Yarisworld Archive

$2.99 Oil Catch Can

53 posts · 27,764 views · page 1 of 2

MorganOriginal postPCB, FL · Jun 19, 2009#1
After disassembling my supercharger the last few days I didn't notice any oil in the charge pipes or in the manifold assembly, but to make myself feel better I got a $2.99 see through fuel filter and installed it in the PCV line. When/If it fills up its cheap to change and saves valuable space in the tiny engine bay. Here's a picture:

Picture not included in this copy

Replies 52

kngrsllSpartanburg, SC · Jun 19, 2009#2
GREAT idea!! wow
KCALB SIRAYVirginia · Jun 19, 2009#3
I'm so hot for you right now because of this, lol. Seriously, great idea
kngrsllSpartanburg, SC · Jun 19, 2009#4
got a part number or what car it came off of by chance?
marcustoronto, canada · Jun 19, 2009#5
now im confuse i thought its suppose to be on the otherside..

like this.. $30 Oil Catch Can, DIY
MorganThread starterPCB, FL · Jun 19, 2009#6
Purolator F21111, any cheap filter will work though. But for the record it came from PepBoys and there were other sizes to pick from that I'm sure would work just as well.

Kcalb- umm, thanks? lol

Originally Posted by marcus ↑
now im confuse i thought its suppose to be on the otherside...
both ports do the same thing, my other one is capped off...
TEHxFALLEN V1.2Calabasas, CA · Jun 19, 2009#7
That's pretty gangster. I like it. I think it's cool.
firebobon the road · Jun 19, 2009#8
I think the oil will go right through that element and there’s no place for it to drain but into the intake.

If you show me the case of those filters so you can change them all the time I give you a +1 but if you didn’t get a case of them then you get -1 for cutting the hose for no reason.
yaris-meAnaheim, CA · Jun 19, 2009#9
Did you use an electric zip tie on the hose to secure it?👍
TamagoOff Grid · Jun 19, 2009#10
Originally Posted by firebob ↑
I think the oil will go right through that element and there’s no place for it to drain but into the intake.

If you show me the case of those filters so you can change them all the time I give you a +1
but if you didn’t get a case of them then you get -1 for cutting the hose for no reason.

😲

🙄

so, unless she bought a case of them before knowing how they'd work, she gets a -1... wow dude.
firebobon the road · Jun 19, 2009#11
I would think that holding it up to the hose and looking you could see it would see that the oil would soak through the filter element and go right into the intake. That’s where the -1 comes in.

I’m sure the cost of the hose is about the cost as a case of the filters I bet.


I would like to say that I’m sorry for giving it a -1.


But now that I look at it closer I give it a +2 for re filtering the air that’s getting sucked into the crank case. If you want it to be an oil catch can then it needs to be on the back hose coming off top of the crank case unless it’s different on the 08 then the 09.

Picture not included in this copy
ddongbaphay · Jun 20, 2009#12
Soo.. wheres the catch?
MorganThread starterPCB, FL · Jun 20, 2009#13
Considering not all engines (not even all 1nz's) are created equally, an oil catch isn't absolutely necessary on every engine. So I either wasted $2.99 on a fuel filter since my engine doesn't have a blow by problem, or I wasted $2.99 on a fuel filter because I would have to buy a much higher capacity oil catch later on, or like I said in the beginning I was curious to see how much oil was actually going through the tube...

But guess what?!?!?! if the filter soaks 100% with oil, the car will still function! Amazing right! 🙄
firebobon the road · Jun 20, 2009#14
With it on the wrong hose it will only see oil if you have an issue.
firebobon the road · Jun 20, 2009#15
In post #1 it says in the PCV line.
MorganThread starterPCB, FL · Jun 20, 2009#16
Originally Posted by firebob ↑
In post #1 it says in the PCV line.
Pull your valve cover. Both of those tubes do the same job. One tube goes to the stock intake manifold, while the other goes just after the MAF. They do the same job. It is redundant to have both tubes. So during the supercharger install, I capped off one of the tubes since my new intake/supercharger set up only had one port (cause it came from a Scion xA/xB and they only have one breather tube). Since I only have the one tube that is where I put the filter.

Both tubes are not necessary for the car to run, Toyota makes redundant systems for reliability and this is one instance where I am willing to give up some of the redundancy to save space.

I suppose you could install the filter in the other line, it would make no difference whatsoever. However, for a catch can to be most effective you need to make sure all pcv hoses are going to the can to get all of the oil that passes through makes it to the catch can.
firebobon the road · Jun 20, 2009#17
Ok sure.

But both hoses do not do the same thing.

