Replies continued
RainSoCal · May 19, 2010#51 Originally Posted by
jhsouders ↑ On my 18.5 mile trip home from class in downtown portland today, i got 55.5 mpg. Anyone know how to post pictures from my own files, not from a url.
You can attach the file that you wanna post.
When you're replying in the thread, there's an option below the text box that says "manage attachment"
jhsoudersThread starterHillsboro OR · May 19, 2010#52This is today, i forgot to take a picture of the gauge setup i had going, ill do that next time. I know it woulda been more convincing to see the mpg, next to the miles driven and average speed.
1 attachment not included in this copy
CarBob08Oregon · May 19, 2010#53 Originally Posted by
jhsouders ↑ When i just want to get somewhere, going a constant 70-75 down the highway, it seems that i get around 40mpg probably closer to what you get right? It might be true that a sedan slides through the air better, but that cant quite be proven.
The only time I have even hit 40mpg was on a long trip, cruise set at about 60mph, and only one stop for gas in a stretch 550 miles long. My average for normal freeway driving is about 37mpg. As was said in another post, it is just too hard to drive really easy to get the uber-mileage, the car is a lot of fun. When I want to go fast AND get good mpg's, I jump over to the motorcycle (50+mpg and crazy acceleration). 😁
KrazyDawgSF Bay Area · Jun 15, 2010#54I haven't hit 40 MPG yet. Is this all flat roads? I have a lot of hills on my highway commute.
jhsoudersThread starterHillsboro OR · Jun 15, 2010#55 Originally Posted by
KrazyDawg ↑ I haven't hit 40 MPG yet. Is this all flat roads? I have a lot of hills on my highway commute.
I actually find that i get better mpg on hilly terrain, granted its still highway. Going down the hills i just throw it in neutral getting around 4-5 hundred mpg while maintaining speed (DFCO would slow my car, and i would again have to use gas, so neutral is better in this case).
There is one hill in particular that i drive all the time, 600 ft elevation gain and loss. From the start of my drive, the hill starts, 2.6 miles up, 3.5 miles back down, when i get to the top im at 24-25mpg, once im back at the bottom, im back to 44-45 mpg, then by the time im home, 13 miles later, im about 50-51mpg.
I think my car is magic... 👍
Also, KrazyDawg, i notice you have an automatic, manuals are definitely easier to get better mileage with (which i have), and i baby mine.
Based on your gas log, you fill your tank quite often, what do you do that requires you to drive so many miles? I ask because i deliver pizza's and i do the same.
daf62757Indianapolis, Indiana · Jun 16, 2010#56 Originally Posted by
CarBob08 ↑ That is amazing. I honestly don't know if I can get another 10+mpg by just slowing down to 55-60mph, I usually only go about 70mph on the freeway. I noticed you have the sedan too, it seems like it is a bit more slick through the air than the HB, so that might help too. I am not complaining about my mileage at all, the best of any car ever owned, just that it seems that many people are able to get SIGNIFICANTLY more than I have ever seen. More power to y'all, whatever it is that you are doing!! 🙇
I have often wondered how so many can get such fantastic mileage yet I still get slightly under 40MPG. Makes me wonder if there aren't some tall tales told here!
127.0.0.1NE · Jun 16, 2010#57 Originally Posted by
daf62757 ↑ I have often wondered how so many can get such fantastic mileage yet I still get slightly under 40MPG. Makes me wonder if there aren't some tall tales told here!
poor measurement of gasoline (1/10th gallon) can throw mileage calcs off.
over-inflation of tires is dangerous, yet many high-milers over-inflate
(dangerous in emergency handling and low traction conditions, not really dangerous
dry pavement non-cornering)
also, extreme use of hypermiling techniques (accelerating absurdly slow after stops for example)
I don't do any of the above, and I am getting 43 mpg tank average with 75%
highway miles at 67 mph 2010 Yaris 5 door automatic
this drops to 36 when I start driving around town on short trips.
YarisduderMontreal, Canada · Jun 16, 2010#58Are the cars mostly empty too? We're almost always three on board, and I'm sure that lowers our fuel economy.
RainSoCal · Jun 16, 2010#59I can get 50mpg driving 80% highway with four people on board
127.0.0.1NE · Jun 16, 2010#60 Originally Posted by
Yarisduder ↑ Are the cars mostly empty too? We're almost always three on board, and I'm sure that lowers our fuel economy.
every single bit of added weight lowers mileage, unless that weight addition
adds power or fuel economy in some way to compensate for itself.
