Replies continued
woofDeep South · Dec 24, 2009#151 just because you are used to a cable accelerator, and a longer friction point in the clutch, doesn't make the car bad, it makes you not willing to learn to drive it, you expect it to be exactly like everything you have ever owned. Well its not.
^if you had an independent mechanic take apart your motor, why didn't you have him fix it?^
I have ALL the symptoms people here are bitching about, but you know what? Its just you (whoever is bitching). I have no issues with shifting/starting on hills/slipping clutch. Learn to drive your NEW car, with its NEW quirks, don't expect it to act like your OLD car did. Its not the same vehicle.
12-22-2009 06:07 PM
My xB1 had fly-by-wire and was flawless at 50K miles. My mechanic and assistant diagnosed slack in cv joints and possibly inside transmission. I've driven nothing but clutches my entire life. Improve you reading comprehension.
seriously, I ride the clutch often for first gear, once i'm moving it's fully engaged, but djgese do i ride it under 5 mph, and to be honest I could care less; you should too, and here's why: by the time this will ever matter in any way, shape, or form the car will be 8-10 years old, and have it's 3rd owner by then (well like 90% of us atleast). And if you keep this car for 10 years and it still is putting along (as I suspect it will) then you my friend have had a great investment on your hands.
can we rename this thread to something more realistic? perhaps, 1st gear sucks goat..., but let's stop the 'whining'?
Unfortunately, it started mattering after six months of ownership. This is not my thread...someone else started it and named it.
Wow, sorry to hear this all.
Makes me feel better about the A/T I got "stuck" with since I could'nt snag a five speed with the coveted power pkg. that I so enjoy.....
The Gulf States guy said Toyota is making it harder for people to get a manual transmission. I guess it's less chance of warranty problems with the a/t.
I could name 3 people off hand who have had their yaris transmission replaced under warranty, but you aren't listening anyway.
Toyota doesn't cover operator error, the Yaris would start at 20k if they did.
First, tell me what they did to have that done? Second, operator error, in the case of an experienced driver, can only come from a defective design especially since I drove the identical drivetrain for 50K miles before the Yaris. Toyota quality has fallen quite a bit. The massive recalls they have going right now are costing about $800M. That's just shy of a billion. On another forum (non-car) someone had started a thread on Toy and two other people have had the same problem with warranty work being denied for lesser problems.
I would like to know what the 20K comment means?
supmetSouthern California · Dec 24, 2009#152 Originally Posted by
woof ↑ First, tell me what they did to have that done? Second, operator error, in the case of an experienced driver, can only come from a defective design especially since I drove the identical drivetrain for 50K miles before the Yaris. Toyota quality has fallen quite a bit. The massive recalls they have going right now are costing about $800M. That's just shy of a billion. On another forum (non-car) someone had started a thread on Toy and two other people have had the same problem with warranty work being denied for lesser problems.
I would like to know what the 20K comment means?
First -
Originally Posted by
Morgan ↑ My third gear syncho when out at around 27,000 miles. I went to the dealership and demanded a new transmission. Being persistent and firm, I got a new transmission.
Second - I'm not arguing the defective design/operator error thing anymore.
Third - toyota had a bad year for VOLUNTARY recalls, but they really didn't have that many more than GM. Toyota recalls just get a lot more press coverage to brainwash america into buying american. Its the american thing to do, especially with the economy the way it is. 🙄
The 20k comment - means if toyota covered every last thing people came in and complained about under warranty, it would cause astronomical inflation to the base price of the yaris, to pay for the extra warranty work.
woofDeep South · Dec 24, 2009#153 The 20k comment - means if toyota covered every last thing people came in and complained about under warranty, it would cause astronomical inflation to the base price of the yaris, to pay for the extra warranty work.
Well, that's what a warranty is for....fixing every last thing. My xB1 was the most flawless car I've owned except for the dash buzz which is operator fixed. I never had to reason to ask for warranty help on anyting, including my 1980 Corrola which was about bullet proof.
When I was getting a 'rigged' second opinion, the service manager was saying "since we don't have a complaint until 20K miles..." I cut him off by holding up a note I wrote dated over two years prior they didn't key in the system apparently. I wished I had let him finish to know what he was going to say.
