Yarisworld Archive

What is everyone paying on insurance?

80 posts · 29,987 views · page 1 of 2

94toy22reOriginal postNorman · Mar 26, 2013#1
For some reason I'm paying 120 a month full coverage on the yaris with multiple vehicle discount. It seems a little high! I had a FJ cruiser 55 a month and Lexus is300 88 a month same discounts and coverage on all of them. So why is the yaris so high? No tickets or accidents same insurance company.

Replies 79

mattiupper midwest · Mar 26, 2013#2
I have a clean driving record and 2012 Yaris for me is $42/month. My wife's car is insured on same policy (Progressive).
tooterLos Angeles · Mar 26, 2013#3
I hold the pink slip on our 2012, and so don't need to carry full coverage for a car financing company. I pay $288 yearly from Wawanesa. That works out to $24 a month. 🙂

You might ask your agent why your Yaris is so high. There has to be a reason.
CTScottUSA, CT · Mar 26, 2013#4
Insurance costs vary quite a bit by location and your coverage, but in my case here in CT, I pay:

$72 per month for my 2011 Tacoma
$60 per month for my 2009 Yaris 5 door
$55 per month for my 2008 Yaris 3 door
$44 per month for my 1992 Celica GT Convertible

This is with State Farm, and I also have my homeowners insurance with them.
nookandcrannycarS.MontgomeryCnty,TX(HoustonMSA) '07=BayouBlue=300,125miles=OrigOwnr '14=ClassicSilvr=29,059miles · Mar 26, 2013#5
I pay a little bit less that Matti. I think I only get billed 11 months out of the year as well. My policy total I know (for that policy) is over 440.00, but under 500.00. I have it (and my homeowner's policy) billed to my credit card monthly to get the frequent flyer miles (and don't pay extra to do that). I have liability only (no comp and collision), but I have AAA's highest personal auto policy limit and an umbrella policy. This is the only car on my policy, but I do get a discount for having my homeowner's insurance with them. I have 0 points on my record, but at my last renewal (reflecting my current rate) I had 1 violation (a driving on the median ticket from 2009 in New Jersey (along with 9 other drivers on the same stop) --- so I couldn't go to traffic school --- New Jersey only allows people who live in NJ, NY, and CT to go to traffic school for their offenses 🙄 (at least that was the case in 2009)). That 1 point just missed coming off on my last renewal (2012) by a few weeks.
nookandcrannycarS.MontgomeryCnty,TX(HoustonMSA) '07=BayouBlue=300,125miles=OrigOwnr '14=ClassicSilvr=29,059miles · Mar 26, 2013#6
Originally Posted by CTScott ↑
Insurance costs vary quite a bit by location and your coverage, but in my case here in CT, I pay:

$72 per month for my 2011 Tacoma
$60 per month for my 2009 Yaris 5 door
$55 per month for my 2008 Yaris 3 door
$44 per month for my 1992 Celica GT Convertible

This is with State Farm, and I also have my homeowners insurance with them.
Does State Farm make you have a rider for Crashy on your homeowners, or are they nice enough to include 'her' without one ? 🙂
CTScottUSA, CT · Mar 26, 2013#7
Originally Posted by nookandcrannycar ↑
Does State Farm make you have a rider for Crashy on your homeowners, or are they nice enough to include 'her' without one ? 🙂
Since she's not registered (nor street legal), I don't carry insurance on her.
nookandcrannycarS.MontgomeryCnty,TX(HoustonMSA) '07=BayouBlue=300,125miles=OrigOwnr '14=ClassicSilvr=29,059miles · Mar 27, 2013#8
Originally Posted by CTScott ↑
Since she's not registered (nor street legal), I don't carry insurance on her.
👍 I realized when I posted that 'she' wouldn't be insured as a vehicle, I just thought State Farm might not consider Crashy a snow plow (I thought in the Northeast snow plows might be included on a standard homeowner's policy) . I sort of have 'vehicles to tend to land' (so to speak) on the brain right now because I walked into a Sears last weekend (for another reason) and saw a sea of riding lawn mowers in a separate area near the entrance. I didn't have time to look at them that day, but I will the next time I go to that mall.
nookandcrannycarS.MontgomeryCnty,TX(HoustonMSA) '07=BayouBlue=300,125miles=OrigOwnr '14=ClassicSilvr=29,059miles · Mar 27, 2013#9
Originally Posted by tooter ↑
I hold the pink slip on our 2012, and so don't need to carry full coverage for a car financing company. I pay $288 yearly from Wawanesa. That works out to $24 a month. 🙂

