chatterskingOriginal postVancouver - B.C. CANADA · Jan 24, 2010#1Toyota Yaris 2008 Auto with 60000 Kilometres. Toyota dealer asked $235 for transmission oil change. On craigslist found somebody willing to do it for $85. The guy drained and filled with about 3 litres of "CASTROL MULTI VEHICLE IMPORT ATF"
Now when Im reading on this site it says that I should only use "GENUINE TOYOTA ATF WS".
Eventhough my car seems to be running fine and didnt see any difference Im extremely worried that I may have used the wrong oil and ruined my transmission. When I called back the guy he says that oil is compatible with all toyota/honda other cars and should be no problem. I know that I should have gone to toyota dealership and get it done there but I was just trying to save some money :( had I known that I should have only used the Genuine toyota atf ws oil I would have never went to this guy.
Im extremely worried that I might have ruined my car and dont know what should i do, i cant even type properly because my hands are shaking. 😢 I have spent a lot of my hard earned money to buy this car and plan to keep it for a long time and dont want to damage it.
Please advise what should I do. 😕 🙁
Replies 67
lowsushiAnaheim, CA · Jan 24, 2010#2I would call a local dealership and ask them just to see what they say. If you know the brand he used try to look up their website and see if there is any info too.
Sorry I can't help more, best of luck.
Doc ZaiusOttawa, ON, Canada · Jan 24, 2010#3I'm pretty sure you're fine! Car manufacturers will always say to use "genuine" OEM products.
Anybody more expert than me want to comment as to the compatibility of these two fluids?
BTW, what's the recommended change interval for ATF?
chatterskingThread starterVancouver - B.C. CANADA · Jan 24, 2010#4according to castrol website it is compatible with Toyota, however i cannot understand what exactly is the difference between castrol atf and toyota atf ws. i really dont know what to do now because every google search im doing is giving my conflicting reports and freaking me out more.
http://www.castrol.com/castrol/secti...tentId=7028224 kargoboySt. Augustine, FL · Jan 24, 2010#5Read your manual. It should be this:
http://www.etimago.com/yaris/TSB/TS-...luid%20%29.pdf Which, by the way is posted right on this forum, too.
The Castrol is not compatible.
That said, I still wouldn't pay a dealer $235, just make sure who you hire is using the right product.
127.0.0.1NE · Jan 25, 2010#6your tranny is not ruined but you must go have it
machine-flushed with the full amount of proper fluid (way more than
can simply drain out) or you do risk damage
UTVitzSalt Lake City · Jan 25, 2010#7If I were in your position, I'd go get it changed to the Toyota ATF. Any local shop can do it, just bring your own fluid or see if the guy that initially did it will give you a break on putting the right stuff in if you buy the fluid. Any transmission is way to expensive to even think about taking a chance on messing around with-that and your piece of mind.
SilverGlowSouthern California · Jan 25, 2010#8You f'd up OP....you should have got the tranny machine flushed and refilled and at the proper temperature too.
You save a few dollars but are vulnerable to big dollars in repair cost. Therefore you saved NOTHING paying that idiot $85 do scam you.
Not too late!!! Just take it to another independent garage WITH the proper flusing machine and use GENUINE Toyota tranny fluid.
Do it ASAP...take off work and get this F-up resolved today. By the way, the Toyota dealership here in Orange County routinely mails out coupons for auto-tranny flushing and these ask only $120 for this service...also, not needed for your Yaris until 100,000+ miles.
ROCKLAND TOYOTAROCKLAND COUNTY NY · Jan 25, 2010#9seeing as this was a DRAIN AND FILL only i say your OK. you could take it to a toyota dealer and get the COMPLETE flush(15 quarts of WS) to be safe or just run it like it is.....
SilverGlowSouthern California · Jan 25, 2010#10 Originally Posted by
ROCKLAND TOYOTA ↑ seeing as this was a DRAIN AND FILL only i say your OK. you could take it to a toyota dealer and get the COMPLETE flush(15 quarts of WS) to be safe or just run it like it is.....
I strongly disagree....drain and flush will not remove all the particulates....his tranny really needs to be flushed for longevity, and using the wrong fluid is just plain wrong. No need to go to a Toy stealership either....better to go to an independent garage, and shop around for price and procedures first, making sure they use Genuine Toy WS fluid...this is what I'd do if I want the tranny to last 250k or more miles.
ddongbaphay · Jan 25, 2010#11Did you guys miss the part where he states his tranny is already ruined?