My major beef is that they are ducking work, folks on other forums are having the same experiences, BUT my mechanic says they are ALL like that: Honda, Nissan, Ford, GM. He also said even with the clunking it is conceivable the car would last indefinitely without a repair. I was interested in keeping this car beyond payoff on a permanent basis because of the incredible gas mileage. Now, that may not be feasible and a trade-in could be seriously damaged if they want to make an issue out of the mechanical noises.
woofDeep South · Feb 21, 2010#154Well, I'm happy that the sorry service manager at Gray Daniels will end up blowing his bottom line this year with the zillion of accelerators to repair.
I'm surprised the Yaris hasn't floated to the top with all the stuff reported here.
gonzo452001French Lick,IN · Feb 21, 2010#155I have 73,000miles on my manual yaris and I am still not very happy with the clutch just can't get used to it but I plan to drive it at least 200,000 miles before I buy my next car
Ramblin yari573 · Feb 21, 2010#156I'll go for months without incident and then kill it twice in one day. Not the end of the world. I do wish I had an automatic though.
tomatoSan Francisco Bay Area · Feb 21, 2010#157the Yaris's clutch is a PITA and could use some improvement IMO
I'm used to it now, but it took long enough. Not so with other brands.
Food for thoughts, Mr. Toyota 🙇🙇 🙂
Hersheynortheast · Feb 21, 2010#158wonder if the 2010 clutch engagement is any better . Any input from 2010 manual owners , renters or test drives ? We too had a bit of trouble with the clutch engagement in 1st gear of the 2008 3 door that was traded in for an automatic '09 5 door . Otherwise liked the quicker starts and the fun of driving a 5 speed manual . Especially after changing out the GL-5 factory gear oil to REDLINE MT-90 synthetic gear oil that's 75w-90 and GL-4 👍 . Maybe someday we'll trade in for another manual if clutch engagement is better and then refill with REDLINE once again 🙂 .
yaris2010RSAngus, Ontario · Feb 21, 2010#159my 2010 is great. the DBW is the only realy problem with taking off (and the fact the clutch grabbs at a different point each time.....
CrashmasterFranklin VA · Feb 22, 2010#160The problem that I had was getting used to the friction point on the cluch and the touchyness of the throttle. To me I feel this is all due to the fact that the throttle and cluch have no linkages, they are all operated by electronics. It just took me the better part of a year to get used to this thats all.
bitz767Harrisburg, PA · Feb 22, 2010#161My 2010 yaris is just as bad as you all say, I killed it twice yesterday and once this morning. Its a PITA, but i still love it. I've only had it 2 weeks, so i think that I might be able to get used to it, hopefully
mrb3990Midwest USA · Feb 25, 2010#162I own a 2010 manual yaris. It took me about a month to become comfortable with the clutch, but I have no problems driving it now. What does PITA stand for?
bitz767Harrisburg, PA · Feb 25, 2010#163 Originally Posted by
mrb3990 ↑ I own a 2010 manual yaris. It took me about a month to become comfortable with the clutch, but I have no problems driving it now. What does PITA stand for?
pain in the ass
TamagoOff Grid · Feb 25, 2010#164 Originally Posted by
twocvforme ↑ Who has problems with clutch, gas and start off in first gear... ???
Yes, we can do it - but in comparison to the FIT and the Versa....The Yaris idle is so low and the clutch is so touchy.. and with a slight incline one stalls at times ..It's such a simple vehicle..........What a dissappointment.
Please test drive before buying..............
A real discussion topic in many other Yaris forums and many are trading already.........mostly for safety issues with stalling in intersections and or being rear ended..👎
sounds like 100% driver error
mrb3990Midwest USA · Feb 25, 2010#165Thanks for the explanation, bitz. Tamago, neither I nor most other posters had the OP's difficulties with our stick shifts. After reading the whole thread, I think the OP's problems were that he owned to many cars with manual transmissions and just couldn't get used to the Yaris, or possibly something was wrong with his car.
tomatoSan Francisco Bay Area · Feb 25, 2010#166 Originally Posted by
mrb3990 ↑ Thanks for the explanation, bitz. Tamago, neither I nor most other posters had the OP's difficulties with our stick shifts. After reading the whole thread, I think the OP's problems were that he owned to many cars with manual transmissions and just couldn't get used to the Yaris, or possibly something was wrong with his car.