The set up is to pull in air form before the throttle body through the crankcase and dump it back into the intake. The hose that dumps back into the intake has the check valve. When you let off the gas the throttle body closes down most of the way and the motor would suck air though the crank case and burn off the fumes in the crank case.

But with only one you will only get blow by and a bit of air from the change in the temp as the car heats up and cools down out of that hose. I didn’t see that you had removed the other hose.
yaris-meAnaheim, CA · Jun 20, 2009#18
Originally Posted by firebob ↑
Ok sure.

But both hoses do not do the same thing.

The set up is to pull in air form before the throttle body through the crankcase and dump it back into the intake. The hose that dumps back into the intake has the check valve. When you let off the gas the throttle body closes down most of the way and the motor would suck air though the crank case and burn off the fumes in the crank case.

But with only one you will only get blow by and a bit of air from the change in the temp as the car heats up and cools down out of that hose. I didn’t see that you had removed the other hose.
I'm confused. The hose from the PCV goes to the intake manifold after the throttle body and there is another hose that goes after the MAF. What is the point in having two? After throttle shut down wouldn't it just circulate air through the hose to the manifold?😕
eTiMaGoBangkok, Thailand · Jun 20, 2009#19
Originally Posted by firebob ↑
Ok sure.

But both hoses do not do the same thing.

The set up is to pull in air form before the throttle body through the crankcase and dump it back into the intake. The hose that dumps back into the intake has the check valve. When you let off the gas the throttle body closes down most of the way and the motor would suck air though the crank case and burn off the fumes in the crank case.

But with only one you will only get blow by and a bit of air from the change in the temp as the car heats up and cools down out of that hose. I didn’t see that you had removed the other hose.
+1, mine was originally set up like this too, on the atmospheric pressure hose, and never caught a drop of oil. It's gotta be on the vacuum hose connected to where your stock manifold used to be, as the vacuum in there (off-boost now, obviously) is what will suck the fumes through the system. Otherwise you're just filtering clean air.
eTiMaGoBangkok, Thailand · Jun 20, 2009#20
Originally Posted by yaris-me ↑
I'm confused. The hose from the PCV goes to the intake manifold after the throttle body and there is another hose that goes after the MAF. What is the point in having two? After throttle shut down wouldn't it just circulate air through the hose to the manifold?😕
vacuum sucks, simple as that. There is a difference in pressure on the ends of each hose, so the PCV system works as a kind of restricted bypass
firebobon the road · Jun 20, 2009#21
There are 2 hoses.

#1 goes form the PCV valve that is screwed into the crank case to the intake.
#2 goes form the air intake to the crank case.

In the red box is #1. The black fitting is the PCV valve.
In the green box is where #2 should be. With a stock car this would only see clean air.

1 attachment not included in this copy

TamagoOff Grid · Jun 20, 2009#22
Originally Posted by firebob ↑
There are 2 hoses.

#1 goes form the PCV valve that is screwed into the crank case to the intake.
#2 goes form the air intake to the crank case.

In the red box is #1. The black fitting is the PCV valve.
In the green box is where #2 should be. With a stock car this would only see clean air.

where did you get this information FORM? 😆
firebobon the road · Jun 21, 2009#23
I guess I can’t spell after 11:30 at night after being up all day and drinking a few. 🍻
yarisugiハワイ · Jun 22, 2009#24
What is the inside diameter of the hose that you're connecting it to?
I might do the same, but need to know the inside diameter
marcustoronto, canada · Jun 22, 2009#25
Originally Posted by firebob ↑
There are 2 hoses.

#1 goes form the PCV valve that is screwed into the crank case to the intake.
#2 goes form the air intake to the crank case.

In the red box is #1. The black fitting is the PCV valve.
In the green box is where #2 should be. With a stock car this would only see clean air.
so does this mean we only need one filter which is on the red box.
MorganThread starterPCB, FL · Jun 22, 2009#26
Originally Posted by yarisugi ↑
What is the inside diameter of the hose that you're connecting it to?
I might do the same, but need to know the inside diameter
I had a small length of 3/8" [I think that's the size it was] tubing I put on the filter then put the ventilation hose around that with a zip tie, there's a lot of stretch in that hose once you cut away the protective wrap. But the filter does have a very small inlet and outlet so instead of zip ties a screw clap might be an easier solution.
marcustoronto, canada · Jun 22, 2009#27
anyone confirmed the 5psi drop for using the filter is that affecting any hp at all..
eTiMaGoBangkok, Thailand · Jun 22, 2009#28
Originally Posted by marcus ↑
anyone confirmed the 5psi drop for using the filter is that affecting any hp at all..
It should not, that PCV section is basically just a bypass, any air that is slowed down there will just go through the main intake tubing...
TamagoOff Grid · Jun 22, 2009#29
Originally Posted by marcus ↑
anyone confirmed the 5psi drop for using the filter is that affecting any hp at all..
vacuum is not measured in PSI

what psi drop are we talking about? i guess i should have read the rest of the thread.
marcustoronto, canada · Jun 22, 2009#30
ok thanks etimago..im on this.


