cali yarisOriginal postCanoga Park, CA · Jun 19, 2012#1I'm thinking about my next street car.
The Question: If it were going to be one of these two, which would you buy?
I'm not including a "neither" choice because I'd like opinions from people who would consider these two cars also. I know there are other good cars out there these days, but these two "grab" me. So here we go....
Fiat 500 Abarth
Picture not included in this copy
Scion FR-S
Picture not included in this copy
Replies 36
CTScottUSA, CT · Jun 19, 2012#2I love the Abarth, especially after seeing some really nice ones in Europe, but I think I'd buy an IQ over it, so for me between these two it would be the FR-S.
suckerfaceMilwaukee, WI · Jun 19, 2012#3To an extent, I agree with Scott. The Abarth, while an amazing little car, doesn't really grab me. Something about it's design doesn't do it. Same with the iQ and ForTwo.
The FR-S reminds me of the Tiburon, which I've always had a thing for. That, and with it being RWD, could lead to being MUCH more fun.
fnkngrvIn The Hotbox · Jun 19, 2012#4When you say street car Garm are you referring to leaving it be for the most part and not attempting to triple the HP/torque that it comes from the factory with? I guess the reason why I ask is because before I would make a determination it would hinge upon how upgrade friendly it would have to be. We all know how much Toyota locks things down, etc. From what I have seen there are already a lot of nifty things that you can do with the Abarth that don't have to be particularly crazy yet yield great improvements and the fun factor.
tk-421Dagobah · Jun 19, 2012#5I think the FR-S is way more mod-friendly (Scions always are). Plus RWD takes the cake IMO.
Jason@SportsCarDebary, FL · Jun 19, 2012#6The amount of goodies coming down the pipe for the Scion/Subi are ridiculous. 👍 Looks like a fun car with a lot of possibilities.
The Fiat... Do you really need a slower egg? 👎
TamagoOff Grid · Jun 19, 2012#7FRS. RWD!
johnny_vitzHamilton, Canada · Jun 19, 2012#8Definitely FR-S
GolddeenohColumbia, SC · Jun 19, 2012#9FR-S is an awesome Toyota, and the aftermarket will be similar to the aftermarket of the tC or other Scions. plus it drives different and will be more fun to drive. The Fiat is over priced garbage that isn't really worth you getting unless the criteria for the car is the "Micro" factor, but you can always include the FR-S into that group as it isn't a big vehicle. plus the space under the hood will make space for good turbos. the FR-S also reminds me of a simple little supra puppy that just wants to go play.
jpmck03USA · Jun 19, 2012#10You already have a hot hatch that is a labor of love... no need to buy another...
I sat in an FR-S last week when I went to the Toyota dealership (little sister is getting a new Yaris!). Let me tell you, just sitting in it inside the showroom and I was already drooling by the time I sat down...
🤤
KioshiFremont, CA · Jun 19, 2012#11FR-S.
I'm subscribed to JapanParts and....the ridiculous amount of aftermarket parts coming out from Japan for the Toyota 86 & Subaru BRZ is insane.
FR-S all the way.
New line, new experiences, and new meaning to driving.
Klink10910 · Jun 20, 2012#12Street meaning daily driver? The Fiat. Another to modify? The FR-S.
cali yarisThread starterCanoga Park, CA · Jun 20, 2012#13Thanks everyone. I did mean daily driver. And I'm trying to think of it independently of also owning the Yaris, even though that's difficult.
13-0. Wow.
YaristeveLos Angeles · Jun 20, 2012#14 Originally Posted by
jpmck03 ↑ You already have a hot hatch that is a labor of love... no need to buy another...
🤤
Originally Posted by
Tamago ↑ FRS. RWD!
RWD FTW!!!!
Oh, BTW, I plan to buy an FRS next year (waiting for new car bugs (if any) to be sorted and "gee whiz" dealer markups to subside). I don't see any point to buying the Fiat since you (I) already have a Yaris.
vtencolumbus · Jun 20, 2012#15Or sell the Yaris to me and get the fr-s... Lol
I test drove the fiat , less impressed other than the exhaust note. I'm comparing to my supercharged Yaris off course .... Can't imagine compare to your white devil .
Saw the fr-s in person yesterday, took a couple pics ...but I'm too afraid to get into the car , even though the owner gave me his permission ..... I'm afraid I would go to the dealership to get a hold of one .
The owner said the handling is amazing ... It'll be a good dd for you , Garm.
And if you starting to itch , coming from the joining world of Subaru and Toyota, the mods would be abundant !!
Just my .02cent
suckerfaceMilwaukee, WI · Jun 20, 2012#1617-1...I think you have your answer.
And use it as a DD? Garm? I don't believe that for a second. I'm expecting 350+ whp on that thing within a year of your purchase. ;0)
why?harnett county NC · Jun 20, 2012#17From what I've read everyone that has one is madly in love with the FR-S. Handling is almost too aggressive from what a lot of people are saying, especially with the Prius tires.
Plus there are constant rumors of factory boost coming.
thebarberGrand Rapids, MI · Jun 20, 2012#18Factory f/I FTW.
ShroomsterOrlando · Jun 20, 2012#19 Originally Posted by
why? ↑ From what I've read everyone that has one is madly in love with the FR-S. Handling is almost too aggressive from what a lot of people are saying, especially with the Prius tires.
Plus there are constant rumors of factory boost coming.
Prius tires?
@Garm:
if we were getting the unfiltered abarth ss, I'd say go with that for DD....but we are not.....
why?harnett county NC · Jun 22, 2012#20 Originally Posted by
Shroomster ↑ Prius tires?
