I had an experience with a very small turbo -- Garrett GT1548
http://turbobygarrett.com/turbobygarrett/turbocharger So I though I could share :P
Before I start explaining the whole situation/setup I will give you my main idea about a ''too small'' turbo;
''NEVER AGAIN'' 1. When a turbo is too small, it is not working in is efficient area... I burnt 2 GT1548 because it was too small, overtime it put too much stress on the CHRA, with both brand new turbo the wheel fins scrapped the housing!
2. Low rpm power was a great gain over stock, lets say amazing :P But high end was a real bull****, N/A 1nzfe was faster at high rpm or high speed 100km/h+ :/
3.If you still choose to go small, get at least 3inch exhaust system from turbo to the back. My setup used a 2¼inch full turbo back straight pipe. Smaller turbo = huge exhaust, because smaller turbo creates a lot of backpressure!
I am now running a Garrett GT2252 turbo, this is the smallest turbo I would use with a stock 1nzfe engine & the CHRA is journal bearing so cheaper than ballbearing. I also got an extra Garrett GT2554R ballbearing which is the best turbo for a 1nzfe up to 200whp.
The GT2252 turbo is alright with my 2¼ exhaust, much less backpressure than the GT1548. Still 3'' would be the best.
I put the link for garrett website so you can compare my GT1548/GT2252 to yours!