Yarisworld Archive

is 5000 miles too long to wait for an oil change?

62 posts · 37,360 views · page 1 of 2

Yarus MaximusOriginal postNYC · Jul 18, 2010#1
Why does Toyota recommend a conventional oil change at 5000 miles for the Yaris? Every other car I've owned required a conventional oil change at 3000 miles (or 5000 if synthetic).

Replies 61

britishbikesPensacola, FL · Jul 18, 2010#2
I think the 3000 mile interval is for Super Lube to make more money. A car that is driven in normal conditions does not need that frequent of an oil change. If you drive at high speeds, or pull a trailer then the interval should be reduced. The Dodge Ram truck owners manual goes into detail about this because trucks tend to pull heavy weight, etc. The oil change light on my car comes on at about 4500 miles, and the oil still looks fairly clear; the level is still at the full mark. I just checked the valve clearances at 82,000 miles and they are all still within spec, so there does not appear to be any noticeable engine wear. Valve cover pretty clean, almost like a motorcycle engine in there it was so clean. I have a MT '08 Sedan w/TRD suspension, it gets driven pretty hard on the twisties about twice a month including a couple of jumps, I run about 77 mph on the interstate for 400 miles per week, redline the engine frequently.
britishbikesPensacola, FL · Jul 18, 2010#3
So in a short answer, no 5000 miles is not too long for a Yaris, especially driven like most people drive. The car appears to have very good blowby control; very little contaminants get into the oil.
custom LftbackHouston, TX · Jul 18, 2010#4
I change mine every 7500 miles with fully synthetic oil. No problems!
big loLoiza,Puerto Rico · Jul 18, 2010#5
I dont think that is a problem, I allways change mine to 5000 to 6000 and my car has 58789 miles and with no problems at all.
AstromanWenatchee, WA · Jul 18, 2010#6
That's "old school" thinking. Following toyotas recommended oil change interval is just fine.
Hersheynortheast · Jul 18, 2010#7
no problem with a good 5w-30 conventional oil such PENNZOIL ( now rated SN ) , HALVOLINE , etc..
127.0.0.1NE · Jul 18, 2010#8
Originally Posted by Yarus Maximus ↑
Why does Toyota recommend a conventional oil change at 5000 miles for the Yaris? Every other car I've owned required a conventional oil change at 3000 miles (or 5000 if synthetic).

3000 miles change is an old recommendation when engines and
oil formulas were built to less exacting standards. that crap doesn't
apply anymore, but oil change places put the fear into you so they make more loot



follow the owners manual.

if you use mobil 1 go to 10,000 miles before oil change
BilliamUSA · Jul 18, 2010#10
Thread locked in 3, 2, 1......
MadMaxSan Antonio, Texas! · Jul 18, 2010#11
Originally Posted by 127.0.0.1 ↑
if you use mobil 1 go to 10,000 miles before oil change
This. 👍

Oil is a precious and limited natural resource, and people are pouring it away because of some outdated information. Luckily some of it can be recycled, but it would be better to use it to its maximum extent than to needlessly change it because of ignorance!
BailOutReno, Nevada, USA · Jul 18, 2010#12
Originally Posted by MadMax ↑
This. 👍

