ever thought the news give any simple excuse as to not complicate things? just a thought and my 2 cents....
Toyota Recalls
527 posts · 1,279,032 views · page 5 of 11
Replies continued
Originally Posted by cali yaris ↑At least these posts show that it's not all just driver stupidity, we ARE dealing with a real problem with a physical part, not just a floor mat -- so can we just drop that?
http://www.autoblog.com/2010/02/01/u...river-reporte/Originally Posted by why? ↑That would rock! I'm kinda shocked we haven't heard of at least 1 person doing something like this to get revenge on someone, its the perfect excuse.
Now you have heard!
Police reports stated that incident was intentional...Originally Posted by markitect ↑
yeah... couldn't figure that one out even if it was the answer to Clue. Man, some people are just overly stupid... when you buy a vehicle, there is a thing called a Lemon Law, which tells the customer how long of a period they have to return a vehicle. Some states, such as Colorado, have a Now You Are An Owner policy. Once you drive it off the lot, it is yours forever. And it's not like Toota isn't tring to help customers out through this thing, they are doing everything they can as fast as the can. Hence they offered this customer a loaner car until his truck was fixed. The dealership should simply have him pay for damages, and nothing else. Obviously his truck, but he owned it, so I hope he has GAP insurance, or he's screwed.
Unfortunately, there are way too many idiots in the world! I hope his insurance denies his claim because it was deliberately crashed. It would serve this moron right to have to pay for all the damages out of pocket!
This small problem does by no means make Toyotas "lemons." If that logic were true, then basically every car ever built qualifies as most have had a recall for some reason or another.
I found this article interesting, it only shows that no matter what the issue, it is the perception that matters...
Yes, a sticking gas pedal can be a problem and Toyota has a fix for it before it happens; but to listen to the press you would think cars are crashing left and right and people are burning to death in the aftermath!
But I am a daredevil...I used to drive a Pinto!
Cheers! M2
This small problem does by no means make Toyotas "lemons." If that logic were true, then basically every car ever built qualifies as most have had a recall for some reason or another.
I found this article interesting, it only shows that no matter what the issue, it is the perception that matters...
Toyota's other pedal problem: LawsuitsNote the paragraph I highlighted...the U.S. National Highway Traffic Safety Administration says it has no proof that anyone was injured by a stuck pedal!
NEW YORK (Reuters) - Toyota Motor Corp is facing a growing number lawsuits from consumers who complain their vehicles suddenly accelerate or may do so, and want the world's largest automaker to pay for it.
U.S.
Last week, Toyota stopped selling eight models in the United States and Canada, including its popular Camry and Corolla, because of possible unintended acceleration.
Some 8 million vehicles are up for repair worldwide over problems including alleged faulty accelerator pedals made by the supplier CTS Corp, and the possibility that floor mats could jam the accelerator pedal.
Other recalled Toyota vehicles are the Avalon, Highlander, Matrix, RAV4, Sequoia and Tundra.
The problems have tarnished Toyota's reputation for making some of the most reliable vehicles on the road. It is the most prominent auto safety issue since reports surfaced in 2000 that many Firestone tires mounted on Ford Explorers failed.
"Liability for Toyota could run in the billions of dollars, because of the number of vehicles involved and the fact there are serious injury and death claims," said Gary Robb, a partner at Robb & Robb LLC in Kansas City, Missouri. He said his firm has fielded inquiries from consumers and may sue Toyota.
The U.S. National Highway Traffic Safety Administration says it has no proof that anyone was injured by a stuck pedal. It said it has confirmed to its satisfaction that five people have died as a result of floor mat entrapment.
Since November, at least 10 lawsuits seeking class-action status have been filed against Toyota in U.S. courts and in the Ontario Superior Court of Justice in Canada.
It is possible that some U.S. litigation could be combined because the claims are similar and it would be too unwieldy to try cases one owner at a time.
Toyota on Monday had no immediate comment on the lawsuits.
NEW LAWSUITS
Legal experts said drivers might have more difficulty recovering if they cannot show their cars actually experienced sudden acceleration. Fear that it could happen may not be enough.
"In a significant majority of states, there is no remedy for mental upset and fright, absent a consequential injury to people or property caused by the defect," said James Henderson, a Cornell Law School professor and product liability expert.