You might ask your agent why your Yaris is so high. There has to be a reason.
You lucky (and smart) dog (your rate!). I had to do a serch for Wawanesa after seeing your rate. Unfortunately (in the U.S.) they only insure in California and Oregon 😠.
jRossIndianapolis, IN · Mar 27, 2013#10
Wth! I'm paying 155 a month for my yaris's full coverage. Granted, i have one speeding ticket and i'm a 22 year old man in Indianapolis, but it still seems way too high. Should i try a different comany or what? Cause this payment is killing my wallet.
mattiupper midwest · Mar 27, 2013#11
It never hurts to go out and get a few quotes.
YodaBirdToronto · Mar 27, 2013#12
Where I live insurance is high. Most people I know pay $175 a month or higher, with $250 being average.
jayehBritish Columbia, Canada · Mar 27, 2013#13
Originally Posted by YodaBird ↑
Where I live insurance is high. Most people I know pay $175 a month or higher, with $250 being average.
YAY Ontario! Expensive booze and insurance!

I pay $126 a month and It's a steal compared to what I used to pay in Toronto!
jayehBritish Columbia, Canada · Mar 27, 2013#14
Originally Posted by jRoss ↑
Wth! I'm paying 155 a month for my yaris's full coverage. Granted, i have one speeding ticket and i'm a 22 year old man in Indianapolis, but it still seems way too high. Should i try a different comany or what? Cause this payment is killing my wallet.
Move to Toronto, get a quote, then move back to IN and you'll feel better about your rate. 😁

When I was your age I think I was paying $475 a month on a car that was worth about $50.00
ExiwolfmanWasaga beach · Mar 27, 2013#15
106 per month in Collingwood , Toronto would be way more ..looks like USA insurance is way cheaper .
edmscanCanada · Mar 27, 2013#16
I pay about $74 a month for my 2007 Yaris, including collision. Happy I don't live in Ontario .. but those rates in the US ($288 per year) is pretty amazing.
nookandcrannycarS.MontgomeryCnty,TX(HoustonMSA) '07=BayouBlue=300,125miles=OrigOwnr '14=ClassicSilvr=29,059miles · Mar 27, 2013#17
Originally Posted by YodaBird ↑
Where I live insurance is high. Most people I know pay $175 a month or higher, with $250 being average.
$250 a month AVERAGE! For ONE car? That is insane. That's a bit more than CTScott pays for 4 cars, not 1.
edmscanCanada · Mar 27, 2013#18
Originally Posted by nookandcrannycar ↑
$250 a month AVERAGE! For ONE car? That is insane. That's a bit more than CTScott pays for 4 cars, not 1.
Welcome to Canada, where we are used to getting screwed over for just about everything. 👎
nookandcrannycarS.MontgomeryCnty,TX(HoustonMSA) '07=BayouBlue=300,125miles=OrigOwnr '14=ClassicSilvr=29,059miles · Mar 27, 2013#19
Originally Posted by edmscan ↑
I pay about $74 a month for my 2007 Yaris, including collision. Happy I don't live in Ontario .. but those rates in the US ($288 per year) is pretty amazing.
Yeah, and Tooter's company (the $288 company) is Canadian. The very short description of his company on the DuckDuckGo search page says that it is a mutual company (owned by the policyholders). Such companies don't always keep their initial low rates. I used to have great policies with Nationwide (also a mutual style company). They jacked my rates up one year without anything changing on my profile.
edmscanCanada · Mar 27, 2013#20
We have Wawanesa here too .. and they are not one of the cheaper rates out there.
tooterLos Angeles · Mar 28, 2013#21
I can't complain about Wawanesa.
I'm happy to pay $24 a month. 🙂
nookandcrannycarS.MontgomeryCnty,TX(HoustonMSA) '07=BayouBlue=300,125miles=OrigOwnr '14=ClassicSilvr=29,059miles · Mar 28, 2013#22
Originally Posted by tooter ↑
I can't complain about Wawanesa.
I'm happy to pay $24 a month. 🙂
Oh, definitely. My intended point was that not all mutual insurance companies are as good as yours/created equal, but I neglected to come to that direct point. If I still lived in California I'd definitely give Wawanesa a call 😁!
RipsawFlorida · Mar 28, 2013#23
Not knowing your age. If over 50 try AARP/Hartford for a quote!
phaznetYGK · Mar 28, 2013#24
280$ / month
26/male/ontario

beat that!
veewonwonNorth York, ON, Canada · Mar 28, 2013#25
Toronto, $125.75 / month, '12 Yaris SE, 5-Sp, 5-dr, TD Insurance Meloche Monnex