@Garm:
if we were getting the unfiltered abarth ss, I'd say go with that for DD....but we are not.....
The tires the FR-S comes with are very thin 17's that originally were on the Prius as a sport option.
While I don't think they are low traction eco tires, they are nowhere near as grippy as the top of the line tires most enthusiasts would choose.
ShroomsterOrlando · Jun 22, 2012#21Oh gotcha.
thebarberGrand Rapids, MI · Jun 23, 2012#22Fr-s has 215-45-17....not exactly narrow for an OEM tire. Miatas only have 205 17's
fnkngrvIn The Hotbox · Jun 23, 2012#23toadbowser's castle · Jun 23, 2012#24 Originally Posted by
why? ↑ The tires the FR-S comes with are very thin 17's that originally were on the Prius as a sport option.
While I don't think they are low traction eco tires, they are nowhere near as grippy as the top of the line tires most enthusiasts would choose.
i've read somewhere that they intentionally put those tires on so that the car can more easily get loose. i don't know - maybe that's true or maybe they just had a lot of prius tires laying around? either way i vote for the fr-s! 👍
eTiMaGoBangkok, Thailand · Jun 23, 2012#25Or maybe they know that 95% of owners will put on some new wheels and rubber anyhow :D
craigqOttawa · Jun 23, 2012#26Oil change on the FR-S will be dead simple compared to the Abarth 😁
cali yarisThread starterCanoga Park, CA · Jun 23, 2012#27^ Well that does it right there! 😆
craigqOttawa · Jun 23, 2012#28 Originally Posted by
cali yaris ↑ ^ Well that does it right there! 😆
Glad I could be of help 👍 😆 Honestly though, there's nothing like difficult or moronic maintenance to make me hate a car (how difficult can it be to engineer the vehicle for simple maintenance 😕 )
I guess I would have to test drive both to see which one I prefer. Neither would work well for me, as having 2-doors and kids can get old quick 🙁
why?harnett county NC · Jun 23, 2012#29 Originally Posted by
thebarber ↑ Fr-s has 215-45-17....not exactly narrow for an OEM tire. Miatas only have 205 17's
Depends what you compare it too. Stock wrx wheels are 235, genesis 225/245 f/r. I think 215 is a good size though, my Viggen had 215's. For the power they are a good choice. And they are cheaper since they are on other vehicles.
Originally Posted by
toad ↑ i've read somewhere that they intentionally put those tires on so that the car can more easily get loose. i don't know - maybe that's true or maybe they just had a lot of prius tires laying around? either way i vote for the fr-s! 👍
They did. There is an article where the Toyota engineers explained it all. The wide tires of today are good for high horsepower cars, but the wider a vehicle the harder it is to make the car handle. Just look at how some of the autocrossers on here are doing against some really expensive cars.
detroiterMetro Detroit · Jun 23, 2012#30Being from the Detroit area, I see TONS of cars that are unreleased, testing, etc all of the time from all of the manufacturers. I have to say that I'd go FR-S on this one. There's a person who drives an Abarth at my work and it looks good in person but it just doesn't do it for me. And the power just doesn't make up for it.
The FR-S needs about a one inch drop AT LEAST and it would be unbelieveably clean and smooth looking. My only gripe is the stealership markup. I watched a recent dyno and the FR-S is only putting down about 150hp or so, which after powertrain loss, isn't too bad. I hear rave reviews from some local owners about how it stays flat like no other in the corners and it basically does what you want it to, very controllable almost like the Rx8 (but I don't think it's as forgiving and easy to drive as that car).
I'd do FR-S if you can get a reasonable price.
tk-421Dagobah · Jul 19, 2012#31markitectMichigan · Aug 5, 2012#32I went with an FR-S. It handles great stock, and stays nice and flat. It is a little tail happy, but it is some amazing fun.
1 attachment not included in this copy
toadbowser's castle · Aug 5, 2012#33^nice! VERY jealous right now.
cali yarisThread starterCanoga Park, CA · Aug 5, 2012#34^ Markitect, is that you with a helmet on?
ChitownY@RisChicago · Aug 6, 2012#35For the sake of argument, I'd say get an FRS. But back to my opinion, the styling is extremely boring and conservative, and would never stand out to me in gridlock traffic. With a hideous front that resembles a Tiburon without makeup, and a rear that looks like an s2000, styling wise, it looks very been there seen that.
When I sat in one in the showroom, I was appalled at how cheap everything looked and felt. Was really surprised that I was sitting in a $30K car.
Obviously though after Garm is done modding it, it will be a far cry from stock, lol.
markitectMichigan · Aug 6, 2012#36 Originally Posted by
cali yaris ↑ ^ Markitect, is that you with a helmet on?
Yup, that is me going around Waterford Hills.
auxmikeLI, New Yawk · Aug 12, 2012#37Dare I say I like the Fiat better? The Fiat stands out looks wise and appears to have lots of goodies already installed from the factory. The FRS looks kinda like a Hyundai. Not a very exciting design. Also, living in the Northeast rear drive is pretty much a no go in winter. I'm sure the Fiat is probably not very reliable, and there's only one dealer in my county I'd be stuck using..... I'm thinking Fiat will last 2-3 years more max since they just don't seem seem to sell well at all as compared to the Minis...... Remember the Daewoo Lanos, Nubria, and Leganza??? Daihatsu Charade and Rocky? Or perhaps the Yugo GV? All gone!