Yarisworld Archive

Optimal MT shift points.

23 posts · 17,613 views

10DG22Original postArizona · Apr 1, 2010#1
So I'm just wondering when taking off in first gear I'm trying to find the best RPM to engage the clutch at with out hurting the transmission/clutch. Also what does everyone else shift at?

Replies 22

SilverBackEl Monte, Ca · Apr 2, 2010#2
Search button is your friend
BailOutReno, Nevada, USA · Apr 2, 2010#3
Welcome to YarisWorld, 10DG22. 🙂

I always shift at 2k RPM unless I'm merging onto the highway, in which case I allow for 2,400 RPM.

On steep grades, such as in the mountains, I shift at 2,600 RPM in order to keep some torque.
10DG22Thread starterArizona · Apr 2, 2010#4
Thanks a lot.
BuildCodeNorthern Illinois · Apr 3, 2010#5
I have the clutch fully engaged under 1,100 RPM. Generally what I do is when letting the clutch out at the very moment it starts catching I give some gas (very little), but continue engaging clutch staying around 1,000 RPM or so. This all happens quickly of course, maybe 1 second? - my goal is to engage the clutch as quickly as possible, and at as low an RPM as possible (without dipping below idle RPM). To me, this will make the most of clutch life. Once I have the clutch engaged it's another story though, I usually accelerate pretty "spirited."

Shift points totally depend...sometimes I play the 2,000 RPM game like BailOut, but usually it's just all about surrounding environment - that's what so perfect about manual transmissions, the shift points happen exactly when and where you want them to, 100% of the time. Don't worry too much about it - listen to what the car tells you and enjoy the drive!
dingbatMid-Turn (probably late apexing) · Apr 5, 2010#6
Originally Posted by 10DG22 ↑
So I'm just wondering when taking off in first gear I'm trying to find the best RPM to engage the clutch at with out hurting the transmission/clutch. Also what does everyone else shift at?
From standing, when I'm trying to be good to a car, I've always engaged a clutch with as little throttle as I can get away with without a stall or stutter. Basically, as little slip as possible. For shifting my Yaris ('10 3 door), I mostly wind it out toward red line with my foot in it most of the time (after the oil is warmed up of course) and I'm still getting 33-34 mpg on VT and Western MA mountain roads. I'm pretty shocked by the gas mileage. It's far beyond what I expected.🎉
AdeJong 03LA, CA · Apr 5, 2010#7
6500 rpm is the absolute best!
minnyarMinneapolis · Apr 6, 2010#8
I shift out of first between 2500 and 3000, and second through fourth at 2500. On braking it really depends how far I have to travel, if traffic's light and the light is red a quarter mile ahead, I go in to neutral and coast, If I am coming of the interstate I leave it in 5th and downshift to fourth around 30, then go to neutral. I have no idea if this is 'optimal' but I get a solid 39mpg in ver cold MN winters and 42-43 in the summer.
goliath1812Ocala Florida · Apr 6, 2010#9
Originally Posted by minnyar ↑
I shift out of first between 2500 and 3000, and second through fourth at 2500. On braking it really depends how far I have to travel, if traffic's light and the light is red a quarter mile ahead, I go in to neutral and coast, If I am coming of the interstate I leave it in 5th and downshift to fourth around 30, then go to neutral. I have no idea if this is 'optimal' but I get a solid 39mpg in ver cold MN winters and 42-43 in the summer.
If you downshift all the time, instead of putting it in neutral and coasting, you'll get better mileage by using DFCO.
minnyarMinneapolis · Apr 6, 2010#10
Originally Posted by goliath1812 ↑
If you downshift all the time, instead of putting it in neutral and coasting, you'll get better mileage by using DFCO.
Debatable. It really depends on how far away that red light/stop sign/etc is. There is a point at which coasting is going to be more efficient than downshifting. Downshifting is practical if I need to come to a stop, or want to casually reduce speed without using the brakes, but if a light has turned green and I know that by the time I get to the light 1/4 or 1/2 mile away all the cars in front of me are up to speed it makes more sense to coast. Think of it this way: Lets assume the speed limit is 55. Am I really saving fuel by leaving the car in gear or downshifting to obtain DFCO and I lose 20 mph of speed (at which point traffic ahead is moving sufficiently to speed up) only to have to accelerate the 20 mph back to 55. If the car was in neutral I may only lose 5 mph over the same distance. Although the engine was burning fuel by idling rather than DFCO, I only need to accelerate 5 mph. You are never going to use more fuel, in any car, than during acceleration. So while your point if valid, if you need to stop or decelerate quicker, it really depends on the distance involved.
BailOutReno, Nevada, USA · Apr 6, 2010#11
Originally Posted by minnyar ↑
Debatable. It really depends on how far away that red light/stop sign/etc is. There is a point at which coasting is going to be more efficient than downshifting. Downshifting is practical if I need to come to a stop, or want to casually reduce speed without using the brakes, but if a light has turned green and I know that by the time I get to the light 1/4 or 1/2 mile away all the cars in front of me are up to speed it makes more sense to coast. Think of it this way: Lets assume the speed limit is 55. Am I really saving fuel by leaving the car in gear or downshifting to obtain DFCO and I lose 20 mph of speed (at which point traffic ahead is moving sufficiently to speed up) only to have to accelerate the 20 mph back to 55. If the car was in neutral I may only lose 5 mph over the same distance. Although the engine was burning fuel by idling rather than DFCO, I only need to accelerate 5 mph. You are never going to use more fuel, in any car, than during acceleration. So while your point if valid, if you need to stop or decelerate quicker, it really depends on the distance involved.
Well said, minnyar.
BailOutReno, Nevada, USA · Apr 17, 2010#12
Originally Posted by jones ↑
I usually shift between 2,500 and 4,000 for first gear, because of the ridiculously different ratio's for first and second, then it's usually around the 2,500 - 3,200 mark.
The OP is looking for the optimal shift points as it concerns fuel efficiency. The RPMs you listed are much too high for that. In fact, the RPMs you listed are where I shift while accelerating from zero on a 6% grade!
10DG22Thread starterArizona · Apr 17, 2010#13
Thanks for everyone's input.
Bluevitz-rsOshawa, Ontario, Canada · Apr 18, 2010#14
My last tank yielded me 36.7MPG (US) with shifts anywhere from 2700-6000rpm. Most of my driving was conservative, but some was WOT having fun with the new 6spd.

