Yarisworld Archive

The battle of the Droids??!

501 posts · 113,943 views · page 1 of 11

tomatoOriginal postSan Francisco Bay Area · Apr 9, 2010#1
OK, guys, I'm really torn between these 2 droids 🆘🆘

1) Nexus One

2) Droid


If you had to choose between the 2 which one would you get?

(the Droid's slider keyboard is a huge advantage to me, but the kb itself is not the greatest and the N1 is faster [snapdragon 1g processor] and looks brighter in direct sunlight [amoled display]). I'm confused.

I gotta try to figure out the total cost to own between the 2, exactly, but it looks like the N1 would cost me less in the long run but not by a whole lot.

Any input would be greatly appreciated here, thanks!

2 attachments not included in this copy

Replies 500

tomatoThread starterSan Francisco Bay Area · Apr 9, 2010#2
If you're interested, there is a good side by side comparison here n1 v. droid

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=v3CT1s01Hu8 (part 1 of 2)

it'll take 20 minutes to watch both parts.
AND189australia · Apr 9, 2010#3
man up crack open a new iphone mate
ShroomsterOrlando · Apr 9, 2010#4
Originally Posted by AND189 ↑
man up crack open a new iphone mate

if she had wanted iPhone input she would have asked for it. Please, lets not clutter this.




I honestly think it comes down to manufacturers. do you want HTC or do you want Motorola. honestly I'd go with HTC.
eTiMaGoBangkok, Thailand · Apr 9, 2010#5
I have a Droid (well technically a Milestone, the international GSM version) and it's awesome... Sure, it's slower (can't say it's really noticeable, but then you can overclock it)

A friend of mine for an N1, I played around with it, it is rather nice but just feels kinda flimsy, the Motorola could do well in a pinch as a bludgeoning tool 😆

Also, although the N1's screen is technically superior (AMOLED is rather nice), and with the same resolution, it just does not look as sharp, like the pixels are not square, almost fuzzy... I just looooove the Motorola's screen, as sharp as a Hattori Hanso sword 😛

Design-wise, the N1 does look like a pretty generic HTC handset, the Droid/Milestone has a rather unique design... The slide-out keyboard, I do not often use it unless I am typing a long email, one way or another no phone can touch the Blackberries when it comes to keyboards :D

And, with the Android 2.1 update, you get a lot of the N1's eyecandy now... Tomato, go search the market for "live wallpaper", there's a whole bunch of cool free ones :)

OK, I think I've went on long enough :D
Kal-ElMassachusetts · Apr 9, 2010#6
I love my Motorola Droid. I bought it before the Nexus 1 came out. If I were buying a phone now, I'd take a strong look at the N1 for one particular reason - I don't use the slide out keyboard on the Droid because the virtual one is way faster and easier to use. So the Nexus has the advantage of being slimmer. Other than that, they match up pretty closely. Also depends if you like the chiselled look and feel of the Droid or the soft rounded N1. I also don't think the N1's processor isn't that big of a difference.
tomatoThread starterSan Francisco Bay Area · Apr 9, 2010#7
Just to get it out of the way, the iPhone is not an option for me at the moment
(I know it's a cool phone, I've played with it, too, just not an option, enough said 😁)

I also know that Blackberry is rumored to be working on a "T" model (model T ? 😆) with a slider KB and a bigger screen.

http://www.phonedog.com/2010/03/03/p...device-emerge/

I know the minute I see it, I'm gonna kick myself for not waiting [I just loved the way the BB Bold 9700 handled mail and messages, the simplicity of the interface, the battery lasting for days 🙇 🙇🤤], but I've made up my mind to not wait any longer than May / June at the latest.

There are other phones I'm interested in are: HTC Incredible, and HTC Evo but right now, nobody's seen them in person since they're due to release in a month or so, and we don't know how much they're gonna cost, what plans come with them, on what carriers etc. so that's why I've pretty much narrowed it between the 2 current Android top dogs : Nexus 1 and Droid.

