Yarisworld Archive

The great intake debate!

75 posts · 37,260 views · page 2 of 2

Replies continued

camelllHome · Oct 6, 2009#51
Originally Posted by fmicle ↑
Alright, here they come:

California has special requirements for gasoline, which makes it more expensive because of less availability. We also use different blends for winter vs. summer. That's what I was referring to when I said "grade". Never thought or meant octane, you did.

http://www.physics.uci.edu/~silverma/gasoline.html

Here is the article on cold air intakes on Wikipedia (I really don't know what will convince you because you seem so arrogant as to believe that you and only you know the truth). The first sentence is:

Standard air intake systems tend to be very restrictive, in order to eliminate engine noise.

The whole article: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cold_air_intake

I remember seeing a video interview with an engineering expert, when I was shopping for my intake and he was saying the same thing. That's the main reason, noise. I did not come up with this in my dreams. Unfortunately, I can't find the link to the video right now, but I will eventually and will post it here, so you can be enlightened as well.
The problem with your wikipedia cold air intake is that it says this right at the top.

" This article or section has multiple issues. Please help improve the article or discuss these issues on the talk page.

* It does not cite any references or sources. Please help improve it by citing reliable sources. Tagged since July 2008.
* It may contain original research or unverifiable claims. Tagged since July 2008.
* It may require general cleanup to meet Wikipedia's quality standards. Tagged since July 2008.

Originally Posted by cali yaris ↑
@ camelll:

You said: It WON'T pass.

I said: They do pass.

You are incorrect that "it won't pass". That is not a factual statement.

You can say "it won't legally pass", which I would agree with. But you didn't.

done.
It technically won't pass, because someone does not feel like doing their job does not mean it is okay.

Originally Posted by Tamago ↑
explain how an intake can reduce or increase emissions please.

Originally Posted by fmicle ↑
Well see that's camell's point, I never said a CAI had anything to do with emissions. I said the stock intake's main purpose the way it is (different from a CAI) is to reduce noise.

So I believe you and I are on the same page here. But camell keeps stating that it's the emissions, which I disagree with.
Originally Posted by Tamago ↑
noise is an emission

but from the aspect of "air quality" emissions, i have no idea how an intake would cause your car to blow out more "bad" gasses. now, if you're bypassing your PCV setup with your intake (dumping oily air into the environment) that could affect emissions, but it would not be measurable at the tail pipe with a sniffer.
Originally Posted by fmicle ↑
Amen! 👏

That's what I think, too, it's the air/fuel ratio, the gasoline itself and the catalytic converter which determines what comes out the exhaust, not the air intake.
More oxygen= more gas, more gas= more emissions. Your cats will do their job but you are still producing more emissions. Your air/fuel ratio is determined by how much air you put in from the intake. The maf makes adjustments as needed. When you have a lean condition, which you get by adding more oxygen, your maf tells the ecu to dump more fuel which in turn does so which raises emissions. Your cats are gonna remove noxious emissions but you are still putting more into your cats.
Originally Posted by fmicle ↑
Camelll, here is more technical info, from www.autoanything.com:

Automakers design your vehicle's intake tube to be the quietest possible unit that can fit in your engine compartment.

The complete link for your reading pleasure: http://www.autoanything.com/air-intakes/50A5A115A1.aspx
Of course someone who is selling you something is gonna say it is okay, if they did otherwise it would have a negative impact on their sales. If the air intake does not affect emissions why do they even bother with it for carb?

Originally Posted by tk-421 ↑
Moved previously OT posts to this thread. Have fun fellas.

For the record, I'm 100% sure I can pass emissions with my Simota CF box filter. 👍
Thanks TK, It probably pass but not if you follow the rules.
Originally Posted by HTM Yaris ↑
I say the primary function is shared .

In a cold air system there isn't any "box" or baffles to help muffle or deflect (maybe redirect is the proper term) the sound waves coming from the engine . Actually the exhaust and intake work almost identically , with the exception of the temps and flow direction . Take off your muffler and what happens ..... That's right... it gets louder . Same with the intake box . CAI are designed to increase flow . Sure your filter may be away from the engine or even shielded from the engine , but the actual intake tube is still being heated by means of convection (air flowing through radiator ) and conduction ( you know , those explosions that are generated in the cylinders ) not to mention friction . A true CAI would address all heat issues . A refrigerated wrap around ( the intake tube ) blanket comes to mind .