David Owen, a law professor at the University of South Carolina and director of its Office of Tort Law Studies, said Toyota might be more at risk in U.S. states that impose on manufacturers of a "duty to warn" consumers about a defect.
"The grounds to sue are that there was a design defect, regardless of what Toyota may do to mop up the consequences, and the possibility that a post-sale warning was delayed too long," he said.
"If it turned out that Toyota delayed the recall beyond the point when a reasonable manufacturer would have done so, then punitive damages in substantial amounts might be available to whoever was physically injured," Owen added.
Some plaintiffs are expected to seek recovery for an expected loss of resale value tied to the stigma from the recalls, though Owen said courts are generally "unresponsive" to such claims, including in Firestone tire lawsuits.
Others may seek to recover for expenses tied to the recall, including lost work hours and the cost of finding alternative transportation while their vehicles are being fixed.
POSSIBLE STIGMA
Four of the most recent lawsuits were filed on Friday.
In a federal lawsuit filed in Corpus Christi, Texas, the plaintiffs Albert and Sylvia Pena alleged that their 2008 Toyota Avalon unexpectedly accelerated at least twice, and on January 14 caused a collision at a stop sign.
"Toyota has long known about the defect with their throttle control, and has done too little, too late to correct it," said Robert Hilliard, a lawyer representing the Penas.
Three other federal lawsuits were filed in New Orleans on behalf of Avalon and Camry owners. These plaintiffs' lawyers were unavailable to comment.
Robb said Toyota might learn from Johnson & Johnson's 1982 withdrawal of Tylenol from stores, after seven people died from ingesting medicine spiked with cyanide.
The crime was never solved, but the company's response, including the introduction of tamper-resistant packaging, is considered to be a textbook example of how to handle recalls.
"They saved not only their public image, but that brand," Robb said. "There are real doubts as to whether Toyota's brand, from a PR standpoint, can survive this (recall) intact. This has dragged on too long and there have been too many excuses."
Yes, a sticking gas pedal can be a problem and Toyota has a fix for it before it happens; but to listen to the press you would think cars are crashing left and right and people are burning to death in the aftermath!
But I am a daredevil...I used to drive a Pinto!
Cheers! M2
According to this article: http://money.cnn.com/2010/02/02/news...dex.htm?hpt=T2 The NHTSA is looking into a hypothesis that electromagnetic interference may somehow be causing the ECU to malfunction causing uncontrolled acceleration.
Nissan says the'll offer you 1000 MORE, if you trade in your Toyota for a Nissan. Epic.
Screw that!😠Originally Posted by ddongbap ↑Nissan says the'll offer you 1000 MORE, if you trade in your Toyota for a Nissan. Epic.
The Versa has a below average reliability rating according to Consumer Reports. They really HATE the Yaris and won't recommend it. Yaris and Versa both featured in this months issue of CR.
Dog eat dog.Originally Posted by ddongbap ↑Nissan says the'll offer you 1000 MORE, if you trade in your Toyota for a Nissan. Epic.
Its all a goverment conspiracy to boost the sale of GM car
the USA is not a nation but a corporation GM is part of the corporation
the USA is not a nation but a corporation GM is part of the corporation
I test drove the Versa before I had purchase my Yaris. The Versa felt tinny compared to the Yaris.
I knew it was the ECU!Originally Posted by Yaris Hilton ↑According to this article: http://money.cnn.com/2010/02/02/news...dex.htm?hpt=T2 The NHTSA is looking into a hypothesis that electromagnetic interference may somehow be causing the ECU to malfunction causing uncontrolled acceleration.
And nobody believed me. 😛
🙄 Oh come on, everything is a conspiracy...Originally Posted by bigbang ↑Its all a goverment conspiracy to boost the sale of GM car
the USA is not a nation but a corporation GM is part of the corporation
It's a conspiracy headed by Jesse Ventura to promote his "Conspiracy Theory" show.
I am beginning to believe it is a conspiracy, and I don't subscribe to most conspiracy theories; but this press released makes me wonder...Originally Posted by Yaris Hilton ↑It's a conspiracy headed by Jesse Ventura to promote his "Conspiracy Theory" show.