I read the whole thread, too, because I had similar problems in the beginning. The Yaris MT *does* take a while to get used to. It's not a deal breaker by any means, just something to be aware of.🤷
Originally Posted by
Tamago ↑ sounds like 100% driver error
yeah, partly. They just needed a little more time to adapt to the car.
why?harnett county NC · Feb 25, 2010#167heh, when the car originally came out people just didn't like it. This was quite a huge debate back then, it is funny that this thread hasn't died.
Even after almost 4 years of driving my Yaris i still stall it once in a while.
There were a few people that did the 1 month and traded it in because they just couldn't stand the clutch and dbw. The must have had money to burn.
talnlnkySpokane, Wa · Feb 25, 2010#168 Originally Posted by
tomato ↑ I read the whole thread, too, because I had similar problems in the beginning. The Yaris MT *does* take a while to get used to. It's not a deal breaker by any means, just something to be aware of.🤷
yeah, partly. They just needed a little more time to adapt to the car.
I wonder how many people in the world refuse to drive a manaul because the first few times they tried to learn how to drive it they just had too much difficulty? Society looks at those people as being lame, lazy, and quiters.... how is it any different for somebody who sells a yaris after 1 month of ownership?
why?harnett county NC · Feb 25, 2010#169lots of people nowadays refuse to drive a manual, that is why it is very hard to find a lot of models of cars with anything but a slush box.
I remember trying to teach my best friend, she took five minutes and then decided she didn't need to learn...
tomatoSan Francisco Bay Area · Feb 25, 2010#170hmmm... I never had a choice. I learned how to drive on an old MT. It was either that or nothing, so I learned on the old MT and continued driving MT's for pretty much the rest of my life (except for a couple of old V8's along the way ;).
I like MT. I think switching gears manually is part of the fun. But then again, I enjoy driving.
ddongbaphay · Feb 25, 2010#171 Originally Posted by
why? ↑ lots of people nowadays refuse to drive a manual, that is why it is very hard to find a lot of models of cars with anything but a slush box.
I remember trying to teach my best friend, she took five minutes and then decided she didn't need to learn...
IDK about that one, BMW made a e60m5 with a crappy 6speed just to satisfy the 'Purist' driver. Most people couldn't stand it wasn't a manual, even tho the SMG was SUPER FAST.
Yaris#2indiana · Feb 25, 2010#172Ok, I just read through this entire thread. I've had my 5dr manual just under 2 wks now and since I normally drive a 5 speed Nissan pick-up, I know that its going to take a while to get used to the difference in the clutchs and I end up slipping the Yaris in first and doing the same to the truck when I get back in it. I wish it didn't rev when I shift, but I got 32mpg on the first tank of gas driving all but a few miles in town in the winter! I can't get that in my 4 cylinder 5sp truck even if I shut it off and coast down hill on the highway! I love the car. The reving between shifts makes me think people are laughing that I don't know how to drive a stick, but then I realize, the ones that are really laughing are laughing that I'm driving a Yaris, because they have never driven a Yaris! The car is a blast to drive and with the manual, I can still leave most of the drivers on the road in my dust anytime I choose to. Oh, and I'll use less gas doing it than they are putzing along.
He who laughs last, laughs best :)
tomatoSan Francisco Bay Area · Feb 25, 2010#173^ nobody is laughing, and just wait and see, once you're no longer having to think about the clutch, the car becomes *really* fun to drive.
And by the way, welcome to the forum 🙂
pawsplusColumbia, TN · Mar 3, 2010#174I just got my 2010 3dr 5-speed and have only had it a week. I did have a bit of trouble getting used to going from zero to first gear, but it's getting better and I'm getting used to it. It's just a matter of adjusting to the individual car. They're all different. I stalled out a few times the first few days and found I just need to give it a little more gas than I would have thought. We're all good now!
MUSKOKA800Chatham, Ontario, Canada · Mar 4, 2010#175 Originally Posted by
twocvforme ↑ Who has problems with clutch, gas and start off in first gear... ???
