Replies continued
daf62757Thread starterIndianapolis, Indiana · Dec 22, 2011#51 Originally Posted by
bronsin ↑ Sadly, the day of the diesel engine as an economic proposition is over. Diesel fuel is over 25% more expensive than gasoline, effectively nullifying any advantage it used to have. When you factor in the added premium of a diesel engine over a gas powered one that is the final nail in the coffin.
No the most cost effective engine is a small gas one in the lightest car possible.
Yea....no! I think your thinking is reminiscent of early times when US auto makers tried to produce diesels and failed....as most US manufactures do! There is a new generation of diesel engines that are clean burning and offer 20 to 30 percent better gas mileage than a gas engine of the same size. Now if diesel fuel, when comparing mileage vs cost, is more expensive than regular unleaded gas, then you comments holds true. But if the mileage is better and cheaper even when factoring in more expensive fuel, then diesel is a good alternative.
As more people start to use diesel, you can expect the price to drop as more dealers carry more non-freight diesel. Not the landslide of savings and increased mileage, but for those who pinch pennies, it might be a winning long term alternative.
TLyttleKeremeos BC · Dec 23, 2011#52You ain't old enough, Big Dave. No one here knows about the Cummins-powered racers at Indy in the 30s! They did well, without all the razzmatazz of, say, the later Novi. A lesson wasted on people who could buy Gasoline for 15c a gallon....
bronsinnj · Dec 23, 2011#53You need help if you think the Yaris is outdated.
Quality NEVER gets old.
Diesel=Hybrid=Jerkoff.
Diesel option costs nearly what the hybrid option does. (compared to buying a Yaris)
Diesel fuel is currently 25% MORE than gasoline. Explain how paying a premium for a diesel engine PLUS 25% more for fuel is going to cost LESS.
I await your answer and if you are right I will be the firt to admit it.
Originally Posted by
daf62757 ↑ Here is a question for you. Is the Yaris outdated? Seems like there are many other models....some much larger....that give you equal to if not better than gas mileage.
I bought my Yaris for a specific purpose to drive back and forth to Chicago and wanted a car that gave me great mileage. Hyundai, Kia, GM, and other car makers have quickly closed the gas mileage gap and overtaken the Yaris.
So that begs the question, is the Yaris outdated? The 2012 new generation model is basically the exact engine and transmission(s) of the earlier generation and no difference in mileage. I was hoping that Toyota would give us a smaller gas engine or even, I dare to say, a clean diesel engine that could produce some super mileage.
I would trade my 2009 model in for a diesel Yaris.
Any thoughts?
Edwin5000Chicago · Dec 25, 2011#54Diesels and hybrids are good. Manufacturers are finding that people WILL pay a premium for efficient cars. I know that I will seriously consider a Prius c along with the Yaris next spring when I buy a car.
Any 'Yota made in Japan is a great 'Yota.
bronsinnj · Dec 27, 2011#55 Originally Posted by
Edwin5000 ↑ Diesels and hybrids are good. Manufacturers are finding that people WILL pay a premium for efficient cars.
Which car would cost LESS to buy and drive for 100,000 miles, a Prius or a Yaris?
Well, lets see!
Yaris = $15,000
Prius = $25,000
Oh my my my you just spent $10,000 more if you bought a Pruis!
Now for 100,000 miles at $3 a gallon assuming your Prius gets 40 miles per gallon you are going to spend $7500 for gas.
At 30 mpg for the Yaris you will spend $10,000.
Well gee golly willikers you spent $10,000 more and SAVED $2500 by buying a Prius instead of a Yaris!
That cost you $7500!
What you did was take the money you would have given to Exxon and gave it instead to Toyota! And, you're so considerate of others, you gave Toyota a $7500 BONUS besides!
How NICE of you!
And all because you want to drive a more fuel efficient car!
Still LearningLansing, MI · Dec 27, 2011#56That doesn't even take into consideration all the batteries that you have to eventually replace in the Prius.
TLyttleKeremeos BC · Dec 28, 2011#57Not so far, by what I hear. Our local dealer says that the have yet to hear of a battery replacement anywhere in North America. Also, the price has gone down significantly since the pack was introduced.
Just what I hear...
daf62757Thread starterIndianapolis, Indiana · Dec 29, 2011#58 Originally Posted by
TLyttle ↑ You ain't old enough, Big Dave. No one here knows about the Cummins-powered racers at Indy in the 30s! They did well, without all the razzmatazz of, say, the later Novi. A lesson wasted on people who could buy Gasoline for 15c a gallon....
I think I was referring to the diesels that GM tried to sell back in the 80s. They were junk....as are most GM products.
daf62757Thread starterIndianapolis, Indiana · Dec 29, 2011#59 Originally Posted by
bronsin ↑ You need help if you think the Yaris is outdated.