Transportation Secretary Ray LaHood just went nuclear in his tirade against Toyota: He is now advising owners of the eight recalled models to park them and not drive them until they can be brought into dealers to have their accelerator pedals repaired. (full story)What BS! As I stated earlier, the NHTSA has stated they know of no accidents or injuries that have occured as the result of the sticking gas pedals (that straight from their web site), and now LaHood is telling everyone not to drive their cars?!?
Wow, I guess bailing out the US auto industry wasn't enough, now the Obama Administration has to start a smear campaign against the competition...
this is sad I heard toyota will be stopping all production for a while.
supposedly computer keeps throttle open . The woman who had her '05 PRIUS crash said that she checked the floor mat and that pedal was not stuck ( used foot to unstick it ) . Thus a fault in the 'puter . This could get very interesting if pedal fix doesn't work .
to be fair, my floor mat hook popped completely out of the base carpet and was a bit of a bitch to pop back in. so a sliding floor mat is totally possible, especially if operator does not notice and drives around like this.Originally Posted by silver_echo ↑it is my OPINION that the recall should not even exist at all... i am in the toyota t ten service training program and we are keeping ourselves up to date on this... the problem is that with the affected models, there is no hook for positive retention of the floormats, and most of the american idiots prefer to stack another mat on top, to "protect" the factory floormat from getting dirty... when you stack the extra floormats, they can slide up under the pedals and get stuck...
I agree with everything except that Toyota is not competition for GM. Anyone who takes customers away (which Toyota does easily) is competition.Originally Posted by PK198105 ↑Toyota is not competition , Toyota is the Holy Grail for GM, they'll never even come close to them.
I believe Toyota did the right thing with the preventive recall and temporary halt to production even though it is only the US that has experienced this kind of "failure". Sure they maybe realized the mechanism could be improved and perfected so instead of waiting for actual accidents to happen they prevented them. And its not like Toyotas are going HAL on their owners all over the place.
But the way the media (and Administration) are playing this is very suspicous. The reason I mentioned the fact that no accidents or injuries have occurred was to point out how the sensationalized press is reporting this. Based on what you see on the news, cars should be crashing all over th place and bodies spewed across America's roadways. We all know that isn't true, but bullshit like LaHood is saying reeks of other motivations...
Now the Prius has brake problems and is being recalled.......
Toyota is really in the midst of a design quality crisis.
Now is the time for owners of a Yaris with aceleration delay issues to take the car back to the dealer and demad a souution as it now appers that toyota has mutiple ECU/electrical problems with multiple cars.
BTW, there is a report that eltromagnetic radiation (such as cell phone signals, etc) may possibly be causing some Tyota ECUs to malfunction.
Toyota is really in the midst of a design quality crisis.
Now is the time for owners of a Yaris with aceleration delay issues to take the car back to the dealer and demad a souution as it now appers that toyota has mutiple ECU/electrical problems with multiple cars.
BTW, there is a report that eltromagnetic radiation (such as cell phone signals, etc) may possibly be causing some Tyota ECUs to malfunction.
Woz says it's a computer problem:
http://www.foxnews.com/story/0,2933,584716,00.html
http://www.foxnews.com/story/0,2933,584716,00.html
Maybe his feet hit all 10 pedals at once?
And it gets worse...
Transportation Secretary Ray LaHood told Toyota owners Wednesday they should stop driving their vehicles, then quickly took back his words, adding to confusion over the safety of millions of recalled cars. Toyota, for its part, tried to reassure drivers that sticky gas pedals have been rare — and the cars can be stopped in any event by firmly stepping on the brakes.Issa is right, LaHood's original comments were inflammatory and he should be held accountable. He was nominated by Obama and most likely got that because he is from Obama's home state of Illinois. His résumé on transport matters is seen as thin by many critics...
The final word from LaHood: "What I meant to say or what I thought I said was, if you own one of these cars or if you're in doubt, take it to the dealer and they're going to fix it."
The back-and-forth played out as word surfaced that Toyota Motor Corp. also has been the subject of more than 100 complaints in the U.S. and Japan about brake problems with the popular Prius gas-electric hybrid, which is not part of the recall. The National Highway Traffic Safety Administration has received about 100 complaints, two of them involving crashes that resulted in injuries. In addition, Japan's transport ministry said it had received 14 complaints.
