Yarisworld Archive

07 Yaris Sedan Manual Tranny Problems

31 posts · 37,388 views

sk8manmikeOriginal postCO · Mar 6, 2010#1
I've read a lot of posts on Yaris Manual Transmissions on this site, and found that a lot of people dislike the way their car shifts. I feel like I describe my shifting problems a little different that most people have.

The Problem:(hard to explain)
75% of the time when I shift to and from any gear the shifting feels rough and like I'm rubbing up against something at certain point during the shift. Also, when I am coming to a stop I can shift to gear 1 until I'm completely stop (it just won't let me). Same thing with gear 2 - I can down shift to it until I'm around 10-13 mph. Needless to say both problems are very irritating.

Since I'm still under Drivetrain warranty for another year, I took it in to the local Toyota dealership about 2 month ago (been busy). I explained to them what I've been experiencing, but I only felt like the rough shifting was a problem at that point (keep in mind I knew nothing of this sight before going in, and that this was a coming thing). This is what they told me:



So they tell me the shifter is worn, and I decline because that sounds pretty crazy for an 07 with 35k miles to have a worn shifter.

I've recently took of the cover off and took some photos to see if the shifter was really worn (whatever that means). I took the photos of the shifter exactly how I found it - not sure what that circular ring was doing there.........I know I didn't take everything off to give you guys a better view, but then again I don't know what I'm looking for.

Various Angles:
http://i1014.photobucket.com/albums/...e/IMG_2083.jpg
http://i1014.photobucket.com/albums/...e/IMG_2077.jpg
http://i1014.photobucket.com/albums/...e/IMG_2079.jpg
http://i1014.photobucket.com/albums/...e/IMG_2080.jpg
http://i1014.photobucket.com/albums/...e/IMG_2081.jpg
http://i1014.photobucket.com/albums/...e/IMG_2082.jpg

I don't see anything that looks worn. I just ordered the NSTSSK09
Engine Bay NST product, and will probably order the shifter one as well, but it would be nice to know if I have a more serious problem that I can use my warranty to fix. I'm the second owner and have had the car for about 6 months.

Thoughts? - any input is appreciated.

