Originally Posted by
YarisSedan ↑ Well rotational mass is going to be a big factor. The larger the rim typically the heavier it will be.
This is moving in the right direction, but misses out on the other key factor: distribution of mass.
Caution, physics ahead! This is a very general overview of the effects of diameter and mass on rotational acceleration. The numbers aren't terribly accurate, but it's meant to give an impression of why larger/wider/heavier tires and wheels hurt acceleration.
Two cylindrical shapes of equal mass but different distributions will exhibit very different acceleration, due to different
moments of inertia. For simplicity's sake, it's easier to evaluate a thin-walled cylinder, whose moment of inertia is its mass times the radius squared.
I = mr^2
Going from a 7.5" to 8" radius results in a pretty significant change in moment of inertia, assuming that the mass stays the same. I.e. 0.391*m lb*ft^2 vs 0.444*m lb*ft^2. In reality, a larger diameter (and typically larger width too) means an increase in mass as well, further increasing the moment of inertia. If we assume that half of the mass of the rim is in the outer ring, that a typical low end 15" rim weighs 14 lbs, and that a low end 16" rim weighs 15 lbs, the difference becomes even more pronounced. The 15" rim then has a moment of inertia of 2.73 lb*in^2 and the 16" rim is 3.33 lb*ft^2.
The real kick in the huevos comes from the calculation of acceleration, which is the torque divided by the moment of inertia (for constant acceleration only).
a = T/
I Assuming that torque is fixed (and it has to be for this equation) and our moment of inertia
I changes from 2.73 to 3.33, the
acceleration has to decrease to keep the equation balanced. I.e. 1/2.73 is larger than 1/3.33, meaning a larger acceleration value for the smaller/lighter rim.
"But Cranky," you say, "what if I get some super light weight rims?" Well, look back at the moment of inertia formula. Changing the weight has a very small effect on moment, but changing the radius has a huge impact. Even assuming that the distribution is the same, going from a 14 lb to a 12 lb wheel makes a very small dent in the numbers.
So having bored/scared/enlightened everyone, let me conclude by saying that ultimately, it comes down to what you're trying to achieve. If you want to show off how much you spent on them, go for some 18" rims. If you want bigger contact patches, get wider tires/rims. If you want firmer cornering, get lower profile tires. If you want better acceleration, get smaller diameter wheels. If you want higher top end speed, get bigger diameter tires. Mixing up these combinations can give interesting results: Jason@sportscar uses some crazy 13x10" rims with racing slicks on the track--huge contact patches, better acceleration, but at the cost of top end speed.