Yarisworld Archive

Shifting without the clutch

92 posts · 25,232 views · page 1 of 2

mark293Original postHOUSTON · Jun 18, 2010#1
Does anyone routinely shift without using the clutch? I did this for years on my 5 speed F350, and as long as you are in the right rpm range the shifts are just as smooth as using the clutch. The Yaris seems tailor made for this type of driving if you use common sense.

Replies 91

Yaris HiltonBristol, Tennessee, USA · Jun 18, 2010#2
Using common sense implies using the clutch. Transmission synchros can cope with clutchless shifting to a point, if you're cruising under neutral power so there's little or no torque on the gears, but they'll wear out a lot faster than if you declutch as you should. If you really want to reduce wear, you'll double clutch to match the speed of the gears before they start to engage again. The proper way to shift without using the clutch is to buy an automatic.
Kongo-OttoGermany · Jun 18, 2010#3
Why should one not use the clutch? Laziness?
The Yaris has no dogbox so you should use the clutch at any gear change. It is no "kind of driving" it is just abuse.
matanfrIsrael · Jun 18, 2010#4
excuse me,Yaris Hilton..
but what do you mean by "double clutch"? and can i perform it if i have robotic transmission?
Kongo-OttoGermany · Jun 18, 2010#5
Originally Posted by matanfr ↑
excuse me,Yaris Hilton..
but what do you mean by "double clutch"? and can i perform it if i have robotic transmission?
You have MMT? You can't double clutch then. It is not necessary anyways. The Yaris is no oldschool bus or truck.
mark293Thread starterHOUSTON · Jun 18, 2010#6
No need to call me names. Lazy I am not. I was just curious if this technique was used by anyone else. BTW, using this technique my F350 had 576,000 miles on it before I gave it away to a gentleman in the church who needed a reliable daily driver. I hope your Yaris last at least half as long. Ill continue to do what I want and you all can continue your childish ways. Thanks and have a great day.
Kongo-OttoGermany · Jun 18, 2010#7
Originally Posted by mark293 ↑
No need to call me names. Lazy I am not. I was just curious if this technique was used by anyone else. BTW, using this technique my F350 had 576,000 miles on it before I gave it away to a gentleman in the church who needed a reliable daily driver. I hope your Yaris last at least half as long. Ill continue to do what I want and you all can continue your childish ways. Thanks and have a great day.
Sorry, but it is abuse to shift a manual car without using the clutch. We are not talking about race cars, do we? That has nothing to do with "call me names" or "childish". Nice to hear your old car did not take any damage with your so-called technique. 👍

That is no offense. 🙂 I still don't get the advantage of your technique. Can you explain it to us?
mark293Thread starterHOUSTON · Jun 18, 2010#8
Its not like Im saving a few milliseconds by not using the clutch, I was just making a statement as to what was possible. However the clutchless shifting appears to be slightly smoother.

Its funny how so called forum experts chime in as to what is detrimental to a vehicle, such as in oil debates, but they have no empirical proof. Im sure no one expected the 400k Yaris on this forum to last that long while doing regular top speed runs. My vehicle is paid for and I plan on keeping it for its entire service life. When I get to 200, 300, or even 400k miles without a transmission related failure, Ill let you know. Until then keep on giving expert advice.
bronsinnj · Jun 18, 2010#9
Sure I did/do it all the time with my ECHO and now with my Suzuki DL1000. Its a good skill to have. Once on a 500 mile trip from home my Toyota pickup had the clutch pedal freeze in the up position. You couldnt push it dowm. A bolt had worked out and got jamed in the mechanism. I had to R&R the trans and fix it. But before I could do that I drove 500 miles home with no clutch! If youre wondering how to start moving heres how: put the trans in first and crank the engine. The vehicle will move and the engine start. If you have a "push the clutch in to start" car, then youll have to disable it. First thing Idid on my ECHO.
Clutchless shifting on my Suzuki is incredibly smooth. Even downshifting. That transmission is amazing.
Yaris HiltonBristol, Tennessee, USA · Jun 18, 2010#10
Originally Posted by matanfr ↑
excuse me,Yaris Hilton..
but what do you mean by "double clutch"? and can i perform it if i have robotic transmission?
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Double_clutch
thebarberGrand Rapids, MI · Jun 18, 2010#11
i could do it in my matrix xrs...but i cant remember the rpms to do it

i havent found the clutchless spot on the yaris (yet)...if you find out, let us know

i don't think it hurts the synchros at all, PK, there just an area in the gearing in most cars where you can pull it out of gear and put it into the next one w/o using the clutch
AND189australia · Jun 18, 2010#12
everyone is an expert on here that is why we are here ha ha i was keen to master the clutchless shift just to see if i can do it
lutchless shifting is ok for straight cut gears not helical like the Yaris
well i can say i only did it once not a good sound ha ha, but if someone can shed some light on speed / rpm just to see if i can do it, it would be helpful mark293 ???
Kongo-OttoGermany · Jun 18, 2010#13
Originally Posted by bronsin ↑
Clutchless shifting on my Suzuki is incredibly smooth. Even downshifting. That transmission is amazing.
It is because it has a straight gearbox, like most other regular motorcycles. You can shift up without a clutch and if you are not doing it completely wrong there will be no more wear to the transmission.