ZaphodSomewhere in the vacinity of Betelgeuse · Jun 16, 2010#61 Originally Posted by
daf62757 ↑ I have often wondered how so many can get such fantastic mileage yet I still get slightly under 40MPG. Makes me wonder if there aren't some tall tales told here!
Stop and go can really hurt your mileage. When I'm doing city driving, I do a lot of compression braking (manual transmission), I time the lights and maintain constant speeds wherever possible. Engine braking with your foot off of the gas shuts off fuel completely so it's even better than idling in neutral! Of course knowing that, you can start off with more of your friction brake earlier to stay in compression braking for longer ;)
When you think about it, if you just reduce the number of times you even need to accelerate, it's even better than accelerating slowly. Very few people drive like that, if you're like the other 90% out there you just follow nose to bumper, mimicking the car in front of you with very little space or time to do anything different.
So knowing that, you should always be paying enough attention to what's going on in front of you to know when you need to start gliding in neutral to slow down, or when you need to start engine braking, always keeping things as smooth as possible for any cars behind you. As a rule of thumb, one should very very rarely need to use friction brakes on the highway. Thinking ahead, paying attention and driving more proactively is the key here, which is actually safer then following bumper to bumper and reacting.
You have to remember that your mileage really starts to drop off after 55, so I like to keep it between 50 and 60, in fact when there's no traffic behind me, I like to make it a point to allow the car to drop to 50 at the crest of a hill, and speed up no faster than 60 at the bottom, making small adjustments to that accelerator pedal where necessary. If there are downhill slopes that allow me to maintain the speed limit at 60 in neutral, I'll do it. And of course I'll use less gas on hills approaching areas where I know I can actually gain speed in neutral. And of course I'll even throw it in 5th gear and use DFCO when I know it will maintain it's speed, essentially using no fuel at all and holding the speed limit.
For me the real limiting factor for my fuel efficiency is that my trips are usually too short to allow the engine warm up enough. Heck, if you're mostly doing short trips like me and you do a lot of city driving you might be right on.
It's really all up to the individual and their driving conditions, but I can tell you from 1st hand experience it's very easy to achieve 50mpg on long trips if you can manage to keep the speed down.
KrazyDawgSF Bay Area · Jun 17, 2010#62 Originally Posted by
jhsouders ↑ Based on your gas log, you fill your tank quite often, what do you do that requires you to drive so many miles? I ask because i deliver pizza's and i do the same.
I have a 130 mile RT commute for work. On the weekends, I still commute a bit, so the Yaris never gets a break.
TheRealEnthMiami, FL · Jun 21, 2010#63Im only getting 250-300 on a tank. So that's about 22-27mph if im correct. I drove once super slow and hypermillerish, and i think i still achieved only like 310-320 which is still about 29mpg... What do you guys recommend? Im about to change the spark plugs and air filter, any other ideas?
Boost AddictedAlbany NY · Jun 21, 2010#64 Originally Posted by
TheRealEnth ↑ Im only getting 250-300 on a tank. So that's about 22-27mph if im correct. I drove once super slow and hypermillerish, and i think i still achieved only like 310-320 which is still about 29mpg... What do you guys recommend? Im about to change the spark plugs and air filter, any other ideas?
Do you get up to speed slowly from a dead stop? Are you trying to keep your RPM's low by upshifting as much as possible? Cause if you're doing these things, THATS whats killing your fuel mileage.
Fuel consumption is all about load... Load can be visually seen if you use a vacuum gauge. High vacuum is low load, low vacuum is high load, and you'd be surprised to see what little usage of your right foot can do to your vacuum levels.
Think about it this way.... You're on the leg press machine starting with your knees at your chest... What takes more energy? Pushing the weight stack away from you, or holding it there? Holding it, right? the quicker you get there, the less energy you use. It would be like doing a slow leg press to the extended leg position, vs. extending your legs as quickly as possible and holding it there.
