Yarisworld Archive

Is going 55 mph really the best speed?

61 posts · 30,258 views · page 1 of 2

fatlardOriginal postchicago burbs · Apr 27, 2011#1
I know many of you expressed going 55 mph the best speed but is that really the optimal point if you want to keep up with traffic while at the same time getting decent fuel economy

Replies 60

frownonfunRGV, Texas · Apr 28, 2011#2
i know it's not the optimal speed if your goal is to ALSO keep up with traffic. not in a 70mph zone anyway. i have a scooter that tops out at about 55-60 and i've had it out on the highway a few times. it's downright terrifying.
malibuguyWestminster, MD · Apr 28, 2011#3
its the best mileage parked in your driveway while you ride a bicycle...
thebarberGrand Rapids, MI · Apr 28, 2011#4
you want the lowest speed in the highest gear....

best mileage i ever got was 5.5L/100km (43mpg) while doing about 80-85km/h (50mph) on back roads in 5th gear. i accelerated slowly and downshifted while slowing down so the injectors don't run (vs neutral)

this was all during my 1000km engine break-in period...

ive never got that great an economy since, lol
2009ToyotoadCalifornia · Apr 28, 2011#5
Thought I read elsewhere on the forum that 68 mph was the optimal speed. That's usually my commute speed at 5:00 A.M. and 2:30 P.M. and the mpg is consistently 40.5 to 41.5.

edit: I'm feeling a little inspired this week, particularly today. I noted that today was "ride your bicycle to work day," and while that's not practical for me, running 55 mph during my commute was a resonable alternative. Looking forward to seeing my mpg numbers for the week.
STCState College, PA, USA · Apr 28, 2011#6
Maybe President Jimmy Carter knew what he was talking about? Eh? Of course he did... and it saves lives too! 😉

Cheers! 🙂
rningonfumesSoCal · Apr 28, 2011#7
LOL, going 55 with no metal cage around you will terrifying to anyone if cars are constantly passing you up.

Look if you want to do it, go ahead you'll get used to it, the fear of being hit will subside. Think about it this way, if you wouldn't want your front end hitting the back end of another car, why would other drivers want any different? Those drivers breathing down your ass won't want anything happening to their precious cars.

The argument about holding up traffic? I consider it null as along as you're on the far right on a major multi lane freeway. If a driver has a problem with not being able to use the far right to pass cars, the driver has problem because the far right is not a passing lane.

Basically do everything you can to help out the flow. I've notice that if the flow is high, the freeway is most likely open and there's room for people to pass on the left. If the flow is slow, there must be congestion, speeds as a whole are low. When traffic is high with high speeds? People like to travel in packs, that current pack of cars will pass soon enough.

Edit:

Use psychology, I've said this before to follow a truck, not for drafting purposes but to make people think it's the truck that is slow. People will see the truck before they see you and will prepare to pass you.
SKurjGTA · Apr 28, 2011#8
Until this past winter I was always in the fast lane always 120-140kmh and over the winter months rarely getting more than 550kms to a tank. This winter I backed it off, kept speeds 110ish and 650kms per tank has been rather easily accomplished, sometimes closing on 700kms...

Thats with the 04 echo HB which has 258,000kms on it... The new Yaris seems to be around the same mebbe a tiny bit better
fatlardThread starterchicago burbs · Apr 28, 2011#9
Well at cruise control at 55mph with a sedan auto have given 47mpg.... I guess I will stay at that speed
why?harnett county NC · May 7, 2011#10
55 was never the best speed for anything. It is really relative to a ton of stuff, and finding what is best for you takes time and lots of experimenting.
IdahotomIdahoi · May 8, 2011#11
My main drive is a 45 mph secondary road I drive at 47 (cruise set) and on the few level stretchs my ScanGauge always shows very high 40's MPG. Low 50's if I have a tailwind!
fatlardThread starterchicago burbs · May 9, 2011#12
So.. this past weekend, I drove 70mph on cruise control this weekend for about 200 miles and I got 45 mpg... so I am as confused as ever.... just more data.
daf62757Indianapolis, Indiana · May 9, 2011#13
Originally Posted by fatlard ↑
So.. this past weekend, I drove 70mph on cruise control this weekend for about 200 miles and I got 45 mpg... so I am as confused as ever.... just more data.
Could have been you had a great tailwind....flat terrain....or your Yaris was just in the "zone"!
daf62757Indianapolis, Indiana · May 9, 2011#14
Originally Posted by STC ↑
Maybe President Jimmy Carter knew what he was talking about? Eh? Of course he did... and it saves lives too! 😉