Quality NEVER gets old.
Diesel=Hybrid=Jerkoff.
Diesel option costs nearly what the hybrid option does. (compared to buying a Yaris)
Diesel fuel is currently 25% MORE than gasoline. Explain how paying a premium for a diesel engine PLUS 25% more for fuel is going to cost LESS.
I await your answer and if you are right I will be the firt to admit it.
The Yaris is getting old. The engine is old, there are other cars that are starting to get 40 mpg, and Yaris is essentially the same car as it was back in 2006. In today's world of car's being completely redesigned every 3 to 4 years, having basically the same car in 2012 as 2006 leads you to think it is outdated. I don't know if the term quality is what I think of when I think of the Yaris. Do a google search on quality car and Yaris doens't come up. Reliable, yes....quality...no. Its cheap, has the basics, and and will last over 300K miles so longevity and quality don't meet at the Toyota dealer under the line of Yaris cars.
As for the diesel, I think if enough are produced, the cost will not be 25% more. I personally would like to have one as it would give you better mileage. Now I don't know the cost of diesel fuel in your area, but here in Indy, diesel fuel is only 7& more expensive.
Multiple the savings by 300k miles and I believe you will come out ahead in the long run.
bronsinnj · Dec 30, 2011#60 Originally Posted by
TLyttle ↑ Not so far, by what I hear. Our local dealer says that the have yet to hear of a battery replacement anywhere in North America. Also, the price has gone down significantly since the pack was introduced.
Just what I hear...
That is substantially correct. The batteries dont fail, last a long time, and replacements are on ebay for half what the dealer wants.
Having said that the car is a total ripoff. Bottom line it makes no sense whatsoever.
bronsinnj · Dec 30, 2011#61The ECHO got 40 mpg + back in 2000. How nice the so call "new and improved" models from other companies are "starting" to get 40 mpg.
I would argue the Yaris is a step in the wrong direction from the ECHO. It is heavier. Remember the 1985 Honda Civic? The one that got ~50 mpg highway?
What are the "new and improved" ones getting, huh? 35 mpg hiway?
And I do not believe for one second those claims of Ford and others with larger engines than the ECHO/Yaris that they get an honest 40 mpg. No sir!
The 1.5 liter engine in the ECHO/Yaris is the best small engine made today by a large margin. Nothing else comes close. MPG wise and powerwise (106 hp)
Although the "engine of the future" is even smaller IMO.
Before you buy one of these "cutting edge cars of the future" with a hybrid or diesel engine that will "pay off after 300,000 miles" (are you kidding me?!)
all I ask is you DO THE MATH beforehand.
Originally Posted by
daf62757 ↑ The Yaris is getting old. The engine is old, there are other cars that are starting to get 40 mpg, and Yaris is essentially the same car as it was back in 2006. In today's world of car's being completely redesigned every 3 to 4 years, having basically the same car in 2012 as 2006 leads you to think it is outdated. I don't know if the term quality is what I think of when I think of the Yaris. Do a google search on quality car and Yaris doens't come up. Reliable, yes....quality...no. Its cheap, has the basics, and and will last over 300K miles so longevity and quality don't meet at the Toyota dealer under the line of Yaris cars.
As for the diesel, I think if enough are produced, the cost will not be 25% more. I personally would like to have one as it would give you better mileage. Now I don't know the cost of diesel fuel in your area, but here in Indy, diesel fuel is only 7& more expensive.
Multiple the savings by 300k miles and I believe you will come out ahead in the long run.
TLyttleKeremeos BC · Dec 30, 2011#62Yeah, my buddy's Echo still gets better mileage than my Yaris, but it IS smaller. We could never been able to make it do as much as the Yaris, strictly because of its lack of room. Other than that, my main objection to the newer cars is the added BS that one must buy on a standard model. I don't NEED the alarms and other electronics; I just want a car that will move me from A to B with as little trouble as possible, using as little fuel as possible. 40mpg is not new to me; I was getting that from my cars in the 60s.
I do, however, enjoy the lack of corrosion built into today's cars, and the longevity they are showing. Somehow, I just know that it will be the damn electronics that will kill my Yaris...
sickpuppy1Kansas · Dec 31, 2011#63You guys may know it already, but I just read today that the 2012 is available in 3 door and 5 door only, no sedan this year, that sucks. When I have to get rid of this one, no more yaris for me.......waaaaa
daf62757Thread starterIndianapolis, Indiana · Jan 1, 2012#64 Originally Posted by
TLyttle ↑ Yeah, my buddy's Echo still gets better mileage than my Yaris, but it IS smaller. We could never been able to make it do as much as the Yaris, strictly because of its lack of room. Other than that, my main objection to the newer cars is the added BS that one must buy on a standard model. I don't NEED the alarms and other electronics; I just want a car that will move me from A to B with as little trouble as possible, using as little fuel as possible. 40mpg is not new to me; I was getting that from my cars in the 60s.
