Yarisworld Archive

VOTE! (Turbo vs. S/C)

95 posts · 23,088 views · page 2 of 2

Replies continued

ozmddDFW, TX · Oct 12, 2009#51
Originally Posted by JCS_IMPORT_25 ↑
Lets have a vote.
which is best.

Supercharged Yaris
Turboed Yaris

🎉👍🤣👏🤘:eyebulg e:🤮😈🍻🙌:wink :😳😕🙁😁😠🙂:t ongue:🤷😎😲🤤
I'm sorry, but where is choice #3: "Turbo" badge w/ interfooler??
hatchbackkid82. · Oct 14, 2009#52
I don't think a 175whp Yaris could take an EVO, I love my car but i know when it's out gunned. He would get you off the launch, even if your running slicks

Originally Posted by scape ↑
a 175 hp yaris would practically beat out a lancer evo... i'd say that's a great turbo option haha
why?harnett county NC · Oct 14, 2009#53
This has been a fun thread to read. I vote turbo because there is nothing like a turbo kicking on and that torque steer snapping your car 4 feet sideways. That was one of the absolute most fun feelings I've ever had driving.

Saying that I think I'd invest in figuring out how to make my Yaris AWD before adding a turbo. Then when I had the power I could use it well.
RacerFreakXXXSomers NY · Oct 17, 2009#54
IMO the only good awd car for racing is a rwd/awd setup like the evo or gtr. FWD is not bad, especialy on light weight hatches.

I have grown to love both turbo and supercharger. They both have their ups and downs and are better suited for different applications. I have decided supercharger for my situation unless a inexpensive small bolt on turbo kit was available but that may never happen.
The SpectacleTampa, FL · Oct 18, 2009#55
I didn't read the whole thread but I'll throw some comments out there:

The only thing I see holding the Yaris back from making good, reliable power is the lack of a real engine management system. Piggybacks like the Emanage aren't the best solution because they just trick the ECU into seeing conditons that don't really exist, which limits the capability of the solution. If AEM or another company made a standalone EMS for the Yaris like they do for the TC, the possibilities would be a lot greater.

With that said, with the availability of engine management on the market right now, I'd go with a SC. They're very linear and predictable and therefor easier to tune. Turbo's are a different animal and take a lot more care on the tuning side to get dialed in right to make the vehicle have stock drive ability like characteristics.
jt258HOUSTON · Oct 19, 2009#56
EVO IS FRONT WHEEL DRIVE BASED AWD. THE GTR IS RWD BASED AWD.
cali yarisCanoga Park, CA · Oct 19, 2009#57
48 - 11
PETERPOOPOahu · Oct 19, 2009#58
Doesn't this inspire you to get a MI turbo kit for us? :)
mikebdubsubyOntario, CA · Oct 19, 2009#59
I personally prefer turbo, I've driven in supercharged cars and turbo cars, my DD is a WRX swapped Impreza RS and I just feel like a turbo is more power efficient.

I'm new to the Yaris, me and my gf just bought ours like 2 weeks ago, but from what I've read there's more options for supercharging over turbocharging for this platform.

I also agree with the earlier posts about buying a faster car, a Yaris makes what like 120 hp? Not a really great starting point for a build. It's a nice, clean, economy car, I'd just keep it that way. Well that's my newb forced induction Yaris opinion. Maybe as I learn more it'll change.
CaysEUSA · Oct 19, 2009#60
Turbo is always better in terms of power.

