Yarisworld Archive

Fuel Efficiency and the Yaris

303 posts · 1,163,418 views · page 4 of 7

Replies continued

LorenSafety Harbor, FL · Mar 11, 2010#151
Originally Posted by Boost Addicted ↑
All I'm saying is, with the way I drive as specified above (this is for the Jetta, my girlfriend has the Yaris) I get 34mpg combined city highway.
34mpg is good for your car, I'm not going to say it isn't. But...

34mpg is only 17% more than the EPA rating of 29 hwy for your Jetta.

Who do we trust for advice on how to most efficiently drive a Yaris? The guy who drives a Jetta and only beats EPA by 17%... or the guys who drive Yarii, and regularly beat EPA by over 30%?

I took the advice of the guys getting over 30% better than EPA (that's 47+mpg), learned and practiced the techniques, and now I *am* one of those guys.
Boost AddictedAlbany NY · Mar 12, 2010#152
lol my friend, I'm not driving an RX-8 with a wankel rotory engine... Our engine designs are nearly identical. Four pistons, same injection system, both gasoline engines, and so on... Theories that work on a Volkswagen will work on a Toyota, a Honda, a Ford, and so on. Both are manual transmissions... So think about it. And learn to read, because 34mpg is my combined city/highway. Pure highway is about 37mpg.


Must I say again, this is my two cents... Take it or leave it. I don't care. But please don't argue untill you read thuroughly and know the facts of the argument, like internal combustion engine function, and transmission syncro operation. Not tryin to be a dick here, my initial intentions were to help out. Clearly I am not, so I'll end this here... If I wanted to fight with people I'd head to vwvortex.
sbergman27Oklahoma City, OK · Mar 12, 2010#153
Originally Posted by Boost Addicted ↑
But please don't argue untill you read thuroughly and know the facts of the argument, like internal combustion engine function, and transmission syncro operation.
Actually, this can all be settled in a fairly straightforward way. As I've said before, we need data. And that's exactly what the Scangauge II collects very well.

To what temperature would you recommend warming the engine before starting to drive? (The "Cold" light goes off at 130F.)

I can simply pick, say, two very different courses. One which requires only light throttle to reach a particular close by destination. And another which involves getting right onto the highway.[1] Both courses can be run, always from a cold start at similar ambient temperature, with a warm up period, and without.

That should throw some illumination upon this subject of contention. And the results might suggest a further experiment or experiments. Arguing in a vacuum is kind of pointless.

This would address the fuel consumption issue. The engine wear issue is, unfortunately, more difficult to put numbers on.

That said, I'm off to the Rocky Mountains shortly, and will likely not begin to address this until at least early next week. But anyone with the proper instrumentation should feel free to start without me. ;-)

-Steve

[1] Making certain, of course, that both courses are long enough that the engine is at 180F by the end of them, even without a separate warm up period.
Boost AddictedAlbany NY · Mar 13, 2010#154
''Collects very well''? Did I read that correctly? You use a $200 scan tool that has 5 buttons to figure out all the necessary information? Soo... Can you read fuel maps/trims? Read individual measuring blocks for injector pulse width and duty cycles? Open and closed loop? Monitor and log multiple sensor outputs? Suggested vs. actual MAF, MAP, TB measurments? ... Do you even have wideband oxygen sensors to measure your precise fuel combustion? Oooor... Do you just have some magic program that calculates fuel mileage? Cause I have that on my dashboard in the Jetta... I don't need a scan tool to do this. I can just go ahead and do it for you if it's gonna be the same thing.

Come back when you have a TIS Techstream.

Until then, Mr. Burgman, you can get yourself a nice magnetic drain plug, and again, as said before, drive one cycle of 5000 miles driving cold, right off the bat... No waiting. Then another 5000K miles letting the car warm (in winter months), or giving her 10 seconds minimum for proper distribution of lubrication if in summer months, then compare volume of metal material on the magnet.

If you don't give a damn about engine wear and all you care about is fuel mileage, then by all means let me dismiss this situation now... Because you've got larger problems in life to deal with if you consider engine wear<minimal fuel savings.
sbergman27Oklahoma City, OK · Mar 13, 2010#155
Originally Posted by Boost Addicted ↑
''Collects very well''? Did I read that correctly? You use a $200 scan tool that has 5 buttons to figure out all the necessary information?
The necessary information to resolve the fuel economy question is nothing more than total fuel consumption for the trips. Think about it. So all of your hand waving about sensor outputs, etc. is completely irrelevant. I have already expressed, clearly, in a previous post in this thread, that engine wear is a factor that needs to be taken into account. Engine overhauls represent a fair investment in resources. Not to mention personal expense. But I also noted that engine wear is more difficult to quantify and would be beyond what my methodology would try to address. You might want to review the thread.