As for emissions , that's easy . Add more air (CAI) and the ecu will compensate by adding more fuel . Which in turn means more pollution . A turbocharger or supercharger is a perfect (extreme) example of this . Yes I understand that a Turbo or SC forces air into the engine , but my point is more air = more exhaust . Keep in mind , any engine , is nothing but an air pump with accessories attached .
+1 someone who knows.

If you removed your cats and did a sniff test with the stock box and then removed the stock box and put a cai on your emissions will be higher. The debate is not about if your catalytic converters do their jobs it is if the air intake will affect emissions.
camelllHome · Oct 6, 2009#52
Originally Posted by fmicle ↑
But you don't need a CAI for that, just press the gas pedal harder and you'll get more air into the engine 🙂 So what's the difference in the end? 🙂
Your getting more warm air into the engine with the stock box, you are getting more cold air with a cai, cold air is denser than warm air.
fmicleThread starterSan Jose, CA, USA · Oct 6, 2009#53
So, I shouldn't believe Wikipedia, I shouldn't believe AEM, I shouldn't believe autoanything.com, but I should believe YOU, because YOU put my best interest at heart, while everyone else is just trying to trick me into buying their product.

Sure...
camelllHome · Oct 6, 2009#54
No you believe what you want. That wiki entry is not reliable because: "It does not cite any references or sources. Please help improve it by citing reliable sources. Tagged since July 2008.
It may contain original research or unverifiable claims. Tagged since July 2008."

No one has been able to verify the claims and if it has no references to back up its claims then it is a moot point.

People that are selling you products are out to make money, not to give you the best advice possible. Again if a cai did not affect emissions then why would carb bother with it? You can believe what you want I have no benefit from telling you this. An easy way to prove this about a company is to dyno your car with your stock box on and then put the cai on and dyno it again. You are not going to get 5 hp from your intake. Do you have a cai or a sri?
fmicleThread starterSan Jose, CA, USA · Oct 6, 2009#55
Originally Posted by camelll ↑
Your getting more warm air into the engine with the stock box, you are getting more cold air with a cai, cold air is denser than warm air.
And how does that make the exhaust gas more polluting? You still haven't explained that!

More air means more exhaust. Duh, of course!!! So does more driving. I still don't see the point.

If, say, 20% of the exhaust are emissions, if you put more air in, you'll get more exhaust, but still, only 20% of that will be emissions. So how is that worse?

Smog measures the percentage of pollutants in the exhaust gas and so far nobody has shown that more air in the engine increases the percentage of pollutants. You've only said that more air in equals more exhaust, to which I say: DUH!
HTM Yarissouth Carolina · Oct 6, 2009#56
Other than increased pollution , none .

Excuse me , I got this dumb ass deer in my yard . I got to eliminate him from the gene pool . Besides...... I'm hungry ........ Can you say "Smoked Tenderloin" . See Ya after dinner .................
fmicleThread starterSan Jose, CA, USA · Oct 6, 2009#57
Originally Posted by HTM Yaris ↑
Other than increased pollution , none .

Excuse me , I got this dumb ass deer in my yard . I got to eliminate him from the gene pool . Besides...... I'm hungry ........ Can you say "Smoked Tenderloin" . See Ya after dinner .................
I see a lot of increased pollution too: the gun powder used to eliminate the deer, unless you're using a bow and arrow 😉 and then there is the smoked tenderloin, which speaks pollution with a capital P 😉

Some pictures would be nice 🙂
camelllHome · Oct 6, 2009#58
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Combustion. Yes this needs additional citations for verification, but it has sources and does not have any unverifiable claims. If you don't think that adding and burning more fuel does not cause more emissions then I don't know what to tell you.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Exhaust_gas
"Although the largest part of most combustion gases is relatively harmless nitrogen (N2), water vapor (H2O) (except with pure-carbon fuels), and carbon dioxide (CO2) (except with hydrogen as fuel), a relatively small part of it is undesirable noxious or toxic substances, such as carbon monoxide (CO), hydrocarbons, nitrogen oxides (NOx), partly unburnt fuel, and particulate matter."
camelllHome · Oct 6, 2009#59
Originally Posted by fmicle ↑
And how does that make the exhaust gas more polluting? You still haven't explained that!

More air means more exhaust. Duh, of course!!! So does more driving. I still don't see the point.

If, say, 20% of the exhaust are emissions, if you put more air in, you'll get more exhaust, but still, only 20% of that will be emissions. So how is that worse?