Oil is a precious and limited natural resource, and people are pouring it away because of some outdated information. Luckily some of it can be recycled, but it would be better to use it to its maximum extent than to needlessly change it because of ignorance!
Well said! And there are "extended performance" blends out there that let you go all the way to 15k miles between drain intervals. I've been doing this along with a high performance filter since the first change and things are running fine at 65k miles. I have yet to find any metal on the magnetic drain plug.
sidewinderboston · Jul 18, 2010#13
5000 miles on an oil change, it depends on how much you love your car. Yes todays engines are better built then long ago, I was a mechanic then and still am. I also worked in an oil testing facility in the military. There is more break down of the oil the longer you use it, except synthetic oil. Toyota does not make any money from you by having engines last 500,000 miles. They want the engines to wear out sooner so they make more money. I did my first oil change on my "S" liftback at 1800 miles and my routine oil changes are at 2500 miles. Oil is cheap,engine work is not. Yes, you believe what you want to. Our 1.5 is a small motor that works hard and makes alot of heat. I have tested oil for many engines in a lab environment. Its science, not speculation.
yarrrnew mexico · Jul 18, 2010#14
Originally Posted by sidewinder ↑
5000 miles on an oil change, it depends on how much you love your car. Yes todays engines are better built then long ago, I was a mechanic then and still am. I also worked in an oil testing facility in the military. There is more break down of the oil the longer you use it, except synthetic oil. Toyota does not make any money from you by having engines last 500,000 miles. They want the engines to wear out sooner so they make more money. I did my first oil change on my "S" liftback at 1800 miles and my routine oil changes are at 2500 miles. Oil is cheap,engine work is not. Yes, you believe what you want to. Our 1.5 is a small motor that works hard and makes alot of heat. I have tested oil for many engines in a lab environment. Its science, not speculation.
Well the yaris has been proven to go 400k miles with 5k intervals. 80 extra changes over that period is ~1500-2000 bucks. I could get a salvage engine and install it for half of that. Oil is not cheap, and BP just let the rest of the "cheap" oil flow into the ocean... lol
RedRideMiddletown, NY · Jul 18, 2010#15
Originally Posted by Yarus Maximus ↑
Why does Toyota recommend a conventional oil change at 5000 miles for the Yaris? Every other car I've owned required a conventional oil change at 3000 miles (or 5000 if synthetic).
It all has to do with marketing.
Auto manufactures want to claim that their cars are more maintainence free and "greener" than the competition.
Bottom line, it's your car, you are paying for it so, change the oil when you want to.

Personally, I change my oil about every 3k miles or so. 🙂
fmicleSan Jose, CA, USA · Jul 19, 2010#16
By the way, when I was living in Europe I've never heard of or seen anyone do their oil change under 13,000 miles, synthetic or not. And last time I checked, their cars were running just fine :) And let's not forget, in Europe a 2 liter engine is a BIG engine!

I also don't really buy the theory that a smaller engine somehow makes more heat than a bigger engine. Yes, they do work harder, because you have to rev them up to get into their optimal power range. As far as I know, modern engines are much more efficient than 20-30 years ago, in fact they are so efficient that they don't produce enough heat to heat up the car in the winter and you need extra gadgets to warm up the car...

And even if it did make more heat, applying the same logic, wouldn't it be easier to cool as well? Because it's smaller it has less thermal mass, right?

Bigger engines last longer because they produce more power at a lower RPM and low RPM means longer life.

My $0.02
Hersheynortheast · Jul 19, 2010#17
was told by head tech that TOYOTA will be going to 10,000 mile intervals and the use of 5w-20 . Not sure if synthetic or conventional or both .
PhillyGgeorgia · Jul 19, 2010#18
Originally Posted by RedRide ↑
It all has to do with marketing.
Auto manufactures want to claim that their cars are more maintainence free and "greener" than the competition.
Bottom line, it's your car, you are paying for it so, change the oil when you want to.

Personally, I change my oil about every 3k miles or so. 🙂
Amen brother! testify!.... YOU bought the car.. toyota does not own it anymore.. You do what YOU feel is right..
jambo101Montreal Canada · Jul 19, 2010#19
10K with synthetic for me,my way of helping out the environment in a small way.also helps on whats in my wallet.
33OHDover, Ohio · Jul 19, 2010#20
I run AMSOIL synthetic, change the oil every 25K miles. Change the filter every 10K miles.
ctrjUpland, CA · Jul 19, 2010#21
Use Amsoil and go 15k miles.