I'm not addressing the magnetic drain plug bit since I assume that it was not intended to be taken seriously. I suppose something might be done using UOA results, to the extent that one trusts them... which I don't particularly.

BTW, you didn't answer my question about your preferred target temperature for the warm ups.

Also, you really need to calm down. Your post is borderline irrational, and frankly, inappropriate in tone. In short, you seem to be frothing a bit.

This is the only response that I intend to make to a nonconstructive post in this thread. Life is too short to waste time on such things.

-Steve
127.0.0.1NE · Mar 13, 2010#156
Originally Posted by Boost Addicted ↑
''Collects very well''? Did I read that correctly? You use a $200 scan tool that has 5 buttons to figure out all the necessary information? Soo... Can you read fuel maps/trims? Read individual measuring blocks for injector pulse width and duty cycles? Open and closed loop? Monitor and log multiple sensor outputs? Suggested vs. actual MAF, MAP, TB measurments? ... Do you even have wideband oxygen sensors to measure your precise fuel combustion? Oooor... Do you just have some magic program that calculates fuel mileage? Cause I have that on my dashboard in the Jetta... I don't need a scan tool to do this. I can just go ahead and do it for you if it's gonna be the same thing.

Come back when you have a TIS Techstream.

Until then, Mr. Burgman, you can get yourself a nice magnetic drain plug, and again, as said before, drive one cycle of 5000 miles driving cold, right off the bat... No waiting. Then another 5000K miles letting the car warm (in winter months), or giving her 10 seconds minimum for proper distribution of lubrication if in summer months, then compare volume of metal material on the magnet.

If you don't give a damn about engine wear and all you care about is fuel mileage, then by all means let me dismiss this situation now... Because you've got larger problems in life to deal with if you consider engine wear<minimal fuel savings.
is 11 years 190,000 miles considered long enough ?


I 'll say something for engine wear and toyota motors. I operate a 5VZFE. I owned my 4runner from new in Dec 1998 to today, it has 190,000 + miles on it. all it ever got since mile 600 was mobil 1 5-30 every 8000 miles.

(plus timing belts and regular owners manual maint. at the dealer)

I always, ALWAYS just jump right in and drive it, zero or minimal warmup
(only as long as it takes me to adjust whatever I am doing. I get in car and always go immediately.) transmission and engine still run better now than the first 10,000 miles. ya I don't stomp it hard until it is warm but I go the speed limit. engine is still maybe 40 or 50 deg and climbing I am already doing 40mph.



so....I live in NE and oh yeah you betcha I do this when it is 10 deg out as soon as I get in it I drive it. I start the thing so often I am on my 3rd set of starter contacts. and guess what ? NO damage to motor of any significance...it is just getting broken in at 190,000 miles.

today, it still gets better than EPA, in 8000 miles it burns only 2mm of oil
level on the dipstick and passes emissions with tests with ease. it makes all the compression it should, it makes more BHP than it should on 87 octane no engine mods whatsoever.


this is not the 50's anymore with your grandpa-era motors found in high school shop class...


...engine wear schmengine wear just drive the thing immediately it will not do any harm if you plan on keeping a toyota..what ? 11+ years like I have...and it is real in-my-driveway-come-look-at-it-for-yourself results, not some crap from a book

I will say it may not be fair to compare a 5VZFE...the motor is legendary as being absolutely bombproof...same with my A340 tranny
and transfer case
sbergman27Oklahoma City, OK · Mar 13, 2010#157
127.0.0.1,

My Chevy Sprint (Suzuki 1.0L 3 cyl) has about 350,000 miles on it and has had 3 overhauls. The first one was at 140,000 miles and not due to any sort of wear, but due to a ring which had lost tension. (This engine uses a special low friction ring configuration with 1 oil ring and 1 compression ring, so there is not a lot of margin for error.) Typically, over temperature is the cause of this. But we never determined for sure. Anyway, the engine looked great so we just did rings and bearings. Though the existing bearings actually looked pretty good.

The second overhaul was at 260,000 and was actually due to a mistake made during the first overhaul which ended up causing the timing gear keyway at the front of the crankshaft to wallow out, destroying the crankshaft. We were impressed that at 260,000 we only had about 0.004 - 0.005 cylinder wear. We did rings and bearings again, in addition to replacing the crank. The existing bearings looked remarkably good. And the crank was fine... except for the keyway.

At 318,000 miles it cracked a piston. Probably that 0.004 - 0.005 cylinder wear had increased and fatigued the piston. This time we bored it and went with new pistons. The cam shaft was still in great shape. No action was necessary there.