Smog measures the percentage of pollutants in the exhaust gas and so far nobody has shown that more air in the engine increases the percentage of pollutants. You've only said that more air in equals more exhaust, to which I say: DUH!
You are saying it yourself, that the air intake can affect emissions. What more can I say.
fmicleThread starterSan Jose, CA, USA · Oct 6, 2009#60
Originally Posted by camelll ↑
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Combustion. Yes this needs additional citations for verification, but it has sources and does not have any unverifiable claims. If you don't think that adding and burning more fuel does not cause more emissions then I don't know what to tell you.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Exhaust_gas
"Although the largest part of most combustion gases is relatively harmless nitrogen (N2), water vapor (H2O) (except with pure-carbon fuels), and carbon dioxide (CO2) (except with hydrogen as fuel), a relatively small part of it is undesirable noxious or toxic substances, such as carbon monoxide (CO), hydrocarbons, nitrogen oxides (NOx), partly unburnt fuel, and particulate matter."
Do you understand the concepts of "absolute" and "relative"?

20% of 100 is the same as 20% of 1,000,000 in "relative" terms. THE SAME. That's how smog is measured in percentage!!!

Yes, I am putting out more exhaust, but it doesn't have a higher percentage of pollutants, it's the same percentage!

A CAI is causing more emissions the same way driving more causes more emissions. Someone driving 100 miles will cause double the pollution of someone driving 50 miles. Simple enough for you? According to your logic the first guy should not pass the smog 🙂
fmicleThread starterSan Jose, CA, USA · Oct 6, 2009#61
Originally Posted by camelll ↑
You are saying it yourself, that the air intake can affect emissions. What more can I say.
How old are you?
mikenacaratoBrentwood, TN · Oct 6, 2009#62
this thread is fail.

cant we all just say that it depends on where you live as to wether you will pass or not. from what it seems we all have had different experiences.
fmicleThread starterSan Jose, CA, USA · Oct 6, 2009#63
Originally Posted by mikenacarato ↑
this thread is fail.
Sadly, I agree.

Originally Posted by mikenacarato ↑
cant we all just say that it depends on where you live as to wether you will pass or not. from what it seems we all have had different experiences.
That's not what we're debating. The issue here is whether the main purpose of the restrictive stock intake is to reduce noise or to improve emissions.
camelllHome · Oct 6, 2009#64
Originally Posted by fmicle ↑
Do you understand the concepts of "absolute" and "relative"?

20% of 100 is the same as 20% of 1,000,000 in "relative" terms. THE SAME. That's how smog is measured in percentage!!!

Yes, I am putting out more exhaust, but it doesn't have a higher percentage of pollutants, it's the same percentage!

A CAI is causing more emissions the same way driving more causes more emissions. Someone driving 100 miles will cause double the pollution of someone driving 50 miles. Simple enough for you? According to your logic the first guy should not pass the smog 🙂
To say that 20 percent of 100 is the same as 20 percent of a million is silly, 20 pph is different than 20 ppm. You will not pass if you are putting out 20 pph but you may pass with 20 ppm. I don't live in California and cannot tell you how they do smog test. What is the baseline and what percentage do you need to pass? To say that burning more fuel does not equate to more emissions or noxious gas is silly.
Originally Posted by fmicle ↑
How old are you?
HA HA enough to know that burning more fuel makes more emissions.
HTM Yarissouth Carolina · Oct 6, 2009#65
20 % of 3.0 liters (.6) ( or whatever they measure air in ) is greater than 20 % of 1.5 liters (.3) . I'm not sure ( We don't have smog test here in South Carolina ) , but I would guess that the percentage would based in part by the number of cylinders . I mean that is the whole idea behind CAFE , which starts next year ...I think . A 4 and 8 cylinder may have the same percentage , but the actual number value won't be the same .
camelllHome · Oct 6, 2009#66
Originally Posted by mikenacarato ↑
this thread is fail.

cant we all just say that it depends on where you live as to wether you will pass or not. from what it seems we all have had different experiences.
Why would you even post or read if you feel that way. This thread is about intake and emissions, not if it will pass or fail. Unsubscribe if you don't want to read it.
camelllHome · Oct 6, 2009#67
Originally Posted by fmicle ↑
Sadly, I agree.
Why are you participating then?
mikenacaratoBrentwood, TN · Oct 6, 2009#68
camelll must be supmets brother...

well here is my two cents...did you know a cold air intake causes the air to be more dense and combust better...IE more fuel is burned off and less emissions are created. Ill say it one more time so you understand... the more complete the burn..the less emissions you will have. CAIs help this process.

this brings me to my next point...how come they are called airbox silencers? because their primary function is to reduce cabin noise.
fmicleThread starterSan Jose, CA, USA · Oct 6, 2009#69
I feel like giving up. If you don't understand that 20% is the same as 20% I can't debate you anymore.