Originally Posted by MadMax ↑
This. 👍

Oil is a precious and limited natural resource, and people are pouring it away because of some outdated information. Luckily some of it can be recycled, but it would be better to use it to its maximum extent than to needlessly change it because of ignorance!
ctrjUpland, CA · Jul 19, 2010#22
Originally Posted by 33OH ↑
I run AMSOIL synthetic, change the oil every 25K miles. Change the filter every 10K miles.
🎉
BilliamUSA · Jul 19, 2010#23
goliath1812Ocala Florida · Jul 19, 2010#24
i go about 8000-9000 on royal purple... no probs so far.
sickpuppy1Kansas · Jul 19, 2010#25
Oil changes are a different story between convention loil and synthetic IMO. I can see synth oil on a 10-15 or 20k oil change, but last I heard there is still a sludge issue in toyota engines,at least compared to say Honda(but they get the oil VERY hot as a way to keep from sludging) and my car has a lifetime drivetrain warranty as long as mfg maitainence is followed and records kept.I will use ONLY WIX or better yet Purolator PueONE So I will be doing my 3-5k oil changes for a long time! I noticed on the tranny dipstick (auto)it states no changes needed under normal use, 1st time I've seen that!
goliath1812Ocala Florida · Jul 19, 2010#26
you think purolator is better than WIX?
jambo101Montreal Canada · Jul 20, 2010#27
Originally Posted by sickpuppy1 ↑
So I will be doing my 3-5k oil changes for a long time!
Drill baby drill.
firemachine69Sudbury, On · Jul 20, 2010#28
To the OP:


I'm brutal on my engine. Cold-starts, short trips, etc.

Even so, all my Blackstone Oil Analysis reports come back with stellar results, and lots of oil life left. Blackstone is always trying to encourage me to go 6K miles on conventional Shell 5w-30, however I don't (yet), due to the warranty...
Hersheynortheast · Jul 20, 2010#29
Originally Posted by firemachine69 ↑
To the OP:


I'm brutal on my engine. Cold-starts, short trips, etc.

Even so, all my Blackstone Oil Analysis reports come back with stellar results, and lots of oil life left. Blackstone is always trying to encourage me to go 6K miles on conventional Shell 5w-30, however I don't (yet), due to the warranty...
what brand of oil do you use ?
yaris4062007northern california · Jul 20, 2010#30
i changed mine every 5k - 8k miles with mobile 1 and kn filter :)
tk-421Dagobah · Jul 20, 2010#31
R2D2, where are you?!
firemachine69Sudbury, On · Jul 20, 2010#32
Originally Posted by Hershey ↑
what brand of oil do you use ?


Motomaster Formula 1 conventional. Basically, a Shell conventional oil, privately-branded, with a slightly lesser additive-pack.


Next OCI will be actual Shell-branded 5w30.
R2D2ME · Jul 20, 2010#33
I'm right here tk!
Hersheynortheast · Jul 21, 2010#34
Originally Posted by firemachine69 ↑
Motomaster Formula 1 conventional. Basically, a Shell conventional oil, privately-branded, with a slightly lesser additive-pack.


Next OCI will be actual Shell-branded 5w30.
o.k. . We're using SHELL 5w-30 conventional for now . Get it for $2.20 a quart . Dumped the SHELL 5w-30 synthetic for both to see if the leak stops for both with conventional . May go to a run of VALVOLINE 5w-30 dino . That's apparently a little thicker . Checked the 2010 earlier for the leak after being driven for over a 100 miles in 2 days and there was no oil . When drove the 2008 for 100+ miles in 1 day it was wet to the touch . Recleaned both . Will keep monitoring the two 🙄 . Thanks .
firemachine69Sudbury, On · Jul 21, 2010#35
Oh yeah, thanks for the reminder Hershey. I'm gonna have to check my Yarii, haven't lifted the hood since my last jug of washer fluid... two months ago. 😳
QuaiferStrathroy, ON · Jul 22, 2010#36
Originally Posted by 33OH ↑
I run AMSOIL synthetic, change the oil every 25K miles. Change the filter every 10K miles.
You are crazy man. Not only is that way too long, AMSOIL is not a very good synthetic to begin with.


