Yarisworld Archive

$86.44 for oil change? I feel screwed

95 posts · 41,207 views · page 2 of 2

Replies continued

daf62757Indianapolis, Indiana · Dec 22, 2009#51
Originally Posted by behour ↑
I have no experience with vehicles. My yaris is the first new car I bought. I sadly feel often screwed. I went to get an oil change today and was charged 86.44 for it.

Here is my questions

It was full syntetic oil. Is this the best to get or should I avoid?
I was over charged...correct? It seems ridiculously high.
My bill looks something like this

Labor 33.84
Parts 48.20
Shop Material 1.35
Sales tax 3.05
Total 86.44



This is my 2nd oil change at 10,000 miles. My first oil change I asked for syntetic from another Toyota dealer and was only charged $41.45. I was not sure if I was given full synthetic oil even when told otherwise. I was charged with "lube synthetic oil for $10.00". The bill was not clear. I have had problems with the sales department so I tried another dealer. Looks like I should of just stayed with them for a $40 dollar change in price and a 20minutes extra drive.

Any opinions and help would be great for someone as clueless as me with cars. I just want to take the best care for it you know?

I have a question.....would it have been worth a few dollars more to have someone come to your home...or work place....and change your oil?

I have toyed with the idea to start a valet oil change business that specializes in full synthetic oil and comes to where ever it is convenient for you.

How many would pay $100 for that?
SpaceShotNH · Dec 22, 2009#52
I would certainly recommend learning to do it for yourself. The oil change on the Yaris is not hard as engines go. You can even do it without jacking the car up. (not the most comfortable approach) The trickiest part is finding a filter wrench that will fit the little tea cup of a filter it has and not slip. Proper filters and oil can be found in any parts store or even Walmart.

If you don't have the Saturday morning to spare and a suitable garage or driveway, you can look for an independent shop. Try
http://www.cartalk.com/ct/mechx/find...63101&miles=50
if you have no one local that can recommend a shop.

There is nothing magic about dealer service. In many locations independent shop mechanics pass the same certifications the dealer staff do. If you are worried about warranty, just keep your receipts on file.

Quick lube places are another story. If you have no other choices, look for one that has certified staff (on hand if not under your car) and where you can watch the service being done. If you use one of these, you should check the level and fittings when you get home. (making it less of a convenience perhaps, but keeping your engine safe)
Hersheynortheast · Dec 22, 2009#53
would think synthetic be better for the 1.5 ltr. engine due to working harder to climb hills and highway speeds ( higher r.p.m. ) . Be better for very cold day starts and those hot commutes in summer .
supmetSouthern California · Dec 22, 2009#54
Originally Posted by YarisSedan ↑
I pay 11 dollars a quart for amsoil from my local kragens
Dude, honestly, if you can't argue the facts at hand I'm going to start ignoring your posts. We're not talking amsoil, and we're not talking 20 dollar changes. AND we're not talking about an independent shop who buys their shit from kragen.
coffiendOmaha, NE · Dec 22, 2009#55
Uhhhh Missouri does get pretty cold.

Idk what your standard of cold weather is but single digit temps is pretty darn cold in my eyes.

I would think synthetic oil is justifiable in those conditions.

Also, unless the average oil changing chain is losing 50ish bucks every oil change they make, there is definitely a profit in an $80 oil change... if they really were losing that much each change, those places would not exist...