So that engine went 318,000 miles before a wear condition caused problems. The first 2 overhauls were completely unrelated to wear.

I've always been a fan of Mobile 1, which is what I always attributed the low wear to. But I've never been one to formally warm an engine up. I do try to go easy on them until they are at least partially up to temperature.

-Steve
Boost AddictedAlbany NY · Mar 14, 2010#158
Originally Posted by 127.0.0.1 ↑
is 11 years 190,000 miles considered long enough ?


I 'll say something for engine wear and toyota motors. I operate a 5VZFE. I owned my 4runner from new in Dec 1998 to today, it has 190,000 + miles on it. all it ever got since mile 600 was mobil 1 5-30 every 8000 miles.

(plus timing belts and regular owners manual maint. at the dealer)

I always, ALWAYS just jump right in and drive it, zero or minimal warmup
(only as long as it takes me to adjust whatever I am doing. I get in car and always go immediately.) transmission and engine still run better now than the first 10,000 miles. ya I don't stomp it hard until it is warm but I go the speed limit. engine is still maybe 40 or 50 deg and climbing I am already doing 40mph.



so....I live in NE and oh yeah you betcha I do this when it is 10 deg out as soon as I get in it I drive it. I start the thing so often I am on my 3rd set of starter contacts. and guess what ? NO damage to motor of any significance...it is just getting broken in at 190,000 miles.

today, it still gets better than EPA, in 8000 miles it burns only 2mm of oillevel on the dipstick and passes emissions with tests with ease. it makes all the compression it should, it makes more BHP than it should on 87 octane no engine mods whatsoever.

this is not the 50's anymore with your grandpa-era motors found in high school shop class...


...engine wear schmengine wear just drive the thing immediately it will not do any harm if you plan on keeping a toyota..what ? 11+ years like I have...and it is real in-my-driveway-come-look-at-it-for-yourself results, not some crap from a book

I will say it may not be fair to compare a 5VZFE...the motor is legendary as being absolutely bombproof...same with my A340 tranny
and transfer case
So what you're saying is;

1. You have put your 4Runner on a dyno? Makes MORE BHP than it should? I'd like to see that dyno sheet.

2. You go 8,000 miles before changing your oil... And continue to say you have more EPA horsepower ratings, fuel mileage, etc?... Right. Proof?

3. ''All the compression it should'', yet you don't have a number...

4. No damage to the motor whatsoever? So you must know of Blackstone Labs? May as well post up your progressive stack of every oil analysis you've gotten, along with that dyno sheet.

I'm afraid, my friend, I do not go to high school 🙂, so the cars you speak of, ''grandpa era'', are not a factor. But it made you sound kinda badass I guess 🎉

Mr. Burgman... I'm seriously convinced you have no idea what you're talking about. I'll take your ignorance to my last post as a sign of you not knowing what aaannny of that actually is (measuring blocks, open/closed loop, etc). Using biiiig sophisticated words doesn't help the fact that you're talking from your ass... And speaking to me as a lesser person isn't gonna go very far. Props for trying though. This is a technical forum, not a pissing contest (🤮).

And in all seriousness, the two of you should check out mobil 1's formula list...
127.0.0.1NE · Mar 14, 2010#159
Originally Posted by Boost Addicted ↑
So what you're saying is;

1. You have put your 4Runner on a dyno? Makes MORE BHP than it should? I'd like to see that dyno sheet.

2. You go 8,000 miles before changing your oil... And continue to say you have more EPA horsepower ratings, fuel mileage, etc?... Right. Proof?

3. ''All the compression it should'', yet you don't have a number...

4. No damage to the motor whatsoever? So you must know of Blackstone Labs? May as well post up your progressive stack of every oil analysis you've gotten, along with that dyno sheet.

I'm afraid, my friend, I do not go to high school 🙂, so the cars you speak of, ''grandpa era'', are not a factor. But it made you sound kinda badass I guess 🎉

Mr. Burgman... I'm seriously convinced you have no idea what you're talking about. I'll take your ignorance to my last post as a sign of you not knowing what aaannny of that actually is (measuring blocks, open/closed loop, etc). Using biiiig sophisticated words doesn't help the fact that you're talking from your ass... And speaking to me as a lesser person isn't gonna go very far. Props for trying though. This is a technical forum, not a pissing contest (🤮).

And in all seriousness, the two of you should check out mobil 1's formula list...
What I said was: NO damage to motor of any significance.

You are preaching 'technical', yet cannot even read correctly. idiot.