20% of 1,000,000 = 200,000 and not 20 ppm. I have a math degree and your statements make me shake my head in disbelief.

The smog checks percentage of pollutants in exhaust, so unless the percentage changes, the smog results are the same, no matter how much are you're pushing through the engine.

To make it easy for you to understand: about 20% of air is oxygen, alright? Whether it's a room full of air or a small bag, it's still 20%. Just because a room has more air it doesn't mean the air is cleaner than in a smaller space!

Here is how the smog check is done - I honestly don't understand how you can even argue with me when you don't know how the smog test is done. You're telling me I am wrong and at the same time you say you don't know how the smog is done! How ridiculous is that?

3. Emissions Test:
So what exactly is the sniffer measuring?

HCs are essentially unburned fuel. When you hear about octane it's often a reference to the anti-knock index at the pump (87 etc) but it is also a reference to the chemical composition of fuel, part of which is made from C8H18 (eight carbon atoms and 18 hydrogen atoms; hence octane). HC is measured in parts per million (ppm) by the sniffer.

When fuel (HC) and air (O2 + N2) are combusted the ideal product would be energy and water vapor (H20). Because the combustion process is imperfect, CO is one of the byproducts produced. CO is measured as a percentage of the exhaust gas. It is a colorless odorless gas and if you breath it, it will combine with the hemoglobin in your blood and make you sick or kill you in larger doses. Running your engine in the garage is a great way to pass out and possibly die.

CO is also used as an indicator of fuel mixture ratio. An ideal percentage of excess CO would be zero. In practice the %CO measured is a few percentage points: a fuel ratio the VW engine can burn efficiently in all climates, temperatures and conditions. For example, 1-2% would be a relatively lean fuel ratio for a VW especially fuel injected models; 10% very rich (so much so that you can smell the unburned fuel from the exhaust pipe).

NOx is produced when combustion chamber temperatures are high. It was once viewed as the #1 enemy and responsible for the smog in the LA basin. At that time emission reducing devices were geared towards reducing it at the expense of other emissions. That was 20 years ago and since then scientists have come to understand that all the emissions are destructive especially CO2 (a harmful greenhouse gas).

Unfortunately on a VW there is no simple way to minimize all three emissions at once like a modern car is able to do. Lower the HC and CO by leaning out the engine and you produce too much NOx and vice versa. Plus, the catalytic converter (which few models are equipped with) can only do its job at the near perfect fuel ratio (theoretically ideal) which isn't the best ratio for long life of an air-cooled engine.
fmicleThread starterSan Jose, CA, USA · Oct 6, 2009#70
Originally Posted by camelll ↑
Why are you participating then?
Not much longer, this is hopeless, because you don't know what you're talking about, you just like to argue.
TamagoOff Grid · Oct 6, 2009#71
i'm not gonna waste time quoting but the "more air = more emissions" comment cracks me up. yes, you are physically moving more air in and out of your engine using a less-restrictive intake, but in what way does that make it "bad" emissions? more emissions generally means more BAD air, not just more air in general. if this were the case then a V8 would automatically not pass the sniff test simply because it moves more "emissions" (lol) at idle than a yaris.

🙄 🙄


i'm officially leaving this thread. people are trying to be too smart for their own good. yet another fine example of overthinking the pointless debate.
fmicleThread starterSan Jose, CA, USA · Oct 6, 2009#72
+1
camelllHome · Oct 6, 2009#73
Bye!😆, and thanks for your comments.
camelllHome · Oct 6, 2009#74
Originally Posted by mikenacarato ↑
camelll must be supmets brother...

well here is my two cents...did you know a cold air intake causes the air to be more dense and combust better...IE more fuel is burned off and less emissions are created. Ill say it one more time so you understand... the more complete the burn..the less emissions you will have. CAIs help this process.

this brings me to my next point...how come they are called airbox silencers? because their primary function is to reduce cabin noise.
Well glad to see that you agree with me on the fact that a CAI will in fact change emissions. Congrats on realizing what the debate is about. Noise reduction is a secondary advantage of the stock boxes.

Originally Posted by fmicle ↑
I feel like giving up. If you don't understand that 20% is the same as 20% I can't debate you anymore.

20% of 1,000,000 = 200,000 and not 20 ppm. I have a math degree and your statements make me shake my head in disbelief.

The smog checks percentage of pollutants in exhaust, so unless the percentage changes, the smog results are the same, no matter how much are you're pushing through the engine.