SilverGlowSouthern California · Jan 25, 2010#12 Originally Posted by
ddongbap ↑ Did you guys miss the part where he states his tranny is already ruined?
You need to learn to read! ;-)
He never said the tranny was ruined. He is worried that it might be ruined...big diff, yea?!? lol
ddongbaphay · Jan 25, 2010#13 Originally Posted by
SilverGlow ↑ You need to learn to read! ;-)
He never said the tranny was ruined. He is worried that it might be ruined...big diff, yea?!? lol
O sry. Btw, it says MY CAR IS RUINED in his title. Thats all I had the attention span to read. MY ADDHD DHDHDHD is in full effectx today.
ROCKLAND TOYOTAROCKLAND COUNTY NY · Jan 25, 2010#14 Originally Posted by
ROCKLAND TOYOTA ↑ seeing as this was a DRAIN AND FILL only i say your OK. you could take it to a toyota dealer and get the COMPLETE flush(15 quarts of WS) to be safe or just run it like it is.....
Originally Posted by
SilverGlow ↑ I strongly disagree....drain and flush will not remove all the particulates....his tranny really needs to be flushed for longevity, and using the wrong fluid is just plain wrong. No need to go to a Toy stealership either....better to go to an independent garage, and shop around for price and procedures first, making sure they use Genuine Toy WS fluid...this is what I'd do if I want the tranny to last 250k or more miles.
disagree with the COMPLETE FLUSH suggestion?
YarisSedanCalifornia - Bay Area · Jan 25, 2010#15Castrol ATF is not compatable with the new world atf our yaris have. If it was a older toyota yes. But not ours. Even if it was your not supose to drain and refil our type of transmission. Only 100 percent exchange according to toyota. You can not reuse any of the old fluid its not compatable to mix old with new. Why i dont know you probally could be okay.
But either way you look at it your only option is to now take it to toyota and have them do a complete flush of the system. Which is probally why it was costing 235. Which is not untirely unreasonable. Since our systems can take as much as 15 quarts sometimes more of transmision fluid. And i know its really expensive for the fluid. Around 10 bucks or more per quart. They have to disconect the lines from your transmission to the radiator and hook up the machine to evacuate all the fluid and put in fresh new.
I wouldnt worry about anything honestly since its such short term you should be okay. I was just get the flush the dealer was goign to perform. I would not mention anything about what you just did. They can try to hold it against you incase of any warrenty issues with the transmission incase it does fail. And guess what if it does fail shortly after it would be after they performed a transmission service heh.
YarisSedanCalifornia - Bay Area · Jan 25, 2010#16Not to rub it in if you look at what you were getting, paying little over 200 is not a rip off but paying 80 bucks for what you got was a rip off. Just draining out and topping off 3 quarts of generic fluid. Its like you paid 80 bucks for a oil change but with no filter.
127.0.0.1NE · Jan 25, 2010#17 Originally Posted by
ROCKLAND TOYOTA ↑ disagree with the COMPLETE FLUSH suggestion?
exactly. it is not as though he got water in it, it is only the wrong ATF. the difference between ATF as WS is not so significant to require a rebuild or new clutch packs. just get it flushed once and go with it. maybe flush again in 30,000 to be sure. WS is lifetime stuff. ATF is not.
supmetSouthern California · Jan 25, 2010#18I've had dexron 7 in my transmission for like 20,000 miles or more now, which the dealer told me is not compatible.. my car runs fine
You can get a salvage tranny for the cost of 2 or 3 flushes. I wouldn't worry too much
oh and lifetime any fluid is a joke.
chatterskingThread starterVancouver - B.C. CANADA · Jan 25, 2010#19First of all thank you so much for your replies - your information was very valuable and helpful to me and I thank you all from the bottom of my heart.
Please let me have a moment to explain the whole situation.