Rep. Bart Stupak, chairman of the House Energy and Commerce investigative subcommittee, said he planned to ask Toyota about the complaints related to the Prius.
Further clouding the picture for consumers: the notion that problems could extend beyond Toyota vehicles. Federal officials have widened their investigation of malfunctioning gas pedals to see if the same problem exists in cars made by other auto companies.
The traffic safety agency said it had sent a letter to CTS, the Indiana company that made the pedals for Toyota, to find out more about the pedals it has manufactured for other auto companies, including Honda, Nissan and a small number of Fords in China. CTS has been adamant that the issues are limited to Toyota alone.
The Toyota recall in the U.S. covers 2.3 million vehicles and involves 2009-10 RAV4 crossovers, 2009-10 Corollas, 2009-10 Matrix hatchbacks, 2005-10 Avalons, 2007-10 Camrys, 2010 Highlander crossovers, 2007-10 Tundra pickups and 2008-10 Sequoia SUVs. The recalls also extend to Europe and China, covering nearly 4.5 million vehicles overall.
Toyota said the sticking gas pedal situation is unusual and "generally does not occur suddenly. In the rare instances where it does occur, the vehicle can be controlled with firm and steady application of the brakes."
LaHood said the government is considering civil penalties against the carmaker but that it appeared "Toyota is making an all-out effort to do all that they can to fix these cars."
Rep. Darrell Issa, R-Calif., said plenty of questions remain.
"Obviously, there are concerns regarding the consistency of information that is entering the public domain," he said.
This looks like media hype to me. Of course, society at large can be rather weak-minded and believe everything they hear on the 'news'. Pretty soon, angry mobs are going to attack Toyota owners and dealers. Now, since they smell blood in the water, they are going to start on something else....Prius brakes. It is all overblown BS propagated and exacerbated by a pukey, liberal media who believes that all corporations are inherently evil anyway. This does not affect my feeling on Toyotas one little bit. I would buy another and probably will one day.
Agreed, we are looking at a Venza to possibly replace our Honda Odyssey when it craps out one day. You can really mod them to look quite nice...Originally Posted by galactus ↑This does not affect my feeling on Toyotas one little bit. I would buy another and probably will one day.
Picture not included in this copy
Originally Posted by galactus ↑This does not affect my feeling on Toyotas one little bit. I would buy another and probably will one day.
As long as Toyota provides good customer service and continue to build fun to drive and fuel efficient cars (like the Yaris) I'll stay with them. I'm planning to stay w/ my Yaris long term. It's an excellent little car!
The fact that this thread is 14 pages long and the Yaris isn't in the recall only proves the fact that this American media classic fear campaign has really gotten to people.
If you operate a machine and you are unaware of how to use it properly and completely you take that responsibility and any consequences into your own hands.
This wouldn't be a problem if it took more than 5 minutes to get a drivers' license in America. Or more than $5.
If you operate a machine and you are unaware of how to use it properly and completely you take that responsibility and any consequences into your own hands.
This wouldn't be a problem if it took more than 5 minutes to get a drivers' license in America. Or more than $5.
^ LOL 🙂 +1
Well, there are wait times at the DMV, and I thought there were card fees?Originally Posted by advocate ↑The fact that this thread is 14 pages long and the Yaris isn't in the recall only proves the fact that this American media classic fear campaign has really gotten to people.
If you operate a machine and you are unaware of how to use it properly and completely you take that responsibility and any consequences into your own hands.
This wouldn't be a problem if it took more than 5 minutes to get a drivers' license in America. Or more than $5.
And I think there should be testing and licencing to have and operate horns.
Aren't the Prius brake parts the same as the ones used in the yaris? I know a lot of our parts are the same.
Prius has a software glitch
just needs new software loaded.
Toyota officials described the problem as a "disconnect" in the vehicle's complex anti-lock brake system (ABS) that causes less than a one-second lag. With the delay, a vehicle going 60 mph will have traveled nearly another 90 feet before the brakes begin to take hold.