Replies 30

TheSilkySmoothNew Hampshire · Mar 6, 2010#2
When my shifting get rough or notchy - it is my clutch not fully disengaging. It only completely disengages about 1/4 " off the carpet. Thinking this is some air bubbles in the slave cylinder or the connected parts. Problem comes and goes. I havent bled the clutch hydraulics yet - MY GF wont help me work on the car!
sk8manmikeThread starterCO · Mar 6, 2010#4
Originally Posted by TheSilkySmooth ↑
When my shifting get rough or notchy - it is my clutch not fully disengaging. It only completely disengages about 1/4 " off the carpet. Thinking this is some air bubbles in the slave cylinder or the connected parts. Problem comes and goes. I havent bled the clutch hydraulics yet - MY GF wont help me work on the car!
Notchy is a good way to describe my problem, but even when the car is off and I cycle through the gears it feels the same - not sure that that would be the clutch not disengaging. Am I wrong?
TheSilkySmoothNew Hampshire · Mar 11, 2010#6
Originally Posted by sk8manmike ↑
Notchy is a good way to describe my problem, but even when the car is off and I cycle through the gears it feels the same - not sure that that would be the clutch not disengaging. Am I wrong?
Trans doesnt work right when the car is off - only when spun up - so the feel when you are engine-off doesnt mean too much. Check and see where your clutch begins to engage - a good way is: if you can get the car on level ground and cant roll at idle, put it in second and slowly release the clutch (giving no gas!) and see when it JUST begins to grab at all - which U would notice by the idle speed lowering a tiny bit - this is the engagement point and if its not at least 1/2" or more off the floor, then the clutch master and slave hydralics arent working right and U will need a bleed or some other adjustment.
TheSilkySmoothNew Hampshire · Mar 11, 2010#7
Anyone try the walmart supertech semi syn - some other forums (WRX) seem to think its a good STD replacement for those who dont want to spend 30 bucks on 2 qts of gear oil.
_S7V7N_South Texas · Mar 11, 2010#8
Do you have multiple floor mats ? If so the clutch may not be all the way to the floor, i've had this prob when starting the car.
sk8manmikeThread starterCO · Mar 12, 2010#9
Originally Posted by TheSilkySmooth ↑
Trans doesnt work right when the car is off - only when spun up - so the feel when you are engine-off doesnt mean too much. Check and see where your clutch begins to engage - a good way is: if you can get the car on level ground and cant roll at idle, put it in second and slowly release the clutch (giving no gas!) and see when it JUST begins to grab at all - which U would notice by the idle speed lowering a tiny bit - this is the engagement point and if its not at least 1/2" or more off the floor, then the clutch master and slave hydralics arent working right and U will need a bleed or some other adjustment.
I'll give this a try on my way home from work today.
sk8manmikeThread starterCO · Mar 12, 2010#10
Originally Posted by _S7V7N_ ↑
Do you have multiple floor mats ? If so the clutch may not be all the way to the floor, i've had this prob when starting the car.
Checked floor mat and the clutch clears the single one I have.
sk8manmikeThread starterCO · Mar 12, 2010#11
I just got the NST Short shifter engine bay piece, and it definitely helped shorten the throw, but unfortunately my previous symptoms are still present. I think I'm actually going to have Toyota put in the new shifter so they can move on and find the real cause.
1stToyotaOklahoma · Mar 12, 2010#12
Originally Posted by Hershey ↑
try REDLINE - MT 90 ( www.redlineoil.com/product.aspx?pid=46&pcid=7 ) or AMSOIL MTG ( www.amsoil.com/storefront/mtg.aspx ) true synthetic gear oils . Both are 75w-90 and GL-4 . May help . Either one is less than $13 each . You'll need 2 quarts . GOOD LUCK .
And +1 on the Amsoil; made a noticeable difference in mine. Tried GL-5 Lubro-Moly 75W-90 Synthetic Gear Oil prior to the Amsoil; the Lubro-Moly made no difference at all over the factory fill.
zachrybolesFt. Worth, Tx · Mar 12, 2010#13
as far as the ring you found..... it goes to the shift boot at the top right under the shifter knob... it holds the shift boot to the shaft
YarisSedanCalifornia - Bay Area · Mar 12, 2010#14
Notchyness is usually due to a worn syncro inside the transmission. That or the fluid needs to be changed. I dont think changing the shifter will do anything for you. You can try changing the fluid. Sometimes it helps smooth things out.

I remember on the older hondas you could use 10w30 oil as a replacement for their manual transmission and it would cause notchyness because of lack of friction modifiers. Some people liked that feel though.
sk8manmikeThread starterCO · Mar 12, 2010#15
Originally Posted by 1stToyota ↑
And +1 on the Amsoil; made a noticeable difference in mine. Tried GL-5 Lubro-Moly 75W-90 Synthetic Gear Oil prior to the Amsoil; the Lubro-Moly made no difference at all over the factory fill.
I definitely would love to use the Redline and i'm sure that would improve things at least a little bit, but I'm worried voiding my warranty in case something more serious is wrong with it - that does void the warranty right?

Originally Posted by zachryboles ↑
as far as the ring you found..... it goes to the shift boot at the top right under the shifter knob... it holds the shift boot to the shaft
Thanks, was wondering what that was doing there
zachrybolesFt. Worth, Tx · Mar 12, 2010#16
Originally Posted by sk8manmike ↑
I definitely would love to use the Redline and i'm sure that would improve things at least a little bit, but I'm worried voiding my warranty in case something more serious is wrong with it - that does void the warranty right?



Thanks, was wondering what that was doing there
yah.... enjoy getting that thing back on. i did that to my old sedan and it was a mofo to get back on right.😠
TheSilkySmoothNew Hampshire · Mar 13, 2010#17
Originally Posted by sk8manmike ↑
I definitely would love to use the Redline and i'm sure that would improve things at least a little bit, but I'm worried voiding my warranty in case something more serious is wrong with it - that does void the warranty right?



