Yarisworld Archive

Consumer Reports not too pleased with Yaris

133 posts · 104,466 views · page 3 of 3

Replies continued

PetersRedYarisThe Black Hills of South Dakota · Dec 21, 2006#101
When buying my wifes new Civic I told the salesman I was going to buy a Yaris. He of course tried to push me into a Fit. He showed me multiple reports and with each article the Fit beat the Yaris.

Heres the catch; In each report the Yaris was compared to a Fit Sport. Did you know the Fit Sport starts in the $17,000 range? In my opinion this is not even the same price bracket as the Yaris.

What makes the Fit Sport beat the Yaris? I think the real difference is the Fit has a 5 speed automatic, paddle shifters on the steering wheel, outside temp. guage, a tachmeter, and dual front, side, and side curtain airbags.

Five speed auto; I admit it works very well in my wifes Civic with a 1.8L, however, since the Yaris beat the Fit in acceleration I don't see the need for it. Paddle shifters; This isn't a Ferrari, do people really want to push the 1.5L to the max. An outside temp guage and Tach would be nice. Lastly, Toyota really needs to make 6 airbags standard like Honda. Safety is a big issue in these reports.

As far as looks, the Yaris blows the Fit out of the water.
ParsToronto · Dec 21, 2006#102
All the Fit models gets the 6 airbags (not just the sport), but here in Canada, the Yaris also gets a tachometer (which is a very good thing...no tach is a deal breaker in my opinion). Outside temperature gage would be safety issue here in Canada, with the temperature constantly handing around zero Celsius.

It seem that style is a motivating factor when purchasing a new car and the Fit without the skirt package is too simplistic, so it'd require the Fit's Sport model with the skirt package to compete with Yaris's looks. And those skirts on the Fit comes at a hefty premium. Here in Canada, a loaded 5dr Yaris goes for $16720 while the Fit sport cost $19480.

The Fit's standard side airbags got good results in side impact test, as did the optional airbags in the Yaris sedan. In rear end crash test, the Yaris faired better then the Fit. So overall, the Yaris could be a safer car. But since the side airbag isn't offered in the liftback model (which is very popular in Canada), the Fit wins in that department.
corey415San Fran, CA · Dec 21, 2006#103
Originally Posted by PetersRedYaris ↑
He showed me multiple reports and with each article the Fit beat the Yaris.

Heres the catch; In each report the Yaris was compared to a Fit Sport. Did you know the Fit Sport starts in the $17,000 range? In my opinion this is not even the same price bracket as the Yaris.

What makes the Fit Sport beat the Yaris? I think the real difference is the Fit has a 5 speed automatic, paddle shifters on the steering wheel, outside temp. guage, a tachmeter, and dual front, side, and side curtain airbags.

Five speed auto; I admit it works very well in my wifes Civic with a 1.8L, however, since the Yaris beat the Fit in acceleration I don't see the need for it. Paddle shifters; This isn't a Ferrari, do people really want to push the 1.5L to the max. An outside temp guage and Tach would be nice. Lastly, Toyota really needs to make 6 airbags standard like Honda. Safety is a big issue in these reports.

As far as looks, the Yaris blows the Fit out of the water.
Most of those articles test the Yaris with options as well you know. Its not like they would compare a base Yaris with a Fit Sport. If they did, that is obviously an apples to oranges comparison. A comparably equipped Yaris does end up costing within the general vicinity of the Fit Sport, albeit a little cheaper.

With regards to why the Fit wins comparos; its mainly due to the classier interior and Fit is often described to have the "sport[iest] handling", especially when compared to its subcompact brethern.

Also, the paddle shifters may be more useful than you think. They are sort of gimmicky, but they can come in handy. It is nice to be able to control what gear you are in when descending down a curvy mountain road for example. One can do this with a regular automatic, but it definitely is a more akward task to accomplish. Another use is to do a downshift when you know you are going to need passing power, perhaps whilst on the freeway. If they really annoy you that much, you dont even have to use them.
boris13Royal Oak, MI, USA · Dec 21, 2006#104
C'mon, let's say it: the Fit is just plain UGLY.