1 second is an ETERNITY in a panic. I will still buy a dozen Toyotas over any other maker, but DANG!!!!
just needs new software loaded.
Toyota officials described the problem as a "disconnect" in the vehicle's complex anti-lock brake system (ABS) that causes less than a one-second lag. With the delay, a vehicle going 60 mph will have traveled nearly another 90 feet before the brakes begin to take hold.
1 second is an ETERNITY in a panic. I will still buy a dozen Toyotas over any other maker, but DANG!!!!
On the positive side, when Toyota starts selling the recalled vehicles again, they will inevitably be offering some great rebates and other incentives to get customers back.
conspiracy!!
Take Ford for instance, and not that long ago. In October of last year, Ford recalled 4.5 million cars to replace a faulty cruise control deactivator, which was shown to be a fire hazard. That brought the total number of cars recalled for this specific problem up to 16 million - the largest single recall ever in automotive industry history.
were is the media on this story
Take Ford for instance, and not that long ago. In October of last year, Ford recalled 4.5 million cars to replace a faulty cruise control deactivator, which was shown to be a fire hazard. That brought the total number of cars recalled for this specific problem up to 16 million - the largest single recall ever in automotive industry history.
were is the media on this story
yeah. Fords would catch fire while sitting in your garage at night and burn your whole house down. the switch always had current and when it failed, it Trogdor'ed yer arse.Originally Posted by bigbang ↑conspiracy!!
Take Ford for instance, and not that long ago. In October of last year, Ford recalled 4.5 million cars to replace a faulty cruise control deactivator, which was shown to be a fire hazard. That brought the total number of cars recalled for this specific problem up to 16 million - the largest single recall ever in automotive industry history.
were is the media on this story
Yes, I remember this! And while it was in the news, I don't remember it being made up to the same level that this Toyota thing is.Originally Posted by 127.0.0.1 ↑yeah. Fords would catch fire while sitting in your garage at night and burn your whole house down. the switch always had current and when it failed, it Trogdor'ed yer arse.
S.U.V.s that rollover easy , tires that blow , and a roof that collapses during a rollover . No thank you . Still stick with TOYOTA .
Now is a great time to buy toyota stock...
If Yaris is not on the list in U.S.A, in Europe it is.
http://www.iltalehti.fi/autot/2010012911024699_au.shtml (Finnish)
http://www.iltalehti.fi/autot/2010012911024699_au.shtml (Finnish)
http://translate.google.com/translat...ml&sl=fi&tl=enOriginally Posted by Yar15 ↑If Yaris is not on the list in U.S.A, in Europe it is.
http://www.iltalehti.fi/autot/2010012911024699_au.shtml (Finnish)
NBC news Washington tonight covered the fact that pedals are getting stuck on the pile of floor mats that a lot of people have under the drivers pedals
Great news... the fix is out and we have fixed all the vehicles on our lot. We can now sell all vehicles. The Prius glitch is kinda funny, because it isn't as much of a glitch as it is just the electric motor taking a second to pull electricity back to the battery. The brakes work fine, and even last a lot longer than they should. Several cab coimpanies in New York are actually complaining that there is something wrong with their cabs, because at 90K miles in a cab in New York, the brakes still don't need to be replaced. Of course, if you use synthetic in a Prius, the oil doesn't need to be changed until 10K miles. These people that are having issues really need to research their vehicles before they go to the news. It would be like saying "Theres something wrong with my Prius, because the engine just shuts off while I drive down the road, but it keeps on moving foreward. And then, the engine just kicks back on all by itself... IT'S TRYING TO KILL ME!!!" Or the guy we had come in and said the Prius won't come to a complete stop... even though it was at a complete stop. The tires on the computer were still moving, so he kept pushing on the brakes harder and harder. It was funny enough that all of us here explained it several times, and he still wouldn't listen, so we just laughed at how stupid he was.
i hate to add fuel here but if anyone is interested, check out this video. this is of my own yaris which appears to have an issue.....
http://www.youtube.com/user/jeffisthebest21
http://www.youtube.com/user/jeffisthebest21
My last car was a ford puma (small coupe) which blew up on the motorway... Then I decided to go for something more reliable, either a honda or a toyota but I didn't really like the jazz (fit) and the civic was too expensive with only a 1.4 engine so the yaris was the obvious choice. I've done 1000 miles so far and I love it, especially after installing the rear sway bar :p Sure the recall is a pain but they are doing their best to fix it.Originally Posted by 127.0.0.1 ↑yeah. Fords would catch fire while sitting in your garage at night and burn your whole house down. the switch always had current and when it failed, it Trogdor'ed yer arse.