I am not saying it will never wear out, I am saying that 11 years of 'start and go immediately' have no real impact
on the thing as a daily driver. you can sit and warm up your car all you want there, Chieftain... all you will
do is waste gas. I can start and go and still have a decent engine at 11 years plus. so there. real world use.

if you race a car that is a different matter entirely. warm ups are needed on race engines.

yes, a warm motor does perform better, but is warmup needed on a daily around town driver. NO.

Whatever. I am not into finite oil or engine analysis on my cars. it is a friggin car, not a nuclear warship. I worry more about steam engines and ceramic impellers in real life.
----
tests were done at 166,340 miles

dyno results were

original dyno run at 2000 miles was
163 hp /234 torque (186 hp adjusted)

166,340 miles run was
168 hp /234 torque (190 hp adjusted)

compression tests at 166,355 miles

1- 178psi
2- 175psi
3- 181psi

4- 188psi
5- 182psi
6- 179psi


all 6 tested on warm engine within 2 minutes

I did these checks because I -was- gonna sell it, but then decided I will never
sell it



Do I know of Blackstone Labs ? sheesh are they any better than Lockheed Martin or Pratt and Whitney at
materials analysis ? want me to send you some NASA stickers ? done with this one. pointless.
sbergman27Oklahoma City, OK · Mar 14, 2010#160
Originally Posted by 127.0.0.1 ↑
What I said was: NO damage to motor of any significance.
From my own experience, I would be inclined to say "impressively little" wear. Significance is relative. I tend to keep my cars a very long time. Like 20 and 40 years. (Call me sentimental.) And I dread overhauls. They always seem to result in some sort of complication. And, at the very least, expense... no matter how long the original lasts. It's possible that a certain amount of extra warm up might be beneficial over the very long run. Or... it could be, as you say, insignificant... even in my situation.

It's an interesting topic. Actually "topics", since we have two questions. How do warm ups affect fuel economy under different use scenarios? And how do they affect wear? I was planning on scoping out the easier of the two: fuel economy, this week. But surely Car & Driver, or Consumer Reports, or *someone* with better resources has researched these things.

I just now got back from a long trip and am not too keen on a Google-hunt, sorting out all the credible wheat from the unreliable chaff. But I figured I'd mention.

-Steve
Boost AddictedAlbany NY · Mar 14, 2010#161
Originally Posted by 127.0.0.1 ↑
What I said was: NO damage to motor of any significance.

You are preaching 'technical', yet cannot even read correctly. idiot.

I am not saying it will never wear out, I am saying that 11 years of 'start and go immediately' have no real impact
on the thing as a daily driver. you can sit and warm up your car all you want there, Chieftain... all you will
do is waste gas. I can start and go and still have a decent engine at 11 years plus. so there. real world use.

if you race a car that is a different matter entirely. warm ups are needed on race engines.

yes, a warm motor does perform better, but is warmup needed on a daily around town driver. NO.

Whatever. I am not into finite oil or engine analysis on my cars. it is a friggin car, not a nuclear warship. I worry more about steam engines and ceramic impellers in real life.
----
tests were done at 166,340 miles

dyno results were

original dyno run at 2000 miles was
163 hp /234 torque (186 hp adjusted)

166,340 miles run was
168 hp /234 torque (190 hp adjusted)

compression tests at 166,355 miles

1- 178psi
2- 175psi
3- 181psi

4- 188psi
5- 182psi
6- 179psi


all 6 tested on warm engine within 2 minutes

I did these checks because I -was- gonna sell it, but then decided I will never
sell it



Do I know of Blackstone Labs ? sheesh are they any better than Lockheed Martin or Pratt and Whitney at
materials analysis ? want me to send you some NASA stickers ? done with this one. pointless.
Hahaha yes indeed, I must be an idiot. Well I guess the three of us can agree on one thing... That this is a complete waste of time. So this shall be my final post as well on this thread.
sbergman27Oklahoma City, OK · Mar 14, 2010#162
Originally Posted by Boost Addicted ↑
Well I guess the three of us can agree on one thing... That this is a complete waste of time. So this shall be my final post as well on this thread.
Boost Addicted,

I don't think that this thread necessarily has to be a waste of time. It could be a good thread or a bad thread, depending upon how the participants handle it. 127.0.0.1 and I tend toward the "just drive it" opinion. You're the fellow carrying the "warm it up first" side. And that's a very reasonable view. But maybe it seems like we're ganging up on you or something. I don't know.

I'm less concerned about right or wrong, or the winning or losing of an argument, than I am with what useful, helpful, or education information comes out of the thread.

I'm wondering... where is the pivot point? How far or little can you push the throttle before wear per mile stops decreasing and starts increasing... or fuel per mile stops decreasing and starts increasing.