I ordered my loaded Yaris hatchback at a price of about $15,800. The main thing it lacks in comparison to the Fit Sport ($17,000+) is a tach. It's not as roomy inside as the Fit, but it's not bad... enough room for me.

A Yaris that's well equipped competes very well with the Fit Sport, IMO.
ParsToronto · Dec 21, 2006#105
The RS version of the Yaris is a rip-off. You're basically paying a huge premium for minor stuff that would be standard on most entry level cars. So, using the Yaris RS as a comparison point against the Fit just doesn't make sense. It's Yaris's LE model that dominates the road. Reason being, it looks exactly the same as the RS model (except for painted side mirror) has the same power options and sells for about $3000 less.

However, in appearance, there's a noticeable difference between Fit LX vs Sport. The LX version without the skirt package looks bad. And to avoid the dopey look, you need to pay a huge premium ($19480) for the Sport. Considering that the Civic DX-G can be had for less, paying that much for the Fit is stupid.

If you really want to compare apple vs apple, then pit the Fit LX against the Yaris LE. Considering that both cars will be running on similar size tires and the Fit's plain-jane looks will be noticeable without the skirts, it'd put the the Fit at a huge disadvantage, even though equipment level and price are almost identical (Canadian models only). In the States, the Fit's sport model is more reasonably priced, so pitting it against the Yaris makes sense, but here in Canada, the Sport model is totally over priced when compared to a loaded Yaris.

Regarding interiors. I like the Yaris seating and view of the road (but Fit is almost as good, so no clear winner). The Fit has a very upscale dash layout, but the Yaris simplistic but elegant design has it's own character, so once again, no clear winner. For me the deciding factor was the placement of my portable NAV system, which mounted perfect onto the glass covering for the Yaris's instrument panel and actually gives the dash a more upscale appearance since the Magellan unit has the same chrome finish and blends in with the stock layout.
PetersRedYarisThe Black Hills of South Dakota · Dec 23, 2006#106
Originally Posted by corey415 ↑
Most of those articles test the Yaris with options as well you know. Its not like they would compare a base Yaris with a Fit Sport. If they did, that is obviously an apples to oranges comparison. A comparably equipped Yaris does end up costing within the general vicinity of the Fit Sport, albeit a little cheaper.

With regards to why the Fit wins comparos; its mainly due to the classier interior and Fit is often described to have the "sport[iest] handling", especially when compared to its subcompact brethern.

Also, the paddle shifters may be more useful than you think. They are sort of gimmicky, but they can come in handy. It is nice to be able to control what gear you are in when descending down a curvy mountain road for example. One can do this with a regular automatic, but it definitely is a more akward task to accomplish. Another use is to do a downshift when you know you are going to need passing power, perhaps whilst on the freeway. If they really annoy you that much, you dont even have to use them.
Classier interior? More functional seat adjustments I admit, but thats it. The comparisons I saw was a Fit Sport vs. Yaris LB base model, no airbags. Thats a $17,000 plus Fit vs. a $11,900 Yaris. No wonder the Fit won, but mot buy much.
corey415San Fran, CA · Dec 23, 2006#107
Might you have links to said articles which make such ridiculous comparisons?

Of course looks are subjective, but the Fit is often praised by automotive journalists as having a "classier interior"...
Jem_hadarCollingwood, ON · Dec 24, 2006#108
Yeah, I think generally the Fit has an interior dash look that would appeal to most ppl far more than the Yaris's does...

but myself I like the Yaris's interior look much better!

Its more "techno" 😉 hah
ParsToronto · Dec 24, 2006#109
Same here, I'm personally in favor with clean looking dash layout in the Yaris, but the Fit's dash looks rich. In fact, a friend of mine who drives a new Accord prefers the Fit's dash over her Accord.