Stupid analogy, I know, but hopefully you can see how it works. I'm not saying peel away from every stop light, but do NOT be afraid of RPM's. Shift at 3-4K RPM's, cruise at no less than 2K, and get up to speed more quickly. You don't need to be unsafe about it, but I guarantee you'll see a difference in fuel mileage. Oh, and when coming to a stop, keep your car in gear.... Above 1200RPM's (IIRC) IN GEAR while your foot is off the throttle, your injector solenoids shut off... So you're using ZERO fuel.
/rant lol
PS. Air filters are most efficient at 60% of their life. A clean air filter allows only a slightly better flow, but a much less efficient ''cleaning'' of intake air.
Yaris HiltonBristol, Tennessee, USA · Jun 21, 2010#65Changing spark plugs won't increase your mileage or power if you're not getting misfiring, which sets the "Check Engine" light and a trouble code. The original plugs are iridium ones good for 100,000 miles. Save your money.
STCState College, PA, USA · Jun 21, 2010#66 Originally Posted by
TheRealEnth ↑ Im only getting 250-300 on a tank. So that's about 22-27mph if im correct. I drove once super slow and hypermillerish, and i think i still achieved only like 310-320 which is still about 29mpg... What do you guys recommend? Im about to change the spark plugs and air filter, any other ideas?
What kind of driving in Miami? Mostly highway or city? Miami driving can be very challenging to get high FE.
I used to live in Miami. All the stop and go driving will kill your FE. If you are driving like Kendall Drive (SW 88th Street) from Dadeland to West Kendall, I can see you averaging around 22-27mpg!
The previous poster, "Boost Addicted" gives you good advice!
Cheers! 🙂
yarr_isWest LA · Jun 21, 2010#67Too much speeding yo
TheRealEnthMiami, FL · Jun 22, 2010#68haha. ;d i try to keep highway speeds at 60-70 and drive down streets at 50-60
daf62757Indianapolis, Indiana · Jun 30, 2010#69I did change my spark plugs and it sure felt like I had more power. No scientific evidence to support this, but the fool behind the wheel test was successful so that is the only evidence I really care about!
daf62757Indianapolis, Indiana · Jun 30, 2010#70 Originally Posted by
Zaphod ↑ Stop and go can really hurt your mileage. When I'm doing city driving, I do a lot of compression braking (manual transmission), I time the lights and maintain constant speeds wherever possible. Engine braking with your foot off of the gas shuts off fuel completely so it's even better than idling in neutral! Of course knowing that, you can start off with more of your friction brake earlier to stay in compression braking for longer ;)
When you think about it, if you just reduce the number of times you even need to accelerate, it's even better than accelerating slowly. Very few people drive like that, if you're like the other 90% out there you just follow nose to bumper, mimicking the car in front of you with very little space or time to do anything different.
So knowing that, you should always be paying enough attention to what's going on in front of you to know when you need to start gliding in neutral to slow down, or when you need to start engine braking, always keeping things as smooth as possible for any cars behind you. As a rule of thumb, one should very very rarely need to use friction brakes on the highway. Thinking ahead, paying attention and driving more proactively is the key here, which is actually safer then following bumper to bumper and reacting.
You have to remember that your mileage really starts to drop off after 55, so I like to keep it between 50 and 60, in fact when there's no traffic behind me, I like to make it a point to allow the car to drop to 50 at the crest of a hill, and speed up no faster than 60 at the bottom, making small adjustments to that accelerator pedal where necessary. If there are downhill slopes that allow me to maintain the speed limit at 60 in neutral, I'll do it. And of course I'll use less gas on hills approaching areas where I know I can actually gain speed in neutral. And of course I'll even throw it in 5th gear and use DFCO when I know it will maintain it's speed, essentially using no fuel at all and holding the speed limit.
For me the real limiting factor for my fuel efficiency is that my trips are usually too short to allow the engine warm up enough. Heck, if you're mostly doing short trips like me and you do a lot of city driving you might be right on.
It's really all up to the individual and their driving conditions, but I can tell you from 1st hand experience it's very easy to achieve 50mpg on long trips if you can manage to keep the speed down.
When you have to drive on Interstates, driving slow is dangerous. I drive to Chicago once a week and I am lucky to drive 75 MPH without being run over. At 75MPH, I usually get around 35 to 38 MPG. I wish I could get 50 MPG, but for me, that isn't a realistic goal.