Thanks, was wondering what that was doing there
Red line wont void the warranty its a 75w-90 API GL-4 gear oil and the yaris owner's manual calls for either GL-4 or GL-5. Since there is no hypoid final drive then GL-4 is what you want. Even a superbike oil like Mobil 1 racing 4T real synthetic would work fine since 75w-90 gear oil equals 5W/10W/15W-40 engine oil - as long as it doesnt have friction mods which bike oil does not have.
Hersheynortheast · Mar 13, 2010#18
keep receipts for the REDLINE or AMSOIL . If you don't do the tranny gear oil change yourself be sure to get and keep it from whom does the change for proof . Good luck with your problem .
sk8manmikeThread starterCO · Mar 14, 2010#19
Originally Posted by TheSilkySmooth ↑
Red line wont void the warranty its a 75w-90 API GL-4 gear oil and the yaris owner's manual calls for either GL-4 or GL-5. Since there is no hypoid final drive then GL-4 is what you want. Even a superbike oil like Mobil 1 racing 4T real synthetic would work fine since 75w-90 gear oil equals 5W/10W/15W-40 engine oil - as long as it doesnt have friction mods which bike oil does not have.
awesome - ordering it now than, thanks guys
bankrobberCentral Florida · Mar 14, 2010#20
Originally Posted by TheSilkySmooth ↑
Anyone try the walmart supertech semi syn - some other forums (WRX) seem to think its a good STD replacement for those who dont want to spend 30 bucks on 2 qts of gear oil.
Yes, I did because there was no Mobil1 on the shelf. I changed mine around 80,000 for first time. It shifted much smoother but, it was way overdue for a change. I did gain about 1 MPG.
TheSilkySmoothNew Hampshire · Mar 17, 2010#21
Good to know. I have AMALIE 75w-90 GL-5 MT-1 and it s OK but I am not hog wild about it; at least not wild about it enough to rec it.
dennischan0919Lowell MA · Mar 18, 2010#22
TSB 0068-09? transverse engine mount-abnormal noise and vibration on acceleration during accelerating from a stop or shifting gears.
fiiasilver spring, md · Mar 18, 2010#23
Originally Posted by 1stToyota ↑
And +1 on the Amsoil; made a noticeable difference in mine. Tried GL-5 Lubro-Moly 75W-90 Synthetic Gear Oil prior to the Amsoil; the Lubro-Moly made no difference at all over the factory fill.

For the 75w-90 oils, can you mix these with the standard stuff Toyota puts in (10w40) or do you have to completely drain that out first?
also, at what mileage intervals is it recommended to use these?
I have about 15k but I often drive through heavy traffic on the highway and sometimes experience similar shifting problems, so I was looking to use redline. Any thoughts?
QR25DE_SpecVAustin, TX · Mar 18, 2010#24
You're experiencing what is called transmission lockout. This is because the synchronizers in the Yaris transmission are small, and weak as hell. There are a few things you can do to combat this though.

First gear lockout is actually very common in manual transmissions, and you'll find very few transmissions that allow you to shift to first gear at speed. This is by design, to reduce the likelihood of you screwing up and valve floating your engine to death. One car I've driven that allows you to shift to first while at any speed is the Lotus Elise/Exige, for obvious purposes.

1) Better fluid. AMSOil is pretty awesome stuff, as already stated in the thread. I'd personally recommend that.

2) Double clutching. This may sound silly, but I promise you it works. In my SpecV you can't put the car in first unless you're damn near stopped. If I double clutch, I can get it in doing 20.

3) Try rev matching in conjunction with double clutching. Both of these will eliminate the need for the syncro entirely, and the gear should slide in.

If you're unfamiliar with double clutching, it's pretty simple. Stab the clutch while taking the car out of what ever gear you're in, release the clutch, then depress the clutch again, and at the same time rev match and slide the gear in.

Works every time with me.

EDIT: I've only experienced transmission lockout on a few other cars, all of which were 'cheap' in nature. The Hyundai Genesis Coupe 2.0T had horrible second gear lockout, even when rev matching. This is either due to cheap design, inadequate syncros, or poor fluid. Probably more than one, if not all of these are the reason why you're having that experience.