But if we're voting for better in general, I'd say a supercharger is just plain easier to deal with.
PETERPOOPOahu · Oct 19, 2009#61
Originally Posted by mikebdubsuby ↑
a Yaris makes what like 120 hp?.
More like 85 whp, stock.
mikebdubsubyOntario, CA · Oct 19, 2009#62
I meant like to the crank, so I guess I was pretty close. I don't see why you would wanna drop that much $ on something with that baseline. A swap or a different seems like a better investment. It's just like when people mod a non vtec d series. Seems pointless when you can do a head swap or a b series swap for around the same cost.
CaysEUSA · Oct 19, 2009#63
A swap to a better engine is always good, but it's like all those non-VTEC D series cars: sometimes it's good just to see what you can do with what you have. There's always something faster out there. :)
mikebdubsubyOntario, CA · Oct 19, 2009#64
Yeah I can appreciate that. When I bought my car (04 Subaru Impreza RS) I really wanted to build the N/A 2.5, but then I learned about cars lol. So building an engine with an open deck block didn't seem worth it when I couldn't make very much reliable hp. I swapped in my WRX motor and I feel like that was the better way to go.
Blown_xaVirginia · Oct 19, 2009#65
Originally Posted by mikebdubsuby ↑
I meant like to the crank, so I guess I was pretty close. I don't see why you would wanna drop that much $ on something with that baseline. A swap or a different seems like a better investment. It's just like when people mod a non vtec d series. Seems pointless when you can do a head swap or a b series swap for around the same cost.
the point is, it's more satifying to make a slower car fast. And it's harder. Anybody with the funds can go to the dealership and buy a fast car, and do well in motorsports event with minor work... but where is the blood and sweat in that? There are so many fast Evos and s2000's and STI's and Mazdas speeds... it's not uncommon. What is great is passing those guys on the track. And it can be done. Nobody remembers that "fast Evo" at track day, because there were 5. People remember the Yaris or xA that passed that evo though.
frownonfunRGV, Texas · Oct 20, 2009#66
to buy a car and swap the engine with a different car makes no sense to me. why didn't you just buy the car with the engine you swapped to in the first place?
CaysEUSA · Oct 20, 2009#67
An engine is just a bunch of parts; it's like swapping any other part of the car. One could argue, "why modify a car at all?" You know the answer to that: you're on an enthusiast forum, after all. Most people here are modifying their cars.

Anyway, to answer your question more directly: it saves money. You can transfer a stronger engine that was never available for your model car. For example: say I like my 1992 Camaro but want to be as fast as modern Corvettes. I'm not going to spend $60k just to buy the Vette; I'm going to spend $6k to swap in an LSX motor.
mikebdubsubyOntario, CA · Oct 20, 2009#68
Originally Posted by frownonfun ↑
to buy a car and swap the engine with a different car makes no sense to me. why didn't you just buy the car with the engine you swapped to in the first place?

Because I didn't know how significant the difference in holding boost was between a closed deck and open deck block. And once I bought the car and wanted to turbo it and did research and found out that my engine wouldn't hold, swapping seemed like a better option than selling my car and taking a loss. Swapping isn't a big deal. It was a weekend project. It was simple. I'm able to retain my complete stock drivetrain. All that was really involved was pulling one motor, swapping out the fuel pump for a higher flowing one, and then swapping the crossmember, drop the other motor in and you're done. With that mentality, why do anything to your car instead of buying a car that was modded by the previous owner? Because we're car enthusiasts.
RacerFreakXXXSomers NY · Oct 20, 2009#69
the only upside to swapping in a wrx motor on a rs is saving on insurance costs, rofl. I would have gone sti motor swap if you are gonna go that far though. On the yaris you are better off building the engine because weight is the key factor in the car.

Again as it will for a while, once a good tuning option comes along for the yaris there will be more turbo options. For right now a supercharger on an un-tuned yaris seems safer than a turbo yaris in a lot of people's minds. If only we had something like k-pro for our toyota's. I feel like people have forgotten a lot about them in the tuning industry (not that toyota puts out a sports car any more cough cough).
frownonfunRGV, Texas · Oct 20, 2009#70
Originally Posted by mikebdubsuby ↑
With that mentality, why do anything to your car instead of buying a car that was modded by the previous owner? Because we're car enthusiasts.
which was kind of my point. i see posts all too often (like yours) questioning why people make performance modifications to a car like the yaris. i just don't get it. what does it matter to anyone else what one does to THEIR car? some people swap out perfectly good engines and others mod econoboxes. either way what's the problem?

and besides the poll doesn't ask hey do you think people should mod their yaris to make it faster.

not picking on you personally but i just wish people would stop popping into threads talking about how it doesn't make sense to mod the yaris. why does it have to make sense?
Blown_xaVirginia · Oct 20, 2009#71
Originally Posted by mikebdubsuby ↑
Yeah I can appreciate that. When I bought my car (04 Subaru Impreza RS) I really wanted to build the N/A 2.5, but then I learned about cars lol. So building an engine with an open deck block didn't seem worth it when I couldn't make very much reliable hp. I swapped in my WRX motor and I feel like that was the better way to go.
You can make a lot of reliable power with an open deck motor. I guess you have a high number in mind to be conserned about open vs closed deck design. Of coarse Im refering to Toyota power plants, maybe with Subaru motors they are not strong blocks.
RacerFreakXXXSomers NY · Oct 21, 2009#72
Picture not included in this copy