My yaris is at 65,000km (40,389miles). I was using Castrol 5w30 conventional but switched to Mobil 1 5w30 Full Synthetic on my last oil change. I am choosing to go 8,000km (5000miles), using a Fram Tough Guard filter on my first oil change.

The first thing I noticed when I switched to Synthetic was my engine ran a little quieter. Second was just performance, it seemed to accelerate a bit quicker and smoother. I know the filter says it's good for 12,700km (7500miles) but I don't feel comfortable going that kind of distance. I do a lot of highway driving going back and forth to work so I will find out in a month how the oil works out.
AstromanWenatchee, WA · Jul 23, 2010#37
Ok, amsoil states using their filters you CAN go that long, and it is excellent oil. Lets keep this as facts not speculation please. This is why oil threads go south 👍
127.0.0.1NE · Jul 23, 2010#38
every stinking oil discussion has 'amsoil' in it somewhere.

the ONLY reason for amsoil fanbois is: Amsoil markets their products through a Multi-Level Marketing (MLM) network of dealers


MLM and that fact that every backwater racetrack has someone who is trying to make a buck (it is a business, is it not ?) and tout the incredible capabilities of amsoil vs (xyz) oil...so they may sell some....there is more 'word of mouth' about amsoil and the grapevine and somehow people seem to think that carries more weight than corporate marketing and buying something off the shelf at wally-world.

amsoil is no better and no worse than any other big brand oil with the same API specification. do not believe the hype, because it is hype.

this very post of mine is going to get someones panties in a bunch I imagine.

the chemists at Amsoil are good and they won't make a bogus product, but you are not missing anything
by not buying amsoil.
AstromanWenatchee, WA · Jul 23, 2010#39
Actually that was the reason I switched from amsoil, couldn't find a seller in Wenatchee. Went with royal purple since I can buy it almost anywhere.
firemachine69Sudbury, On · Jul 23, 2010#40
Originally Posted by 127.0.0.1 ↑
every stinking oil discussion has 'amsoil' in it somewhere.

the ONLY reason for amsoil fanbois is: Amsoil markets their products through a Multi-Level Marketing (MLM) network of dealers


MLM and that fact that every backwater racetrack has someone who is trying to make a buck (it is a business, is it not ?) and tout the incredible capabilities of amsoil vs (xyz) oil...so they may sell some....there is more 'word of mouth' about amsoil and the grapevine and somehow people seem to think that carries more weight than corporate marketing and buying something off the shelf at wally-world.

amsoil is no better and no worse than any other big brand oil with the same API specification. do not believe the hype, because it is hype.

this very post of mine is going to get someones panties in a bunch I imagine.

the chemists at Amsoil are good and they won't make a bogus product, but you are not missing anything
by not buying amsoil.

AMSoil makes all their products (minus one, because it was a customer request) with Group IV bases.

That can't be said for Mobil1 (EXCEPT for the zero-weight [0w-**] oils).


They have one of the best additive packages in the synthetic automotive application industry.

Castrol has one of the worst.


They don't rely on colours gimmicks to sell their oil.

Can't say the same about Royal Purple.


They don't try to pass off "full synthetic" from a Group III base-stock.

Sorry, Pennzoil, you're out.


They don't need to run million-dollar "feel good" commercials about how one "feels the power" with their superior oil.

Sorry Quaker State, maybe next time.


🍻



Ten bucks says Quaifer is talking out of his ass, AND has never had an oil analysis done. You know, a sample of data to see where your Si stands, fuel-dilution, flash point, etc. Any takers?
Hersheynortheast · Jul 23, 2010#41
SHELL motor oil is part of S.O.P.U.S. family .
ctrjUpland, CA · Jul 23, 2010#42
Lets see some facts to back this up!!!