One thing I totally dislike about the Yaris's in-dash system is No AUX port for an MP3 Player and paying over $300 for an iPod adapter is ridiculous when everyone else is offering it for free. It's not going to cost the manufacture that much more to offer a stereo system with AUX-in port. So why leave it out? My old Civic had an Alpine system with an iPod adapter and now with the New Yaris, the iPod is collecting dust on the dresser and I'm listening to AM/FM for my music. How primitive. But on the bright side, I'm working on getting a 2 din DVD player with iPod adapter which should also add some 'richness' to the centre dash's appearance.😎
foxtrot685Buckley AFB, CO · Dec 24, 2006#110
well... this is 2006 and ABS is standard on almost every other car in its class, including the scion cousins, even the Hyundai accent sedan has it... its becoming one of those features that is now expected on a car in this price category to be standard equipment. how dare they compare a yaris to an aveo... ewww! the difference between them is night and day. they should have had a separate category for the aveo... "super ultra crappy Korean-built car segment"
graywolf_14Wichita ks · Dec 25, 2006#111
Shoot for 17k you can get a yaris with every option they have and that is with the 18"s.
foxtrot685Buckley AFB, CO · Dec 25, 2006#112
thats close to a fit sport with automatic tranny and no upgrades (meaning the stock 15 inch alloys)
eTiMaGoBangkok, Thailand · Dec 27, 2006#113
I just have my 2 cents to share 😉

I have never driven a Fit, but I am back home now down in Phuket where my mother has a 3-year-old Honda City, which for all intents and purposes you could call a Fit Sedan. Similar styling, same motor and platform, very similar interior layout. More info can be obtained here:

http://www.honda.co.th/city/


I've been driving it quite a bit since a few days that I am back here, and can make some comparisons.

First of all, the manual shifter in the Honda is so much better than the Yaris. The throw is quite short, it moves from gear to gear easily and with a very positive feel, you can just flick it, basically, no need to really push the stick into gear. I'm sure when I install my TWM short shifter I'll have a similar experience in my Yaris, but this I consider a very big difference, if you are into manual cars, it's a joy to change gears.

The clutch is also very light, and much more intuitive than the Yaris. Driving slow and shifting smoothly is not a problem.

I can't really compare the engines since this City has the non-VTEC engine (rated at only 88hp!), but this motor has a lot of low end torque (peak at 2,700rpm!) so you don't need to be shifting around all so much, even going up hills. I'm sure the 110hp VTEC engine has a similar response to our engines, though.

The car's handling is difficult to compare as I have basically never driven a stock Yaris, nor have I driven a Yaris on a mountain road as I have driven this City. But, the ride is firm but comfortable, though on fast turns you do lose traction pretty easily. Which is fun in its own way, nothing like sliding that tail out 😁 The steering wheel (and the whole feel of the car) is light, but not twitchy as ours can be on rough roads or at high speed.

I really wish I could have taken my car down here and see how it behaves in the hills, that would have been so much fun 🙁 Maybe I'll rent one, but it's pretty sure to be an automatic...

Interior wise, it is a lot more traditional than the Yaris, and the high center console does give it more of a big car feel. But, you can easily feel the difference in storage space, the main passenger side glove compartment is full of manuals and documents, and apart from that, there isn't a lot of space to keep stuff.

I'm not sure if the USDM Fits would come similarly equipped, but I am constantly pleasantly surprised at the stock sound system. This car came with a single-DIN Sony cassette player, but the stock speakers are more than adequate and can handle a pretty good amount of bass. All we did was to add a 10-disc changer in the trunk, but it could also do with a couple of tweeters to bring up the sharps.