Right now, Nexus 1 runs on TMobile (AT&T is not an option for me), which makes it a little more accessible for me (cheaper to own) but the network is a little spotty in some areas; and the Droid runs on Verizon, which has a rock-solid network in San Francisco although they do charge a little more for it.
tomatoThread starterSan Francisco Bay Area · Apr 9, 2010#8
Oh, nooooooooooooooooooo here comes the Incredible!!!

http://www.phonedog.com/2010/04/09/h...ate-confirmed/

Look at these specs

e now official specs are as follows:

* CPU speed: 1 GHz (Snapdragon processor)
* Platform: Android™ 2.1 (Éclair) with HTC Sense™
* Memory: ROM: 512 MB, RAM: 576 MB
* Display: 3.7-inch AMOLED touch-sensitive screen with 480 X 800 WVGA resolution
* Onscreen navigation: Optical joystick
* GPS
* Sensors: G-Sensor, Digital compass, Proximity sensor, Ambient light sensor
* Connectivity: Bluetooth® 2.1, Wi-Fi®: IEEE 802.11 b/g/n, 3.5 mm stereo audio jack, micro-USB (12-pin micro-USB 2.0)
* Camera: 8 megapixel color camera with auto focus and flash
* Expansion slot: microSD™ memory card (up to 32GB)

hmmmm....
eTiMaGoBangkok, Thailand · Apr 9, 2010#9
My dear, if I can give some simple advice, waiting for the "next best thing" to be released will keep you phone-less for a long time 😆

Although on the other end of the spectrum, keeping on the bleeding edge is a very expensive process... 😉
tomatoThread starterSan Francisco Bay Area · Apr 9, 2010#10
^ that's true. That's why I gave myself a deadline and narrowed it down to the Android topdogs above. But another 2 weeks isn't gonna make a big difference ;)

To complicate things further, the 2 phones (OK, 3 or 4 phones ;) I'm looking at, are not on the same network at the moment.

So , for example, the N1 would cost me approx. $20 less a month, maybe a bit more, than the Droid. Doesn't look like much each month, but over 2 years, it's $480. 🤷

The Droid on Verizon is rock solid though. *sigh* If the phone is slower, I can't tell because the network is so fast !
tomatoThread starterSan Francisco Bay Area · Apr 9, 2010#11
Originally Posted by Kal-El ↑
I love my Motorola Droid. I bought it before the Nexus 1 came out. If I were buying a phone now, I'd take a strong look at the N1 for one particular reason - I don't use the slide out keyboard on the Droid because the virtual one is way faster and easier to use. So the Nexus has the advantage of being slimmer. Other than that, they match up pretty closely. Also depends if you like the chiselled look and feel of the Droid or the soft rounded N1. I also don't think the N1's processor isn't that big of a difference.
I know what you mean, I've noticed the same thing. The droid's physical kb is really nice to have but it's not the greatest. I get frustrated with it and just for that reason, I've started using the virtual KB much more (in landscape).

I think the Droid looks just fine, got no problem with the angular look, can even handle the extra weight. Not a fan of the display in the sun light, though.

this is driving me crazy. Maybe I ought to flip a coin 🙄
darthbauerUSA · Apr 9, 2010#12
Go HTC. My gf has/had the moto one and it had issues. I would compare the issues that she was having to the one's that I used to have with my Razr and any other Moto phone that I have had for that matter.
H3LlIoNMidatlantic · Apr 9, 2010#13
Originally Posted by AND189 ↑
man up crack open a new iphone mate
Why? The iphone doesn't even compare.




I have the droid, it's awesome. Although I think the nexus one comes with the snapdragon 1ghz, which you have to root/overclock droid to achieve.
tomatoThread starterSan Francisco Bay Area · Apr 9, 2010#14
OK, I put up a poll.

Yes, I know, I left out the iPhone.