Originally Posted by 127.0.0.1 ↑
every stinking oil discussion has 'amsoil' in it somewhere.

the ONLY reason for amsoil fanbois is: Amsoil markets their products through a Multi-Level Marketing (MLM) network of dealers


MLM and that fact that every backwater racetrack has someone who is trying to make a buck (it is a business, is it not ?) and tout the incredible capabilities of amsoil vs (xyz) oil...so they may sell some....there is more 'word of mouth' about amsoil and the grapevine and somehow people seem to think that carries more weight than corporate marketing and buying something off the shelf at wally-world.

amsoil is no better and no worse than any other big brand oil with the same API specification. do not believe the hype, because it is hype.

this very post of mine is going to get someones panties in a bunch I imagine.

the chemists at Amsoil are good and they won't make a bogus product, but you are not missing anything
by not buying amsoil.
BilliamUSA · Jul 23, 2010#43
Originally Posted by Billiam ↑
Thread locked in 3, 2, 1......
1stToyotaOklahoma · Jul 23, 2010#44
Originally Posted by Astroman ↑
Ok, amsoil states using their filters you CAN go that long, and it is excellent oil. Lets keep this as facts not speculation please. This is why oil threads go south 👍
I think Amsoil issued a warning that their ea filter [made by WIX] in our Yaris needs to be changed every 5k miles, even though it's rated by Amsoil for about 25k miles....so yeah, I guess if you're instructed by Amsoil to change their 25k mile filter every 5k miles their oil will easily last the claimed 25k miles/1yr.
HTM Yarissouth Carolina · Jul 23, 2010#45
I find it interesting that Toyota will be switching to 10,000 mile oil change intervals . I'm willing to bet they will be using Amsoil or made by Amsoil .

If you do a comparison with Amsoil and Mobil1 like I did , you will come to the same conclusion that I did . At 5000 miles the Mobil1 was "black" while the Amsoil was still somewhat lucent . Visual inspection alone clearly (pun intended) shows that Amsoil is a superior product .

I change filter at 5K (Toyota) and my Amsoil at 10K .
sleey0PA · Jul 23, 2010#46
Royal Purple FTW!!

I would use amsoil but it doesn't exist in my neck of the woods. RP can be had for a good price though.
Happy Little PonyTampa, FL · Jul 25, 2010#47
I don't want to get involved in another oil thread, but I can't believe that we're three pages into this thread and nobody has shown up to preach the virtues of SJ rated lawn mower oil.

Why doesn't everyone just pay for oil analysis so we can have some actual facts and not just speculation.
1stToyotaOklahoma · Jul 26, 2010#48
Originally Posted by HTM Yaris ↑
I find it interesting that Toyota will be switching to 10,000 mile oil change intervals . I'm willing to bet they will be using Amsoil or made by Amsoil .

If you do a comparison with Amsoil and Mobil1 like I did , you will come to the same conclusion that I did . At 5000 miles the Mobil1 was "black" while the Amsoil was still somewhat lucent . Visual inspection alone clearly (pun intended) shows that Amsoil is a superior product .

I change filter at 5K (Toyota) and my Amsoil at 10K .
I doubt that Toyota will be using an oil that doesn't even have their own base stock...Amsoil just adds their additive package to their competition's [Mobil] base stock.

Some people like seeing black oil because they claim it means that the oil has enough detergents to clean the motor better. Maybe it's just urban legend that my grandfather helped to get started. Personally, I don't like seeing the oil go completely black at 5k in a well maintained low mileage Yaris, but that's what happened when I also drained the M1 (0w30) out on a 5k mile OCI ...first time that's ever happened, and I've used Eneos, PP, HP Amsoil, etc...
birdmanUSA · Aug 11, 2010#49
How long would a Yaris run if you never changed the oil and kept it topped off?
tdinutLI, NY · Aug 11, 2010#50
Originally Posted by birdman ↑
How long would a Yaris run if you never changed the oil and kept it topped off?
Not sure about a Yaris, but one of the guys I used to work with bought a new Honda Prelude many years ago. He NEVER changed the oil or had it serviced. I don't believe he even checked the engine bay at all. That car went almost 2 years until it seized up on the highway. Poor car. I hope she did not suffer too long before she died😢

Joe