80 is absolutely crazy to me...
mrb3990Midwest USA · Dec 22, 2009#56
What I have been led to believe by visiting different forums (bob is the oil guy and cartalk, primarily) is that synthetic is superior to dino oil in extremely cold temperatures (like -20 F and below) not single digits. Dino oil can handle single digits. Also, synthetic is important for high performance engines and any engines for which is it specified in the owner's manual. The question is whether or not synthetic oil is beneficial for an engine like the one in the yaris. The Yaris owner's manual does not specify synthetic. I'm not knocking anyone who uses synthetic oil in their yaris (it's your baby, I understand) but if the OP is complaining about a high price oil change, I just wanted to put it out there that he/she might just want to use dino oil. I only have 2200 miles on my yaris, but I plan on using dino oil when the time comes to get that first oil change.
Yaris HiltonBristol, Tennessee, USA · Dec 22, 2009#57
Yep. Dino oil at recommended change intervals is what my Yaris is getting, and I expect my engine life to be as good as anyone's.
swiddCentral Alabama, GOD BLESS AMERICA · Dec 22, 2009#58
Uh, no, that's not so overpriced. I've been upset with the price of synthetic oil change myself, but if you're asking for full synthetic, that's within the price range. At walmart or auto-zone, the top brand full synthetic will run 35-45 dollars, some of them closer to $50 (Mobil-1). + filter, + labor, and you're there. If I'm going to do it myself I'd still spend $60 in 'parts'.
b_hickman11Tyler, TX · Dec 22, 2009#59
Originally Posted by swidd ↑
Uh, no, that's not so overpriced. I've been upset with the price of synthetic oil change myself, but if you're asking for full synthetic, that's within the price range. At walmart or auto-zone, the top brand full synthetic will run 35-45 dollars, some of them closer to $50 (Mobil-1). + filter, + labor, and you're there. If I'm going to do it myself I'd still spend $60 in 'parts'.
I'll stay with my $2.20 per qt oil and $3 filter. Been using it for years with no problems. Ends up costing me around $100 a year(8-9 oil changes). With synthetic it would be $425 if I did it myself or $735 if I went to behour's dealer. If I was a rich man maybe I wouldn't care but then again I wouldn't be driving a Yaris either.
scapeBeaufort, South Carolina · Dec 22, 2009#60
that sounds about right for synthetic from the dealer. i hope they rotated your tires too. looks like you paid for labor at a half-hour which with oil change and rotation, up and down on the lift it would be close to 25 minutes
DerFlosserUSA · Dec 22, 2009#61
Anybody that thinks a dealership isn't ripping them off is clueless. A dealership is the LAST place that I would bring a car to be worked on. Any mechanic(s) that is worth a shit is working for themselves as an independant garage anyhow. Dealerships have been called "Stealerships" for years now and it's no coincidence. The argument for synthetic is better lubrication and cleaner engine. There is no question that a synthetic is superior to a conventional in those two areas. I believe their ability to suspend particulates and harmful combustion bi-products may even be superior but I haven't done the research to say that with confidence.
coffiendOmaha, NE · Dec 22, 2009#62
^ I agree with saying that dealerships in general over charge,but saying that all mechanics that don't work for independent shops aren't "worth shit" is a little over the top... Not to mention incredibly rude and mean.
YarisSedanCalifornia - Bay Area · Dec 22, 2009#63
Originally Posted by supmet ↑
Dude, honestly, if you can't argue the facts at hand I'm going to start ignoring your posts. We're not talking amsoil, and we're not talking 20 dollar changes. AND we're not talking about an independent shop who buys their shit from kragen.
Okay this is starting to turn into a flame war here so this will be the last post i will make on this thread. What i noticed on threads that start to go this route is people who respond and join in dont read the thread and reponses from start to finish and may only read the last 1 or 2 pages and then comment typing in all caps and start using curse words without knowing the whole story.

If you account the fact that he payed in addition to his oil change for a tire rotation which was 26 dollars. Otherwise he would have payed pretty much 60 dollars for just a synthetic oil change alone at the dealership. Which 60 dollars is not entirely unreasonable. Jiffy lube charges 79.95 for synthetic oil change using penzoil platinum for up to 5 quarts. I am not sure if they adjust the price down if a vehicle takes less oil.

I am not tryign to say you should go to the dealership just try to explain why they charge a higher labor rate.

The reason I am comparing it to a normal 20 dollar oil change is to show you the labor rate is the same as a synthetic oil change. They labor they charged the Origonal Post was about 7 dollars. the extra 26 dollars came into play when he decided to get a tire rotation.

So really the only question should be the price he payed for the oil. We cant say for certain what type of oil he got in his car when going to the dealer. Unless someone here works for toyota they can state the brand. Sure they may buy it in massive bulk and get a discount rate which gives them a greater margin of markup but in reality it is not that great. If they sell the synthetic for 11 bucks i dont realisticly think they payed 2 or 3 bucks. At a minumum its about 5 bucks. Unless its some generic brand synthetic. I have worked with a lot of venders and i know what the prices are out on the market. If you dont want to believe me you have the right to your opinion just like i have the right to my own.
supmetSouthern California · Dec 22, 2009#64
Originally Posted by YarisSedan ↑
the extra 26 dollars came into play when he decided to get a tire rotation.
And that in itself is a ripoff. I get free rotations, and if you have it up for an oil change, you're adding 90 seconds. Even at the ripoff rate of 95 dollars an hour that's $2.40.