Downshifting without clutch needs a little more practice and i would not recommend it even if it could work smoothly.
Yaris HiltonBristol, Tennessee, USA · Jun 18, 2010#14
Originally Posted by AND189 ↑
everyone is an expert on here that is why we are here ha ha
You got it! 😁
SAV912Savannah, GA · Jun 18, 2010#15
Originally Posted by mark293 ↑
No need to call me names. Lazy I am not. I was just curious if this technique was used by anyone else. BTW, using this technique my F350 had 576,000 miles on it before I gave it away to a gentleman in the church who needed a reliable daily driver. I hope your Yaris last at least half as long. Ill continue to do what I want and you all can continue your childish ways. Thanks and have a great day.
How the hell is it CHILDISH to use a car the way it was suppose to be used?

If not using the clutch pedal was smoother or more economical or faster or, hell, brought magical baby unicorns back from extinction, then there wouldn't be a clutch pedal in the car. It was easier on a damn F350 because that's a work truck with some meaningful torque to it.

Don't walk onto these forums and immediately start throwing boulders in your glass house because everyone else here shut you down with your clutchless shifting.

-SAV🍻
thebarberGrand Rapids, MI · Jun 18, 2010#16
Originally Posted by SAV912 ↑
How the hell is it CHILDISH to use a car the way it was suppose to be used?

If not using the clutch pedal was smoother or more economical or faster or, hell, brought magical baby unicorns back from extinction, then there wouldn't be a clutch pedal in the car. It was easier on a damn F350 because that's a work truck with some meaningful torque to it.

Don't walk onto these forums and immediately start throwing boulders in your glass house because everyone else here shut you down for being an idiot with your clutchless shifting.

-SAV🍻
lol

unicorns are extinct and therefore actually exisited?

and who's slinging boulders now, mr 26 posts...?
SAV912Savannah, GA · Jun 18, 2010#17
Originally Posted by thebarber ↑
lol

unicorns are extinct and therefore actually exisited?

and who's slinging boulders now, mr 26 posts...?
Yep. I saw them in my dreams. 😁

Come now, good sir, low post counts does not mean a lack of knowledge. I've lurked for a few years now. What was that saying about being thought a fool, rather than opening your mouth so everyone KNEW you were a fool? 🤷

-SAV 🍻
bronsinnj · Jun 18, 2010#18
Originally Posted by Kongo-Otto ↑
It is because it has a straight gearbox, like most other regular motorcycles. You can shift up without a clutch and if you are not doing it completely wrong there will be no more wear to the transmission.

Downshifting without clutch needs a little more practice and i would not recommend it even if it could work smoothly.

Practice on a Zuk DL1000 and you'll be an expert in no time!
mark293Thread starterHOUSTON · Jun 18, 2010#19
[QUOTE=SAV912;482078]How the hell is it CHILDISH to use a car the way it was suppose to be used?

If not using the clutch pedal was smoother or more economical or faster or, hell, brought magical baby unicorns back from extinction, then there wouldn't be a clutch pedal in the car. It was easier on a damn F350 because that's a work truck with some meaningful torque to it.

Don't walk onto these forums and immediately start throwing boulders in your glass house because everyone else here shut you down with your clutchless shifting.

Then maybe this is not the forum for me. I was under the impression that this forum was a place where useful ideas and opinions could be expressed without fear of abuse regarding our beloved Yaris. Im sorry you do not agree with my shifting technique and Im not holding a gun to your head to follow in my footsteps. All I was asking was if anyone else employed this technique. It looks like some do and some dont. Fine by me.

Dont walk in here....damn f350...unicorns? It is quite possible sir that the reason I do not have 500 posts is because my Yaris is trouble free and I have finer things to do then spend my unaccounted for time on an econobox forum. But good luck to you.
SAV912Savannah, GA · Jun 18, 2010#20
Originally Posted by mark293 ↑

Dont walk in here....damn f350...unicorns? It is quite possible sir that the reason I do not have 500 posts is because my Yaris is trouble free and I have finer things to do then spend my unaccounted for time on an econobox forum. But good luck to you.
Maybe that is possible. I'm right behind you in that case, as this would be my 28th post, so I've got quite a ways to go before I get to 500. But just for you, Pumpkin, I'll do my best. 🙂

My Yaris is trouble free as well and the only problem I've had with it was something I did myself. Cracking the front bumper running over a tractor gator on I95. But I hardly consider that the car's fault.