I purchased a used Yaris Sedan with 50K Kilometres and considering it is a 2008 model i would say it was driven a lot. Therefore my transmission oil was found dirty during a recent oil change. After contemplating back and forth regarding the "lifetime" oil guarantee from Toyota I thought to better be safe then sorry and decided to change my transmission fluid for good. However Toyota quoted me something around $200 for a "DRAIN & REFILL" (trust me they say they only do this method). I found a better deal thru a local "mechanic" for $85. As per my previous post he proceeded to use three one litre cans of Castrol Multi Import Vehicle ATF and claimed that it is compatible for Toyota based on the product labelling. Satisfied and happy I drove back home enjoying the smooth feel of my car without having any single clue of what was about to come. Since I dont have an owners manual I was not able to read the important information regarding proper Toyota transmission fluid. After coming back home and stumbling around this website I found out the real truth. Obviously since the repair was done by a local "mechanic" in his backyard and by cash I screwed myself big time as this son of a gun will not stand his service.
Today after reading all your reviews I went to Toyota dealership and purchased genuine Toyota ATF WS one case of 12 cans for $100. Obviously the parts department guy was wondering why do i need so much instead of just 3,4 liters. I told him everything honestly as what had occurred and he suggested to me that instead of going to another local mechanic whose flushing methods may not be proper I should rather do it from them. Having no choice and learned my lesson I decided to flush my transmission from them.
The total came out about $200 plus my earlier $100 for the fluids. Not to forget the earlier $85 that i had spent on the idiot.
Anyways i was not able to see what exactly Toyota did since i was called back after an hour but i believe that they did carried out all the necessary repairs as were needed. There is no difference in driving and my car still runs smooth as it used to be before all this hoopla.
After going thru all these experiences and learning a valuable yet painful lesson i find myself still confused regarding what to believe. Genuine vs non genuine, dealer vs local mechanic and all that. I guess it is all about common sense knowing what and who to choose for when!
Again thank you so much for all your help - let my experience serve as a lesson to all of you so that god forbid you dont have to go thru this. 🙄
Hersheynortheast · Jan 25, 2010#20the A.T.F. can go as far as 100,000 miles . Makes me believe that it's a synthetic tranny fluid . Any thoughts on this ?
auxmikeLI, New Yawk · Jan 25, 2010#21I don't know, but I'm not messing with mine!
There is a sticker right on the neck of the tranny dipstick stating no need to change the fluid.
Stick to oil changes.....😁
Hersheynortheast · Jan 26, 2010#22take a look at this .
www.amsoil.com/storefront/atl.aspx . Makes me think the WS is a synthetic . Know that the newer VIBES and MATRIX now use synthetic gear oil ( GL-5 ) for the manual tranny . Not sure about new COROLLAs and SCION XDs . Would think so since they too have the same 5 speed manual transmissin and 1.8 ltr. engine . Wonder if the manual tranny for YARIS now comes with synthetic gear oil . 🤷 Hard to get that kind of info out of TOYOTA . Bummer . 🙄
ctrjUpland, CA · Jan 26, 2010#23Manual Yaris does indeed come with WS. I drained mine at 75k and refilled with Mobil 1 synthetic.
Hersheynortheast · Jan 26, 2010#24manual tranny for YARIS uses gear oil , not A.T.F.. If I read what you wrote right .
ctrjUpland, CA · Jan 26, 2010#25 Originally Posted by
Hershey ↑ manual tranny for YARIS uses gear oil , not A.T.F.. If I read what you wrote right .
No, from what I understand, they put WS fluid in the manual tranny too. I will check with a tech today to confirm.
127.0.0.1NE · Jan 26, 2010#26 Originally Posted by
auxmike ↑ I don't know, but I'm not messing with mine!
There is a sticker right on the neck of the tranny dipstick stating no need to change the fluid.
Stick to oil changes.....😁
all that matters is:
Toyota WS is lifetime, no need to change it unless:
it becomes discolored
it becomes burnt smelling
so that basically means you may end up changing it around 150,000
YMMV
what makes it special is: ws stands for world standard and was developed
with the hybrid synergy drive systems in mind. Toyota uses it everywhere now
so there will be less mistakes moving forward, and one simple ATF fluid for all
Toyotas.
it is the only ATF that won't destroy toyota hybrids and electric drive systems
it has a lower viscosity when cold for energy savings,
and lower viscosity at operating temps...the viscosity rises when it gets really hot and then
matches atf T-IV viscosity
transmissions are specifically built for it.
any other fluid can and will cause long term clutch failures, solenoid failures...etc...
