Yarisworld Archive

Oil filter study

7 posts · 4,729 views

sbergman27Original postOklahoma City, OK · Mar 28, 2010#1
Some here are no doubt already familiar with this. But I figured I'd post it. I'm not starting another oil thread, you understand. I'm starting an oil *filter* thread. :-)

Filter Study (Just the facts, Ma'am.): http://tinyurl.com/6gn7x
Discussion (The *real* dirt): http://tinyurl.com/b5qx8
FAQ: http://tinyurl.com/ykvy8cz

An interesting bit of unconfirmed "dirt" that I've heard is that the discussion page was separated from the main study page in response to threats from a certain very well known manufacturer of bright orange oil filters, the name of which I shall refrain from mentioning.

-Steve

Replies 6

jambo101Montreal Canada · Mar 28, 2010#2
Originally Posted by sbergman27 ↑

An interesting bit of unconfirmed "dirt" that I've heard is that the discussion page was separated from the main study page in response to threats from a certain very well known manufacturer of bright orange oil filters, the name of which I shall refrain from mentioning.

-Steve
You must be referring to those crappy Fram filters.
sbergman27Thread starterOklahoma City, OK · Mar 28, 2010#3
Originally Posted by jambo101 ↑
You must be referring to those crappy Fram filters.
Say it isn't so! ;-)

An important question, which remains unanswered, is "How much difference do the variations between the different filters tested actually make in real life?".

If someone with the resources took a bunch of the "crappiest" Fram filters and a bunch of top of the line Mobil 1 filters (which is really just a K&N without the nut, BTW) and tested them over the life of a bunch of 1NZ-FE engines... would there actually be a statistical difference in engine life?

Does Fram's anti-drainback valve design actually matter? Does the Mobil 1's ability to filter tiny particles actually matter?

So many situations in life are like this. We have a plethora of less useful data, while the most important questions remain unanswered.

As it happens, however, I can answer the question regarding the anti-drainback valve... at least for our engines: No. It doesn't make any difference; Our filters mount vertically. :-)

-Steve
bronsinnj · Mar 28, 2010#4
No it doesnt matter one tiny little bit. My air cooled VWs didnt even HAVE an oil filter. + they only had 2.5 quarts of oil. One of my friends VWs in college (1976) dropped a valve and I rebuilt the engine using parts from two wrecked engines we got at a junk yard. (with new bearings and gaskets and a valve job) He moved to Africa in the 1990's and gave the car to his son... Not unusual to get 200 k miles from the crankshaft, cam shaft, pistons and cylinders (but not the rings and not the valves) All this stuff about FRAM oil filters makes me LAFF.
sbergman27Thread starterOklahoma City, OK · Mar 28, 2010#5
Originally Posted by bronsin ↑
No it doesnt matter one tiny little bit. My air cooled VWs didnt even HAVE an oil filter.
Wow. You're right. The Beetle had a strainer, but no filter. I had no idea.

Fram and Prestone *both* must have hated that car! ;-)

-Steve
Happy Little PonyTampa, FL · Mar 28, 2010#6
Originally Posted by sbergman27 ↑
Some here are no doubt already familiar with this. But I figured I'd post it. I'm not starting another oil thread, you understand. I'm starting an oil *filter* thread. :-)

Filter Study (Just the facts, Ma'am.): http://tinyurl.com/6gn7x
Discussion (The *real* dirt): http://tinyurl.com/b5qx8
FAQ: http://tinyurl.com/ykvy8cz

An interesting bit of unconfirmed "dirt" that I've heard is that the discussion page was separated from the main study page in response to threats from a certain very well known manufacturer of bright orange oil filters, the name of which I shall refrain from mentioning.

-Steve
The links you have are really out of date. Try this, the "River_Rat" tests from the "Bob Is The Oil Guy" forum. It's more recent.

http://filtrationcomparisons.weebly.com/index.html

My Take? I think that for most people even the cheap filters are "good enough." The oil will probably break down and go bad before the filter does.

I also used to own a air cooled VW with no filter, and I ran a Subaru for over 200,000 miles using whatever the cheapest filter that K-Mart or Wal-Mart had in stock. These days, I've been using Purolator PureOne and Bosch (same filter), but I have a Denso 150-1000 ready to go on at my next oil change. It looks like a good filter too.
Hersheynortheast · Mar 28, 2010#7
used FRAM filters years ago . Had a '86 5 door liftback CHEVY Nova ( Corolla ) that reached over 274,000 and used FRAM for many of the oil changes . Been using TOYOTA ( DENSO ) filters for many years now . Have used AC/DELCO oil filters w/o any issues .