I do, however, enjoy the lack of corrosion built into today's cars, and the longevity they are showing. Somehow, I just know that it will be the damn electronics that will kill my Yaris...
Makes me remember cars that came with manual chokes and manual floor vents for ventilation. How long would today's cars last if they had these old systems?
bronsinnj · Jan 1, 2012#65[QUOTE=TLyttle;621242] 40mpg is not new to me; I was getting that from my cars in the 60s.
QUOTE]
Granted mileage was better in the 80s than it is today.
I know Honda Civics in 1985 got nearly 50 mpg highway. And my brothers 1983 Renault Alliance got 53 mpg when we were on a trip from Morgantown WV to Houston.
But what car(s) was it that got 40 mpg in the 60s?
TLyttleKeremeos BC · Jan 2, 2012#66Morris Minor for one. Mine got 59mpg Imp, but I helped it a bit. Minis got even better mileage, and a few other orphans got better than that on poorer fuel. I must admit that I go back to the 50s as well as the 60s, but in those days I couldn't afford gas guzzlers even at 35c/gal.
And I didn't mind adjusting my floor vents and manual chokes and starter buttons (they're back, fergodsakes!), it was just part of driving a car. We also had no-draft vents that worked very well indeed! I don't need my Minor back, but it wouldn't be any surprise or drawback.
bronsinnj · Jan 2, 2012#67My father adored his Moris Minor. There were not a lot of them in Brooklyn and that was long before foreighn cars became in any sense of the word acceptable so it was something of a cross to bear.
Especially driving across the GW Bridge in any kind of wind.
charles nelsonSt Cloud Minnesota · Jan 17, 2012#68I just read a new 2012 report that states that the new compact cars are more gas efficient than sub-compact. Partly because the compacts have slightly longer chassis which allow a better airflow than the short stubby sub-compacts.
With the 55-mpg rules coming on in a few years a lot of aerodynamic studies have been done. Most subcompacts also have nearly vertical rear ends to maximize rear seat-rear storage space. Engineers have not been able to smooth the airflow as much as the longer compacts' rear sheet metal.
Both GM and Toyota are finding that their newly designed compacts are getting 40-50 mpg while their sub-compacts are struggling to reach 40 mpg.
DamoPerth, Western Australia · Jan 18, 2012#69Luckily I didnt buy my Yaris being overly concerned with mileage.
For me it was all about the 14 cup holders :)
junorico24Sydney · Jan 20, 2012#70Here, in Sydney. Yaris are every where the 2nd generation is multiplying on the road.
Most are 3 doors hatch backs.I noticed that this year so many people are buying Yaris
docBWestern N.Y. · Jan 20, 2012#71Why isn't a prius diesel/battery car available? How come a Chevy volt doesn't have a tiny tubine? It would be great to run any type of full just to recharge the battery to power the thing to extended range. I think it would be awesome to loose all the airbags in exchange for all the stupid people who don't believe that driving requires one's undivided attention. I had an '89 Justy w/ the 3 hole engine and a CVT. Got over 49 mpg on a trip with it. It had a carb. The fuel we burn could give us better milage, too. Get rid of the alcohol. Look at F1 and the custom blends of full they got to make mileage and power at the end of the turbo era...
doc
TLyttleKeremeos BC · Jan 21, 2012#72In my experience, turbines are THIRSTY! Chrysler found that out 50 years ago, Rover before them. Here in the model builders world, miniature turbines are the rage, and their fuel loads are outrageous! I run small diesels, and the fuel tanks are really small; models running 90mph for miles on 1oz of fuel.
US safety laws have made sure that we must buy heavy vehicles so that we survive running into bridge abutments at 55mph; answer is not to run into bridge abutments at 55 mph. The extra weight costs us fuel, period.
malibuguyWestminster, MD · Jan 21, 2012#73I dont know how anyone gets below 40mpg in a yaris...i have to beat mine 100 % of the time to get low 40s
CanIHazYarisHatch?Texas · Feb 16, 2012#74It's not outdated.
It's PROVEN.
daf62757Thread starterIndianapolis, Indiana · Apr 5, 2012#75 Originally Posted by
TLyttle ↑ In my experience, turbines are THIRSTY! Chrysler found that out 50 years ago, Rover before them. Here in the model builders world, miniature turbines are the rage, and their fuel loads are outrageous! I run small diesels, and the fuel tanks are really small; models running 90mph for miles on 1oz of fuel.
US safety laws have made sure that we must buy heavy vehicles so that we survive running into bridge abutments at 55mph; answer is not to run into bridge abutments at 55 mph. The extra weight costs us fuel, period.
Government costs us money. Period!