And you're also acting like a lube tech works on one car, and one car only until its done. Like he sits there and watches it drain or something. When working in a shop, you know full well a lube tech can and will do as many cars as there are lifts or pits.

I realize its convenient to fudge the facts to support your business, but nobody is buying it.

Originally Posted by YarisSedan ↑
Sure they may buy it in massive bulk and get a discount rate which gives them a greater margin of markup but in reality it is not that great. If they sell the synthetic for 11 bucks i dont realisticly think they payed 2 or 3 bucks. At a minumum its about 5 bucks.
If I buy full synthetic for less than 5 dollars a quart, I doubt the dealership spends more.



Originally Posted by YarisSedan ↑
I have worked with a lot of venders and i know what the prices are out on the market.
I browse the kragen ads too dude..
b_hickman11Tyler, TX · Dec 22, 2009#65
Originally Posted by YarisSedan ↑

If you account the fact that he payed in addition to his oil change for a tire rotation which was 26 dollars.

.

I can rotate my tires in less than 7 minutes using 1 jack stand and the pos factory jack. And it will be free. The dealership has a lift. With 1 tech they could rotate in probably 2 minutes or less, with 2 techs less than a minute. So thats $26 for a minute or two of work. Thats about $1500 an hour!! But still you say thats not a profit? Your dealership must have a water park in it for the customers to use while getting their car serviced!
ctrjUpland, CA · Dec 23, 2009#66
You didn't get screwed. You signed the repair order before your car was worked on didn't you? They quoted you a price didn't they?

Your price seems right for a dealership oil change.

$10 for the oil filter
$10/qt for synthetic oil x 4 = $40

At my shop, techs get about .3 of an hour for an oil change. They get an extra .1 if they have to pour the oil in from bottles instead of the overhead oil. Labor at my shop is $118 an hour.

There is quite a bit of markup in synthetic oil. I think we pay about $4 a quart for Mobil 1, but charge $9 a quart.

Thankfully, there are many people like you who come and get their oil changed at the dealership or I wouldn't have a job. I can't afford the $80 oil changes, but do it at home. $3 for a Toyota filter and $22 for a jug of Mobil 1 and 30 minutes is all I need.
DerFlosserUSA · Dec 23, 2009#67
Originally Posted by coffiend ↑
^ I agree with saying that dealerships in general over charge,but saying that all mechanics that don't work for independent shops aren't "worth shit" is a little over the top... Not to mention incredibly rude and mean.
As somebody once said...the truth hurts. Good Mechanics work at independant garages because independants can't afford bad or average mechanics and dealerships simply don't share the same stakes because lemmings come to dealer over and over regardless. Simple as that...
CosworthMI · Dec 23, 2009#68
$86 for an oil change + tire rotation? It seems steep IMO. Maybe it's time to invest in a floor jack & a set of jack stands (plus a decent torque wrench & a metric socket set).

It's really easy to change oil in Yaris compared to some !!@# cars out there.

As for full synthetic vs. dino oil... I really don't see a huge difference between the two, but I drive my Yaris only during summer.
RUFFSTUFFKINGSLAND, GA · Dec 24, 2009#69
Yeah, I just did my 5000 mile change... it was ridiculously easy and I probably could have done it without the ramps. Though I do wonder why they angled the drain plug towards the right wheel.
yaris-meAnaheim, CA · Dec 24, 2009#70
Originally Posted by RUFFSTUFF ↑
Yeah, I just did my 5000 mile change... it was ridiculously easy and I probably could have done it without the ramps. Though I do wonder why they angled the drain plug towards the right wheel.
So you don't confuse it with transmission.
RUFFSTUFFKINGSLAND, GA · Dec 24, 2009#71
Aha! Good call...
Twistoffate0817Voorhees, NJ · Dec 24, 2009#72
I paid 60 dollars for my synthetic oil change.
Yaweshlong island · Dec 25, 2009#73
Originally Posted by behour ↑
I have no experience with vehicles. My yaris is the first new car I bought. I sadly feel often screwed. I went to get an oil change today and was charged 86.44 for it.