-Steve
Hersheynortheast · Mar 14, 2010#163
we drive from start up if possible . Depends if there's frost , ice , or snow on it .
Hersheynortheast · Mar 14, 2010#164
The ECO-METER shows good amount of fuel consumption when using the AVERAGE M.P.G. MODE if have to let it defrost thanks to higher idle at start ups and the tranny remains in 3rd gear until car reaches normal operating temperature ( blue light goes out ) 🙁 .
R2D2ME · Mar 14, 2010#165
I'm in the drive easy until it warms up crowd. I give it a good 15 sec after I start it then drive very gently and keep the rpms down until it warms up. I clear the ice and snow before I start it. I do use a block heater when it's cold though.

R2
sbergman27Oklahoma City, OK · Mar 15, 2010#166
Originally Posted by Hershey ↑
and the tranny remains in 3rd gear until car reaches normal operating temperature ( blue light goes out ) 🙁 .
Yeah, what's up with that? I Just checked by starting and immediately getting on the 60 MPH expressway and the transmission really does wait that long to kick into 4th. In fact, whereas the light goes out at 130F, the transmission actually waited until more like 139F. Although the temperature was increasing fast enough that those events were actually within about 10 seconds of each other.

I'm wondering what the rationale is for locking out 4th at low engine temperatures. I tend to want the transmission to keep the RPMs *lower* when the engine is cold.

-Steve
Hersheynortheast · Mar 15, 2010#167
takes ours about 1 mile before it's capable of using overdrive . We drive under 40 m.p.h. to help keep the R.P.M.s down . Also try to leave the heater core on cold to cut off flow of antifreeze to speed up the use of 4th gear . Then turn on heat if needed . Figure less distance for coolant to travel letting the anti-freeze go around engine picking up the heat generated to help with quicker normal temperature operation so blue light disappears and idle drops sooner . Thus saving some fuel . Is a nuisance . 🙄
Hersheynortheast · Mar 21, 2010#168
since removal of 4 studded tires and warmer weather the 2010 3 door with auto is now getting 40 + miles per gallon . This is VALERO 87 octane ( 10% ethanol ) at 1 click of nozzle at full speed ( always same pump ) , tires set at 36 p.s.i. , 2 people , some headwinds of 25 + m.p.h. , and an average of 50 m.p.h.. Before were lucky to get 36 . Not sure if summer blend has reached our region as of yet , if not can possibly see more of increase 🤤 . 1st fill after removal of studded snows the calculated mileage was 44 while the ECO-METER read 41 . Which one should we believe 🤷 . That's the most the E.M. has ever been off ( wonder if E.M. was only familiar with the studded snows ? ) . Before the E.M. has been only off by less than .5 below the calculated mileage . Either way I'll take it . 44 be nicer . Since the 2nd fill the car lost the 1st bar at 80.1 miles and is averaging 41.1 on the E.M..
sbergman27Oklahoma City, OK · Mar 22, 2010#169
Originally Posted by Hershey ↑
Also try to leave the heater core on cold to cut off flow of antifreeze to speed up the use of 4th gear . Then turn on heat if needed .
Note that this practice makes a *substantial* difference. Even in relatively mild winter weather, say 50F, the Yaris is unable to maintain a coolant temperature of more than about 155F at idle with the heater on high. It's 30F here right now and I just got back from a trip to Walmart. I know from experience that with the heater off, the engine reaches 130F and the "cool" light goes off before I get to the Walmart parking lot. This morning, I left the heater on high. It didn't hit 130F until I was almost *back home* on the return trip. And when I pulled into my parking space, the temp was 136F. That's still 4 degrees shy of when the transmission would have made 4th gear and converter locking available. (And the interior wasn't exactly toasty yet.)

The heater on the Yaris can accurately be considered an auxiliary radiator.

-Steve
Hersheynortheast · Mar 22, 2010#170
🎉 . Literally 😁 .
BailOutThread starterReno, Nevada, USA · Mar 22, 2010#171
All the more reason to use a grille block in the cold months. I just took mine back out last weekend. I'll put it back in sometime in November or December.
sbergman27Oklahoma City, OK · Mar 22, 2010#172
Originally Posted by BailOut ↑
All the more reason to use a grille block in the cold months. I just took mine back out last weekend. I'll put it back in sometime in November or December.
There was a post on teamswift.net some time back from a guy who lived in (I think) Alaska... or Antarctica... or somewhere. He posted an interesting HowTo on lining the bottom side of the hood of his Geo Metro with a heat reflective blanket with a layer of insulation bonded to the back of it. The idea being to reflect any radiant heat back onto the engine, while providing extra insulation, as well.