Hersheynortheast · Jan 26, 2010#27 Originally Posted by
ctrj ↑ No, from what I understand, they put WS fluid in the manual tranny too. I will check with a tech today to confirm.
it's gear oil . Had an '08 manual and changed factory installed gear oil to a better synthetic gear oil . REDLINE MT-90 ( GL-4 , 75w-90 ) .
supmetSouthern California · Jan 26, 2010#28 Originally Posted by
127.0.0.1 ↑ all that matters is:
Toyota WS is lifetime, no need to change it unless:
it becomes discolored
it becomes burnt smelling
My tranny fluid was "discolored" at about 10k, maybe earlier. 🤷
I changed it at 60k, when the shifting became noticeably less smooth.
Hersheynortheast · Jan 26, 2010#29apparently to verify the type of A.T.F. you'll need to remove the transmission dipstick and should see either W.S. or T-IV stamped just above the FULL MARK . The W.S. stands for WORLD STANDARD .
LazerdotEuless Texas · Jan 27, 2010#30I put AMSOIL Severe Gear 75w-90 in my MT.
1stToyotaOklahoma · Jan 27, 2010#31 Originally Posted by
Lazerdot ↑ I put AMSOIL Severe Gear 75w-90 in my MT.
You probably should have used AMSOIL 75W-90 GL-4 Transaxle Lube...it's what I used and GL-4 is better for the transaxle than the severe gear GL-5, which is meant for differentials.
TheSilkySmoothNew Hampshire · Jan 27, 2010#32Most high performance ATF is synthetic. Just pull the msds and look at the oils.
jambo101Montreal Canada · Jan 28, 2010#33I wouldnt think about changing tranny fluid till at least 100k,in fact my last 2 cars got at least 200k on the manual trannies before i sold the cars and i never did get around to changing the tranny oil at all.😁
LazerdotEuless Texas · Jan 29, 2010#34My owners manual said GL-5. Plus since I run it hard some times, seemed like a good idea. So far its working real good.
Hersheynortheast · Jan 29, 2010#35I believe the SEVERE GEAR is formulated so not to corrode brass parts of manual tranny , unlike most GL-5 gear oils .
cali yarisCanoga Park, CA · Jan 30, 2010#36 oh and lifetime any fluid is a joke.
does that include sealed rear differentials?
,in fact my last 2 cars got at least 200k on the manual trannies before i sold the cars and i never did get around to changing the tranny oil at all
may be semantics, but that's pretty much "lifetime" -- longer than I've ever owned a car, (and I'm pretty old). LOL.
Hard_YarisEdmonton Alberta · Jan 30, 2010#37I've driven my 2005 toyota Echo 190,000KM with noproblems and I've owned it since its birth... it Met a Curb @ 70KM/h and was destroyed in 2009.
Also, I was told that My 2008 Yaris has Gear Oil 75-90. I was going to replace it with the synthetic AMSoil Gear Oil 75-90 and im sure its a GL-4... is that OK?
Hersheynortheast · Jan 30, 2010#38yes , GL-4 is fine .
1stToyotaOklahoma · Feb 1, 2010#39robkayNW OH · Feb 3, 2010#40Chattersking, let me tell you a story that might make you at least feel a little better.
When I was first married, many years ago, my new wife called me from her parents home one day. She said it was a nice summer day and she was bored and wanted something to do. She knew the car was due for an oil change and asked if it was OK for her to do it. I said NO, I would take care of it myself at a later time. But, she begged me and reminded me that she had taken a Powder Puff Car Maintenance course in high school (a car maintenance class for girls) and that she knew exactly how to do it. Reluctantly, I said "OK, go ahead."
An hour later she proudly called me to tell me that she was all done, but was surprised at how hard it was to pour the motor oil into that metal tube and that she had to borrow a funnel from her father to get the oil into that tube.
I said, "What metal tube????" She said, "The one that has the dip stick in it."
I said, "You didn't remove the round cap on top of the engine that says, 'OIL'?"
There was a long pause, and then, "No. I took out the dip stick on the side of the engine and poured it down the tube. Did I not do it right?"
I said, "No. You just poured 4 quarts of motor oil into the transmission!"
I was freaked just as you were.