DevilGirlLehigh Valley, PA · Jun 30, 2010#71 Originally Posted by
daf62757 ↑ When you have to drive on Interstates, driving slow is dangerous. I drive to Chicago once a week and I am lucky to drive 75 MPH without being run over. At 75MPH, I usually get around 35 to 38 MPG. I wish I could get 50 MPG, but for me, that isn't a realistic goal.
Agreed. Local turnpike (toll road) that I drive daily for approximately 54 miles out of my 100-ish mile commute, the posted limit is 65. I don't dare go much under that for fear of being run over (it's nearly happened a few times).
But even doing 65, I can easily average around 38mpg (occassional 37, or 40).
Not as great as what others can get with their Yarii, but truthfully, it's certainly good enough for me! It's better than most any other car out there performing under similar conditions (ex. prior car was a Mitsu Lancer ES; averaged 27mpg).
bkrowndUpper Waiakea Forest Reserve · Jun 30, 2010#72Some of you peeps need to leave your Road Raging areas and find saner corners of the country to live in.
I really hated it when some of the roads went to 75. Never drove faster than 65 max on those, and never will. As a passenger I was in a car that hit a deer at 75 in heavy traffic, and we escaped death by mere inches. Once was enough...
bkrowndUpper Waiakea Forest Reserve · Jun 30, 2010#73 Originally Posted by
jhsouders ↑ I actually find that i get better mpg on hilly terrain, granted its still highway. Going down the hills i just throw it in neutral getting around 4-5 hundred mpg while maintaining speed (DFCO would slow my car, and i would again have to use gas, so neutral is better in this case).
I've always suspected I get better MPG going up and down shallow mountain slopes than I would cruising at constant speed on flat ground. More energy is wasted turning the motor at cruising RPM than at idling RPM, so storing energy as elevation gain on the uphill climb and coasting or engine braking most of the way back down should yield higher MPG than cruising at high RPM on flat ground. Even despite the extra energy used to climb and the thinner air at higher elevations.
Just make absolutely sure that you're in a car that WILL NOT STALL while coasting. My stickshift Toyotas will idle happily until The End Of Time, but I've encountered some SUV type cars with automatic transmissions that will not idle reliably and are not safe to coast.
sailbobGreen Cove Springs, FL · Jun 30, 2010#74 Originally Posted by
Zaphod ↑ Stop and go can really hurt your mileage. When I'm doing city driving, I do a lot of compression braking (manual transmission), I time the lights and maintain constant speeds wherever possible. Engine braking with your foot off of the gas shuts off fuel completely so it's even better than idling in neutral! Of course knowing that, you can start off with more of your friction brake earlier to stay in compression braking for longer ;)
When you think about it, if you just reduce the number of times you even need to accelerate, it's even better than accelerating slowly. Very few people drive like that, if you're like the other 90% out there you just follow nose to bumper, mimicking the car in front of you with very little space or time to do anything different.
So knowing that, you should always be paying enough attention to what's going on in front of you to know when you need to start gliding in neutral to slow down, or when you need to start engine braking, always keeping things as smooth as possible for any cars behind you. As a rule of thumb, one should very very rarely need to use friction brakes on the highway. Thinking ahead, paying attention and driving more proactively is the key here, which is actually safer then following bumper to bumper and reacting.
You have to remember that your mileage really starts to drop off after 55, so I like to keep it between 50 and 60, in fact when there's no traffic behind me, I like to make it a point to allow the car to drop to 50 at the crest of a hill, and speed up no faster than 60 at the bottom, making small adjustments to that accelerator pedal where necessary. If there are downhill slopes that allow me to maintain the speed limit at 60 in neutral, I'll do it. And of course I'll use less gas on hills approaching areas where I know I can actually gain speed in neutral. And of course I'll even throw it in 5th gear and use DFCO when I know it will maintain it's speed, essentially using no fuel at all and holding the speed limit.
For me the real limiting factor for my fuel efficiency is that my trips are usually too short to allow the engine warm up enough. Heck, if you're mostly doing short trips like me and you do a lot of city driving you might be right on.
It's really all up to the individual and their driving conditions, but I can tell you from 1st hand experience it's very easy to achieve 50mpg on long trips if you can manage to keep the speed down.
The ScanGuage supports your statement exactly. If I keep the speed down under 45 on level ground with little stop and go (country road) I can actually obtain a little over 60 mpg. However accelerating to 70 and no regard for pedal control mileage drops to 32 to 35 and with an opposing wind 28 mpg. The a/c drops it another 10 mpg.