As you know, I'm a sort of show-me-the-data kind of guy... so I'm not actually advocating this. But it is, at least, an interesting idea. Especially for perpetually cold climates. I assume that he already used a grille block.

Funny... those fake louvres we see on some cars as decorations (Hi 1979 Lincoln Mark V! I'm thinking of you!) used to actually function, back in the day. The driver had a pull-knob to close them to facilitate warm up. Then again, the driver also had a choke pull-knob and an ignition timing pull-knob. Always remember to pull both of those before trying to start the car. Failing to retard the timing could actually be deadly to the person turning the starting crank.[1] But that issue was a bit earlier, back in the 1900s and 1910s. It was a fellow whose friend was killed in just such a timing/crank accident who invented the electric starter which Cadillac introduced in 1912.

-Steve

[1] Consider what happens when the timing is advanced before TDC.
sbergman27Oklahoma City, OK · Mar 28, 2010#173
Originally Posted by R2D2 ↑
I'm in the drive easy until it warms up crowd.
Me too. This morning, I did run a test to get an idea how much (or little) fuel it actually takes to warm the engine to 128F (when the "Cool" light goes off), and to 140F, when the automatic transmission makes 4th gear and torque converter lock-up available. I found the answer to be a bit surprising. At an ambient temperature of 43F, it's only 0.03 gallons in both cases. (Scangauge doesn't go beyond 0.01 gal precision.) The "Cool" light went off just as the readout clicked over to 0.03. This is significantly less than I would have guessed.

-Steve
LorenSafety Harbor, FL · Mar 28, 2010#174
Sounds insignificant when you put it that way. And for someone who puts a lot of miles on their car every day, it probably is.

My typical trip is 3-5 miles. At 40 mpg, that's an average of about .10 gallons per trip.

If I let the car sit and warm up before every trip, I'd use 30% more fuel!!!

(even if you only count the .03 gallons on the initial start-up, it still adds up to 15% of my total fuel usage on a typical day)

Needless to say, I'm in the "drive it easy until it warms up" contingent. I get in the car, buckle my seatbelt, put the transmission in gear (manual trans), release the handbrake and check my mirrors all before turning the key. As soon as the engine is started I'm letting the clutch out and backing out of my driveway!

Unless the air temp is fairly cool (below 60-65 degrees), the "cool" light is usually off after the 3rd stop sign in my neighborhood, just before I turn onto the main road.
sbergman27Oklahoma City, OK · Mar 28, 2010#175
Originally Posted by Loren ↑
Sounds insignificant when you put it that way. And for someone who puts a lot of miles on their car every day, it probably is. My typical trip is 3-5 miles. At 40 mpg, that's an average of about .10 gallons per trip.
Yes, indeed. I'm not necessarily *prescribing* anything. My usage is substantially skewed towards longs trips where I get in the car at 6 AM in Alamogordo, New Mexico, and get out of the car, not knowing what time it is, in "What Town Was This, Again", Montana. No one even bothered to find out what the warm up fuel consumption was before having a back and forth discussion of the relative merits of warming up the car earlier in this thread.

I'd just like to see more quantitative discussions.

City driving *is* admittedly a lot messier, though.

-Steve
sbergman27Oklahoma City, OK · Mar 28, 2010#176
Originally Posted by Loren ↑
My typical trip is 3-5 miles. At 40 mpg, that's an average of about .10 gallons per trip. If I let the car sit and warm up before every trip, I'd use 30% more fuel!!!
No. Because even driving gently, you'd be using a lot more fuel than the tiny sip the engine takes at idle. And that additional fuel would be used under cold conditions in which the engine would be consuming significantly more fuel per horsepower-second than it would if it had been warmed up (investing that 0.03 gal of fuel) first.

My *intuition* agrees with you. But my intuition could be as wrong as yours. We need to test experimentally. (My bad. I haven't gotten to it.) Otherwise, we're no better scientists than was Aristotle.

-Steve
LorenSafety Harbor, FL · Mar 28, 2010#177
I get what you're saying. Potentially, the fuel used to warm-up plus the first mile or so of driving a WARMED UP engine could add up to less fuel usage than driving a cold engine for a mile or so. Maybe in some super-cold climate this might be possible. I can tell you from my observations in MY climate (Florida, almost always above 60 degrees) using a ScanGauge that eliminating the warm-up gives me better results. I don't need to quantify it more than that for my own purposes.

I'm not a "pure numbers" guy. I understand the physics and usually have a grasp on the math involved, but I "live" the philosophy derived from it.
sbergman27Oklahoma City, OK · Mar 28, 2010#178
Originally Posted by Loren ↑
I can tell you from my observations in MY climate (Florida, almost always above 60 degrees) using a ScanGauge that eliminating the warm-up gives me better results.
You know what? If your State weren't so damned far away, I'd likely be there every weekend from November through March.