Sorry I just had to 🙄
CaysEUSA · Oct 21, 2009#73
Clearly.
advocatelocation · Oct 21, 2009#74
Image dimensions: 3871px × 3248px
mikebdubsubyOntario, CA · Oct 21, 2009#75
Originally Posted by Blown_xa ↑
You can make a lot of reliable power with an open deck motor. I guess you have a high number in mind to be conserned about open vs closed deck design. Of coarse Im refering to Toyota power plants, maybe with Subaru motors they are not strong blocks.
I'm not looking to make my dd into a race car, but my target goal is around 350whp which will be pretty doable with my current engine. My stock motor with 165 to the crank just wasn't gonna put down the kinda of power I wanted and be reliable at the same time. I could've supercharged that motor or turbo'd it, but stock it already had 10:1 compression, it was SOHC, it just wasn't a good starting point. Not for what my car weighs anyway. Now I have .5 liters less displacement, but DOHC, and a closed deck block. There's just more options for me now. With a turbo upgrade, injectors, exhaust, and a bit of open source tuning I should be able to squeeze out a lot of power for not much $.
window_leeCanada · Oct 30, 2009#76
Originally Posted by RacerFreakXXX ↑
you have to look at it like this:

blitz supercharger $3400 + intake $200 + injectors $100 + pulleys $250 + header $200 + ems $500 = $4650.00

xb hks turbo kit $2600 + intercooler $500 + piping $700 + injectors $150 + hks bov $300 + hks boost controller/ turbo timer $400 = $4650.00

In the end the price is basically the same, even with the supporting mods and gauges you need plan to spend about 6-7k to have it done right.
what about the labour??? supercharger is much easier to install
chongopantsHouston · Oct 30, 2009#77
I have been looking into this and the turbo will perform better, but its simply much more of a pain in the arse to get working without damaging the vehicle in the long run. I would go S/C if I just had the cash to blow, but I can build up my turbo a lot cheaper, and it will have more HP, so again I am torn...
The SpectacleTampa, FL · Nov 2, 2009#78
Originally Posted by frownonfun ↑
not picking on you personally but i just wish people would stop popping into threads talking about how it doesn't make sense to mod the yaris. why does it have to make sense?

It does have to make sense to those of us who value money and not throw it in the toilet because of a 100hp car. Modding this car for power is just plain...ugh I'll reserve my comments to avoid hurting someones feelings.
thebarberGrand Rapids, MI · Nov 2, 2009#79
i voted turbo, but id rock either

but i have a greddy s/c coming cus i got it used on the cheap and its easier and less invasive to install than a turbo kit. though itll never make as much power as a turbo can.
PETERPOOPOahu · Nov 2, 2009#80
Originally Posted by The Spectacle ↑
It does have to make sense to those of us who value money and not throw it in the toilet because of a 100hp car. Modding this car for power is just plain...ugh I'll reserve my comments to avoid hurting someones feelings.
Why'd you spend money on a stainless steel exhaust setup for the yaris? 🤷 Help it "breathe" better?
thebarberGrand Rapids, MI · Nov 2, 2009#81
Originally Posted by PETERPOOP ↑
Why'd you spend money on a stainless steel exhaust setup for the yaris? 🤷 Help it "breathe" better?
Picture not included in this copy
frownonfunRGV, Texas · Nov 2, 2009#82
Originally Posted by The Spectacle ↑
It does have to make sense to those of us who value money and not throw it in the toilet because of a 100hp car. Modding this car for power is just plain...ugh I'll reserve my comments to avoid hurting someones feelings.
plain what? i have modded mine and now i like it more than i did when i first bought it. doesn't seem like much of a waste of money to me. if modding this car as a hobby is really so stupid please let me know what are spectacle approved hobbies and maybe i'll take one of those up. til then i'll continue to spend a portion of my hard earned dollar on my yaris. because frankly i enjoy it.
N3misiSSouth Africa · Nov 3, 2009#83
Turbo, Hands down,
cali yarisCanoga Park, CA · Nov 3, 2009#84
yeah that is pretty far off. Why put an intake on one and not the other?
Here it is again (using your number for the HKS stuff, I have no clue where those came from):

blitz supercharger $3400 + + injectors $100 + crank pulley (the only one that matters) $110 = $3610.00. No tuning or management required.

