 2014#12Let me know what you need and I'll be glad to chip in. I'll be keeping the yarii until I drive it into the ground =].
why?harnett county NC · Mar 24, 2014#13all good ideas. The biggest problem is the admins though. too bad we couldn't just get an entire new domain.
tk-421Thread starterDagobah · Mar 24, 2014#14We need a new domain for this project. It's just a matter of deciding on the name.
fnkngrvIn The Hotbox · Mar 24, 2014#15It is great that you have decided to step up and make these proposals. I have recently joined another club/forum and their design and back end seem to be much more up to date and robust. I have also been a member on other forums where there is constantly redirects that are invalid, etc. I guess what I am driving at is that we need for sure a hierarchy that will allow for growth, interest, etc. I am fine with paid and VIP member type of stuff as well. I will need to read more into Discourse. At a quick glance it appears to be very similar to what you would find on Techspot, Engadget, Gizmodo, etc. Not saying that is good or bad. It would be a tremendous departure from standardized forums for sure.
Regardless the route taken it definitely needs a much more elegant mobile solution that "pinch to zoom" mobile browser access. I know there are a bunch of folks out there that don't mind that, but let's be honest...how can you be taken seriously and draw a growing/contributing user base if you are not going to cater to true mobility. It is the way of the future no matter how you slice it.
It almost sounds like we would essentially need to perform a massive exodus from YW. Special pinned posts being placed with an explanation on why we are doing what we are doing and essentially just let YW become a stale point in the ether. This isn't an "admin" thing, this is a straight up owner situation where for some reason they have the misconception that they have the ability to make money on a site that has been going the way of the DoDo for years.
fnkngrvIn The Hotbox · Mar 24, 2014#16Since I am running into the same redirect issue on voting:
What do you think? (Votes are anonymous)
I like the idea and would consider paying a small monthly donation if given the chance
I support the idea, although I would only be able to make a donation every now and then
I support the idea but would probably never donate (just being honest)
I think the current site is just fine and I don't really care about what happens to the data
cali yarisCanoga Park, CA · Mar 24, 2014#17I'm just going to point out that the owner's resources (server/hosting/forum) are being used here to discuss this. Someone is paying so this forum continues on -- in my opinion, after all these years, that is GENEROUS of him at the very least.
Let's not forget how we were allowed to meet on here in the first place.
/rant
tk-421Thread starterDagobah · Mar 24, 2014#18They have been very generous for sure. It's just that their lack of communication leaves a lot (too much) to the imagination. I have sent them many messages over the years and received ZERO replies. It just wears you out after a while...
tk-421Thread starterDagobah · Mar 24, 2014#19 Originally Posted by
fnkngrv ↑ I will need to read more into Discourse.
You can check out
http://try.discourse.org to try out a live server instance. It's got a pretty cool and damn snappy UI even under not so great wifi.
you can read more about their reasoning behind this approach here:
http://www.discourse.org/about/ It almost sounds like we would essentially need to perform a massive exodus from YW. Special pinned posts being placed with an explanation on why we are doing what we are doing and essentially just let YW become a stale point in the ether.
Well, yes and no. My idea is to grab all the threads that we want with us and integrate them into the new system. That way our existing community and our data is preserved and we get a way nicer platform as a result.
This isn't an "admin" thing, this is a straight up owner situation where for some reason they have the misconception that they have the ability to make money on a site that has been going the way of the DoDo for years.
Actually, YarisBueller has stated that he doesn't care if he makes money on YW or not, and I tend to believe him. It's just that if he's not interested in making money AND he's also not interested in being a part of the community, then what exactly keeps him motivated to keep YW afloat for the next 5 years?
fnkngrvIn The Hotbox · Mar 24, 2014#20 Originally Posted by
tk-421 ↑ Actually, YarisBueller has stated that he doesn't care if he makes money on YW or not, and I tend to believe him. It's just that if he's not interested in making money AND he's also not interested in being a part of the community, then what exactly keeps him motivated to keep YW afloat for the next 5 years?
I suppose that I should clarify a little better. With what has been shared with me when the owner has been approached about possibly handing off the torch to someone else my understanding is there was a discussion about what the site was worth in a monetary measurement.
That is the last I will say about it. I have given my input. 🙂
tk-421Thread starterDagobah · Mar 24, 2014#21No worries, I totally understand your point. 👍
All I'm saying is that what really makes YW valuable is the community and its data. The domain name is currently semi-valuable SEO-wise because we generate all this original content and most of the traffic for free, but if we move our traffic someplace else the actual value of the domain name would be diminished in a matter of months, if not weeks.
Not to mention that this new platform is way more SEO friendly and would be much more easily digested by search engines than vbulletin or phpbb are.
why?harnett county NC · Mar 24, 2014#22 Originally Posted by
cali yaris ↑ I'm just going to point out that the owner's resources (server/hosting/forum) are being used here to discuss this. Someone is paying so this forum continues on -- in my opinion, after all these years, that is GENEROUS of him at the very least.
Let's not forget how we were allowed to meet on here in the first place.
