Yarisworld Archive

Garm's AFE intake vs. TRD high flow air filter????

29 posts · 22,350 views

computerlove87Original postjOakland · Jul 20, 2009#1
I am trying to decide if I should go with the AFE intake on micro-image or the trd high-flow filter. My main interests are low maintenance, fuel efficiency, sound, and a little bit of a performance gain, the price isn't as important if the AFE is really worth twice as much.

Does anyone who has used either solution have anything to say? How is the performance, fuel mileage with each? Would Toyota dealers not honor my warranty because of the AFE intake? Overall is the AFE really worth 2x more $? Any suggestions are helpful.

👏

Replies 28

KioshiFremont, CA · Jul 20, 2009#2
They won't honor your warranty if a CEL or anything is to backfire from the intake... they didnt honor my Fujita F% last time i went there for a problem~~
If you have TRD CAI AND installed by them, they will warranty it then, and only then~

AFE is easier to maintain, clean filter, etc...I dont have to much insight on it, but a lot of people on here are happy w/ it :)
PETERPOOPOahu · Jul 20, 2009#3
aFe FTW
BrianRiverside, CA · Jul 20, 2009#4
Originally Posted by Kioshi ↑
They won't honor your warranty if a CEL or anything is to backfire from the intake... they didnt honor my Fujita F% last time i went there for a problem~~
If you have TRD CAI AND installed by them, they will warranty it then, and only then~

AFE is easier to maintain, clean filter, etc...I dont have to much insight on it, but a lot of people on here are happy w/ it :)
TRD CAI does not have a warranty because its for off road use only no matter if its installed
by the dealer or not.
YodaFL · Jul 20, 2009#5
Originally Posted by Brian ↑
TRD CAI does not have a warranty because its for off road use only no matter if its installed
by the dealer or not.
Not true all TRD parts if installed by your dealer is under warranty. Your dealer must suck. Cause up here they will even locate the parts for u😉
QmobileHoytville, ohio · Jul 20, 2009#6
acaully it says that it's for off road use on online 2 trduasa.com
BrianRiverside, CA · Jul 20, 2009#7
Originally Posted by Yoda ↑
Not true all TRD parts if installed by your dealer is under warranty. Your dealer must suck. Cause up here they will even locate the parts for u😉
That only applies to TRD parts approved for highway use. Check the TRD website for the warranty
info. It states that there is no warranty for the off road use only products. Whether or not your
dealership will warranty the part is up to them but TRD will not.
Sparks Toyota-TRDMyrtle Beach, SC · Jul 20, 2009#8
TRD parts are covered under warranty. TRD parts have a parts based warranty as well if installed by a dealer a labor warranty. Don't let your dealer tell you otherwise. They have to prove to you otherwise.

If you install a TRD part you still have a parts warranty on that product and the dealership has to prove your install is what broke the TRD part.


Tim
computerlove87Thread starterjOakland · Jul 20, 2009#9
Actually I was talking about the TRD high flow air filter:

Picture not included in this copy

It is basically just a deep pleet oil media replacement for the crappy paper filter that comes stock. The TRD cai system is like $1,000! \

It seems like everyone pretty much agrees though that the AEM is a lot better even though it costs more than 3X more?

1 attachment not included in this copy

cali yarisCanoga Park, CA · Jul 20, 2009#10
AEM? I thought we were comparing this filter to the aFe intake.

The aFe intake has larger piping throughout, so it's actually a replacement for the whole intake system, ending at the throttle body.
TamagoOff Grid · Jul 20, 2009#11
AFE. all the way. and i don't even own one (stock airbox and stock air filter here lol)
KioshiFremont, CA · Jul 20, 2009#12
computerlove87, get the TRD CAI from Sparks...its like $300...or get Garm's AFE for under $200?

Thanks for clearing up Tim... Some of your guy's dealerships like to throw false info at you, dont let them do that... My service managers have specifically said TRD are under warranty if installed by dealers...they didnt cover the (install yourself) and you still have parts warranty w/ me because they were looking to make money off of me~~
kngrsllSpartanburg, SC · Jul 20, 2009#13
i just ordered an aFE, i think its one of the best looking* intakes ive seen made for a car in awhile.