DevilGirlLehigh Valley, PA · Jul 1, 2010#75 Originally Posted by
bkrownd ↑ Some of you peeps need to leave your Road Raging areas and find saner corners of the country to live in.
I really hated it when some of the roads went to 75. Never drove faster than 65 max on those, and never will. As a passenger I was in a car that hit a deer at 75 in heavy traffic, and we escaped death by mere inches. Once was enough...
Actually I do live in a relatively sane area. It's just the commute to work, since I do live "in the country" as opposed to the city where the work is...
STCState College, PA, USA · Jul 1, 2010#76 Originally Posted by
DevilGirl ↑ Actually I do live in a relatively sane area. It's just the commute to work, since I do live "in the country" as opposed to the city where the work is...
Yeppers! Sane here... You know how State College area is! When they call for "rush hour" it's more like 'rush minute". 😁
Cheers!
daf62757Indianapolis, Indiana · Jul 4, 2010#77You know, the difference between 41 and 38 MPG is not really that much. The creature comfort of cruise control and AC make it well worth the 3 or 4 MPG that these luxuries cost me.
Chuck GThe Great Northwest · Jul 4, 2010#78 Originally Posted by
daf62757 ↑ You know, the difference between 41 and 38 MPG is not really that much. The creature comfort of cruise control and AC make it well worth the 3 or 4 MPG that these luxuries cost me.
👍
Yaris HiltonBristol, Tennessee, USA · Jul 4, 2010#79Yeah, I've said the same thing. I'm using them and taking what I get. I drive reasonably, but I don't do real "hypermiling."
bkrowndUpper Waiakea Forest Reserve · Jul 5, 2010#80 Originally Posted by
daf62757 ↑ You know, the difference between 41 and 38 MPG is not really that much. The creature comfort of cruise control and AC make it well worth the 3 or 4 MPG that these luxuries cost me.
YMMV. I will get out and push for 3 extra MPG. ;)
gokartrideTexas · Jul 5, 2010#81AC isn't really a creature comfort here...it's life support!
Kal-ElMassachusetts · Jul 5, 2010#82I'd still run my AC even if it dropped FE by 25%.
If the cabin temp is above about 72 degrees, I run the AC.
YarisduderMontreal, Canada · Jul 6, 2010#83So what was said above is that if on my two best tanks I hadn't run the AC I'd have gotten about 50mpg? How much energy does it really require to run the AC? 1hp? 2hp? I doubt more than that, so I should probably see a mere 1 to 2% increase in fuel mileage if I turn it off. Thinking back though, my best mileage is with the air conditioner turned on, maybe it's because the fuel atomizes better in hotter weather? Maybe it's because I changed the engine air filter? It certainly has nothing to do with the AC.
Does the Yaris require the full power of it's engine to keep moving? Is it possible that the AC operates on extra power that would otherwise be wasted and therefore only affects your fuel efficiency when accelerating or driving very very fast?
yarrrnew mexico · Jul 6, 2010#84 Originally Posted by
Yarisduder ↑ So what was said above is that if on my two best tanks I hadn't run the AC I'd have gotten about 50mpg? How much energy does it really require to run the AC? 1hp? 2hp? I doubt more than that, so I should probably see a mere 1 to 2% increase in fuel mileage if I turn it off. Thinking back though, my best mileage is with the air conditioner turned on, maybe it's because the fuel atomizes better in hotter weather? Maybe it's because I changed the engine air filter? It certainly has nothing to do with the AC.
Does the Yaris require the full power of it's engine to keep moving? Is it possible that the AC operates on extra power that would otherwise be wasted and therefore only affects your fuel efficiency when accelerating or driving very very fast?
On the freeway, having windows down creates drag which hurts your FE than having the A/C on.
And no, the A/C doesn't run on magical "extra energy." Just about every ounce of wasted energy has been engineered out of modern highly fuel efficient cars.
YarisduderMontreal, Canada · Jul 6, 2010#85I never drive with the windows open, and except for the last two tanks of gas because of a road trip all my driving is city driving.
