Yarisworld Archive

Clutch shudder when setting off in 1st gear

76 posts · 87,036 views · page 2 of 2

Replies continued

woofDeep South · Dec 24, 2009#51
The clutch chatter in my Yaris has gotten to be a real issue. So many of you have reported it that you should take a clue: defective design! My xB1 did not have this bad of a problem.

Here's what I think:

The Yaris is geared taller than my xB so it doesn't have the same mechanical advantage when pulling the car off the line.

The Yaris fly-by-wire ECU was designed to sip as little fuel as possible. Makes it easier to kill, especially with the dead feel of the clutch and throttle.

My clutch chatter just got worse over time and my dealer will not recognize it as a problem which tells me it's an "unknown" problem. (Nothing official.)
Lucas13Fort Lauderdale · Dec 26, 2009#52
Sometimes happens to me but only when it’s cold, and if I release the clutch too quick I get the shudder in reverse is even trickier, but when the engine is warm it doesn't happen to me, I try to drive it softly while it warms up and it happens much less



I’ve driven all my life stick, this where my cars in the past and I experienced it in all of them


2007 Yaris LB (current)

2003 Nissan 350Z

2005 Scion TC

2001 Daewoo Lanos Sport

1989 Honda Accord 2 DR

1996 Renault Twingo


For the Yaris and The Scion TC I had to re adjust to the clutch. It took me like a month to feel comfortable with the clutch.

Is also good to mention that this feeling sometimes can be confused with a flywheel that needs must be resurfaced or replaced, this can happen due to exesive heat when clutch is not used properly or abused.
fastscutrsocal · Jan 11, 2010#53
clutch is now starting to slip for me again after about 3k miles since last replaced under warrantee. Occasionally getting locked out of 5th (don't even feel the shift gate when that happens). Like the other time, dealer won't do anything till it gets real bad and destroys the flywheel... It is still under warranty, but no longer fits my needs as reliable transportation - think its time for a new car... (2010 Subaru WRX :D )
Can't believe I have a British car that has proven to be more reliable (powered by Toyota engine/tranny though) ;P
I wish you all the best of luck in getting a final long term solution to this problem
ddongbaphay · Jan 11, 2010#54
So I installed the TRD roll stopper mount. Shudder went away.
mick.wheelzBrisbane, Australia · Jan 19, 2010#55
My yaris has over 100,000km (~60,000mi) on it now, and does this in 1st when it is cold... only if you let it out either too fast, or dont give it enough gas.

The car is on its orig. clutch, so i doubt it causes any long term reliability issues.
yaris2010RSAngus, Ontario · Jan 21, 2010#56
i find the same problem. i have learned to master 1st but revers....fml man, i back up on my drive way (up hill) and unless i'm riding clutch hard and RPMs atleast 1500 or doing 40km in reverse it looks, feels and sounds very bad.

also with the gearing ratio i find its awkward to slow down and take off again but not stop. too fast for 1st, too slow for second...... any advice? (other then learn how to drive, lol)
DerFlosserUSA · Jan 21, 2010#57
Originally Posted by yaris2010RS ↑
..also with the gearing ratio i find its awkward to slow down and take off again but not stop. too fast for 1st, too slow for second...... any advice? (other then learn how to drive, lol)...
I definitely find this to be evident! I usually just shift into second and give gas but the car really doesn't want to go into 1st gear unless stopped.
yaris2010RSAngus, Ontario · Jan 21, 2010#58
Originally Posted by DerFlosser ↑
I definitely find this to be evident! I usually just shift into second and give gas but the car really doesn't want to go into 1st gear unless stopped.
i find it makes right turns very awkward and red lights that magically turn green a nightmare.... almost feels like its gonna stall. and today i decided to try and ride the clutch a bit.....this will not fix anything, make alot of noise then bounce. lol. guess we gonna have to live with it or change the gears.....
dennischan0919Lowell MA · Jan 26, 2010#59
TSB 0068-09 Transverse Engine Mount-Abnormal noise and Vibration on Acceleration
BuildCodeThread starterNorthern Illinois · Jan 26, 2010#60
Originally Posted by yaris2010RS ↑
i find it makes right turns very awkward and red lights that magically turn green a nightmare.... almost feels like its gonna stall. and today i decided to try and ride the clutch a bit.....this will not fix anything, make alot of noise then bounce. lol. guess we gonna have to live with it or change the gears.....
I sometimes double clutch to get into 1st gear easier... i.e. clutch out, raise RPMs 500-1000 higher than idle, clutch in and shift into 1st gear at a slow rolling speed. This is all at below 5mph speeds of course.
yaris2010RSAngus, Ontario · Jan 26, 2010#61
so u release clutch then rev a bit to get it aprox 2000RPM and then depress clutch and 1st? tomorrow on my way to school will definatly give it a shot.... lol
yaris2010RSAngus, Ontario · Jan 26, 2010#62
something i noticed on my way home today tring to glide down a hill, possibally completly off topic but still has to do with clutch. i was driving down the road at crusing speed 100 KM/H and around 2,500RPM, so i depressed the clutch shifted to neutrel (no gear) and let go of clutch. i watched my RPMs drop to 1,000 then 500(my normal idle) then jump up to 1,500 and kept bouncing from 500 - 1,500. this only happens if i'm off the clutch and in no gear, if i'm holding clutch it wont bounce around. i took a video so if u dont exactly follow what i'm saying follow link

i'm sorry, its very bad quality and uber long, lol, i started messing around after a while, lol. and since my right hand (shifter hand) was holding phone made for a very bad experience. lol