All in all, from a driving experience point of view, if the USDM Fit can be compared to this City, it's really not that bad. Standard and optional equipment, pricing, safety features, and so on, I really cannot comment on as it would be very different between US and Thai spec cars.
HavanaSouth Carolina · Jan 22, 2009#114
When shopping, I compared the 09 Fit to the 09 Yaris. I know Honda and Toyota both make outstanding cars. The Fit was awesome and very fun to drive. It came with more standard features. It was also about $3000 more. Fits are in short supply in my area and manual tranny Fits are virtual blue diamonds. The Honda dealers were not very flexible at all on price. The Yaris is a more simple car but of equal quaility in my opinion. Six airbags and ABS are standard on 09's. There was also a $500 rebate at that time and the Toyota dealers seemed more interested in making a sale. In the end, I got a great car for several thousand less than a Fit. I'm happy with that.
twowheelsCA · Jan 22, 2009#115
Originally Posted by Havana ↑
When shopping, I compared the 09 Fit to the 09 Yaris. I know Honda and Toyota both make outstanding cars. The Fit was awesome and very fun to drive. It came with more standard features. It was also about $3000 more. Fits are in short supply in my area and manual tranny Fits are virtual blue diamonds. The Honda dealers were not very flexible at all on price. The Yaris is a more simple car but of equal quaility in my opinion. Six airbags and ABS are standard on 09's. There was also a $500 rebate at that time and the Toyota dealers seemed more interested in making a sale. In the end, I got a great car for several thousand less than a Fit. I'm happy with that.
Interesting reviving an old dead thread... :-)

I also compared the 09 Fit to the 09 Yaris. A few years ago (07) we were looking at cars but decided to wait put another 50k on the Camry first. At the time I drove a Yaris but wasn't impressed, mostly because of the lack of safety features. I had completely removed it from consideration. I had settled on the Fit and for two years kept saying I'd buy a Fit when the time came. The thing is, both the 07 and the 09 Fit felt 'off' to me. Not sure why, but they did. The handling wasn't anywhere near as impressive as I'd heard. This year I put the Yaris back in consideration due to the standard safety features and as you can probably guess we bought the Yaris.

During the test drive I did feel that the Fit had a slightly more comfortable driver's seat, though my kids said that the back seat was better in the Yaris. The Fit seemed to bounce MORE on big bumps than the Yaris did and though might have been slightly quieter the noise that it did make was more annoying to me. I actually felt like the Yaris was quieter. The lack of cruise on the base Fit meant that I'd have to upgrade to a Fit sport which dropped the MPG rating and raised the price quite a bit. Overall the Yaris ended up being significantly cheaper (about $4000) with the options that we wanted and the rebate from Toyota. We're very happy with it and I *LOVE* how tightly it can turn -- I can't get over how easy it is to park and do U-turns! :-)
PaidTimeOffHawaii · Jan 22, 2009#116
Yup, if there's one thing that all reviewers can agree on (whether they like the car or not), it's that the Yaris' turning radius can't be beat.
rningonfumesSoCal · Jan 22, 2009#117
I got a chance to browse April's Buyer guide from CR.... even with the new safety features, the Yaris does not have a "Recommended" check mark. It listed the last test rive as the 07 model.

Better than average reliability.
HavanaSouth Carolina · Jan 22, 2009#118
It's funny. I don't think I've read a single overall positive review by any professional automotive tester/critic. Yet, actual Yaris owners seem to universally love and recommend the car.
MadMaxSan Antonio, Texas! · Jan 22, 2009#119
Originally Posted by Havana ↑
It's funny. I don't think I've read a single overall positive review by any professional automotive tester/critic. Yet, actual Yaris owners seem to universally love and recommend the car.
Y'know, when I was doing my research on the car I was hard-pressed to find a good review on it; but I read 130+ owner's reviews and they were universally positive of it. I learned a long time ago that professional auto critics are a snobby bunch with little connection to the real world.

Cheers! M2
twowheelsCA · Jan 22, 2009#120
Originally Posted by PaidTimeOff ↑
Yup, if there's one thing that all reviewers can agree on (whether they like the car or not), it's that the Yaris' turning radius can't be beat.
After buying the car and noting how tightly it turns I did some research using edmunds.com's car compare feature. The only car that I found that could beat the Yaris on turning diameter was the Smart ForTwo, and by only two feet!
ddongbaphay · Jan 22, 2009#121
Dude, I pull 360s in two parking spots.
gidNortheast · Jan 23, 2009#123
Originally Posted by rningonfumes ↑
I got a chance to browse April's Buyer guide from CR.... even with the new safety features, the Yaris does not have a "Recommended" check mark. It listed the last test rive as the 07 model.