No multi-car and no house insurance with them.
nookandcrannycarS.MontgomeryCnty,TX(HoustonMSA) '07=BayouBlue=300,125miles=OrigOwnr '14=ClassicSilvr=29,059miles · Mar 29, 2013#26
Originally Posted by phaznet ↑
280$ / month
26/male/ontario

beat that!
Insane. Does that reflect any speeding or other tickets?
goliath1812Ocala Florida · Mar 29, 2013#27
Everything's more expensive in Ontario, but the salaries are higher too....
jayehBritish Columbia, Canada · Mar 29, 2013#28
Originally Posted by goliath1812 ↑
Everything's more expensive in Ontario, but the salaries are higher too....
Except for when you're working a minimum wage job and paying 1/4 of your income for insurance alone... Then it's not so good.
SuperflyIllinois · Mar 30, 2013#29
$110/monthly here in Chitown. Wish it would be cheaper but it is what it is.
goliath1812Ocala Florida · Mar 30, 2013#30
Not saying it's great, but even minimum wage is a lot higher than it is here...
Betriventedmonton · Mar 30, 2013#31
Was just gonna say, insurance for my car for a year is about 2k.
mr9865Green Bay WI · Mar 30, 2013#32
2012 Yaris L, 49.17 a month. 26 year old single male. Snapshot discount

BODILY INJURY & PROPERTY DAMAGE LIABILITY
BI $100,000 EACH PERSON - $300,000 EACH ACCIDENT
PROPERTY DAMAGE LIABILITY - $100,000 EACH ACCIDENT

COMPREHENSIVE ACV LESS $250 DEDUCTIBLE
COMPREHENSIVE WINDOW GLASS
$0 DEDUCTIBLE FOR WINDOW GLASS

COLLISION ACV LESS $500 DEDUCTIBLE

UNINSURED MOTORIST
$100,000 EACH PERSON - $300,000 EACH ACCIDENT
UNDERINSURED MOTORIST
$100,000 EACH PERSON - $300,000 EACH ACCIDENT
kc0rpmDecherd, TN · Mar 30, 2013#33
Damn, and I thought my insurance was high. Now I don't feel so bad. 136 a month for two vehicles and home owners ain't so bad afterall
jayehBritish Columbia, Canada · Mar 30, 2013#34
Anyone else from Canada shocked at how low the liability limits are in the states?

My company won't sell anything other than a 2 million dollar liability policy!
edmscanCanada · Mar 30, 2013#35
Originally Posted by jayeh ↑
Anyone else from Canada shocked at how low the liability limits are in the states?

My company won't sell anything other than a 2 million dollar liability policy!
Same here (I have 2 million as well) ... I think that is probably why we are seeing the rates in Canada are so much higher. Guess it all works out to bang for the buck.
nookandcrannycarS.MontgomeryCnty,TX(HoustonMSA) '07=BayouBlue=300,125miles=OrigOwnr '14=ClassicSilvr=29,059miles · Mar 31, 2013#36
Originally Posted by edmscan ↑
Same here (I have 2 million as well) ... I think that is probably why we are seeing the rates in Canada are so much higher. Guess it all works out to bang for the buck.
I would guess (not an educated guess as I have no information) that how low the companies go in Canada with their limits might have a basis in some law or regulation. I would think that the average accident in Canada would involve more damage than in the U.S. as a whole and that a significant reason would be that all of Canada experiences a 'Northern Winter'. In California, the minimum liability (at least within the least couple of years) hasn't changed in over 30 years at 15k/30k/5k. Here in the U.S. we have umbrella policies that usually require the total liability limit on the underlying policy to be at least 500k and kick in after that. The underlying policy limits are usually 500k or 750k and some companies will do 1 million. The umbrella policy adds an additional 1 million of liability coverage for typically $100 to $300 per year (not per month) depending on various factors. The umbrella policy also covers liability at your home (if someone trips and falls, for example) unrelated to vehicles. I'm just a diligent consumer, so anyone from the insurance industry please feel free to chime in. Of course some people purchase much higher limits.I heard Dave Ramsey say on the radio the other day (as part of an illustration during a call) that he personally carries an umbrella policy with a 10 million dollar limit and it costs him about $3500 per year. I wondered if 'Northern Winters' and strictness of various state laws in the U.S. might effect limits people choose. In looking at mr9865's post, my guess is that you would be hard pressed to find anyone in Texas, and especially in California making under $10.00 per hour who would carry anything more than the legal minimum. I wonder if the law in Wisconsin makes it prudent to have the limits he does.
FootPalm bay,Fl. · Mar 31, 2013#37
47 dollars a month for full coverage on a 2010 LB.
mr9865Green Bay WI · Mar 31, 2013#38
Originally Posted by nookandcrannycar ↑
I would guess (not an educated guess as I have no information) that how low the companies go in Canada with their limits might have a basis in some law or regulation. I would think that the average accident in Canada would involve more damage than in the U.S. as a whole and that a significant reason would be that all of Canada experiences a 'Northern Winter'. In California, the minimum liability (at least within the least couple of years) hasn't changed in over 30 years at 15k/30k/5k. Here in the U.S. we have umbrella policies that usually require the total liability limit on the underlying policy to be at least 500k and kick in after that. The underlying policy limits are usually 500k or 750k and some companies will do 1 million. The umbrella policy adds an additional 1 million of liability coverage for typically $100 to $300 per year (not per month) depending on various factors. The umbrella policy also covers liability at your home (if someone trips and falls, for example) unrelated to vehicles. I'm just a diligent consumer, so anyone from the insurance industry please feel free to chime in. Of course some people purchase much higher limits.I heard Dave Ramsey say on the radio the other day (as part of an illustration during a call) that he personally carries an umbrella policy with a 10 million dollar limit and it costs him about $3500 per year. I wondered if 'Northern Winters' and strictness of various state laws in the U.S. might effect limits people choose. In looking at mr9865's post, my guess is that you would be hard pressed to find anyone in Texas, and especially in California making under $10.00 per hour who would carry anything more than the legal minimum. I wonder if the law in Wisconsin makes it prudent to have the limits he does.