Fortunately, there was a good shop not far away and the mechanic said, "Don't worry. Just have her put oil in the engine and run it down here. We'll flush and refill the transmission and you will be fine." That was many years ago and at that time a flush was only about $80, but that was still the most expensive oil change I've ever had in my life! We've been married 33 years now and I've made sure she has not lived that one down!! 😁
Doc ZaiusOttawa, ON, Canada · Feb 3, 2010#41^^^ But the dipstick tube is for measuring the engine oil level... not transmission fluid..? Sound like she just added an extra 4 quarts to the engine oil already in there. Which isn't great either b/c the crank would churn it and get bubbles and etc. Your tranny should've been fine.
robkayNW OH · Feb 3, 2010#42Nope--33 years ago, Doc. Different technology. Rear wheel drive. That was how you added tranny fluid in those days. You removed the dipstick from a tube that went down to the transmission (not transaxle) and used a long, skinny funnel that fit into the tube. You would add a little fluid, stick the dipstick back in and check it, stick the funnel back in and add a little more, check it again. Fun times.
Doc ZaiusOttawa, ON, Canada · Feb 3, 2010#43Huh! Well how about that! I stand corrected, sir! 🙇
robkayNW OH · Feb 3, 2010#44 Originally Posted by
Doc Zaius ↑ Huh! Well how about that! I stand corrected, sir! 🙇
Yep...so did the wife! 😁
Hersheynortheast · Feb 3, 2010#45we had similar issue with a '93 FORD Festiva ( Mazdz 121 ) with 5 speed manual . Took it to dealer service center to get tranny fluid changed . Come to find out they dumped gear oil in it instead of A.T.F. fluid that it called for ( MERCON ? , long time ago to remember 😉 ) . They must of assumed that it being a manual tranny that it took gear oil . Took it back and they wouldn't change it back to A.T.F. for free 😠 . So , left and did the next 2 changes myself . The car did fine after that . Well until it was rear ended while waiting at red light during a wet snowfall . Since that I always check fluids and level after any service is done .
N9QGSGeorgetown, KY · Feb 4, 2010#46You know what is really sad... Okay so you guys got my hopes up of going to Toyota and getting a complete flush just to be on the safe side... They wont do it, they said it never requires servicing and just to check level at 100,000. And then they got paranoid saying their flush machine is not set up for World Standard fluid and id hate to mix the fluids together. (meaning there would be cross contamination with the fluid the machine is normally being used with), so it sounds like this would be a problem anywhere than to get it flushed. Seriously what am I dealing with here?
UPDATE AGAIN: Toyota referred me to a technical service bulletin stating, and these are the exact words: 100,000 Maintenance Interval — Inspection only; ATF-WS does NOT require any flushing or changing during the life of the vehicle.
This is why Toyota dealerships wont touch my car, they said I should be just fine with what I've been doing. Now you may say go find an independent shop, question is what about cross contamination of and fluids that are already still in their machine if I brought them 15 to 20 qts of ATF-WS, this was a concern to Toyota while they were pondering if they would even consider attempting to do it for me.
N9QGSGeorgetown, KY · Feb 4, 2010#47Okay I think I have my answer, but I will need you guys to verify's this all applies to a Yaris. Im reading to do this yourself (exchange much of the fluid), drain pain of fluid, and refill. Locate and disconnect the transmission return line, and put clear tubing on it to a drain container. Start the car, and put in drive with emergency brake, and you will get the flow of transmission fluid in the convertor and all that draining out and it says to do this process until you see a change in the color of the liquid, then shut engine off, reconnect transmission return line, top fluid, and road test and recheck level. If this is what you recommend I do vs trying to worry about Toyota comments, if its really this easy, Im doing it this weekend. hahah
Anyone know what tool I made need and how to properly identfy where Im disconnecting this transmission line? and what size clear tubing will fit this best? also will I need to keep filling the transmission up during this process (reason I ask draining pan, is putting about 2 to 3 qts of fresh fluid in, if i'm pumping out 10 to 15 qts of old fluid, im gonna run out somewhere, and i dont know if running out while the car is in drive is a good idea)
thanks.. Ron
SilverGlowSouthern California · Feb 8, 2010#48 Originally Posted by