Cheers! 🙂
Jimmy Carter? Wow...now I am going to have nightmares! 😲😲😲
daf62757Indianapolis, Indiana · May 9, 2011#15
Originally Posted by fatlard ↑
I know many of you expressed going 55 mph the best speed but is that really the optimal point if you want to keep up with traffic while at the same time getting decent fuel economy
Here in Indiana, on the interstates, you would be a road hazard. You would save money, but it actually wouldn't be safe. 65 MPH is a better speed here for safety and it lets you keep up with the 18 wheelers.

Maybe on a state highway its a safe speed, but in too many places, you are an obstacle that people have to go around.
BEEFnorth carolina · May 9, 2011#16
looking at it strictly scientifically

I have seen graphs on aerodynamic drag that show there is a deflection point where drag increases sharply. the sharp increase is usually between 50 and 60 mph depending on the aerodynamics of the particular vehicle. I know I saw one that showed the optimum for a vehicle being 53MPH. I can't remember what vehicle was tested but I do remember it being old.

that may be where the whole 55MPH thing came from. it gives you the most speed for the least amount of drag.

there again, I may be reading way too much into the question.
TLyttleKeremeos BC · May 9, 2011#17
Somehow, it is the "saving lives" thing that got me. What was it? 40%? What a bonus, even if the percentage is wrong! Nowadays, the cars are keeping the numbers of deaths down, not the drivers: speed limits keep climbing, and US oil dependency follows suit.

Keep up to busy traffic, play P&G when one is on one's own, or whatever fuel-saving game one is into. Myself, I feel that I am driving one of the most fuel-efficent vehicles around, and the savings by hypermiling really ain't gonna make a big difference, considering how much fuel I COULD be burning...
frownonfunRGV, Texas · May 10, 2011#18
I hate to burst anyone's bubble but there is no real solid data that shows that having a national 55mph speed limit saved lives. Not only can it be shown that there were less annual deaths in some years before the Emergency Highway Energy Conservation Act was enacted but you also have to consider that even in the years there were fewer deaths during that period there were also less people on the road to begin with because of the oil crisis that prompted the passing of the EHECA in the first place.

Just sayin.
schumePNW · May 10, 2011#19
Originally Posted by BEEF ↑
looking at it strictly scientifically

I have seen graphs on aerodynamic drag that show there is a deflection point where drag increases sharply. the sharp increase is usually between 50 and 60 mph depending on the aerodynamics of the particular vehicle. I know I saw one that showed the optimum for a vehicle being 53MPH. I can't remember what vehicle was tested but I do remember it being old.

that may be where the whole 55MPH thing came from. it gives you the most speed for the least amount of drag.

there again, I may be reading way too much into the question.
When I worked in HVAC, I came across fan law which can be translated to cars. http://www.hvac-toolbox.com/fan-affi...aws-d_196.html

Aerodynamic drag and engine power needed changes exponentially with an increase in speed. That's why you can't regear a stock Yaris and go 200mph or use hypermiling techniques doing 90. (and expect anything good)

Speed kills.... fuel economy at least :)
tireUS · May 21, 2011#20
Originally Posted by thebarber ↑
you want the lowest speed in the highest gear...
this is correct, for any motor vehicle. anything short of bogging the motor will be ideal for fuel economy.
joe keeneyhemphill texas · Jun 3, 2011#21
55 you'll get flatten by a pick up down here,
PROX4x4CO · Jun 17, 2011#22
I got 45.1 Doing 55-60 MPH, no cruise control.
joe keeneyhemphill texas · Jun 25, 2011#23
55 not in texas you'll be a hood ornament on a pick up,
charles nelsonSt Cloud Minnesota · Jun 26, 2011#24
I average consistently mid-40s mpg while driving at 50 mph.
If there is no wind, the Yaris gets about 50 mpg at 50 mph. Mileage drops to about 40 mpg at 70 mph. At 30 mph I get high 50's mpg.
With a strong head wind I loose about 10 mpg.
IlovemyyarisUSA but it has green light? · Jul 23, 2011#25
I go about 55 plus or minus all the time. I generally get at least 40 or more mpg. Normally about 45 - 50 mpg if it's just highway.