Just need the bare minimum here in Wisconsin, I was just raised to be well covered. And I dont really feel that poor making 9.50 a hour. Ive got a roof over my head, a nice car, and a computer.
nookandcrannycarS.MontgomeryCnty,TX(HoustonMSA) '07=BayouBlue=300,125miles=OrigOwnr '14=ClassicSilvr=29,059miles · Mar 31, 2013#39
Originally Posted by mr9865 ↑
Just need the bare minimum here in Wisconsin, I was just raised to be well covered. And I dont really feel that poor making 9.50 a hour. Ive got a roof over my head, a nice car, and a computer.
👍 Good for you. Truly. I think quite a few people fill their lives with 'consumerism' and still aren't happy, and I think one of the reasons for this is they lack gratitude, which you obviously have, and I have as well. I had terrible parents, but I had wonderful grandparents who were really more like my parents. I think a lot of people who aren't grateful and who aren't at peace missed having anyone who could give them a sane and grounded foundation. You got that and obviously appreciate it. Makes for a lot of inner peace 👍. In California there are likely some people whose attitude is as upstanding as yours but can't afford the extra cost (less so in Texas...I'm still continually amazed by how much less things cost here), but a larger number would be people who wouldn't entertain having more than the minimum liability because they don't have any assets and think to have a higher limit would simply be a waste of money. On a 'gratefulness note', I don't think I've ever met an unhappy first generation U.S. immigrant, no matter where they came from. Despite all our problems as a country, many people whose past is in another country feel grateful to be here.

P.S. A recent news story -- crazy IF it is true -- 7 billion people in the world. 6 billion have cell phones, but only 4.5 billion have access to a bathroom or latrine.
jayehBritish Columbia, Canada · Mar 31, 2013#40
Originally Posted by nookandcrannycar ↑
I would guess (not an educated guess as I have no information) that how low the companies go in Canada with their limits might have a basis in some law or regulation. I would think that the average accident in Canada would involve more damage than in the U.S. as a whole and that a significant reason would be that all of Canada experiences a 'Northern Winter'. In California, the minimum liability (at least within the least couple of years) hasn't changed in over 30 years at 15k/30k/5k. Here in the U.S. we have umbrella policies that usually require the total liability limit on the underlying policy to be at least 500k and kick in after that. The underlying policy limits are usually 500k or 750k and some companies will do 1 million. The umbrella policy adds an additional 1 million of liability coverage for typically $100 to $300 per year (not per month) depending on various factors. The umbrella policy also covers liability at your home (if someone trips and falls, for example) unrelated to vehicles. I'm just a diligent consumer, so anyone from the insurance industry please feel free to chime in. Of course some people purchase much higher limits.I heard Dave Ramsey say on the radio the other day (as part of an illustration during a call) that he personally carries an umbrella policy with a 10 million dollar limit and it costs him about $3500 per year. I wondered if 'Northern Winters' and strictness of various state laws in the U.S. might effect limits people choose. In looking at mr9865's post, my guess is that you would be hard pressed to find anyone in Texas, and especially in California making under $10.00 per hour who would carry anything more than the legal minimum. I wonder if the law in Wisconsin makes it prudent to have the limits he does.
The minimum liability coverage is $200,000. I've never seen a policy under $500,000 Most policies are $1 or $2 million.