A simple Golden Girls episode on this difficult and thorny social issue would have been nice. I'd love to have seen Betty White trying to work the ScanGauge...

:-)

-Steve
rene0023Coamo, Puerto Rico · Aug 25, 2010#179
Very useful information...
ChaldonSan Jose · Oct 14, 2010#180
jeeze, 11 pages!!! I'll have to take a break and come back...
galactic7geckoPhiladelphia · Oct 26, 2010#181
This is all fascinating info. I have changed my driving habits/maintenance somewhat since discovering this thread. I have a couple questions though. My record MPG is only 36 and this was taking it slow. I have a 3 dr hatchback AT, tires are at 36 PSI (maximum recommended by manufacturer), I use the recommended oil, I just ordered a scan gauge II. I would be ecstatic just to break 40 MPG! I coast whenever possible and shift to neutral whenever possible. I hope the Scan Gauge guide me.

Does anybody have any other recommendations or do I just not have an efficient version of the Yaris!?!?

Thanks!
why?harnett county NC · Oct 26, 2010#182
Originally Posted by galactic7gecko ↑
This is all fascinating info. I have changed my driving habits/maintenance somewhat since discovering this thread. I have a couple questions though. My record MPG is only 36 and this was taking it slow. I have a 3 dr hatchback AT, tires are at 36 PSI (maximum recommended by manufacturer), I use the recommended oil, I just ordered a scan gauge II. I would be ecstatic just to break 40 MPG! I coast whenever possible and shift to neutral whenever possible. I hope the Scan Gauge guide me.

Does anybody have any other recommendations or do I just not have an efficient version of the Yaris!?!?

Thanks!
Slow down. Seriously, if you think you are driving like your grandmother, you are prolly going too fast. And pretend their is a grenade under the pedals. The less you use them, and the softer you press them, the better your gas mileage will be.
KrazyDawgSF Bay Area · Oct 29, 2010#183
Originally Posted by galactic7gecko ↑
This is all fascinating info. I have changed my driving habits/maintenance somewhat since discovering this thread. I have a couple questions though. My record MPG is only 36 and this was taking it slow. I have a 3 dr hatchback AT, tires are at 36 PSI (maximum recommended by manufacturer), I use the recommended oil, I just ordered a scan gauge II. I would be ecstatic just to break 40 MPG! I coast whenever possible and shift to neutral whenever possible. I hope the Scan Gauge guide me.

Does anybody have any other recommendations or do I just not have an efficient version of the Yaris!?!?

Thanks!
What's your commute like? Is it mostly highway or city? Is the terrain generally flat or do you have a lot of hills? What's the average temperature when you're driving? These are other factors that affect your MPG but the biggest thing is driving.
galactic7geckoPhiladelphia · Oct 31, 2010#184
My commute is around 20 miles round trip its mostly flat except for the freeway where it tends to get a little hilly with the exits and ramps and all. The avg temperature of where I drive is around 90 is this beneficial?.. Sunny Corpus Christi, TX... it always seems to be hot! The highest mpg I've managed to achieve is 36 mpg is this because I have an automatic transmission? Thanks for the replies KrazyDawg and Why? I just installed my SGII and I'm awaiting to see how this tank goes. I'm really hoping to break 40, any other words of wisdom?
why?harnett county NC · Oct 31, 2010#185
so you probably use your a/c all the time, that doesn't help, but i wouldn't turn it off either.

The SG2 is a great thing to have. Use it, and it will help you get better gas mileage.
NahtoriousOnt. · Apr 20, 2011#186
Sorry if i've been living under a rock, but what's an SG2?
STCState College, PA, USA · Apr 20, 2011#187
Originally Posted by Nahtorious ↑
Sorry if i've been living under a rock, but what's an SG2?
http://www.scangauge.com/