No, I didn't forget 😁 😁
ShroomsterOrlando · Apr 9, 2010#15
not to sound harsh Tomato, but geez girl you've been biting at this since at least January. that's when I got my MyTouch.....

make a decision already lol :)
tomatoThread starterSan Francisco Bay Area · Apr 9, 2010#16
hahhaha ^ longer, actually! lol. I have wanted to upgrade my phone for a long time, just never really got to it and for someone who's been out of the loop a while, it's a lot of information to take in. 🙂

What would make my life a lot easier is to be able to go see the N1 in person someplace and be able to play with it a little longer than 20 seconds (not that I'm not grateful to the total strangers who've let me play with their phones 20 seconds ;)

The reviews will only tell you so much. Ultimately, you have to have the device in your hands and begin using it to notice everything they're not telling you. That's why I ask you peeps for feedback 😁

(not that I don't get your point 😉)
tomatoThread starterSan Francisco Bay Area · Apr 9, 2010#17
Doesn't help that right now is when they're releasing all the new-and-improved devices.
They seem to do that about twice a year, around mother's day/ father's day, and in October/November.
Nothing wrong with taking your time to get something you're *really* happy with, so you don't have to go back and upgrade constantly. 🤷

Tomato.
Kal-ElMassachusetts · Apr 9, 2010#18
Originally Posted by AND189 ↑
man up crack open a new iphone mate
Originally Posted by H3LlIoN ↑
Why? The iphone doesn't even compare.

I have the droid, it's awesome. Although I think the nexus one comes with the snapdragon 1ghz, which you have to root/overclock droid to achieve.
Seriously, the only advantage to iPhone is more apps and a slicker UI. And the huge app count is largely made up of duplicate app ideas.

Droid/Nexus excel in many more important areas.

- bigger, sharper screen
- bigger, louder, clearer speaker
- better camera with flash (doubles as flashlight)
- open source
- universal hardware
- Google map navigation (the best GPS software)
- Google's accurate speech to text
- removable battery
- expandable memory
- better network

To name a few....😎
tomatoThread starterSan Francisco Bay Area · Apr 9, 2010#19
come on, go click on the poll 🙂 🙂

I really want to know what you think 🙇 🙇
AltitudeColorado · Apr 9, 2010#20
Originally Posted by tomato ↑
Oh, nooooooooooooooooooo here comes the Incredible!!!

http://www.phonedog.com/2010/04/09/h...ate-confirmed/

Look at these specs

e now official specs are as follows:

* CPU speed: 1 GHz (Snapdragon processor)
* Platform: Android™ 2.1 (Éclair) with HTC Sense™
* Memory: ROM: 512 MB, RAM: 576 MB
* Display: 3.7-inch AMOLED touch-sensitive screen with 480 X 800 WVGA resolution
* Onscreen navigation: Optical joystick
* GPS
* Sensors: G-Sensor, Digital compass, Proximity sensor, Ambient light sensor
* Connectivity: Bluetooth® 2.1, Wi-Fi®: IEEE 802.11 b/g/n, 3.5 mm stereo audio jack, micro-USB (12-pin micro-USB 2.0)
* Camera: 8 megapixel color camera with auto focus and flash
* Expansion slot: microSD™ memory card (up to 32GB)

hmmmm....
1 ghz would be the deciding factor for me. I'd wait for the Incredible, it's not that far off.
tomatoThread starterSan Francisco Bay Area · Apr 9, 2010#21
no, it's not 🤤🤤

i don't understand why they feel the need to stick an 8MP camera in there, though. I have a 12 MP Canon and hardly *ever* shoot at full 12 MP.

