Yarisworld Archive

Denied waterpump replacement

86 posts · 18,470 views · page 2 of 2

Replies continued

HersheyThread starternortheast · Jan 19, 2013#51
The other service center replaced it with no hesitation. The tech found coolant weeping from the pump. Had to wait 3 1/2 hours. They replaced the serpentine belt which we paid for with no charge for labor. Got a 15% discount on the belt and a new heavy duty 14 inch wiper blade. They filled the reservior above the FULL line by about 4 inches stating that it will get lower over time as it circulates and pockets of air get forced out. Is that correct? Did make a bit of a mess under the hood with coolant spilled on the splash guard, the intake manifold and on the engine cover. Could smell the coolant coming through the vents while driving on the interstate. After 90+ miles driving home everything seems fine. Will post pictures soon.
HersheyThread starternortheast · Jan 20, 2013#52
Pics :
DSCF1504.JPGDSCF1578.JPGDSCF1580.JPGDSCF1581.JPGDSCF1585.JPG
nookandcrannycarS.MontgomeryCnty,TX(HoustonMSA) '07=BayouBlue=300,125miles=OrigOwnr '14=ClassicSilvr=29,059miles · Jan 20, 2013#53
Originally Posted by Hershey ↑
The other service center replaced it with no hesitation. The tech found coolant weeping from the pump. Had to wait 3 1/2 hours. They replaced the serpentine belt which we paid for with no charge for labor. Got a 15% discount on the belt and a new heavy duty 14 inch wiper blade. They filled the reservior above the FULL line by about 4 inches stating that it will get lower over time as it circulates and pockets of air get forced out. Is that correct? Did make a bit of a mess under the hood with coolant spilled on the splash guard, the intake manifold and on the engine cover. Could smell the coolant coming through the vents while driving on the interstate. After 90+ miles driving home everything seems fine. Will post pictures soon.
👍Great to know they made you whole! Obviously a dealer to stick with (when you need a dealer) if you can. And now we know the best universal reason why the coolant level can go down in a healthy system. The color is kind of funky, and the smell when spilled on a hot surface isn't great, but I've never had a cooling system in any car (all parts and the coolant in my case) perform as well as the cooling system in my Yaris. I don't remember if I first uncovered this with reading, or with a parts person showing me on the computer parts diagram that the dealer and other entities have, but at that point I could see how the underside of the reservoir cap and the side of the reservoir were molded, allowing for any escape. After learrning this, I realized I could just leave my overfill above the full line alone, and I wouldn't have any negative consequences (and I haven't had any negative consequences). I just checked the level of my reservoir for the heck of it (couple of hours since I drove the car) and the level looks even higher above full than when I put coolant in above the fill line....and that coolant add was the last physical interaction I had with or authorized re the cooling system

My previous descriptions of the overflow channel on the reservoir could have been better. On the cap part of the channel, you only see some of what I previously mentioned on the parts diagram. All you see on the cap are the two holes (the ends of the cap part of the channel) on the underside of the cap. One of the holes is basically centered over the neck of the reservoir and the other one is aligned directly on top of the reservoir part of the channel. This is how it looks on my 2007, other Yari might be different, but why change it within the 2nd generation unless that part had a high fail rate (seems unlikely). My 'filling the coolant over the full line initial panic' happened in September of 2012, and (as I mentioned above) my cooling system is still performing very well. I don't think you need to worry. I hope the new water pump lasts the life of your Yaris 👍.