Cheers! 🙂
NahtoriousOnt. · Apr 20, 2011#188
Originally Posted by STC ↑
Oh...that's wicked. i'm gonna have to pick one of those up.
Thanks man.
BizlibatiDhaka · Sep 28, 2011#189
I'm I could increase one thing in regards to the particular exhaust strain problem. I will be today about my own next pair of auto tires about my own '99 Corolla. This kind of established will be the same for the established I needed earlier. These kinds of auto tires are usually Kumho 795 Vacationing A/S. For your initial established, My partner and i preserved the particular recommened strain (this could be the strain outlined around the driver's door) which can be 25 PSI. These kinds of auto tires donned as a result of the particular use cafes with 55K a long way and also My partner and i averaged thirty five MPG above this period (roughly 90% interstate and also 10% metropolis driving). Once i obtained the next established, the particular exhaust person My partner and i obtained these coming from recommended My partner and i work these with 5 PSI on the advised strain. This individual mentioned not merely would certainly my own miles increase, yet thus would certainly treadwear, managing, and also path noises. This individual has been proper. My partner and i will have concerning 50K
KentSzaboGrant, CO · Jan 5, 2012#190
Two fill ups ago I had the first oil change and had them put synthetic 0-20 in my 2012 Yaris. Since then on the past two tankfuls I got 43.4 and 43.2 MPG.
In addition to synthetic oil I run 40 lbs of pressure in the tires.
KentSzaboGrant, CO · Mar 22, 2012#191
I am on my second synthetic oil change with over 10000 miles on it and at the last fill up I got a calculated 44.4 MPG, awesome.
BillsteinSo. Ca. · Apr 1, 2012#192
Here is something interesting I found by accident, When I first got the car I installed a cold air to help My MPG in 2007(I was at the most getting 33 MPG combined) I changed back to stock in 2012 and my MPG increased 6 + miles per gallon..Whaaa Who..I might add I drive 75 to 80 miles an hour on freeway, stock tires now with max air 50 lbs..
SpidermandudJohnson City, Tennessee · Apr 2, 2012#193
That is interesting. Perhaps the CAI helped your foot slow down, so now that you moved back to stock it's natural for you to not stress it as much? Not sure :l

Did you notice much difference reverting?
vincentgPhilippines · Apr 12, 2012#194
Does it make much difference if i gas up at night than throughout the day? and i heard from a good friend of mine that if you gas up notice that there are 2 - 3 types of levels in the nozzle of the gas pump. you only put in in the first level. (or the slowest pump) as to get more gasoline :) is this true? :)
charles nelsonSt Cloud Minnesota · Aug 6, 2012#195
I found that my driving follows the 'Popular Mechanics Fuel Economy' advice. Buy 91% (non-ethanol) gas if price is less than 120% of ethanol gas (has more energy per gallon),
watch upcoming signal lights to sync with green before you have to slow down or stop, if you have auto-trans...accelerate smoothly and quickly to get transmission into higher efficiency upper gears, use A/C if speed is above 30 mph.
RickSWEFWisconsin · Sep 13, 2012#196
Originally Posted by vincentg ↑
Does it make much difference if i gas up at night than throughout the day? and i heard from a good friend of mine that if you gas up notice that there are 2 - 3 types of levels in the nozzle of the gas pump. you only put in in the first level. (or the slowest pump) as to get more gasoline :) is this true? :)
I don't think it matters much what time of day you fill up. However, a slower pump will allow more air to escape your tank when filling up. Trapped air will cause the fuel to come up the filler tube and trigger the automatic shutoff on the pump nozzle. Some people think the tank is full when the nozzle clicks off and just puts the nozzle away without topping off. A slower pump will allow more fuel to enter the tank before the nozzle clicks off, so you end up with a fuller tank. If you're one who tops the tank off, none of this really matters much.

My '08 Yaris gets 36mpg during the winter months and 40mpg in the summer. I think the colder temps have something to do with this, but I also found out that gas stations have a summer fuel mix and a cheaper winter fuel mix. The different mixtures and the temps combined probably cause the difference in mpg. Of course, I'm not a slow poke when on the highway, so I could get better mpg if I tried.
charles nelsonSt Cloud Minnesota · Oct 26, 2012#197
Popular Mechanics Mag tested driving habits and mpg. They found that with an automatic transmission they got better mileage if they accelerated quickly but then tried to coast to a stop. Going faster more quickly put the transmission into the higher more efficient gears more quickly. Slow acceleration kept the cars in the lower mpg range longer.
STCState College, PA, USA · Oct 27, 2012#198
Originally Posted by charles nelson ↑
Popular Mechanics Mag tested driving habits and mpg. They found that with an automatic transmission they got better mileage if they accelerated quickly but then tried to coast to a stop. Going faster more quickly put the transmission into the higher more efficient gears more quickly. Slow acceleration kept the cars in the lower mpg range longer.
Not for manuals. You control your RPM shifts.

Cheers! 🙂
screenprintrNew Jersey · Nov 21, 2012#199
I'm really glad my Yaris gets 34 mpg semi around town and highway. However, I had stopping for gas every 3 or 4 days.

Why didn't they think about a slightly bigger tank? What's up with that?
mattiupper midwest · Nov 21, 2012#200
I also thought a bigger tank would be nice. Certainly not a deal breaker, though.