Yes, we can do it - but in comparison to the FIT and the Versa....The Yaris idle is so low and the clutch is so touchy.. and with a slight incline one stalls at times ..It's such a simple vehicle..........What a dissappointment.
Please test drive before buying..............
A real discussion topic in many other Yaris forums and many are trading already.........mostly for safety issues with stalling in intersections and or being rear ended..👎
They must be either untrained, uncoordinated, spastic, handicapped or texting.
In all cases, best take the bus and spare the rest of the collateral damage they're likely to leave in their wake for the balance of their driving lives.
koolerkingSydney · Oct 19, 2010#176I'll also say i agree with the thread starter. I've been driving for 20 years, 95% of that with a manual. After owning my manual 2007 1.3 yaris I still have the same issues. At first i just thought it was me getting used to manual after driving my old auto subaru, but after 18 months the clutch pick up and throttle lag coming off the gas it is still annoying the hell out me. I have stalled it due to the clutch "bogging down" when it hasn't enough gas from off the line, to the opposite of spinning the wheels all the way through to second (on a hill start) when you give it enough throttle to not bog down!
I hate it! Are any of these after market ECU's any good at the throttle lag? Is the clutch hydraulic or cable? If it hydraulic is it controlled by the ECU and therefore able to be adjusted with a uprated brain?
Id also like to add the spinning of wheels isn't helped by the fact the yaris is VERY light on its front end, even with new Dunlops on!
woofDeep South · Oct 19, 2010#177 Originally Posted by
koolerking ↑ I'll also say i agree with the thread starter. I've been driving for 20 years, 95% of that with a manual. After owning my manual 2007 1.3 yaris I still have the same issues. At first i just thought it was me getting used to manual after driving my old auto subaru, but after 18 months the clutch pick up and throttle lag coming off the gas it is still annoying the hell out me. I have stalled it due to the clutch "bogging down" when it hasn't enough gas from off the line, to the opposite of spinning the wheels all the way through to second (on a hill start) when you give it enough throttle to not bog down!
I hate it! Are any of these after market ECU's any good at the throttle lag? Is the clutch hydraulic or cable? If it hydraulic is it controlled by the ECU and therefore able to be adjusted with a uprated brain?
Id also like to add the spinning of wheels isn't helped by the fact the yaris is VERY light on its front end, even with new Dunlops on!
Well, I still have my hatch and I still manage to kill it once in a while. I have figured out that the first year I had mine that I didn't realize 'dead pedal' was keeping me from getting my foot all the way down to the floorboard. This means that initial clutch take up was nearly zero. It took a long while to actually look and see the geography of the dead pedal and clutch pedal. Once I saw the clutch pedal was nearly dead center of the steering column I adjusted my foot and started getting the pedal all the way down. My xB1 didn't have this dead pedal AND it had a higher numerical overall final drive number--it was geared lower to keep that brick moving through air on the highway. I think this higher overall ratio made it easier to launch the xB1. The Yaris is definitely designed for high mileage unlike my xB1.
Toyota is definitely at fault for the pedal location. What puzzles me is that it was designed in Europe (as I recall) and they don't have dainty feet either!
My greatest disappointment has been the failure of my dealer or Gulf States to do the right thing on this. They know there are problems.
😈
chrisjS. Jesus, Kentucky · Oct 20, 2010#178I always pushed clutches in vehicles all the way to the floor. Habit I guess. Is this the issue with the Yaris? Not doing it far enough? I was thinking about the next one I get (one for me this time) may be a stick, but now I don't know.
Hersheynortheast · Oct 20, 2010#179The 2008 L.B. with 5 speed maual we had was a bit finicky when started out in 1st . Even worse in reverse . But once you got going it was a fun , especially after putting REDLINE MT-90 in the tranny , much smoother shifting and no clunking into reverse . Liked the low gear ratio , could easily creep up to stop sign in 1st , then remain almost still few seconds w/o stalling and away you go . Miss that car 🙁 .
tomatoSan Francisco Bay Area · Oct 20, 2010#180 Originally Posted by
chrisj ↑ I always pushed clutches in vehicles all the way to the floor. Habit I guess. Is this the issue with the Yaris? Not doing it far enough? I was thinking about the next one I get (one for me this time) may be a stick, but now I don't know.