The biggest rub is that there was nowhere near as much coverage in 2008 when Ford had to recall 12 million vehicles due to a cruise-control switch catching fire. As a matter of fact, the top six recalls of all time were American-built cars. The 2.3 million cars affected by the Toyota recall doesn't even make the top ten list of recalls! #10 is the 1987 Ford recall of 3.6 million vehicles, which affected 1.3 million more vehicles than this Toyota recall!
That is not a stock floor mat, and that dealership needs to be talked to (seriously) about putting those floor mats in ANY car. That is why Toyota is having o many issues right now. They probably got some sweet deal on those mat, and that is why they are in there. The stock ones look MUCH different. I will post a pic of one if I can find one (hard to find after recall)Originally Posted by yaris2010RS ↑i hate to add fuel here but if anyone is interested, check out this video. this is of my own yaris which appears to have an issue.....
http://www.youtube.com/user/jeffisthebest21
cover-up?Haha about not buying another toyota because of the gas pedal dealI don't think people are gunning for them. They screwed up big time and several people have died or been injured as a result. I've always thought Toyota would have similar issues to other manufactures when they got as big as GM/Ford.
Ford
Chevrolet
Chrysler
Honda cars are catching on fire
Nissan
On and on and on... it seems all companies except VW have had issues with gas pedals sticking. Kudos to VW too bad the rest of the car is a piece of crap.
The reason it's such a big deal is because it is toyota. When your on top everybody comes gunning for you. Trust me they did not have to come forward to deal with this. Can you tell me when the president of GM publicly apologized for the lack of reliability?
Don't be such a Toyota fan boy. They've know about this problem for years and have done everything in their power to cover it up including buying off government employees.
http://abcnews.go.com/Blotter/RunawayToyot...tory?id=9747342
But internal government memos and court testimony analyzed by ABC News show the federal investigations were extremely limited in scope, after negotiations involving former safety investigators who had been recruited to work for Toyota's Washington, D.C. office.
Wow, the CEO came out an apologized after he couldn't cover it up any longer. What a nice guy.
Yeah, Toyota will bounce back after all all the smoke clears.
People generally realize that all car maufacutures have troubles on ocasion.Toyota is just way overdue.
Perhaps in the long run, this is a good thing in a way as it wiil make auto manufactures more aware of the hazzards of jumping head long into new technology without more thorough testing.
Yes, I know they test everything now but, they still want to hit the market with something new before the compitition.
I can hear now in board rooms: "Let's test it some more so we don't pull a Toyota".
People generally realize that all car maufacutures have troubles on ocasion.Toyota is just way overdue.
Perhaps in the long run, this is a good thing in a way as it wiil make auto manufactures more aware of the hazzards of jumping head long into new technology without more thorough testing.
Yes, I know they test everything now but, they still want to hit the market with something new before the compitition.
I can hear now in board rooms: "Let's test it some more so we don't pull a Toyota".
Originally Posted by eric81 ↑That is not a stock floor mat, and that dealership needs to be talked to (seriously) about putting those floor mats in ANY car. That is why Toyota is having o many issues right now. They probably got some sweet deal on those mat, and that is why they are in there. The stock ones look MUCH different. I will post a pic of one if I can find one (hard to find after recall)
that is just a crappy WalMart mat with the dealership name on it !!!!
yes that dealership should be raked over the coals !!!
[either get a WeatherTech digital fit, or go home.]
I truly believe my Yaris has some issues that need to be resolved. As some may know, I have always felt my yaris had some type of flaw. My Brakes are not stopping my vehicle well enough, and now today I was driving down the road, had a cd in, and it just randomly chaged from the CD to AM radio. It is just all very weird.
🙄🙄🙄
Toyota's once-golden resale value gets dented
CHICAGO – Toyota owners looking to trade in their cars have little reason to sing the carmaker's old ad slogan, "I love what you do for me — Toyota!"