P.S. I hope this experience with the new dealership restores a bit of faith in Toyota for you. It is too bad you gave as much business as you did to a dealership that ended up not doing right by you.
nookandcrannycarS.MontgomeryCnty,TX(HoustonMSA) '07=BayouBlue=300,125miles=OrigOwnr '14=ClassicSilvr=29,059miles · Jan 20, 2013#54
Originally Posted by Hershey ↑
Pics :
My 'overfill with coolant above the fill line' in September brought the level to below where the dealership put your level, but my level as of a few minutes ago (after 2 + hours of not driving) is way above the level the dealership filled your reservoir to, and my system is performing well. It may be nothing (caused only by the angle of the picture) but it looks like (near the 'low end') the reservoir might have the start of a couple of cracks (not enough to yet leak). I was going to say have another pair of eyes look at it, possibly during the next service, but you do your own oil changes. The eyes of other members would help.
HersheyThread starternortheast · Jan 20, 2013#55
Just took these pictures about 10 minutes ago of the cold coolant level overnight . It's now an inch or so under the FULL line . Quite a drop from when the coolant was hot an hour or so after getting home . Picture of Hot level from last night and the cold level today ( 35 degrees outside ) . Hopefully all is well .
DSCF1578.JPGDSCF1628.JPGDSCF1629.JPG
HersheyThread starternortheast · Jan 20, 2013#56
Here's the new hot level from earlier ( 40+ mis. & 30 degrees ) . The other from last night ( 90+ mis. + 42 degrees ) . The other pic is the cold level before leaving earlier today . Should there be such a drop in the Hot level ? Could the difference in the temps and miles traveled make for the drop between the 2 Hot levels ? Air pockets being expelled from the system as well ? I guess time will tell .
DSCF1643.JPGDSCF1578.JPGDSCF1629.JPG
nookandcrannycarS.MontgomeryCnty,TX(HoustonMSA) '07=BayouBlue=300,125miles=OrigOwnr '14=ClassicSilvr=29,059miles · Jan 21, 2013#57
Originally Posted by Hershey ↑
Just took these pictures about 10 minutes ago of the cold coolant level overnight . It's now an inch or so under the FULL line . Quite a drop from when the coolant was hot an hour or so after getting home . Picture of Hot level from last night and the cold level today ( 35 degrees outside ) . Hopefully all is well .
This falls along the line of my observation from post #53 -- when I 'overfilled with coolant above full' my engine was cold and this level was lower than my hot observation from post #53. I think the difference between 1 hour after driving and 2 hours after driving wouldn't be much. Plus you live in a colder climate.
nookandcrannycarS.MontgomeryCnty,TX(HoustonMSA) '07=BayouBlue=300,125miles=OrigOwnr '14=ClassicSilvr=29,059miles · Jan 21, 2013#58
Originally Posted by Hershey ↑
Here's the new hot level from earlier ( 40+ mis. & 30 degrees ) . The other from last night ( 90+ mis. + 42 degrees ) . The other pic is the cold level before leaving earlier today . Should there be such a drop in the Hot level ? Could the difference in the temps and miles traveled make for the drop between the 2 Hot levels ? Air pockets being expelled from the system as well ? I guess time will tell .
As long as you don't notice any leaks, or weeping (unlikely unless the new pump wasn't installed properly, which I think would be very unlikely), I think you will be fine. My hot and cold level difference is much grater than yours (and my system is fine), so if your hot vs cold level difference increases, I wouldn't worry about it. Does your reservoir appear to have any cracks in it? Or is that just something I'm seeing in your previous pictures that doesn't represent any possible cracks?
HersheyThread starternortheast · Jan 21, 2013#59
Nook , where do you see a possible crack in the resorvoir ? Thanks for all your input .
nookandcrannycarS.MontgomeryCnty,TX(HoustonMSA) '07=BayouBlue=300,125miles=OrigOwnr '14=ClassicSilvr=29,059miles · Jan 21, 2013#60
Originally Posted by Hershey ↑
Nook , where do you see a possible crack in the resorvoir ? Thanks for all your input .
You're welcome. One somewhat to the right of the word LOW and one along the 'ridge' below the word LOW. I don't know anything re how to do the 'circling' (to emphasize/isolate within a picture) that you do, nor the arrows, or I'd try one of those or both.
HersheyThread starternortheast · Jan 21, 2013#61
Quite sure it's not a leak . Would of noticed coolant on top of the splash guard .
nookandcrannycarS.MontgomeryCnty,TX(HoustonMSA) '07=BayouBlue=300,125miles=OrigOwnr '14=ClassicSilvr=29,059miles · Jan 22, 2013#62
Originally Posted by Hershey ↑
Quite sure it's not a leak . Would of noticed coolant on top of the splash guard .
👍
HersheyThread starternortheast · Jan 22, 2013#63
Taken earlier . Looks to be staying at about same level while HOT .
DSCF1648.JPGDSCF1644.JPG
HersheyThread starternortheast · Jan 23, 2013#64
New cold level today at 11 degrees compared to Sunday cold level at 35 degrees . Car sat overnight for both pictures .
DSCF1653.JPGDSCF1629.JPG
nookandcrannycarS.MontgomeryCnty,TX(HoustonMSA) '07=BayouBlue=300,125miles=OrigOwnr '14=ClassicSilvr=29,059miles · Jan 23, 2013#65
Looks from the levels (and comparing them to your last set of pictures, etc.) that the 'working its way into the system/air coming out' that this dealer previously mentioned might/would happen is happening.
muffin_topMidwest · Jan 23, 2013#66
First off, I'm glad another dealership was able to handle your problem properly and replace the bad pump. It was without a doubt the right thing to do.