Better than average reliability.
we should be getting the new monthly issue for C.R. that reviews the '09 by the end of next week . Let yeh know the results soon as it gets here . Patience my . The waiting is killin' us both 🤤 .
JetfireKSlidell, LA · Oct 20, 2010#124
Originally Posted by Befuddled ↑
Just got the new Consumer Reports. They were assessing budget cars this month. In the auto transmission category the Yaris came in 6th out of 9 and in the HB, manual category it came in next to last, just ahead of the Aveo. 🤷 In the manual category the Honda Fit came in first with overall score of 75 (Yaris was 36) 😳
Everything I read mostly...does not credit Yaris with good anything...but then...We have to make ourselves happy and when they tout chrysler that tells me I made the right choice....Never driven a Honda...and don't intend to. Remember Toyota is number 1....so why settle for anything less?
fnkngrvIn The Hotbox · Oct 20, 2010#125
wow...way to dust off an old thread. Consumer Reports is corrupt and the people that work there have bad crusties around their mouths from all of the reviewing of the constituent's areas a few inches below their belt line rather than truly checkin out the vehicles.
ChilliwackGuyChilliwack BC, Canada · Oct 22, 2010#126
I gotta admit that the one car I am always checking is the Honda Fit - not sure why - but it just looks cool.

Yet - I'm positive my Yaris is way cheaper on gas and more reliable.

Also, I subscribe to Consumer Reports Canada Magazine - and they are not slamming Toyota - instead they are suggesting that they will not recommend the company - simple because of the numerous recalls.
c-dubI think we're back in Kansas Toto! · Oct 22, 2010#127
granted i dont drive the yaris much if at all, but i can't listen to anyone that talks about a "turning circle" are they writting for 2nd graders or something?
fnkngrvIn The Hotbox · Oct 22, 2010#128
Originally Posted by ChilliwackGuy ↑
I gotta admit that the one car I am always checking is the Honda Fit - not sure why - but it just looks cool.

Yet - I'm positive my Yaris is way cheaper on gas and more reliable.

Also, I subscribe to Consumer Reports Canada Magazine - and they are not slamming Toyota - instead they are suggesting that they will not recommend the company - simple because of the numerous recalls.

Fit = micro minivan

As for the recalls they are like no other company. The difference now is that their recalls are more in the spotlight. If anything Chrysler and Ford on many models in the last 20 years should have had to literally recall the entire vehicle and provide full refunds. Mostly in the 80's, but depending on your age you might not be aware...and oh yeah...how about those totally awesome Chevy Cavaliers of the 90s...ish.
2007yarizNorthern Virginia · Oct 22, 2010#129
Honda Fit looks fugly, like a minivan imo. I heard its gas mileage is not so great on the highway, because it's not aerodynamic.
kroloswa state · Oct 22, 2010#130
I don't know about the current Honda Fit model, but i did test drive the
1st gen. several times, I got to say I did like the looks and the practical
side to it, but the driver seating was plain awkward, the engine was not very
smooth at acceleration or at highway speed.
When I first test drove the Yaris sedan I was impressed the driver seating
was right on and it had nice firm seats, the engine was smooth on acceleration and at highway speed
and it was noticeable more peppier, it just had an overall good comfortable feel to it
that the Fit simply did not have.
I test drove Some other makes also, but Yaris won for comfort and performance and price.
Consumer Reports at least when it comes to auto reviews they are
not to trust worthy, something weird about them😕
fnkngrvIn The Hotbox · Oct 23, 2010#131
After much fanfare and anticipation CR has its latest test vehicle:

Picture not included in this copy

Wonder how they will rate the built in air freshener?
chrisjS. Jesus, Kentucky · Oct 23, 2010#132
As far as getting in and out of a vehicle, since I got my Yaris things have been a dream. Looking at the outside, you'd never realize how much room there is, of course. But I noticed a HUGE difference in getting in and out over our Avalon. That's a big thing to me, so if Consumer Reports bases anything on comfort and calls me, then the Yaris gets high marks from me for that.
bB2NERW.TN · Feb 28, 2011#133
Consumers Reports has out lasted their usefulness. I'm surprised they can stay in business.