I wonder what kind of battery life that thing gets. ??
ezhacker1San Francisco · Apr 9, 2010#22
when it comes to android is there a good amount of game apps for when im bored? The reason i hate winmo which i have is the lack of apps of all sort...
tomatoThread starterSan Francisco Bay Area · Apr 9, 2010#24
[btw, Thomas, I was wrong about the live wallpapers. The US update included them as well (you have to set them up manually, though, they're hidden) ;) ]



whoa ... 6 votes for the Incredible, really? wow... food for thoughts!
Can't wait to see how much that thing is gonna cost and what plans it's gonna be tethered to at VZW.
AltitudeColorado · Apr 9, 2010#25
Originally Posted by tomato ↑
I wonder what kind of battery life that thing gets. ??
You probably already know about this site, but if not check out http://www.xda-developers.com/ go to the forum and search for Snapdragon. You'll probably get some good info on the battery life of similar handsets.
eTiMaGoBangkok, Thailand · Apr 10, 2010#26
Originally Posted by tomato ↑
IMO (and I could be totally wrong, mind you) we're gonna see an exponential growth of apps in the Android market in the near future. It sure looks that way:

http://www.phonedog.com/2010/04/09/a...ions-in-march/
I just spent some time looking though the latest market free apps additions (no access to the paid apps over here...), half of it is crap... wallpaper collections, random pictures that pop up after you complete a call, etc... quantity over quality :p
tomatoThread starterSan Francisco Bay Area · Apr 10, 2010#27
Originally Posted by eTiMaGo ↑
I just spent some time looking though the latest market free apps additions (no access to the paid apps over here...), half of it is crap... wallpaper collections, random pictures that pop up after you complete a call, etc... quantity over quality :p
I think a visit to the US is in order, just to fill up on apps and stuff 😁 😁
tomatoThread starterSan Francisco Bay Area · Apr 10, 2010#28
wow, the incredible is in the lead 😲
GideonSunnyvale, CA · Apr 10, 2010#29
Originally Posted by eTiMaGo ↑
I just spent some time looking though the latest market free apps additions (no access to the paid apps over here...), half of it is crap... wallpaper collections, random pictures that pop up after you complete a call, etc... quantity over quality :p
Very true, because of how open the Android market is it's flooded with crap apps.

Although I have high hopes now that Apple has made a requirement on their app store that apps must be originally written in Objective-C, C, C++. I hope that new ridiculous restriction will push more developers to Android and WebOS.

I voted wait for the Incredible/Evo. The Evo is my next phone, assuming my work gives me one. (Which they will. 😉 )
tomatoThread starterSan Francisco Bay Area · Apr 10, 2010#30
Originally Posted by Altitude ↑
You probably already know about this site, but if not check out http://www.xda-developers.com/ go to the forum and search for Snapdragon. You'll probably get some good info on the battery life of similar handsets.
Thanks, Altitude. PK told me about that site, too, a lot of information there

I forgot about the HTC Desire, which, to be honest, appeals to me more than the N1 because it has an optical trackpad instead of a trackball, android 2.1 and HTC Sense UI on top of it (out of the box), adds flash support, same specs, physical buttons at the bottom. It actually looks like a more refined N1 🤤

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=t-TYfKiXXFE&feature=fvw

This is a really exciting time to be looking for a new phone.🤤

can't wait for the beta testers to render their initial verdict! ;)
tomatoThread starterSan Francisco Bay Area · Apr 10, 2010#31
Thanks Gideon !
You're gonna like it!!! Quite a bit different from the BB collection you have ;)
cali yarisCanoga Park, CA · Apr 10, 2010#32
I'm so lazy.

I've decided to wait until you buy one -- then buy whatever you get. 😆
why?harnett county NC · Apr 10, 2010#33
you've waited so long, might as wait a little bit longer. I would lean to verizon since their network is amazing. its the only reason i've stuck with the garbage phones they've had forever. No other network can compete.
cali yarisCanoga Park, CA · Apr 10, 2010#34
For the places I go, Sprint is better coverage.

When my Palm Pre breaks, I'll get something else -- but Sprint has NEVER had the coolest phones.
tomatoThread starterSan Francisco Bay Area · Apr 11, 2010#35
Originally Posted by cali yaris ↑
I'm so lazy.