People hate me for it though. Sometimes people honk, middle fingers, angry red necks shouting out the window, and etc. Not sure what's so hard about using the other lane for to pass. I've even seen some other people driving the Yaris wizz past me. Am I the only person who lives in GA who knows about this?

Sometimes I follow big rigs if I need to get somewhere faster. I don't do that much because I heard it's dangerous. Just wondering. Anyone know why exactly they say it's dangerous? As long as you're not right up on them. Doesn't it take them a lot longer to come to a stop than a small car?
rningonfumesSoCal · Jul 23, 2011#26
Well along with the stopping issues, trucks tend to kick up things real easily and there is also the possibility of a tire blow out. I see what you mean about the stopping but the latter two is what keeps me from drafting, that and truckers hate it.

LoL, at certain times while on the highway some truckers think I'm drafting them so they slow down to 55 or even 50 to try to shake me off. They don't realize I don't want to speed up.

One other point is that sometimes there is debris on the road that is nothing for a truck to run over but it might be too large for your car to handle. So if you are drafting you won't see this object and will not have time to avoid it.
badmofoSTL, MO · Aug 4, 2011#27
I drive the speed limit (60) to and from work, 70 miles total, all highway. I don't draft, I coast downhills, I use DFCO down steeper hills and when coming to a stop, Accelerate slowly. I've found it's not one thing you do to increase fuel mileage but a combination that gives the best results.
CosworthMI · Aug 4, 2011#28
i haven't found a magic speed that would allow me the highest mileage... having said that I get better mileage when I drive between 55-63mph in 5th gear. At this range, I get anywhere from 45-55 instant mpg according to ecometer. At 70mph, I usually get at least 41mpg on average.
marcustoronto, canada · Aug 4, 2011#29
47 mpg going 90 kph ; 55 mph 90% of the time fully loaded with a/c
caineroadToronto · Aug 7, 2011#30
Originally Posted by marcus ↑
47 mpg going 90 kph ; 55 mph 90% of the time fully loaded with a/c
there must be something wrong with your mpg meter or your calculation.

better yet tell us how many km or miles you can do in a full tank of gas.

im in canada, in my yaris full tank of gas 600km is pretty much top highway driving. That equals 41-42 US mpg

unless you can cover 800km in a full tank, how is 55 US mpg possible?


But conversion from 42 US mpg = 50 UK mpg are you referring to uk units?
rningonfumesSoCal · Aug 7, 2011#31
^ This year I've hit 522.9 (841.5km) miles on 9.877 Gallons. I've hit the magic 500 a couple more times this summer season.

55mph/no drafting(truckers usually are faster)/lots of highway/I like the down hills (you infer what you want).

If I'm alone, no A/C ever- just 1 inch down on both front windows. If I have passengers, I make them comfortable- only complaints I get is I drive too slow. Even my parents tell me to drive faster if they are the passengers.
caineroadToronto · Aug 8, 2011#32
Originally Posted by rningonfumes ↑
^ This year I've hit 522.9 (841.5km) miles on 9.877 Gallons. I've hit the magic 500 a couple more times this summer season.

55mph/no drafting(truckers usually are faster)/lots of highway/I like the down hills (you infer what you want).

If I'm alone, no A/C ever- just 1 inch down on both front windows. If I have passengers, I make them comfortable- only complaints I get is I drive too slow. Even my parents tell me to drive faster if they are the passengers.
841km wow.... impressive

manual tranny works better?
rningonfumesSoCal · Aug 8, 2011#33
Well, I like my 5speed. You don't have to have a manual for the mpg but it helps. There are people on YW who hit 50mpg quite readily who happen to have autos. What this means is it requires patience. The right weather does wonders as well.
caineroadToronto · Aug 8, 2011#34
Say if we are doing the same run of 75miles, considering 55mph vs 75mph. I would finish in exactly 1 hour. Whereas you are saving gas but going slower your car would be running longer, 20 mins more, wouldn't that balance off fuel consumption? Let's say we are both on cruise controls and no a/c, drafting or whatever affecting the car.
rningonfumesSoCal · Aug 9, 2011#35
Apples to oranges? The only thing wasted here is time which I would need to account for ie leave sooner.