xb hks turbo kit $2600 + intercooler $500 + piping $700 + injectors $150 + hks bov $300 + hks boost controller/ turbo timer $400+ EMS (Greddy or FIC) $400 + TUNING $500 = $5550.00

Plus, the second option requires access to a shop with a dyno and a competent tuner.
cali yarisCanoga Park, CA · Nov 3, 2009#85
It does have to make sense to those of us who value money and not throw it in the toilet because of a 100hp car. Modding this car for power is just plain...ugh I'll reserve my comments to avoid hurting someones feelings.
Will someone just ban this goof? What part of "to each his own" don't you get, man? I respect your choices, but you clearly don't respect mine with statements like that.

Ugh is right.
KCALB SIRAYVirginia · Nov 3, 2009#86
The Serve>>>>

Originally Posted by The Spectacle ↑
It does have to make sense to those of us who value money and not throw it in the toilet because of a 100hp car. Modding this car for power is just plain...ugh I'll reserve my comments to avoid hurting someones feelings.
The Return<<<<
Originally Posted by cali yaris ↑
Will someone just ban this goof? What part of "to each his own" don't you get, man? I respect your choices, but you clearly don't respect mine with statements like that.

Ugh is right.
Picture not included in this copy
PETERPOOPOahu · Nov 3, 2009#87
Originally Posted by KCALB SIRAY ↑
The Serve>>>>



The Return<<<<


Picture not included in this copy
The return was actually from me.

Camell and garm: haven't you guys read my responses to the racer guyearlier in this thread? he just doesn't get it.
KCALB SIRAYVirginia · Nov 3, 2009#88
wow, Pete! Did I hurt your feelings or something?
PETERPOOPOahu · Nov 3, 2009#89
I'm broken.
cali yarisCanoga Park, CA · Nov 3, 2009#90
You still do not need to buy injectors or a crank pulley for the blitz.
I just kept that in there... um, for continuity? 🙂
RacerFreakXXXSomers NY · Nov 3, 2009#91
lol... love it, NO you don't technically need anything but the supercharger. However, those extra mods really do help.

I'm hoping to see how cheep I can build a hks turbo kit, want to keep price at $3400 w/o tune:

turbo kit $2600 + downpipe $100 + custom intercooler piping $300 + intercooler $400... my goal is just that... maybe I can find a good small intercooler for $200 and throw in injectors for $3400. Luckily I met some people at my job that know places that will do custom piping work (in upper westechter it is hard to find these things)
lilredrocketDFW, Texas · Nov 4, 2009#92
Originally Posted by cali yaris ↑
yeah that is pretty far off. Why put an intake on one and not the other?
Here it is again (using your number for the HKS stuff, I have no clue where those came from):

blitz supercharger $3400 + + injectors $100 + crank pulley (the only one that matters) $110 = $3610.00. No tuning or management required.

xb hks turbo kit $2600 + intercooler $500 + piping $700 + injectors $150 + hks bov $300 + hks boost controller/ turbo timer $400+ EMS (Greddy or FIC) $400 + TUNING $500 = $5550.00

Plus, the second option requires access to a shop with a dyno and a competent tuner.
The HKS kit for the xB comes with a F-con mini.... Not sure how well that would work with the Yaris ECU
RacerFreakXXXSomers NY · Nov 4, 2009#93
I don't think anyone really does. I'm not going to be running more than 7 or 8psi so tuning will come later.. My main concern is the downpipe... but that's not till next summer, gonna buy a diff and a clutch first (supporting mods that should be done)
cali yarisCanoga Park, CA · Nov 4, 2009#94
downpipe wouldn't be that hard to make if someone knew what they were doing. It's really just a pipe with a couple of bends, flanges at the ends, and a bung or two for sensors.
1.5Tampa · Feb 14, 2010#95
its hard to say "best." With superchargers you usually get lower safer numbers and being that the supercharger is belt driven you get instant boost when you step on the pedal. Superchargers have that beautiful whine, and they make great daily drivers.

Turbos make POWER! You usually get some kind of turbo lag because they are not belt driven. You can drive under boost and not lose the gas mileage as well. I love the sound of a turbo and a BOV as well.

Its hard to say but i want a turbo kit so Ill vote that lol.