N9QGS ↑ Okay I think I have my answer, but I will need you guys to verify's this all applies to a Yaris. Im reading to do this yourself (exchange much of the fluid), drain pain of fluid, and refill. Locate and disconnect the transmission return line, and put clear tubing on it to a drain container. Start the car, and put in drive with emergency brake, and you will get the flow of transmission fluid in the convertor and all that draining out and it says to do this process until you see a change in the color of the liquid, then shut engine off, reconnect transmission return line, top fluid, and road test and recheck level. If this is what you recommend I do vs trying to worry about Toyota comments, if its really this easy, Im doing it this weekend. hahah
Anyone know what tool I made need and how to properly identfy where Im disconnecting this transmission line? and what size clear tubing will fit this best? also will I need to keep filling the transmission up during this process (reason I ask draining pan, is putting about 2 to 3 qts of fresh fluid in, if i'm pumping out 10 to 15 qts of old fluid, im gonna run out somewhere, and i dont know if running out while the car is in drive is a good idea)
thanks.. Ron
You might F it all up....just take it to a dealership or reputable garage and let them use their high tech machine to do this job....and use the Toyota fluid too! I would advise against doing this yourself....Gosh, for $75-$120 bucks just let the pros do it fast, quick and right. They have the tools and knowhow you don't. As to oil changes and other types of maintenence, you can do those yourself because they are much easier and less envasive. If your Toy dealership refuses to flush/drain/refill, then there are others that will do it....mine in So Cal will, and others will too.
CTScottUSA, CT · Feb 8, 2010#49 Originally Posted by
N9QGS ↑ Okay I think I have my answer, but I will need you guys to verify's this all applies to a Yaris. Im reading to do this yourself (exchange much of the fluid), drain pain of fluid, and refill. Locate and disconnect the transmission return line, and put clear tubing on it to a drain container. Start the car, and put in drive with emergency brake, and you will get the flow of transmission fluid in the convertor and all that draining out and it says to do this process until you see a change in the color of the liquid, then shut engine off, reconnect transmission return line, top fluid, and road test and recheck level. If this is what you recommend I do vs trying to worry about Toyota comments, if its really this easy, Im doing it this weekend. hahah
Anyone know what tool I made need and how to properly identfy where Im disconnecting this transmission line? and what size clear tubing will fit this best? also will I need to keep filling the transmission up during this process (reason I ask draining pan, is putting about 2 to 3 qts of fresh fluid in, if i'm pumping out 10 to 15 qts of old fluid, im gonna run out somewhere, and i dont know if running out while the car is in drive is a good idea)
thanks.. Ron
I have been running Napa Dexron VI ATF in Crashy. Her AT was 3 quarts low, since her left front axle was yanked loose during her accident (and as I found out putting her in gear before fully reseating that axle - tranny fluid will gush out when put in gear with the axle not seated). The day I wanted to fire her up Toyota was already closed, so I hit my local NAPA, who of course didn't have Toyota ATF WS. I checked out the MSDS for Dexron VI and it the composition and specs seemed to match those of the ATF WS MSDS, so that's what I went with.
The Automatic Transmission section of the service manual (posted in the DIY section of the Forum) shows the location and function (in/out) of the transmission cooler lines.
Here's Amsoil's procedure for DIY flushing an AT:
Follow these additional 5 steps for complete
transmission pan and torque converter fluid replacement.
1) Obtain the total transmission fluid capacity
from the manufacturer or AMSOIL
and have that amount of transmission
fluid available.
2) Place a drain pan large enough to hold the
total fluid capacity under the oil cooler.
Disconnect the oil cooler lines from the
oil cooler and direct the lines toward the
drain pan.
3) With another person, be prepared to add
ATF to the transmission fill hole (dipstick
hole) at the approximate rate as the fluid
is being pumped out the transmission line
into the drain pan.
4) Start the engine, and as the old fluid is
pumped out, add fresh fluid into the
transmission fill hole.
5) When either the fluid color brightens or
the total capacity has been replaced, shut
the engine off and re-attach the oil cooler
lines. All fluid in the transmission pan
and torque converter has now been
changed.
With the vehicle on level ground recheck the
fluid level using the manufacturer procedures outlined
in the owners manual. Check the transmission
and lines for leaks.
jekqmbSTL · Feb 8, 2010#50Wow should have went and had a fluid exchange, most ATF fluids these days are compatible with the yaris... Best fluid I think is maxatf from Valvoline.