Here is my questions

It was full syntetic oil. Is this the best to get or should I avoid?
I was over charged...correct? It seems ridiculously high.
My bill looks something like this

Labor 33.84
Parts 48.20
Shop Material 1.35
Sales tax 3.05
Total 86.44


This is my 2nd oil change at 10,000 miles. My first oil change I asked for syntetic from another Toyota dealer and was only charged $41.45. I was not sure if I was given full synthetic oil even when told otherwise. I was charged with "lube synthetic oil for $10.00". The bill was not clear. I have had problems with the sales department so I tried another dealer. Looks like I should of just stayed with them for a $40 dollar change in price and a 20minutes extra drive.

Any opinions and help would be great for someone as clueless as me with cars. I just want to take the best care for it you know?
everyone makes mistakes, but the point is not to do it again, aittte. best thing to make up for it is learn how to do the oil change yourself. it's really easy, in fact - i'm an oil change specialist.....and suk in everything else
chaiTexas · Dec 26, 2009#74
You either pay now or you pay later.

I had to invest in tools to do car work:
Ramps - $38
Jack - $96
Jack Stands - $20
Torque wrench - $15
Other tools/sockets - $20

But my oil change cost me <$25 in parts, and that was with Pennzoil Platinum synthetic and a TRD filter. Having those tools available made the decision to buy snow tires/rims and swap them out myself easier. "Free" tire rotations for life now :P

It hasn't hit -20F in WI yet, but it might. Overkill?
sqcompBack at home · Dec 26, 2009#75
hmmm. The dealership I go to has never charged me that much. Why in the name of all that is holy do you need full synthetic? Does the owner's manual call for it? Sounds to me that this dealership needs to lose a customer to one that treats you with more respect and give you a quote before the job.
supmetSouthern California · Dec 26, 2009#76
Originally Posted by chai ↑
I had to invest in tools to do car work:
Ramps - $38
Jack - $96
Jack Stands - $20
Torque wrench - $15
Other tools/sockets - $20
A jack should be 40-50 dollars tops especially for the yaris. The torque wrench should have been more though :P

You only need a socket to do the oil, I haven't jacked it up for the last couple changes.
jambo101Montreal Canada · Dec 29, 2009#77
Originally Posted by b_hickman11 ↑
I actually just got finished changing my oil this morning. Took about 10 minutes and only cost me about $10. I put 5000 miles on about every 6 weeks so spending $10 each time is a lot better than $80+.
What kind of oil and filter are you using that can be had for less than $10 in total😕
Yaris HiltonBristol, Tennessee, USA · Dec 29, 2009#78
If you watch for sales at the auto stores, that's not rare.
MadMaxSan Antonio, Texas! · Dec 29, 2009#79
Yes, even for a dealership, that seems high; but if you include a tire rotation than it's not as bad. Still, there is a reason why many people call them “stealerships!” 😲

As noted, you could easily save a lot of money by either doing it yourself or finding an independent shop to do the work. I change the oil in all my vehicles except for my wife's Honda Odyssey minivan (I hate working on it). It is a simple job for even the most mechanically-challenged individuals; but if you feel you can't do it yourself you might want to consider someplace other than a dealership to have it done.

And in my experience, you are not getting any higher quality service by going to a dealer. I had a free oil change and tire rotation from the dealership where I bought my Yaris, and not only did they screw up and no put synthetic in the car as I requested, the car also drove horribly after they rotated the tires. I went to a Discount Tire store on my way home and bought the lifetime rotation and balance plan for the car for about $60, and after they were done with it, it rode like it was on rails.

I am just about to do the 10K oil change on my car, should take all of 15-20 minutes even being my first time doing this on my Yaris. And no, it does not void the warranty, that is an old myth. As a matter of fact, I prefer to do my own oil changes (except for the minivan) as it is the only way I know it is done right. I do have a lot of faith and trust in the independent shop where I get most of my major repair and maintenance work done, but I know the only person I can count on to be absolutely, 100% committed to doing the work properly is myself. Also, it gives you a better understanding of your car and actually makes you feel closer to it! 🎉