/rant
Yup, too true. And after years of complaints and forum degradation, it is obvious the owners don't care. The only reason this became the Yaris forum of note is because it was the first Yaris forum. As much as we tried to keep the echo forums open, they really never got the Yaris people. And even though there are several toyota forums, the Yaris/Echo sections are pretty much worthless.
All it would take would be for the owner to give a few active mods admin power, and everything could be great. That isn't hard or a big deal, but since it hasn't been done, full out revolt was only a matter of time.
------------
While moving away from traditional forum formats might seem nice, just take a look at the YW social groups to see how it really ends up. Although if it has a powerful search feature with the ability to search for new posts since your last visit, it might be ok. For a well run car community I always look at
NASIOC.com, partly because it is gigantic, but also because they've been around a long time, been through all sorts of crazy stuff including massive forum turmoil, and still stand. Even with numerous competitors covering the exact same topic.
------
ok Discourse does look cool.
Bluevitz-rsOshawa, Ontario, Canada · Mar 24, 2014#23IDK if any of you were a part of echofans.com, but I feel this site going the same way. There's only a couple of threads that I have really worth saving... One being my 5spd to 6spd conversion. But I have that saved as a text doc on my computer already.
aussie muzzaQueensland Australia · Mar 24, 2014#24Guys
As a member who reads this site almost every day I would be very upset if the site disappeared. I don't post very often but I certainly use the information that I find. I am constantly astounded at the amount of knowledge Scott and some of the other high profile members post. It is all appreciated. I would be happy to make a small donation from time to time to keep it rolling. That is if you take Aussie dollars...
Best Wishes Muz.
fnkngrvIn The Hotbox · Mar 24, 2014#25 Originally Posted by
aussie muzza ↑ Guys
As a member who reads this site almost every day I would be very upset if the site disappeared. I don't post very often but I certainly use the information that I find. I am constantly astounded at the amount of knowledge Scott and some of the other high profile members post. It is all appreciated. I would be happy to make a small donation from time to time to keep it rolling. That is if you take Aussie dollars...
Best Wishes Muz.
Thank you for the input. The discussion really is about being able to attempt to elevate the community to a level it once was. The biggest issue really was the hack. Pre-hack this forum was bumpin crazy. After the hack when folks found out that the ownership was for one reason or another oblivious to what they started and what it was becoming because they didn't perform due diligence and have the database with a failover mechanism. Because if this lack of proper handling we lost too much information, etc which in turn caused the site to slowly plateau to what it is now. There shouldn't be a hand full of contributors. There should be a multitude, but most folks need that constant push to better the environmwnt they are in. This forum has lacked that push much to the dismay and chagrin of those faithful out there and that has happened in spite of the "core" folks trying their best. Let's be even more honest. YarisWorld is on life support and it doesn't have a battery back up in caee of a power outage.
tk-421Thread starterDagobah · Mar 24, 2014#26Sad but true. However, things can improve pretty quickly if we act as a unit. 👍
cali yarisCanoga Park, CA · Mar 25, 2014#27 I would be very upset if the site disappeared.
It won't. They are discussing a replacement forum with a different address.
The fact that 15 people have bothered to vote pretty much says it all to me. There are already a bunch of other choices to get information about the Yaris. It will never be the case that one location dedicated to the Yaris alone can be like this forum used to be. Just my opinion, and the reason I built our forums. Too many other interesting vehicles available these days!
tk-421Thread starterDagobah · Mar 25, 2014#28^^ Correct. YarisWorld would stay alive, just not as actively maintained as it is now (at least not by me 🙂). At the rate things are happening now, spam bots are going to take over within a year or so. Moderators need better tools for the job at hand.
I made a little graph of all banned spam accounts separated by date:
http://screencloud.net/v/aGCK We currently have an average of 3 spam accounts being created per day, with the worst day being 198 accounts (back on 2013-04-13). This is pretty bad news, considering that just one of those accounts can generate hundreds of spam posts in a few minutes and that our current forum software and privileges only allow us do so much on our end. I have basically no doubt that it will get worse relatively quickly, especially is spammers are actually sitting down and reading this information and other threads discussing this stuff. 😳
yougojayEast End · Mar 25, 2014#29Love this site, Love my Yaris & plan to keep it for the rest of my life (& I am serious, I am a keeper) I am more than willing to make a few donations a year to help the site out. I check-in quite a few times per day, and am trying to help keep the site active.
Have learned a heck of a lot about this car & other members adventures & lives, I just love this site. Count me in, I voted, same 'voting' glitch as others.
I don't know much at all about the 'behind the scenes' operations of a forum, but am pretty DARN good when it comes to figuring out how they work. They're all basically the same, you just need to follow some instruction and do a little research, example: READ The Instructions, or as we say here, Owners Manual
Whatever is decided, I'll be here & try my best to support. I owe a lot to the other members, they've filled my with all this cool Yaris stuff, it's swirling around in there hourly (believe me, it is!) and I think about, well, you know...🤤 yeah, THAT less than I used to...🤣
YaristeveLos Angeles · Mar 25, 2014#30I too, just found this thread.