*in regards to function rather than form lol
TamagoOff Grid · Jul 20, 2009#14
furthermore an aftermarket intake won't void any portion of your warranty in any way unless it is directly responsible for the failure of the warantee'd part.
kngrsllSpartanburg, SC · Jul 20, 2009#15
Originally Posted by Tamago ↑
furthermore an aftermarket intake won't void any portion of your warranty in any way unless it is directly responsible for the failure of the warantee'd part.
i love that law
TamagoOff Grid · Jul 20, 2009#16
Originally Posted by kngrsll ↑
i love that law
it blows me away that people don't know about a law that is older than most individuals ON THE BOARD itself.
KioshiFremont, CA · Jul 20, 2009#17
Originally Posted by kngrsll ↑
i just ordered an aFE, i think its one of the best looking* intakes ive seen made for a car in awhile.l
It looks a lot like the Typhoon intake from K&N, but wayyyy cheaper 😉
ezhacker1San Francisco · Jul 20, 2009#18
Another thing to think about if you go the AFE route is which filter to get: Pro Dry S, Pro 5R, or Pro-Guard 7. I believe it ranges from highest air flow/least filtration > least/most filtration but still better flow over OEM.
kngrsllSpartanburg, SC · Jul 20, 2009#19
Originally Posted by Kioshi ↑
It looks a lot like the Typhoon intake from K&N, but wayyyy cheaper 😉
ironically, i said the same thing about the K&N when it came out... except that i cant stand oiled filters so the AFE is better in my opinion.
1NZYaris1New Zealand · Jul 20, 2009#20
Go The AFE Dry , you won't regret it , i have had mine on for 20,000KM +
and no problems or CEL's what so ever . 👍
cali yarisCanoga Park, CA · Jul 20, 2009#21
I have the oiled filters in stock, but so far no one has gone for that option. Everyone likes the easy maintenance of the dry filters better.
kngrsllSpartanburg, SC · Jul 21, 2009#23
Most reviews i have read on filter performance fall along these same lines: http://www.mkiv.com/techarticles/filters_test/2/

so it appears to me, the dry media work best, with the oiled media second, and the foam/stainless filters finishing worst. so that may explain some discrepency in sales.
scapeBeaufort, South Carolina · Jul 21, 2009#24
How is the performance, fuel mileage with each?
I would like to know this as well; with all else stock, I don't expect much of a change, if any; I don't know how anemic the stock air-box was to begin with but I don't think any real gains are going to be seen with a stock setup. Maybe someone has a Dyno to show the direct gains?
ezhacker1San Francisco · Jul 22, 2009#25
i was looking up on some more info between the Pro Dry S and the Pro 5r http://www.dieselmanor.com/afe/afe.asp

so the oiled one (Pro 5R) has more air flow over the Dry S, maybe it would come down to ease of maintenance which would be the dry one, and how the air pollution is around where you live.
cali yarisCanoga Park, CA · Jul 22, 2009#26
According to aFE, the oiled media has more airflow (as noted above) than dry, and therefore makes a tiny bit more power.

On our cars, with low horsepower to start with, this difference is negligible, so the dry makes more sense (lower maintenance).
ezhacker1San Francisco · Jul 22, 2009#27
really? i assumed given our low horsepower, a number would have a bigger percentage increase over same number on a higher horsepower engine. Either way, i was also thinking that hte one with more airflow would sound better, but then again im on stock exhaust.
scapeBeaufort, South Carolina · Jul 22, 2009#28
i think the stock airbox might breathe rather efficiently as is, for stock setup. i think to fully use those ram air and such intakes, more modification is needed; but I'm just guessing here
1NZYaris1New Zealand · Jul 22, 2009#29
On a stock set up then why bother putting in the TRD filter setup 🤷.
My engine only has the NST pullies and the AFE intake , and between the
2 , there is a marked differrance in response and fuel economy .
All Positive .👍