Couple of questions: The first dealer stated that a regional technician (actually called a field technical specialist) looked at the vehicle and called it ok? I find that hard to believe. Was the car written up and in the shop on a legit repair order or did they just take a peek undocumented? An FTS will not inspect a vehicle without it being on a legit RO and likely wouldn't look at something as trivial as a water pump. Just smells fishy. Always get the names of these people as they are not closely guarded secrets.

Always insist that the car is formally written up and you get copies of results of the inspection. No technician that I know would have shipped that car with the described condition and called it ok. Granted, as someone else mentioned earlier the time paid by his Platinum contract is the same a conventional warranty, it is considered a taxable, customer pay type transaction and the dealer is fully reimbursed on the next months statement.

Also keep in mind that calling Toyota is the best thing if you can't get proper recourse from a dealer. They open a case that the dealer has to respond to quickly. Failing to do so is not a good thing for the dealer. It has been my experience that if you call them an plead a reasonable case, Toyota will help. They really have gone above and beyond to take care of some of our customers problems when the need has risen.

Loyalty is also a good thing. For those that have a dealer nearby, get your car serviced there. I know not every dealer is super friendly or a good deal from a price standpoint, but do your homework and find a dealer you can work with. That relationship would have come in very handy for Hershey. Many people have had bad experiences at dealerships and feel that they are crooks etc.. I'm sure this stuff does happen, I've seen it first hand and that's why its best to do your homework. Find a dealer with a good rating and build a relationship with them. Many times taking it to the people that know your car best is cheaper and or less time consuming in the long run. Had the technician discovered this leak during the inspection, he may have repaired this concern without intervention on your behalf.

Hopefully the dealership that repaired your car gets your future service business, sounds like they are trying to earn your trust.
nookandcrannycarS.MontgomeryCnty,TX(HoustonMSA) '07=BayouBlue=300,125miles=OrigOwnr '14=ClassicSilvr=29,059miles · Jan 23, 2013#67
Originally Posted by muffin_top ↑
First off, I'm glad another dealership was able to handle your problem properly and replace the bad pump. It was without a doubt the right thing to do.

Couple of questions: The first dealer stated that a regional technician (actually called a field technical specialist) looked at the vehicle and called it ok? I find that hard to believe. Was the car written up and in the shop on a legit repair order or did they just take a peek undocumented? Cardinal sin at Toyota: An FTS will not inspect a vehicle without it being on a legit RO and likely wouldn't look at something as trivial as a water pump. Just smells fishy. Always get names, the FTS' phone number would not be given but not uncommon for a first name.

Always insist that the car is formally written up and you get copies of results of the inspection. No technician that I know would have shipped that car with the described condition and called it ok. Granted, as someone else mentioned earlier the time paid by his Platinum contract is the same a conventional warranty, it is considered a taxable, customer pay type transaction and the dealer is fully reimbursed on the next months statement.

Also keep in mind that calling Toyota is the best thing. They open a case that the dealer has to respond to quickly. Failing to do so is not a good thing for the dealer. It has been my experience that if you call them an plead a reasonable case, Toyota will help. They really have gone above and beyond to take care of some of our customers problems when the need has risen.

Loyalty is also a good thing. For those that have a dealer nearby, get your car serviced there. I know not every dealer is super friendly or a good deal from a price standpoint, but do your homework and find a dealer you can work with. That relationship would have come in very handy for Hershey. Many people have had bad experiences at dealerships and feel that they are crooks etc.. I'm sure this stuff does happen, I've seen it first hand and that's why its best to do your homework. Find a dealer with a good rating and build a relationship with them.
Good to know this. Another point that makes me want to buy another Toyota when my Yaris gets to the end of its life. There are already more Toyota and Lexus vehicles in my extended family than those from all other manufacturers, and each person has had a great ownership experience.
HersheyThread starternortheast · Jan 23, 2013#68
The dealer that turned down the waterpump is where the car was bought . We also purchased a '08 3 door Yaris through them . Traded in a '00 Corolla and an '07 Prius . So , loyalty doesn't always apply . The service manager and general manager of that dealership said it was a regional tech ( field tech . ) that found it to be fine . Were they lying , I don't know . Seems like the service center that repaired the car wouldn't of replaced the pump if a regional ( field ) tech stated the pump to be fine . Called TOYOTA of our concern of loosing coolant and the denial for the pump . They gave a case number . Last , the service manager of where the car was repaired told me the least the 1st service center could of done was to top off the reservoir , which they didn't . Also said it's a sealed system and shouldn't be loosing coolant and set up an appointment . The day the pump was replaced the service advisor and technician said they have replaced other pumps on other YARIS . Had 2 waterpumps in stock . We got one of them . We have both work orders . May post those for proof . Hopefully all is well with the car .
CoryMWhite Rock BC · Jan 23, 2013#69
Glad to see it got fixed. Do not get too worked up about the level of the coolant reservoir. It is just that, a reserve. You will find over time it goes lower anyhow as the water evaporates out of the un-sealed tank.