EDIT #2: I was thinking maybe it's a linkage issue, but that would also impact 4th gear, which you make no mention of. So I'd say this isn't a linkage issue either.
Hersheynortheast · Mar 19, 2010#25
Originally Posted by fiia ↑
For the 75w-90 oils, can you mix these with the standard stuff Toyota puts in (10w40) or do you have to completely drain that out first?
also, at what mileage intervals is it recommended to use these?
I have about 15k but I often drive through heavy traffic on the highway and sometimes experience similar shifting problems, so I was looking to use redline. Any thoughts?
drain and refill . Then use your choice of the REDLINE MT-90 or the AMSOIL MTG . These are GL-4 oils and you will encounter better shifting than with a GL-5 . Also less corrosive . Know from own experience with GL-5 and GL-4 gear oil . GL-4 is a must . GOOD LUCK
MUSKOKA800Chatham, Ontario, Canada · Mar 19, 2010#26
Have you lubed the shift linkage underhood? I just sprayed mine last evening and now not only has the squeak stopped but WOW!, it shifts so, so much smoother now. Best $7.00 I've spent (spray Lithium grease, lifetime supply).

Here's the thread with instructions:

Squeaky Transmission? 5MT
sk8manmikeThread starterCO · Mar 20, 2010#27
Originally Posted by QR25DE_SpecV ↑
You're experiencing what is called transmission lockout. This is because the synchronizers in the Yaris transmission are small, and weak as hell. There are a few things you can do to combat this though.

First gear lockout is actually very common in manual transmissions, and you'll find very few transmissions that allow you to shift to first gear at speed. This is by design, to reduce the likelihood of you screwing up and valve floating your engine to death. One car I've driven that allows you to shift to first while at any speed is the Lotus Elise/Exige, for obvious purposes.

1) Better fluid. AMSOil is pretty awesome stuff, as already stated in the thread. I'd personally recommend that.

2) Double clutching. This may sound silly, but I promise you it works. In my SpecV you can't put the car in first unless you're damn near stopped. If I double clutch, I can get it in doing 20.

3) Try rev matching in conjunction with double clutching. Both of these will eliminate the need for the syncro entirely, and the gear should slide in.

If you're unfamiliar with double clutching, it's pretty simple. Stab the clutch while taking the car out of what ever gear you're in, release the clutch, then depress the clutch again, and at the same time rev match and slide the gear in.

Works every time with me.

EDIT: I've only experienced transmission lockout on a few other cars, all of which were 'cheap' in nature. The Hyundai Genesis Coupe 2.0T had horrible second gear lockout, even when rev matching. This is either due to cheap design, inadequate syncros, or poor fluid. Probably more than one, if not all of these are the reason why you're having that experience.

EDIT #2: I was thinking maybe it's a linkage issue, but that would also impact 4th gear, which you make no mention of. So I'd say this isn't a linkage issue either.
Ya I have to be completely stopped to shift into 1st gear. I double clutch all the time, but usually don't rev match i'll give that a try - thanks man
sk8manmikeThread starterCO · Mar 20, 2010#28
Originally Posted by MUSKOKA800 ↑
Have you lubed the shift linkage underhood? I just sprayed mine last evening and now not only has the squeak stopped but WOW!, it shifts so, so much smoother now. Best $7.00 I've spent (spray Lithium grease, lifetime supply).

Here's the thread with instructions:

Squeaky Transmission? 5MT
I only thought that got rid of the squeaking, but if it also makes it shift smoother than i'm down. I'll pick up some lithium grease will i'm at the auto store getting a funnel to put my redline in.
QR25DE_SpecVAustin, TX · Mar 21, 2010#29
I notice that if you take more time with your double clutching, it's less effective. If you're doing it slowly, try speeding things up a little.
sk8manmikeThread starterCO · May 12, 2010#30
I'm very sorry it has taken me so long to respond to my own post - I've been very busy lately.

But good news, I put Redline MT-90 in and wow what a difference. Fixed all my shifting problems. Shifting now is very smooth - thanks for all your posts!
Hersheynortheast · May 12, 2010#31
👍