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=pEb1NY1xSXU
BuildCodeThread starterNorthern Illinois · Jan 27, 2010#63
Originally Posted by yaris2010RS ↑
so u release clutch then rev a bit to get it aprox 2000RPM and then depress clutch and 1st? tomorrow on my way to school will definatly give it a shot.... lol
Less than that: 1,000 or 1,500 rpm. You'll know it's right when you can shift into first with zero resistance :)

Originally Posted by yaris2010RS ↑
something i noticed on my way home today tring to glide down a hill, possibally completly off topic but still has to do with clutch. i was driving down the road at crusing speed 100 KM/H and around 2,500RPM, so i depressed the clutch shifted to neutrel (no gear) and let go of clutch. i watched my RPMs drop to 1,000 then 500(my normal idle) then jump up to 1,500 and kept bouncing from 500 - 1,500.
I don't put mine in neutral at that high of a speed, but from 40mph (60kmh) my revs will bob once or twice, but not as many times as yours did in the video. I don't worry about it, at all.
PHXDEMONPhoenix, AZ · Jan 27, 2010#64
This isn't a defect or an issue. It is "shuddering" because the first and revers gears don't have syncros. The yaris motor has almost no will to live so in first gear you have to get the RPM's up a little and feather the clutch properly. Problem solved.
PHXDEMONPhoenix, AZ · Jan 27, 2010#65
Originally Posted by Thirty-Nine ↑
I just got a call from Toyota. Looks like they're redoing the entire clutch.

- Clutch disc
- Flywheel
- Throwout bearing
- Clutch cover

Wow ... more updates later.

Nice. Maybe I should take mine in and claim I am having "shudder" issues 😎
yaris2010RSAngus, Ontario · Jan 28, 2010#66
Originally Posted by BuildCode ↑
i don't put mine in neutral at that high of a speed, but from 40mph (60kmh) my revs will bob once or twice, but not as many times as yours did in the video. I don't worry about it, at all.
lol, wasn't really too worried about it and probably not gonna do it too often either. lol. just one day on the highway going down hill and decided to try it.
jsut wondering if it has to do with the constant revving at idle which i do find very annoying.

my friend sudgested it has to do with cold wind coming in and the engine trying to keep going or resistance the tranny is putting it in even in no gear.
yaris2010RSAngus, Ontario · Jan 28, 2010#67
and i gotta take blueberry in soon too...... after the recent toyota recalls i find my clutch can do the same..... happened to me a few times...... not too much of an issue but still
tk-421Dagobah · Jan 28, 2010#68
I'm starting to have shudder issues myself... The weird part is that I have already swapped my clutch once (ACT Stage 1)... Starting to wonder if the tranny fluid is leaking...

Another weird thing is that sometimes I will get a bit of grinding when I downshift from 3rd to 2nd gear (while engine-braking), even if my clutch is completely engaged (foot all the way down).

😕
yaris2010RSAngus, Ontario · Jan 28, 2010#69
I am personally beginning to question the hydraulic fluid....
BuildCodeThread starterNorthern Illinois · Jan 28, 2010#70
Originally Posted by Thirty-Nine ↑
I find this hard to believe. No syncros in first or reverse? If there was no syncro in first, you'd have to come to a complete stop to downshift into it, which you can do (although it's not something I do on a regular basis).

Someone correct me if I'm wrong ...
I'd like to know this as well...reverse probably doesn't have syncros.

However, a lack of syncros would not cause a shudder.
PHXDEMONPhoenix, AZ · Jan 28, 2010#71
Originally Posted by Thirty-Nine ↑
I find this hard to believe. No syncros in first or reverse? If there was no syncro in first, you'd have to come to a complete stop to downshift into it, which you can do (although it's not something I do on a regular basis).

Someone correct me if I'm wrong ...
That's just what I have heard 🤷 You have to bring it damn near to a stop to pop into first wuithout a rough shift.
eventnisSerbia · Feb 4, 2010#72
it probably the "#$#% drive by wire system.thats the only thing that pisses me off with this car.
woofDeep South · Feb 17, 2010#73
This shudder (chatter) seems to be a design flaw just like the "Big Foot Mod" and the imprecise throttle tip-in that causes rough shifts and stalling.

I drove a 5-speed xB for 50K miles before trading for my Yaris and it has been a nightmare with the Yaris. The xB was nearly flawless at 50K and I never had clutch chatter or shifting problems.

And yes, first gear has a synchro on it. It just doesn't work worth a damn.
09SedanPolarWhiteMTSouthern Illinois · Sep 4, 2010#74
Happens to me, my car just rolled over 10K miles. I've noticed it since like 4,000 miles, I drive like you, I try to start with as low RPMs as possible. I thought I was skidding the tires at first but it's happened on flat, dry, gravel-free surfaces. I do not feel any erratic resistance in the clutch, just the lurching of the car. Wonder what's causing it.
Yaris_MacBay Area · Jun 16, 2015#75
Sorry for bringing this thread back to life but is there a fix for this? I've been driving manual tranny since 1992 and this is the worse 1st and reverse gear. My 1976 corolla had better 1st/reverse than this Yaris. Please advise. Thanks!
tmontagueCaledonia Ont. · Jun 17, 2015#76
A permanent fix would be getting a better aftermarket clutch.

Other than that bleeding the slave cylinder helps but it only last a few weeks.