Recalls and a bungled response to safety questions are putting a dent in the resale values of their cars. For years, Toyotas have been praised both for high quality and maintaining their worth. These days, the Toyota in your garage is no longer like money in the bank.
Some dealers are refusing to accept Toyotas for trade, while others are paying considerably less than they did just two week ago. Kelley Blue Book has dropped the value of recalled Toyotas by as much 3 percent. The auto research Web site Edmunds.com estimates resale or trade-in values could fall up to 10 percent in the short term.
The decline will likely continue as long as uncertainty and defects continue to shadow the world's No. 1 carmaker.
Toyota Motor Corp. has so far recalled more than 7 million cars in the U.S., Europe and China over a sticky accelerator and floor mats that can get caught in the gas pedal. Its prized Prius hybrid — which is partially powered by electricity — is under investigation for momentary brake failure. The company is expected to announce its plan for fixing that model this week.
Kelley, which two months ago named Toyota the best brand for resale value, says recalled models are now worth $200 to $500 less per car. Another cut of the same magnitude is planned as soon as the coming week unless the recall controversy abates and demand for Toyotas stops declining, Kelley spokeswoman Robyn Eckard says.
Similarly, since the first recall for sticky accelerator pedals on Jan. 21, Edmunds' estimate for the trade-in value of a 2009 Toyota Camry has fallen by 4 percent to 6 percent to $13,967 while the 2009 Toyota Corolla has declined 6 percent to $11,233.
"My advice to a consumer would be 'If you don't have to trade one in, wait,'" says Michelle Krebs, senior analyst for Edmunds. "Values will stay down for a bit. But Toyota's got really strong brand equity."
The news has unnerved more than a few consumers who had viewed Toyota as a bulletproof brand for quality.
Laura Benin, 34, of New York City chose a 2009 Corolla for her first car purchase a year ago because of Toyota's stellar reputation. Now she's reluctant to drive her car even after the potential acceleration problem is fixed, but knows this is a bad time to try to sell it.
"It's a little bit scary to think the car with the greatest reputation for safety is in the situation it's in now," she says.
Those who are anxious to sell without waiting for a value rebound can turn to the Japanese automaker's rivals. GM, Ford and Chrysler all have announced similar programs that involve offering $1,000 in incentives to Toyota owners who buy their vehicles.
Car dealers are also facing uncertainty.
At River Oaks Chrysler-Jeep in Houston, general manager Alan Helfman told his used car manager to knock 30 to 40 percent of the book value off any recalled Toyotas or Prius hybrids traded in.
"You've got to get them fixed," he said. "You've got to take them in at greatly reduced value."
Chuck Eddy, a Chrysler dealer in Youngstown, Ohio, said he's heard of other dealers refusing to take recalled Toyotas in trade, but said he'll still take them at reduced values.
Two auction houses, where dealers sell trade-ins if they decide not to keep them, have told his dealership that they won't take recalled Toyotas due to legal liability fears. Eddy says customers are nervous about buying Toyotas and the auction houses have further limited his resale options.
Despite the problems, many drivers appear to be sticking with the brand, however uneasily. Leasetrader.com, which acts as matchmaker between buyers and sellers of car leases, says that of several thousand people on a waiting list to take over Toyota leases, fewer than 30 have canceled.
American drivers pushed Toyota's reputation to an unrealistically high level and now a natural adjustment will occur that benefits Ford and General Motors, says John Wolkonowicz, a senior auto analyst for North America at IHS Global Insight in Lexington, Mass.
"I don't think Toyotas are going to suddenly become undesirable on the used car market," he says. "It's just that they have been taken down from this lofty position that they couldn't possibly live up to forever."
Jack Fitzgerald, who owns 12 dealerships including two Toyota stores in the Washington, D.C., area, said he would buy every used Toyota he can get because he's confident they will retain their value.
Fitzgerald said the recall concerns are overblown and should pass quickly once Toyota gets the repair parts to dealers.
"I'm buying every one I can get," he said. "I can't wait for the village idiot to dump his Toyota for nothing. I can certainly make money on it."
___
Associated Press Writer Tom Krisher in Detroit contributed to this report.