So shifting higher doesn't affect MPG as much as you'd think. The higher you rev the motor (to a point at around 3500-4000) the more efficient it is at producing torque. Bogging the motor below 2000 only causes the timing to retard to prevent detonation which decreases it efficiency.
BailOutReno, Nevada, USA · Apr 18, 2010#15
Originally Posted by Bluevitz-rs ↑
My last tank yielded me 36.7MPG (US) with shifts anywhere from 2700-6000rpm. Most of my driving was conservative, but some was WOT having fun with the new 6spd.

So shifting higher doesn't affect MPG as much as you'd think. The higher you rev the motor (to a point at around 3500-4000) the more efficient it is at producing torque. Bogging the motor below 2000 only causes the timing to retard to prevent detonation which decreases it efficiency.
The 36 MPG you reported is the fleet average for this vehicle. Anyone trying for higher efficiency doesn't require much torque and will need to shift at lower RPMs to achieve their goal.

Higher RPM always means more fuel usage, and bogging is a thing of the past for the most part. Modern ECUs simply retard the timing to match the state of things. In almost 60k miles of hypermiling the Yaris in the mountains I have never heard the engine bog.
why?harnett county NC · Apr 18, 2010#16
you shouldn't really worry about hurting the clutch. I think it's been proven that the clutch/transmission in the yaris is rather rock solid, like most toyota's.

i also tend to shift around 2000 rpm's.
bankrobberCentral Florida · Apr 18, 2010#17
I always kinda feather the gas while releasing the clutch. No idea on RPM's as I dont have a tach. Probably between 2,500 and 3,000.
1st to 2nd at 15MPH
2nd to 3rd around 35MPH
3rd to 4th around 50 MPH
5th at 60MPH

I have 85,000 miles. My last truck was a Ram 1500 V-6 5 speed and I always shifted at the top of the power band. Never tried to save gas and shift early. Hell, a few times I hit 70MPH in 3rd gear. It was high geared. Point is I never lugged it always shifted at same speeds/RPM's and the truck loved it. I sold it at 264,000 miles and still ran great.
The Yaris is on it's way to that record
STCState College, PA, USA · Apr 21, 2010#18
Originally Posted by bankrobber ↑
I always kinda feather the gas while releasing the clutch. No idea on RPM's as I dont have a tach. Probably between 2,500 and 3,000.
1st to 2nd at 15MPH
2nd to 3rd around 35MPH
3rd to 4th around 50 MPH
5th at 60MPH
Me too... I must be really feathering!

I generally don't watch my MPH, but all the time I look at my tach.

I think my shifts are roughly?

1st to 2nd at 10MPH
2nd to 3rd around 25MPH
3rd to 4th around 30 MPH
5th at around 40MPH

My environment is big valleys and small mountains... the Northern Alleghenies of PA. When I'm level I shift between 1,600 to 1,900 RPM... Hills and ramps around 2,000 to 2,200... PA mountains around 2,300...

Shifts are with nothing in the car except me @ 160 lbs. Little higher when I have weight.
kounj · Apr 22, 2010#19
average shift point for me dding is1st,2nd and 3rd is 2500-3000rpms 4th-5th approx 2000rpm. I average between 38-42mpg.
bankrobberCentral Florida · Apr 22, 2010#20
Originally Posted by STC ↑
Me too... I must be really feathering!

I generally don't watch my MPH, but all the time I look at my tach.

I think my shifts are roughly?

1st to 2nd at 10MPH
2nd to 3rd around 25MPH
3rd to 4th around 30 MPH
5th at around 40MPH

My environment is big valleys and small mountains... the Northern Alleghenies of PA. When I'm level I shift between 1,600 to 1,900 RPM... Hills and ramps around 2,000 to 2,200... PA mountains around 2,300...

Shifts are with nothing in the car except me @ 160 lbs. Little higher when I have weight.

I was wrong I checked today and I actually shift at lower speeds than I origionally posted.
Do you have the RPM's for your shift points?
I quess I must be stuck in "old school" cause I always try to not lug a standard. From reading other post on here it seems not possible to actually lug a motor anymore
Yaris HiltonBristol, Tennessee, USA · Apr 22, 2010#21
Back in the old days there were a lot of engines with long, skinny, poorly supported crankshafts that had critical speeds in the lower operating range where the power pulses would resonate with natural torsional vibrational frequencies of the crankshaft and could cause the crankshaft to break. You won't find a modern engine you can do that to.
AND189australia · Apr 22, 2010#22
6500 rpm is the absolute best!
__________________
amen
STCState College, PA, USA · Apr 23, 2010#23
Originally Posted by bankrobber ↑
I was wrong I checked today and I actually shift at lower speeds than I origionally posted.
Do you have the RPM's for your shift points?
Yes... when looking closer the other day while driving... my MPH shift points that I listed were @ 2,000-2,100 RPM.