I've decided to wait until you buy one -- then buy whatever you get. 😆
hahaha!!! 🤣🤣

Someone told me the exact same thing last week!!

Originally Posted by why? ↑
you've waited so long, might as wait a little bit longer. I would lean to verizon since their network is amazing. its the only reason i've stuck with the garbage phones they've had forever. No other network can compete.
You're right, VZW is rock solid in SF.
I have a feeling the Sprint network is catching up (in coverage, not necessarily customer service ;) but that could be changing 🤷

There is a coverage by carrier map (in Beta) at CNET if you want to check coverage of the 4 carriers in your area:

http://reviews.cnet.com/cell-phone-coverage-map/

as if it wasn't difficult already to pick a phone, you've also got to pick the best network, the best plan ... pffffff


Originally Posted by cali yaris ↑
For the places I go, Sprint is better coverage.

When my Palm Pre breaks, I'll get something else -- but Sprint has NEVER had the coolest phones.
Well, that could be changing. The EVO is coming. Rumor has it, EVO is supposed to be the BEAST compared to the other phones on the market (kind of like your Yaris compared to our Yarii 😉) The BlackBerry T is supposed to be heading there as well. They still have the Hero and the Samsung Moment which are pretty good phones.
GideonSunnyvale, CA · Apr 11, 2010#37
Originally Posted by tomato ↑
Thanks Gideon !
You're gonna like it!!! Quite a bit different from the BB collection you have ;)
Very true, although keep in mind those were my work phones specifically, I carry two phones on me so the others are normally my work/play phones. I've had more phones than fingers. (My WinMo phones I've used. 😉 )
tomatoThread starterSan Francisco Bay Area · Apr 11, 2010#38
holy cow that's a lot of phones. ^ So I take it Sprint works for you?

I had Sprint years ago, wasn't that great back then but it looks like the network is considerably better these days (according to Root Wireless, Beta)
KioshiFremont, CA · Apr 11, 2010#39
I voted for HTC Evo/Incredible....the 8 mp attracts me, but VZW plans won't :(
Sprint charges an arm and a leg to buy the phone, but cheaper monthly plans than AT&T and VZW....

I am in the market for a phone, but more along the lines of a Motorola Droid type phone. I'd like a 8 megapixel camera w/ that kind of styling...I have a flip phone w/ 5.1 mp...can't downgrade to photo quality and i hate carrying digi cameras...pockets look FAT.
GideonSunnyvale, CA · Apr 11, 2010#40
That's just a few, I'm rocking a Palm Pre right now, which I really like. (Build quality aside)

Sprint has worked very well for me. I travel a decent amount and haven't had any issues. With the exception of visiting relatives in the boonies in upstate NY near the Canadian border. 😆

Customer Care was a different story although Sprint's customer care today is 100x better than what it used to be. No more 50 minute hold times, reps hanging up on you, etc.
tomatoThread starterSan Francisco Bay Area · Apr 11, 2010#41
I got the same impression with Sprint customer care when I tried to get the Hero 2 months ago. It's kind of a long story, but they pretty much refused to give me the plan I had found online at their own website on a technicality (I wanted a business plan and they said self-employment didn't qualify for a business plan, they said I had to be an employee of a corporation. Uh? That's weird, because the IRS and other entities have no problem with that, "dba's / sole proprietorships and small businesses " are businesses too, last I checked 🤷) so anyway after arguing with them a while, then I decided not to get the phone at the moment.

The Sprint business plans are a little different, more flexible (or were, at the time) you could start w/ a 200 minutes voice plan if you wanted whereas the consumer plans start with a 450 minute voice plan, mandatory). I only use an 60 minutes voice per month on average, and that's when I try real hard to use my phone.