Yah, that clutch wants to be pushed *all the way* and won't accept it if you're 2mm off. 🙄
I remember the night I drove that car from the dealership, I got into some serious trouble on the freeway when I had almost reached San Francisco. At some point, I downshifted to 2d to make the turn, and the gears were completely stuck... 😲😲 couldn't get out of the way, couldn't move the car ... ugh.... don't know how I did it but I managed to shift anyway and get going. But the next day, the car did not want to start at all. After trying a number of things, we discovered that the car wouldn't start because the mat was stuck under the pedal, and that was the problem. Turned out when they detailed the car at the dealership before giving it to me, they forgot to hook up the mats (they have holes and you're supposed to hook them into place under the seat).
I stalled the Yaris in city driving for a good couple of weeks after that incident anyway because the clutch's friction points are so different from any other car I've ever driven. Reverse was OK for me but boy, I really hated that 1st gear for **a while** 👎 and almost had to re-learn how to paralel park (even though I've done it every day for *years*) because of the pillar causing a huge blind spot
The Yaris and I are BFF's now, finally, but oh boy we had a rough start, I remember that.
DebbyM46227Indianapolis · Oct 20, 2010#181I've been driving MT's for over 30 years - for the first month with my Yaris, taking off from a dead stop I either killed the engine or revved it way too high and burned rubber. Now I have no trouble taking off in 1st gear, it's just the engine revving up between gears when I know I've taken my foot off the accelerator that sounds strange.
Al_Syd, Aus · Oct 20, 2010#182Never had an issue here, I was always taught to get the clutch to the friction point and then to lift my toes inside my shoes to get a clean transfer and it hasn't failed me yet.
There is some lag in the throttle between gears, before I would release the gas and push in the clutch at the same time for changes, with the yaris I wait until my foot is off the throttle before pushing in the clutch which makes the shifts perfect
wooverstone8Olympia, WA · Oct 20, 2010#183I don't think there is a safety issue with the Yaris manual transmission. I honestly had problems the first month or two stalling or over revving the engine, but I got over it. After that it became a fun to drive car and I rarely stall it these days. Some people just give up too soon.
tomatoSan Francisco Bay Area · Oct 20, 2010#184 Originally Posted by
DebbyM46227 ↑ I've been driving MT's for over 30 years - for the first month with my Yaris, taking off from a dead stop I either killed the engine or revved it way too high and burned rubber. Now I have no trouble taking off in 1st gear, it's just the engine revving up between gears when I know I've taken my foot off the accelerator that sounds strange.
I was wondering how you transitioned from Honda to Yaris.
Completely different experience IMO.
I agree, I wouldn't call it a "safety issue" but people should probably be aware that there is a bit of a curve in the beginning. 2c
marcustoronto, canada · Oct 20, 2010#185ive only driven slow cars..so clutch on these car from dead stop are no issues at all. i find it all the same.. oh by the way most toyota workers dont know how to adjust from car after cars dont know why but they do istall my car as well whenever i bring it there..
why?harnett county NC · Oct 20, 2010#186I hate this clutch. I think I am going to get a throttle controller as soon as I can afford it.
chrisjS. Jesus, Kentucky · Oct 20, 2010#187 Originally Posted by
tomato ↑ After trying a number of things, we discovered that the car wouldn't start because the mat was stuck under the pedal, and that was the problem.
Yeah, when I had my Tacoma, my wife would come in the house telling me the truck wouldn't start. It was the same thing...the mat...every time.
kingbobby83East Texas (Longview) · Oct 30, 2010#188I have a 2009 sedan 5 speed and yes when I first got it , I stalled a few times. Even though I drive Toyotas all day everyday.. I work in the service dept. as a shop lead over the lube techs. I have been known to stall other models too. The reason is that each clutch is diffrent. But once you drive YOURS and get used to it's "points", it is soooo much fun to drive. I rev the rpms up a little before taking off and then just ease on down the road.I have never heard of a "Saftey Issue" or another complaint of this in my three years with Toyota...