It's a total cash grab since the government limits the maximum amount people have to pay out after an accident.

The thing is the difference between the bare minimum and the maximum is about $20 a year.
phaznetYGK · Mar 31, 2013#41
Originally Posted by nookandcrannycar ↑
Insane. Does that reflect any speeding or other tickets?
Nope. I let my license expire. I had to go through the whole licensing g1, g2, full G. Even though I've been driving +10 years they consider me a driver since 2011.
why?harnett county NC · Mar 31, 2013#42
For near state minimums I am 33 y/o single, and pay $748 a year. When I lived in Florida for about the same coverage I was paying $1400 a year.
nookandcrannycarS.MontgomeryCnty,TX(HoustonMSA) '07=BayouBlue=300,125miles=OrigOwnr '14=ClassicSilvr=29,059miles · Mar 31, 2013#43
Originally Posted by why? ↑
For near state minimums I am 33 y/o single, and pay $748 a year. When I lived in Florida for about the same coverage I was paying $1400 a year.
^^^^^ Not surprising. I like a fair number of things about Florida, but the way a lot of people drive (especially in 'South Florida') 😲 (which I imagine would drive up rates) isn't one of those things.
nookandcrannycarS.MontgomeryCnty,TX(HoustonMSA) '07=BayouBlue=300,125miles=OrigOwnr '14=ClassicSilvr=29,059miles · Mar 31, 2013#44
Originally Posted by phaznet ↑
Nope. I let my license expire. I had to go through the whole licensing g1, g2, full G. Even though I've been driving +10 years they consider me a driver since 2011.
SMH. Sounds as though jayeh's 'total cash grab' point also applies to your situation.
jayehBritish Columbia, Canada · Mar 31, 2013#45
Originally Posted by nookandcrannycar ↑
SMH. Sounds as though jayeh's 'total cash grab' point also applies to your situation.
Lapses in insurance are highway robbery. If you can't afford a car for a while they punish you by jacking your rates when you return. No matter what they are set to extract a certain amount of money from you... no matter what!
nookandcrannycarS.MontgomeryCnty,TX(HoustonMSA) '07=BayouBlue=300,125miles=OrigOwnr '14=ClassicSilvr=29,059miles · Mar 31, 2013#46
Originally Posted by jayeh ↑
Lapses in insurance are highway robbery. If you can't afford a car for a while they punish you by jacking your rates when you return. No matter what they are set to extract a certain amount of money from you... no matter what!
I wonder if the same situation in the U.S. causes a similar rate jackup ?
goliath1812Ocala Florida · Mar 31, 2013#47
Originally Posted by nookandcrannycar ↑
^^^^^ Not surprising. I like a fair number of things about Florida, but the way a lot of people drive (especially in 'South Florida') 😲 (which I imagine would drive up rates) isn't one of those things.
The way people drive, and also the fact that 25% of Florida drivers are doing so without insurance. The rest of us have to make up for it. Still much cheaper than Ontario though..
nookandcrannycarS.MontgomeryCnty,TX(HoustonMSA) '07=BayouBlue=300,125miles=OrigOwnr '14=ClassicSilvr=29,059miles · Mar 31, 2013#48
Originally Posted by goliath1812 ↑
and also the fact that 25% of Florida drivers are doing so without insurance.
Nice 🙄. I don't know what the figure is here in Texas, but I believe we have a percentage of people without health insurance that is higher than any other state 👎.
mrpjStaffordshire Moorlands, UK · Apr 1, 2013#49
From the prices being paid in the U.S., as stated in this thread, it makes a refreshing change for something in the U.K. to be cheaper (for some people)!
I pay $302 per annum, at today's exchange rate, for my 2010 5 door Yaris 1.4 Diesel. That's for comprehensive cover, legal cover and protected no claims discount. There's a $532 voluntary excess, which helps reduce the initial premium, to be paid in the event of a claim which I may recover for a no fault accident (that's part of the legal cover). If I didn't take out the optional legal cover the $302 would reduce to about $250/annum.
Uninsured drivers and injury, usually "whiplash", compensation claims (many fraudulent) increase our premiums too
94toy22reThread starterNorman · Apr 5, 2013#50
So I went shopping around today and went to liberty mutual, 60 a month with 100 deductible 👍 we're supposed to have hail/tornados next week so I'm covered, I'm 24 no accidents or tickets and live couple mile south of Oklahoma City.