FWIW, I've tried clutchless shifting in my Yaris and found it to be cumbersome and shaky, at best. Awful grinding noises at worst. I used to be perfectly capable of clutchless shifting on my old Mark III Jetta. And I had to be. The clutch cable on that hunk of shit snapped. Twice. 😲

If you can do it, fantastic. More power to you. It's a carefully executed art, albeit one that I don't care to perfect at the cost of my transmission's synchros. Since I got a moderator to step in though, I do apologize for my harsh first post. I still firmly believe unicorns once existed though. 😁

-SAV 🍻
thebarberGrand Rapids, MI · Jun 18, 2010#21
maybe try microimageonline.com forums...

stick around here too, not all the people are pretards
tomatoSan Francisco Bay Area · Jun 18, 2010#22
Originally Posted by mark293 ↑
Does anyone routinely shift without using the clutch? I did this for years on my 5 speed F350, and as long as you are in the right rpm range the shifts are just as smooth as using the clutch. The Yaris seems tailor made for this type of driving if you use common sense.
No. I don't think the clutch would like it one bit. .02
thebarberGrand Rapids, MI · Jun 18, 2010#23
Originally Posted by tomato ↑
No. I don't think the clutch would like it one bit. .02
clutch wouldnt care....its not getting used....

mark293, im not sure people on this site have every heard about shifting without the clutch...
ddongbaphay · Jun 18, 2010#24
I do it when I'm tired. I down shift w/o the clutch too. 'Cept one time, it made this HUGE clunk. Even huger than normal, and the car did a jolt slow. Idk what it was, but I ignored it.
ddongbaphay · Jun 18, 2010#25
Btw, you guys rage too much. If hes doing it wrong, tell him so. But let him keep doing it wrong. Who cares?
djct_wattThailand · Jun 18, 2010#26
A good skill to have, but it is abusing the transmission. I hurt my left leg badly in a motorcycle accident once, and had to drive myself to the hospital. . . I did it all on one leg. It was in the Yaris.

Use the right leg to engage the clutch and start moving without any gas (lucky there were no hills). Once first was going, it was easy. Clutchless shifting from there on out (and it's very easy). Any car can be shifted that way. . . but your shifts have to be perfect. Mess up once and it's a hard grind. IMO, it's not worth it since it's so easy to just press the clutch.