Yaris HiltonBristol, Tennessee, USA · Jul 6, 2010#86Probably around 35 MPH is a break even point between having the windows open and having AC on. Above that I always close the windows and use the AC as needed. Window drag varies a great deal with the wind conditions, of course. Once I've spent the energy to cool off a hot interior with the AC, I'm unlikely to roll the windows back down. Keeping the AC on low recirculating doesn't take a lot of power.
BailOutReno, Nevada, USA · Jul 7, 2010#87 Originally Posted by
yarrr ↑ On the freeway, having windows down creates drag which hurts your FE than having the A/C on.
This is inaccurate. In both testing with our SGII's and as proven in the 3rd season of the Mythbusters television show, windows down is always more efficient than a/c at any speed.
In fact, with the SGII it is nigh impossible to read the drag hit of having the windows down, but turning on the a/c at any speed is an instant large and sustained hit to FE.
daf62757Indianapolis, Indiana · Jul 7, 2010#88 Originally Posted by
BailOut ↑ This is inaccurate. In both testing with our SGII's and as proven in the 3rd season of the Mythbusters television show, windows down is always more efficient than a/c at any speed.
In fact, with the SGII it is nigh impossible to read the drag hit of having the windows down, but turning on the a/c at any speed is an instant large and sustained hit to FE.
I didn't see that episode, but I did a search on found this website.
http://green.autoblog.com/2007/08/29...-down-episode/ According to the website, windows down does hurt mileage. Just on a simple physics level, the air entering the cabin has to have some breaking action on the vehicle as the air has no place to displace. If you had the tail open, it could be a flow through action that might not effect the velocity of the car.
I am no expert on the matter....but I did stay at a Holiday Inn Express last night and will use my AC....because I love cold air and I am rich enough to afford the extra quarter.
YarisduderMontreal, Canada · Jul 7, 2010#89 Originally Posted by
BailOut ↑ In fact, with the SGII it is nigh impossible to read the drag hit of having the windows down, but turning on the a/c at any speed is an instant large and sustained hit to FE.
Do you have numbers to share with us? How did you control your environment? Was the ground flat? What speeds, was there wind, etc?
-
BailOutReno, Nevada, USA · Jul 7, 2010#90 Originally Posted by
Yarisduder ↑ Do you have numbers to share with us? How did you control your environment? Was the ground flat? What speeds, was there wind, etc?
There was a big thread on it that was lost in the hack, but as I said the Mythbusters found the same thing, as did the folks on CleanMPG, as did the folks on PriusChat, etc. In other words it has become common knowledge.
As for the test environment, etc., it simply doesn't matter. Windows down in any scenario is far, far more efficient than using a/c in any scenario. It doesn't matter if you're pulling into your driveway or cruising down a highway, rain or shine, winds or no.
Tinting goes a long way for avoiding a/c use. When combined with window vents it lets me keep the 35% front window on the sunny side cracked about 2 inches and have the shaded window fully down, or both windows down when the sun is directly overhead or to the front. Aided by the 6% tint on the rear windows and top of the windshield (the darkest allowed by local laws) it helps keep the interior much cooler than without any of these things. In stifling heat I run the fan (just the fan - no a/c) on the fresh intake setting to aid with circulation.
Despite living in a high desert region the only times I have ever run the a/c is when my wife experiences hormonal issues. None of my other passengers ever ask for it.
yarrrnew mexico · Jul 7, 2010#91 Originally Posted by
BailOut ↑ This is inaccurate. In both testing with our SGII's and as proven in the 3rd season of the Mythbusters television show, windows down is always more efficient than a/c at any speed.
In fact, with the SGII it is nigh impossible to read the drag hit of having the windows down, but turning on the a/c at any speed is an instant large and sustained hit to FE.
uh.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/MythBusters_(2004_season)
Myth statement
Running a car with air conditioning on is more fuel efficient than running with the windows down.
Status
Partly Busted
Notes
Tests were performed under varying conditions (55 miles per hour (89 km/h) versus 45 miles per hour (72 km/h)). Also, the 55 mph test was using a computer to estimate fuel efficiency based on air intake, not actual fuel consumption,
and showed A/C was more efficient. The 45 mph test consisted of running the tank until it was empty, and showed open windows were more efficient. This experiment—or one like it—is sometimes cited by the Magliozzi Brothers on Car Talk when presented with this question.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/MythBusters_(2005_season)
Myth statement
Running a car with air conditioning on is more fuel efficient than running with the windows down. (From AC vs. Windows Down)
Status
Partly Re-Busted/Partly Confirmed
Notes
The fundamental flaw in the MythBusters' test was that the point where the drag becomes powerful enough to inhibit a car's performance with windows down was inside their 45–55mph margin at 50mph. Going less than 50mph it is more efficient to leave the windows down,
but going greater than 50mph it is more efficient to use the A/C. The sad thing is I just pull stuff out of my ass most of the time, you write novels on this crap.