You traveled 75 miles at 75 mph
I traveled 75 miles at 55 mph.

This was more complicated than it needed to be but I'll play.

75 miles / 40 mpg = 1.75 gallons used.
75 miles / 50 mpg = 1.50 gallons used.

I'm being conservative on both sets of numbers.

Let's try it differently.

10 gallons x 40 mpg = 400 miles
10 gallons x 50 mpg = 500 miles.

I like these numbers, easier math lol. I went an extra 100 miles over you at the expense of time. Doesn't matter really for daily commutes but the time might build up if it's say a road trip.
UltimateMonkyStatesboro, ga · Sep 16, 2011#36
Originally Posted by Ilovemyyaris ↑
I go about 55 plus or minus all the time. I generally get at least 40 or more mpg. Normally about 45 - 50 mpg if it's just highway.

People hate me for it though. Sometimes people honk, middle fingers, angry red necks shouting out the window, and etc. Not sure what's so hard about using the other lane for to pass. I've even seen some other people driving the Yaris wizz past me. Am I the only person who lives in GA who knows about this?

Sometimes I follow big rigs if I need to get somewhere faster. I don't do that much because I heard it's dangerous. Just wondering. Anyone know why exactly they say it's dangerous? As long as you're not right up on them. Doesn't it take them a lot longer to come to a stop than a small car?
I too live in Georgia and the thing I hate most here, and really most places I've driven, is passage ettiquite! When I have to take the 3 or so hour trek up to Atlanta on 16 it's like hell. People either just cruise at 65 in the left PASSING LANE without a care in the world or ride your ass when you're doing 76 or so in the right lane. As far as I'm concerned the left lane is just a passing lane and you shouldn't take your whole trip on it, it ruins the flow of traffic. Just my little rant!
enviriCT · Sep 16, 2011#37
hell i did 50 mph on the highway, with a slow moving crew of scions for 70 miles and i peaked out at 53.7mpg according to scangauge. I almost wanted to shoot myself, but it was great mileage. this coming from a guy that avgs about 80-90mph :)
BizlibatiDhaka · Sep 28, 2011#38
fifty five had been in no way the very best pace with regard to something. It really is in accordance with a lot of things, as well as discovering what's greatest for you personally requires period and a lot of experimentation.
docBWestern N.Y. · Sep 28, 2011#39
Even the government stats showed 55 didn't save lives or gas.
TLyttleKeremeos BC · Sep 29, 2011#40
Where did THAT info come from?? Anything that I saw during that time (including actual stats) showed otherwise. I realise that 75 was slow and boring in Nevada and other states, but most of the fatalities there were caused by frustration, not excessive speed. What that says to me is that high-speed rail would be of more benefit than 75mph speed limits. Germany has it's Autoroutes, and the skidmarks on those highways tell of the hazards of driving at high speeds.
viggenOntario, Canada · Nov 6, 2011#41
Germany has autobahns and there are no skid marks!

Lowest fatality and accident rate in the world. Anyone who lives North America should try it. Getting passed while doing 200 km/h feels priceless because you can hardly recognize the car that has passed you at 275 km/h.

My echo hb gets 5.5 l per 100km without much fuss🙂
TLyttleKeremeos BC · Nov 6, 2011#42
Sounds good, Viggen, but on my only trip on the Autobahn showed a few places where there were skidmarks, with a good sized hole in the shrubbery, ending with a divot in the farmland beyond. Nothing to do with crop circles, I assure you...
detroiterMetro Detroit · Nov 7, 2011#43
Autobahn drivers have less fatalities while driving compared to Americans because they don't drive acting like the bigger and faster their car is, the bigger their weiner is...
TLyttleKeremeos BC · Nov 7, 2011#44
Not true, detroiter. The licensing system there doesn't allow a high school nitwit to drive a Corvette equivalent. Better yet, they have to start out on scooters, in the city: only then do they learn to pay attention to something more than their own egos. Nothing like finding yourself in the middle of an intersection on your butt wondering what you did wrong. Much better. Much smarter.