If I was that lazy, then I would have gotten an auto.
sickpuppy1Kansas · Jun 18, 2010#27
Truckers do it all the time, but the dont have sychro's and they are designed for this type of shifting after leaving low gear, I've heard its not good on the synchronizers also, but I'm no tranny expert. Funny, heres a video for ya, its called rev matching.
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=jLw0h...=youtu.be&a%29
Yaris HiltonBristol, Tennessee, USA · Jun 18, 2010#28
Originally Posted by sickpuppy1 ↑
Truckers do it all the time, but the dont have sychro's and they are designed for this type of shifting after leaving low gear, I've heard its not good on the synchronizers also, but I'm no tranny expert. Funny, heres a video for ya, its called rev matching.
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=jLw0h...=youtu.be&a%29
Rev matching = double clutching. The idea is to make the two shafts spin at the same speed before they come together. You can do that during the time the transmission's in a "neutral" state between gears without the clutch, but unless you can control the throttle so the gears have zero load on them as you're disengaging and engaging them, you're going to stress them more. The clutch is there to be used. Clutchless shifting is something to do in an emergency.
Yar Is WordPortland, OR · Jun 19, 2010#29
Anyone remember "Clutch Cargo"?
bankrobberCentral Florida · Jun 19, 2010#30
Originally Posted by mark293 ↑
Does anyone routinely shift without using the clutch? I did this for years on my 5 speed F350, and as long as you are in the right rpm range the shifts are just as smooth as using the clutch. The Yaris seems tailor made for this type of driving if you use common sense.
I get lazy sometimes and grind gears from not full pressing in clutch to shift.
My truck a 1988 Ranger 4x4 was no problem to shift with no clutch. I could upshift,downshift, and even go from neutral to first with just tapping the gas while moving.
Maybe the Yaris will start to like it after 200k.
I should add that I drive trucks for a living and only use clutch to start off. If I double clutch each shift I would be on my 3rd knee by now.
A lot of tractor trailers now have automatic transmission.
Probably not the best thing to do till it gets some miles on it
ddongbaphay · Jun 19, 2010#31
Originally Posted by Yaris Hilton ↑
Rev matching = double clutching. The idea is to make the two shafts spin at the same speed before they come together. You can do that during the time the transmission's in a "neutral" state between gears without the clutch, but unless you can control the throttle so the gears have zero load on them as you're disengaging and engaging them, you're going to stress them more. The clutch is there to be used. Clutchless shifting is something to do in an emergency.
Its not the same thing though. They end up doing the same thing, but are done so in different ways.
hwyboxthe big "O" · Jun 19, 2010#32
^^ good stuff haha. I've shifted 1-4 several times in my xB, without using the clutch, and have shown a few passengers it can be done. But the pop noise when you pull the shifter to get out of a gear, it does not sound good, for long term wear and tear. I would not recommend this for normal driving at all.
ddongbaphay · Jun 19, 2010#33
Blip the gas a tad before you bring it out.
djct_wattThailand · Jun 19, 2010#34
^if you are doing it right there should be no pop sound. You need to shift to neutral at zero load; it's the moment you're neither applying
power nor engine braking.
hwyboxthe big "O" · Jun 19, 2010#35
I've done it several time and it always make the noise, maybe the xB is diff?
djct_wattThailand · Jun 19, 2010#36
I've tried it on my yaris, and also on both my xA and tC without the noise. The xB1 shares the same tranny and engine as the yaris and the xA, and the xB2 shares
the same engine/tranny as the tC. So the xB is not different.
hwyboxthe big "O" · Jun 19, 2010#37
Originally Posted by djct_watt ↑
I've tried it on my yaris, and also on both my xA and tC without the noise. The xB1 shares the same tranny and engine as the yaris and the xA, and the xB2 shares
the same engine/tranny as the tC. So the xB is not different.
I know thats why im on this site lol, maybe im a tard...
Yaris HiltonBristol, Tennessee, USA · Jun 19, 2010#38
Originally Posted by Yar Is Word ↑
Anyone remember "Clutch Cargo"?
I do!
bankrobberCentral Florida · Jun 19, 2010#39
Originally Posted by djct_watt ↑
^if you are doing it right there should be no pop sound. You need to shift to neutral at zero load; it's the moment you're neither applying
power nor engine braking.
You need to pull it out of gear at the same time you let off the gas. If not exact on timming you will force it out of gear.
ddongbaphay · Jun 19, 2010#40
Originally Posted by djct_watt ↑
I've tried it on my yaris, and also on both my xA and tC without the noise. The xB1 shares the same tranny and engine as the yaris and the xA, and the xB2 shares
the same engine/tranny as the tC. So the xB is not different.
XB and Yaris trannys are different.
thebarberGrand Rapids, MI · Jun 19, 2010#41
Originally Posted by Yaris Hilton ↑
Rev matching = double clutching
wrong
ddongbaphay · Jun 19, 2010#42
Originally Posted by thebarber ↑
wrong
RONG.
thebarberGrand Rapids, MI · Jun 19, 2010#43
Originally Posted by ddongbap ↑
RONG.
i rev match w/o double clutching daily. double clutching is for trannies w/o synchro's.
djct_wattThailand · Jun 19, 2010#44
Originally Posted by ddongbap ↑
XB and Yaris trannys are different.
Uuuuh. . . they both use C50 transmissions. . .
BuildCodeNorthern Illinois · Jun 19, 2010#45
I've shifted without the clutch on previous cars....just to see how/that it could be done, but I gotta agree with everyone here, it just shouldn't really be done because the transmission has syncros and was designed to be shifted with a clutch, so it is most likely in the transmission's best interest to shift with the clutch.

I double clutch whenever making big downshifts, like for example if I'm going to put the car in 2nd gear at 40mph (for a fun turn) I'll put the car in neutral with the clutch out and blip it up to 4,000rpm real quick, and then it shift into 2nd gear, it's amazing the difference feeling it just "drop" into 2nd in this situation (no waiting for the syncros to work). I believe this (double clutching for big downshifts) is very good for the life of the syncros. Shifting without the clutch would do the opposite to the life of the syncros UNLESS you literally rev matched PERFECTLY every time. Which I don't care how good of a driver you are, the Yaris' electronic throttle and other environmental factors will not allow you to literally perfectly rev match every shift - You're going to be putting wear on the syncros, and it will be more wear than normal.
AND189australia · Jun 19, 2010#46
ladies please
thebarberGrand Rapids, MI · Jun 19, 2010#47
*unsubscribing*
AND189australia · Jun 19, 2010#48
thebarber
can't handle the heat
bronsinnj · Jun 19, 2010#49
Originally Posted by Yaris Hilton ↑
I do!

Animated lips. Never caught on.
AltitudeColorado · Jun 19, 2010#50
Hey, I have a question about oil...