As the engine gets hot, the pressure increases in the cooling system. Once it hits around 16psi, the radiator cap releases pressure to keep it from getting too high. This causes coolant to pass through the hose, and into the tank. The neat thing (that they figured out by accident) is that once the engine cools down, it will create a vacuum and suck coolant back from the tank, keeping the cooling system topped off. So when you say, replace a waterpump, and have some air in the system, it will get burped out, and coolant will be pulled back into the system when it cools down.

Check the level after a day or two of driving, after that just keep it somewhere around full line. It's not a critical amount of fluid.
nookandcrannycarS.MontgomeryCnty,TX(HoustonMSA) '07=BayouBlue=300,125miles=OrigOwnr '14=ClassicSilvr=29,059miles · Jan 23, 2013#70
I felt that what Muffin Top is trying to say is to make sure that Toyota (at the manufacturer level) is properly notified, as it would be a strong backup for satisfaction even if one is not getting satisfaction from a particular dealer. This gives me added peace of mind. The tone of Muffin Top's post adds credibility. It think he takes the reputation for customer satisfaction that Toyota has been known for in the past quite seriously.
HersheyThread starternortheast · Jan 23, 2013#71
The other 1/2 called and left a message to the general manager of the 1st dealership asking for the field tech's name and how to get in touch with him . Never heard back from him to this day . That's what I call courteous . They won't be getting a penny more from us .
HersheyThread starternortheast · Jan 23, 2013#72
Will post more pics of the level as time goes by . Especially if a major drop .
nookandcrannycarS.MontgomeryCnty,TX(HoustonMSA) '07=BayouBlue=300,125miles=OrigOwnr '14=ClassicSilvr=29,059miles · Jan 23, 2013#73
Originally Posted by Hershey ↑
The other 1/2 called and left a message to the general manager of the 1st dealership asking for the field tech's name and how to get in touch with him . Never heard back from him to this day . That's what I call corteous . They won't be getting a penny more from us .
👍 Good for you. I'd say if the 2nd dealership's work holds up, they deserve the first look at your business should you change your mind and consider a Toyota again.
nookandcrannycarS.MontgomeryCnty,TX(HoustonMSA) '07=BayouBlue=300,125miles=OrigOwnr '14=ClassicSilvr=29,059miles · Jan 23, 2013#74
Originally Posted by Hershey ↑
Will post more pics of the level as time goes by . Especially if a major drop .
👍
HersheyThread starternortheast · Jan 25, 2013#75
Update for records . Looks to be holding fairly steady at the HOT level .
DSCF1660.JPGDSCF1648.JPGDSCF1653.JPG
muffin_topMidwest · Jan 25, 2013#76
Originally Posted by nookandcrannycar ↑
I felt that what Muffin Top is trying to say is to make sure that Toyota (at the manufacturer level) is properly notified, as it would be a strong backup for satisfaction even if one is not getting satisfaction from a particular dealer. This gives me added peace of mind. The tone of Muffin Top's post adds credibility. It think he takes the reputation for customer satisfaction that Toyota has been known for in the past quite seriously.
Thank you, and yes I try to treat the guests at our service department with utmost care and sincerity. Toyota takes every call seriously, the analysts at the call center always follow up to make sure the issue was handled and ask if there is anything they can do to help. Not just every now and then, every time like its a religion!
Originally Posted by Hershey ↑
The other 1/2 called and left a message to the general manager of the 1st dealership asking for the field tech's name and how to get in touch with him . Never heard back from him to this day . That's what I call corteous . They won't be getting a penny more from us .
Yeah, contacting the GM seems like the right thing, but truthfully he/she is usually somewhat detached from the "back of the house". Honestly the parts/service director or fixed operations manager (the service manager's boss)
would be a better point of contact. Be calm, tell them what happened and see what they say. If this person blows you off then you know the poor attitude of the service dept is from the "top down" and trying to reason with them will be futile.