Cheers! M2
Yarrris-WenchTexas · Dec 29, 2009#80
Originally Posted by behour ↑
I have no experience with vehicles. My yaris is the first new car I bought. I sadly feel often screwed. I went to get an oil change today and was charged 86.44 for it.
yes i feel your pain. I got my first oil change done @ the place i bought the car from & it was about the same about if not about 10 short of that. 😳 I can tell you one thing I'm never doing that again. lol I think i might try & learn to do it myself. 🆘
junorico24Sydney · Dec 30, 2009#81
U could have done it yourself..nothin to it. the hardest part is getting the yaris on the ramp.That's it, once it's up and secured (safety reason) all you need is spanner and oil pan.
Trompi-XP9Germany NRW · Dec 30, 2009#82
In germany i pay 90$ for oil change (171,45€)
MadMaxSan Antonio, Texas! · Dec 30, 2009#83
AutoZone has a special going right now, last night I picked up 5 liters (5.28 quarts) of Mobile 1 "Full Synthetic" 5W30 and a M1-130 filter for $29.99 + tax. That is usually the price of the oil alone. There were no signs to indicate this, but I did see it later in their current circular. This deal runs through 13 January 2010. 🎉

Cheers! M2
CKaelinBoxborough, MA · Dec 30, 2009#84
My local mechanic (non-dealer) $40 oil/filter and tire rotation. Non Synthetic. Maintenance Light just came on as I hit 24,500 miles last night on my 08. Have had this service every 5000 miles. =) Once I took it to the dealer and the charged my $65. Never again.
b_hickman11Tyler, TX · Dec 30, 2009#85
Originally Posted by jambo101 ↑
What kind of oil and filter are you using that can be had for less than $10 in total😕

I use Mobil Clean 5000 which is $11 for 5 qts but I only use 3.8 qts. And I use a Supertech filter which is only about $2.50. So thats about $10 per change.
Saskatchewan17Aurora, IL · Dec 30, 2009#86
You got screwed big time buddy... sorry to hear man. You shouldn't be charged that much for even a synthetic change.
ZaphodSomewhere in the vacinity of Betelgeuse · Dec 31, 2009#87
I didn't have to use a ramp or jacks when I did my oil change.

It is low to the ground though by comparison to other cars I've owned, but still at the stock height it's not bad at all.
RUFFSTUFFKINGSLAND, GA · Dec 31, 2009#88
Originally Posted by Zaphod ↑
I didn't have to use a ramp or jacks when I did my oil change.

It is low to the ground though by comparison to other cars I've owned, but still at the stock height it's not bad at all.

Plenty of room...
libraryelfHilo, HI · Dec 31, 2009#89
I just paid $64 for my 08 third oil changed. I went to the local EZ Lupe. I think you were way over charged for the oil change. Did they do more than just change the oil?
RUFFSTUFFKINGSLAND, GA · Dec 31, 2009#90
Originally Posted by libraryelf ↑
I just paid $64 for my 08 third oil changed. I went to the local EZ Lupe. I think you were way over charged for the oil change. Did they do more than just change the oil?

$64 is still too much.
TheSilkySmoothNew Hampshire · Jan 4, 2010#91
Isnt mobil1 just 22 bucks for 5qt jug? How is 29 bucks at autozone a deal? Thats just average pricing - no deal?
toyotaOC, CA · Jan 4, 2010#92
yeah i really believe that got ripped off
very badly and as far as them putting
synthetic oil, its kinda of rare for them to
put it on unless you ask for it. I actually
spoke to one of the technicians and
he told me that once you have started
with synthetic you shouldn't go back to
regular and vice versa. He also said that
Toyota made their cars to work with the
regular oil and that is the default oil that
they use when people bring in their
Toyotas for an oil change.

Even though your car is new, just stick
to regular oil. Toyota makes them so
that they work with the regular oil, plus
synthetic will cost more. That really
sucks that it really happened. Try to
learn and do it yourself, look on video
sites such as youtube or have a friend
teach you and you can start saving a
lot of money and putting the rest of your
money on something that is really worth
paying for.

-Sam
RUFFSTUFFKINGSLAND, GA · Jan 4, 2010#93
Originally Posted by TheSilkySmooth ↑
Isnt mobil1 just 22 bucks for 5qt jug? How is 29 bucks at autozone a deal? Thats just average pricing - no deal?


Yep, $22 at Walmart...
MadMaxSan Antonio, Texas! · Jan 4, 2010#94
Not the same thing. The jug at Walmart is a 5 quart one, the one at Autozone is 5 liters. Throw in the free Mobile 1 oil filter (which Walmart doesn't even carry, just that Fram shit) and you come out ahead...
RUFFSTUFFKINGSLAND, GA · Jan 4, 2010#95
The difference between 5 quarts and 5 liters is 9 ounces. Neither is enough for 2 oil changes, so if you kept it you would still have to buy additional oil for the time when you do the second change or a change on another vehicle... How much does that M1-130 filter cost by itself?