To make it easy for you to understand: about 20% of air is oxygen, alright? Whether it's a room full of air or a small bag, it's still 20%. Just because a room has more air it doesn't mean the air is cleaner than in a smaller space!
I understand that 20 percent is 20 percent, I used the pph and ppm as an example not as a fact that 20 percent of 1,000,000 is so many ppm. There is a a lot less air to go around in the smaller space, you may still have the same composition, but it takes a lot less to change the composition of the smaller space.

Originally Posted by fmicle ↑
Here is how the smog check is done - I honestly don't understand how you can even argue with me when you don't know how the smog test is done. You're telling me I am wrong and at the same time you say you don't know how the smog is done! How ridiculous is that?

3. Emissions Test:
So what exactly is the sniffer measuring?

HCs are essentially unburned fuel. When you hear about octane it's often a reference to the anti-knock index at the pump (87 etc) but it is also a reference to the chemical composition of fuel, part of which is made from C8H18 (eight carbon atoms and 18 hydrogen atoms; hence octane). HC is measured in parts per million (ppm) by the sniffer.

When fuel (HC) and air (O2 + N2) are combusted the ideal product would be energy and water vapor (H20). Because the combustion process is imperfect, CO is one of the byproducts produced. CO is measured as a percentage of the exhaust gas. It is a colorless odorless gas and if you breath it, it will combine with the hemoglobin in your blood and make you sick or kill you in larger doses. Running your engine in the garage is a great way to pass out and possibly die.

CO is also used as an indicator of fuel mixture ratio. An ideal percentage of excess CO would be zero. In practice the %CO measured is a few percentage points: a fuel ratio the VW engine can burn efficiently in all climates, temperatures and conditions. For example, 1-2% would be a relatively lean fuel ratio for a VW especially fuel injected models; 10% very rich (so much so that you can smell the unburned fuel from the exhaust pipe).

NOx is produced when combustion chamber temperatures are high. It was once viewed as the #1 enemy and responsible for the smog in the LA basin. At that time emission reducing devices were geared towards reducing it at the expense of other emissions. That was 20 years ago and since then scientists have come to understand that all the emissions are destructive especially CO2 (a harmful greenhouse gas).

Unfortunately on a VW there is no simple way to minimize all three emissions at once like a modern car is able to do. Lower the HC and CO by leaning out the engine and you produce too much NOx and vice versa. Plus, the catalytic converter (which few models are equipped with) can only do its job at the near perfect fuel ratio (theoretically ideal) which isn't the best ratio for long life of an air-cooled engine.

Well I assumed it was done reading part per million or parts per billion, and obviously it is if any part of of there figures are in ppm or pbm. As to how they determine what percentage is acceptable has yet to be provided. Glad you found something on a vw forum about smog testing. Post me something from the carb board that shows testing is done in percentages and not PPM or PPB. Why is your intake not carb legal? Oh because it does not do anything to emissions. You still may be able to pass smog but it certainly changes the amount, for good or bad.

Originally Posted by fmicle ↑
Not much longer, this is hopeless, because you don't know what you're talking about, you just like to argue.
You have not posted one single thing that shows otherwise that air intakes change emissions.

Originally Posted by Tamago ↑
i'm not gonna waste time quoting but the "more air = more emissions" comment cracks me up. yes, you are physically moving more air in and out of your engine using a less-restrictive intake, but in what way does that make it "bad" emissions? more emissions generally means more BAD air, not just more air in general. if this were the case then a V8 would automatically not pass the sniff test simply because it moves more "emissions" (lol) at idle than a yaris.

🙄 🙄


i'm officially leaving this thread. people are trying to be too smart for their own good. yet another fine example of overthinking the pointless debate.
Typical tamago post, this kind of reminds me of the crank pulley. Show me something that can prove otherwise. Your v8 analogy is not accurate either because of intake design, catalytic converters and other emissions components. A 5.0 liter emissions control system is designed for a 5.0 liter, just as a 1.5 is designed for a 1.5.
Originally Posted by fmicle ↑
+1
AGAIN, IF A CAI DOES NOT CHANGE EMISSIONS OR FUEL ECONOMY WHY DOES CARB EVEN DEAL WITH IT? WHY WOULD THEY WANT THE HEADACHE? WHY WOULD TOYOTA NOT MAKE A CAI STOCK? PLEASE DON'T SAY BECAUSE OF COST, I AM PRETTY SURE THEY COULD MAKE CAI'S JUST AS CHEAP. WHY DO MANUFACTURERS OF MOST SRI'S AND CAI'S STATE THEY ARE FOR OFF ROAD USE ONLY? PLEASE ANSWER THESE QUESTIONS.
camelllHome · Oct 6, 2009#75
I have a CAI, thank you very much.