I've learned my lesson, though, next time, I won't even bother going into the store, except for trying out the phones. I'll just do everything online and hope for the best 🤷

That's part of the appeal of the N1 for me. You get the phone on your own, then you shop for the best possible plan you can get and NO CONTRACT. I think when the N1 comes to Verizon and Sprint, that will force more flexibility w/ the plans. That's also part of the reason I'm still waiting even though I started this process 2 months ago already. I don't want to be stuck with a 2 y contract with any given company, if I can find a better rate and no contract, and everybody knew that the N1 was coming to the other carriers in the Spring.

sorry for the long winded post. I just never had any luck with Sprint 🙁
GideonSunnyvale, CA · Apr 11, 2010#42
IIRC when I looked into business plans all they require is a business tax ID number.
tomatoThread starterSan Francisco Bay Area · Apr 11, 2010#43
Kioshi, be sure the quality of the photo is good. The number of MP alone doesn't necessarily equate to good quality photos, and there are other things like shutter speed, on board editing functions, etc.

Still, I can't wait to see the initial reviews for this phone. Hope it won't be too much longer now.
tomatoThread starterSan Francisco Bay Area · Apr 11, 2010#44
Originally Posted by Gideon ↑
IIRC when I looked into business plans all they require is a business tax ID number.
Yeah, but when you file your tax return your business tax ID number is your SS number if you're self-employed. 🤷
GideonSunnyvale, CA · Apr 11, 2010#45
Right, what I meant is they only consider businesses with tax ID #s as businesses eligible for those plans.

Not that I would consider that a problem, since all Sprint's plans are cheaper than Verizon's AND they have some crazy discounts. Like 10% for just being a credit union member, lol. 😆
tomatoThread starterSan Francisco Bay Area · Apr 11, 2010#46
BTW, I'm not saying I wont get a Sprint phone, what I'm saying is if I find an equivalent phone with a better plan attached, I'll go to the better plan (if the coverage is adequate in my area).
tomatoThread starterSan Francisco Bay Area · Apr 11, 2010#47
Originally Posted by Gideon ↑
Right, what I meant is they only consider businesses with tax ID #s as businesses eligible for those plans.

Not that I would consider that a problem, since all Sprint's plans are cheaper than Verizon's AND they have some crazy discounts. Like 10% for just being a credit union member, lol. 😆
10% is that on the phone, or on the plan? I didn't know that. Can you link?

I hear what you're saying but shouldn't these plans just say specifically "these plans are offered if you qualify for ...... and .... and ..." instead of just saying "business plans"?
eTiMaGoBangkok, Thailand · Apr 11, 2010#48
To throw some more oil in the fire, I had to chance to play around with a Sony Ericsson Xperia X10, their own Android superphone.... Snapdragon CPU, very sexy styling, gorgeous, huge screen, and some pretty swanky custom interface improvements.... But I am not sure that it is available in the US... And, it's running on the older Android 1.6, with an upgrade to 2.1 coming "soon"...
tomatoThread starterSan Francisco Bay Area · Apr 11, 2010#49
^ it is, it is *sigh*

http://www.phonedog.com/2010/03/22/s...n-impressions/

At some point, I gotta narrow it down, though. 🙂

I'm not considering any phones attached to AT&T because the coverage is ***terrible*** in SF 👎

that leaves Sprint, VZW, and T-Mobile. In my experience out here in the Bay Area,

- Sprint has good coverage in the Bay Area but still so-so customer service (although they're rumored to be working on it?) pretty good plans, especially if you talk on your phone a lot (I had Sprint for a few years)

- VZW has a rock-solid network, equally solid / extremely professional customer service, but the most expensive plans.

- T-Mo has so-so coverage, but *excellent* and I mean *excellent* customer sce. For each person who drops the ball in some way, there is 1000 others right behind them trying to make it right for you. And their plans are the best, most flexible (especially since they got the N1, they've come up with additional plans)

(this is just my opinion based on where I live).
tomatoThread starterSan Francisco Bay Area · Apr 11, 2010#50
Poor Moto Droid isn't getting any love in the polls, uh? ;)