I don't mind donating but could it be once a year?
tk-421Thread starterDagobah · Mar 27, 2014#31I'm open to all ideas at the moment. Please keep them coming. 👍
Bluevitz-rsOshawa, Ontario, Canada · Mar 27, 2014#32Does google do payed advertising? Maybe that could help
47_MasoN_47Northwest Alabama · Mar 28, 2014#33Just going to throw out there, that if we really want to take this site over, we could just....take it. This thing is running on an old version anyway. Some people know things that can make some other people owners.
I'd hate to see this place go away. I'm not as active as I used to be just because I'm mainly focusing on getting my truck running again, but once that's back in action (hopefully after another week or two) I've got a whole bunch of Yaris stuff I want to do.
AstromanWenatchee, WA · Mar 28, 2014#34Just a note I just got notified and am testing tapatalk on the forum. Maybe the admins had some upgrades going they hadn't told us about. This literally happened a few minutes ago.
Sent from my SCH-I545 using Tapatalk
mazillaSan Jacinto California · Mar 28, 2014#35I may not log in every day but I do check the new posts and the tech guides are invaluable...I'd be in for 20-25 a year as a 'premium member'
tk-421Thread starterDagobah · Mar 28, 2014#36 Originally Posted by
Astroman ↑ Just a note I just got notified and am testing tapatalk on the forum. Maybe the admins had some upgrades going they hadn't told us about. This literally happened a few minutes ago.
Sent from my SCH-I545 using Tapatalk
Yup trying it now myself... Can't really believe it finally happened.
Sent from my Nexus 7 using Tapatalk
cali yarisCanoga Park, CA · Mar 28, 2014#37The timing is extremely coincidental. Probably the next step is everyone in this thread getting banned. 😛
tk-421Thread starterDagobah · Mar 28, 2014#38Hey, at least we're moving forward. Not sure if they're reading this thread or not. 🤷
I'm continuing work on the thread exporter for now. I'm about 70% done as it is.
SeptembersrainSan Antonio · Mar 28, 2014#39Yay! Thank you for Tapatalk. Since I'm at work like 80% of my life, this makes it convenient to keep up with this awesome site!
»Sent from a larger than life device. Using Tapatalk«
aussie muzzaQueensland Australia · Mar 28, 2014#40I just received the email re Tapatalk. It got to me on the other side of the world and I am in your tomorrow.....
It seems like things are getting cracking with the site. Well done.
G'day to my YarisWorld mates from Australia.
regards Muz
fnkngrvIn The Hotbox · Mar 28, 2014#41 Originally Posted by
cali yaris ↑ The timing is extremely coincidental. Probably the next step is everyone in this thread getting banned. 😛
coincidental indeed
fnkngrvIn The Hotbox · Mar 28, 2014#42I am just going to put this right here:
🤣
Bluevitz-rsOshawa, Ontario, Canada · Mar 28, 2014#43Yeah I got a email this morning that YarisWorld is now on tapatalk.
That's so random LOL
Sent from my iPod Touch
tk-421Thread starterDagobah · Mar 28, 2014#44Good to see that almost 80% of current voters would be willing to donate if given the chance.
What would premium members want as far as upgrades go? For now I'm thinking that a "VIP" badge would be nice. I'm also thinking that only VIP members should be allowed to post in the classifieds.
The thread export tool is almost ready for prime time. I'm currently developing a way to deal with threads with multiple pages but that's not a huge deal.
tk-421Thread starterDagobah · Mar 30, 2014#45My thread exporter tool is now 100% functional. 😎
I'll probably start a new thread where people can post the links to threads that they consider worth keeping.
tk-421Thread starterDagobah · Apr 8, 2014#46Bump.
Your feedback is really important to me so please keep it coming. This whole plan is worthless without your support! 👍
Bluevitz-rsOshawa, Ontario, Canada · Apr 8, 2014#47I'm away in Florida right now so I'll link a few I'd like kept when I get back home next week.
Sent from my iPod Touch
fnkngrvIn The Hotbox · Apr 8, 2014#48Did you start the thread to catalog threads to export?
From my m-o-b-i-l-e. Land Speed with a Yaris filled with AMSOIL lubricants as a T-1 Certified Dealer.
tooterLos Angeles · Apr 8, 2014#49I post from a...
DESKTOP 😆
Picture not included in this copy
But think that mobile access is a great addition as it would help this place be more accessible to newer technologies. I'm also in for some bucks to keep the place going. 👍
By the way are there any historical stats on how much traffic this place has been getting? Or even just daily post totals? I'm curious if participation has been going up or down.
Greg
JustPassinThruMontana · Apr 8, 2014#50I get that it costs money to run a website. I'm far from a "fan" but I've gotten some useful information and leads here...a tip o' the hat to CTScott.
I'd be open to a monthly charge. But...since this is all but abandoned, maybe it's time to make a clean break? An orderly move over to a new board; this one will still be up for some time; but the mods can set up another board at a new server, as new owner-mods, if they like.
There are a number of free software options; and webhosting is, I'm told, relatively cheap. If this domain is owned but abandoned, let's move seamlessly to another one, before the plug gets pulled.