It is not the road. It is not the vehicle. It is the driver, and his education. But apparently, everyone, regardless of age, has the right to drive, and drive anything they choose, and that is where the fatalities come from. Dear oh dear, just read the papers, or watch TV news to justify this!
IlovemyyarisUSA but it has green light? · Dec 2, 2011#45
Originally Posted by UltimateMonky ↑
I too live in Georgia and the thing I hate most here, and really most places I've driven, is passage ettiquite! When I have to take the 3 or so hour trek up to Atlanta on 16 it's like hell. People either just cruise at 65 in the left PASSING LANE without a care in the world or ride your ass when you're doing 76 or so in the right lane. As far as I'm concerned the left lane is just a passing lane and you shouldn't take your whole trip on it, it ruins the flow of traffic. Just my little rant!
Yep, before I started hypermiling I would go the speed limit and people would still ride my ass, sometimes I went about ~80mph when the speed limit was no more than 70 and people were still passing me.

It used to stress me out when people got mad at me going ~55 but now I find it funny. There was an incident with a really obnoxious driver from behind me coming from Atlanta a few nights back. I was doing my usual speed in the right lane. There wasn't much traffic and some lone orange car got behind me and turned his bright lights on as if he wanted me to speed up or move over or something so I let my foot off the gas and went a little slower "about ~50" just to show him I wasn't going to just speed up for him. Anyways so he got pissed and passed me honking his horn as he was passing. I really have no idea why people down here just don't get that there are other lanes to pass people if they want to waste their gas to speed off wherever they have to go.

Only time I'll speed up for impatient people is rush hour on the part of the highway where there is only two lanes just so be courteous because semi trucks get behind you and it takes longer for them to pass you and and it creates a long line of traffic.
Uber_OtterDFW · Dec 22, 2011#46
Originally Posted by detroiter ↑
Autobahn drivers have less fatalities while driving compared to Americans because they don't drive acting like the bigger and faster their car is, the bigger their weiner is...
The one key thing they do is "No tailgating" and "move your slow dumb ass over". The tailgating laws on the autobahn are very rigid and heavily enforced, so are the laws to yield to a driver going faster than you. The ticket fines vary because they are a Percentage of your annual income. That way it stings everyone equally.

Tailgate once, license suspended for 3 months + fines. Overtake on the right is forbidden. Drive slow in left lane and they shoot your car with a Old panzer tank.


Most accidents in the US could be avoided if the driver had more than 5 feet between them and the car in front of them. People who do the speed limit in the left lane cause most of the problems and accidents I see. You eliminate those and you have Autobahn safety stats.
JumpmanYarisSO. INDIANA · Dec 22, 2011#47
85 sound good right?😆
docBWestern N.Y. · Jan 20, 2012#48
The the speed one travels is inversely proportional to the attention one gives to the driving task. At 55 you have a lot of time to look around and eat and talk on the phone. Try anything but driving at 140 mph!
doc
charles nelsonSt Cloud Minnesota · Feb 6, 2012#49
When your Yaris is going at 70 mph it has about 60% more energy than when going at 55mph. The vehicle has to absorb 60% more energy if you crash the car. I don't think that Toyota puts 60% more absorption technology into the Yaris to protect you at 70 mph versus 55mph. Maybe Mercedes does, but you certainly pay for it.
charles nelsonSt Cloud Minnesota · Mar 14, 2012#50
My '08 Yaris with AT, has a sweet spot at about 55-57 mph if there is no wind. On the flats, it gets 45-51 mpg. If there is a gentle tailwind I get about +5mpg. A gentle head wind: 5-10 mpg decrease. At 70 mph, my mileage drops into the high 30's. I have drafted behind semi's on the Interstate and gotten 57-67 mpg, but I don't like driving just a few feet behind a truck weighing more than 20 times my Yaris.