BailOutReno, Nevada, USA · Jul 8, 2010#92Interesting, yarrr, but that's not what is shown on the Mythbusters episode. My only mistake was calling it from 2003 rather than the revisit in 2005.
What they found in 2003 was so controversial that they revisited it in 2005 and got the totally opposite response. I'm not sure where the 50 MPG "barrier" idea came from as it's not in the episode (which I just watched again via Netflix) or on the Discovery web site. The only thing shown in the episode was that windows down beats a/c period, and this is what (I say again) consumer testing here on YW, CleanMPG and PriusChat have also shown.
If you don't believe me then get a ScanGauge of your own and go nuts. 🙂
Yaris HiltonBristol, Tennessee, USA · Jul 8, 2010#93I can't believe windows down beats AC in EVERY condition, but I'm not about to buy a Scangauge and do a bunch of testing, either.
Kal-ElMassachusetts · Jul 8, 2010#94If gas was $10/gal, I'd still crank my AC. There's no way in hell I'm sweating my balls off on purpose. And I hate my windows down.
STCState College, PA, USA · Jul 8, 2010#95Well, It's been downright HOT here in Central PA... hazy, humid and no breeze! There has been three days of +95 degree temperature and one of those days close to 100 F!
I've been using A/C more than my usual increments. Around 90% of the time!
I thought this would kill my gas mileage, but it didn't. My Yaris actually does great in the HOT weather. I filled up early this morning and to my suprise I got 49.524 MPG (495/9.995). My second best MPG and no trips... country driving mainly!
I'm taking a trip next week... 🙂 Bring on the HOT temperatures... just for next week. 😛
Cheers!
KrazyDawgSF Bay Area · Jul 12, 2010#96 Originally Posted by
BailOut ↑ In fact, with the SGII it is nigh impossible to read the drag hit of having the windows down, but turning on the a/c at any speed is an instant large and sustained hit to FE.
That's good to know. I always thought 40-45 MPH was the breaking point between having the A/C and window open but I found out I was actually getting higher MPG on one fill-up with the windows open and 90ºF weather.
Does it make a difference if only the driver side window is open? I don't have power windows.
How much of a MPG hit do you take going from A/C level I to level II? What about when you compare no air to air on level II but with A/C off?
bkrowndUpper Waiakea Forest Reserve · Jul 12, 2010#97I had to turn on the heat for a few minutes yesterday. I wonder how it effects my MPG... :D
jhsoudersThread starterHillsboro OR · Jul 16, 2010#98 Originally Posted by
bkrownd ↑ I had to turn on the heat for a few minutes yesterday. I wonder how it effects my MPG... :D
I dont have much experience in the matter as i got my scangauge in the summer, so no heat was needed. But i have heard that heat causes little to no hit on FE, because its only excess heat coming from the engine. Again, have not tested this. And i would assume its not true when the engine is just turned on on a cold morning, but only after its been running a while.
BailOutReno, Nevada, USA · Jul 16, 2010#99 Originally Posted by
jhsouders ↑ I dont have much experience in the matter as i got my scangauge in the summer, so no heat was needed. But i have heard that heat causes little to no hit on FE, because its only excess heat coming from the engine. Again, have not tested this. And i would assume its not true when the engine is just turned on on a cold morning, but only after its been running a while.
There is indeed an FE hit from using the heater as your engine relies on a certain water temperature as a measurement of engine efficiency and will run rich any time it's not meeting it in order to produce more waste heat. However, it is a much smaller hit than a/c usage, and I believe in keeping my joints warm enough to easily control the vehicle in snowy and icy conditions.
daf62757Indianapolis, Indiana · Jul 16, 2010#100 Originally Posted by
bkrownd ↑ I had to turn on the heat for a few minutes yesterday. I wonder how it effects my MPG... :D
You are now on Al Gore's hit list!