I feel awful when someone has an experience like this.. It gives dealership service departments a bad image and we're not all like that!
HersheyThread starternortheast · Jan 25, 2013#77
Was calm and polite . The guy before wasn't . He said about every bad name in the book and called the service manager a d*ck . Also stated he was tired of getting the F'ing' run around with his Scion IQ . After that I figured I would get no place . It's coolant under the hood . Movin' on and keepin' an eye to the reservoir .
nookandcrannycarS.MontgomeryCnty,TX(HoustonMSA) '07=BayouBlue=300,125miles=OrigOwnr '14=ClassicSilvr=29,059miles · Jan 26, 2013#78
Originally Posted by Hershey ↑
Was calm and polite . The guy before wasn't . He said about every bad name in the book and called the service manager a d*ck . Also stated he was tired of getting the F'ing' run around with his Scion IQ . After that I figured I would get no place . It's coolant under the hood . Movin' on and keepin' an eye to the reservoir .
One more question 😁 (can't remember if I asked you this before or not). Was the 'new' (2nd) dealer a higher volume dealer (appreciably) than the first one ?

The dealer closest to me (even though it is in Harris County, to the south of me) is Fred Haas Toyota World. Their new car inventory (last time I checked) was over 3,000 vehicles and they are the #1 Tundra dealer in the world. They are so generous with their time (as helpful in person as people are on Yarisworld) and realize (within reason) that helping customers help themselves generates good will. I wonder if this is because they are so high volume...they don't have to think about 'nickel and diming' people. Gullo Toyota in my county comes in a close second and they are also a high volume dealer (over 2,000 new cars in stock last time I checked).

When Bronsin started a thread last year about a visit to a relatively local Toyota dealer in/near Mt. Laurel, NJ, he wrote about the inventory being 'options laden' (my term,for lack of a better term). I checked the new car inventory (almost always on the dealer's website) for the dealership he mentioned and it was between 200-300. I looked at the same for all the dealers in the vicinity, and the only one that had barely 1k in new inventory was in Philadelphia. With this information, I thought 'I'm glad I live near a high volume dealership'.

P.S. looking at Muffin Top's last post, in relation to my thoughts in this post, I wonder if customer satisfaction at small dealerships vs satisfaction at larger dealerships is something Toyota looks at at an 'above the dealership' level.
HersheyThread starternortheast · Jan 26, 2013#79
It's a larger dealer than the other . The service advisor said the labor / parts(?) from the replacement is money in their pockets . Couldn't understand why the first dealer didn't need the $ .
nookandcrannycarS.MontgomeryCnty,TX(HoustonMSA) '07=BayouBlue=300,125miles=OrigOwnr '14=ClassicSilvr=29,059miles · Jan 26, 2013#80
Originally Posted by Hershey ↑
It's a larger dealer than the other . The service advisor said the labor / parts(?) from the replacement is money in their pockets . Couldn't understand why the first dealer didn't need the $ .
Perhaps the first dealer is small enough that they want a customer who is paying immediately in the 'time slot' that your repair would have taken up, rather than waiting to be reimbursed by Toyota.
HersheyThread starternortheast · Jan 29, 2013#81
1/29/13
DSCF1679.JPGDSCF1673.JPGDSCF1653.JPG
nookandcrannycarS.MontgomeryCnty,TX(HoustonMSA) '07=BayouBlue=300,125miles=OrigOwnr '14=ClassicSilvr=29,059miles · Jan 29, 2013#82
^^^^^ A testament to the quality of the cooling system in the Yaris and Toyota's pink coolant ----- I was just looking at trini_per4mance's '450k in 5 years' thread to see if he has posted any repairs since October 2012 (answer = no --- last repair posted = replacing the fan motor at 479k miles on 10-2-12) and I noticed that he did his first and only cooling system flush at 425k miles.
HersheyThread starternortheast · Feb 11, 2013#83
Found more spray under the hood since the replacement . Should this be happening ? Cleaned it off and will monitor it .
Kaotic LazagnaCentral Valley, CA · Feb 11, 2013#84
I don't think that should be happening unless some how some coolant was accidentally spilled onto the belt before driving the car, which would be unlikely.
nookandcrannycarS.MontgomeryCnty,TX(HoustonMSA) '07=BayouBlue=300,125miles=OrigOwnr '14=ClassicSilvr=29,059miles · Feb 11, 2013#85
Originally Posted by Kaotic Lazagna ↑
I don't think that should be happening unless some how some coolant was accidentally spilled onto the belt before driving the car, which would be unlikely.
^^^^^ This.
HersheyThread starternortheast · Feb 12, 2013#86
Don't forget the car was repaired on 1/18 and has been driven over 700 miles since the replacement . Find it nearly impossible that it's spilled coolant. Have done an oil change since and there was no fluid to be found . Always look for leaks while under the car . Hopefully the spray pattern won't be back . If so , will get a picture .