psi drop due to oil filters.. which mean itll slow down the air going in the intake but as etimago said wont make a difference.
TamagoOff Grid · Jun 22, 2009#31
Originally Posted by marcus ↑
ok thanks etimago..im on this.


psi drop due to oil filters.. which mean itll slow down the air going in the intake but as etimago said wont make a difference.
psi drop where? where is the psi drop?
marcustoronto, canada · Jun 22, 2009#32
Originally Posted by Tamago ↑
psi drop where? where is the psi drop?
its says so on that specific filter when i went to homedepot/canadiantire to check it out right on the filter itself says it will have " 5 PSI " drop by using it.
TamagoOff Grid · Jun 22, 2009#33
Originally Posted by marcus ↑
its says so on that specific filter when i went to homedepot/canadiantire to check it out right on the filter itself says it will have " 5 PSI " drop by using it.
5psi drop at what air flow?
marcustoronto, canada · Jun 22, 2009#34
Originally Posted by Tamago ↑
5psi drop at what air flow?

the excess air coming from the engine thats being recycled back to the intake. that air is whats being filtered due to oil that goes along with it.
i could be wrong though so check with the person that did this already im still in the process..
TamagoOff Grid · Jun 22, 2009#35
Originally Posted by marcus ↑
the excess air coming from the engine thats being recycled back to the intake. that air is whats being filtered due to oil that goes along with it.
i could be wrong though so check with the person that did this already im still in the process..
psi drops depend on the amount of air being forced thru them. if you were to blow thru the filter with your lungs you would not be able to generate a 5psi pressure drop. it would take an extreme amount of air flow (air compressor) to generate that 5psi drop.

the minimal air coming out of the valve cover is not going to cause a 5psi "drop" in this filter. i'd imagine you'd see no drop at all actually.
marcustoronto, canada · Jun 22, 2009#36
i guess that only apply for air compressors...so i guess it has no effect then..
TamagoOff Grid · Jun 22, 2009#37
yup, you're in the clear! :)
marcustoronto, canada · Jun 22, 2009#38
ill pick it up this weekend..
yarisugiハワイ · Jun 22, 2009#39
OK. I'm throroughly confused. Where does what go where?
Referencing firebob's picture (red square, green square):
RED SQUARE --> hose --> FILTER --> hose goes to where?
GREEN SQUARE --> hose goes to where?
marcustoronto, canada · Jun 22, 2009#40
red
firebobon the road · Jun 22, 2009#41
LOL we have a new run at this fad.

I will say there was one point that I was close to installing on at one point but decided that pulling the hose off the fitting every oil change I could feel for my self without having to modify stuff.
marcustoronto, canada · Jun 22, 2009#42
huh? dont you just need to empty the plastic case anytime you want ofcourse b4 it gets full..
yarisugiハワイ · Jun 22, 2009#43
what?
yarisugiハワイ · Jun 23, 2009#45
Thanks for the link... Do we have a PCV valve on our car?
So the filter goes between the crank case and hose that connects to the intake pipe that's between the throttle body and air cleaner?
firebobon the road · Jun 23, 2009#46
If you look in the RED box off the pic I posted you can see the threads of the PCV valve.

If you look at the link that saplaymate posted the Yaris is set up like the second pic of the motor.
eTiMaGoBangkok, Thailand · Jun 23, 2009#47
another related mod that I have not yet seen anyone do, you can replace the atmospheric pressure hose (the one on the front) with a little breather filter. Absolutely no advantage over the stock setup (and you'd have to plug the hole in the intake tube), but it looks pretty cool

Picture not included in this copy
goliath1812Ocala Florida · Aug 24, 2011#49
sorry for the thread resurrection....but has anyone used this crankcase breather filter? any advantages or disadvantages?
CB900F2Toronto · Aug 24, 2011#50
Hi Morgan.. Can you post a recent photo of the filter?.. Wondering how much oil has been captured by the filter since new.

Thanks


Originally Posted by Morgan ↑
After disassembling my supercharger the last few days I didn't notice any oil in the charge pipes or in the manifold assembly, but to make myself feel better I got a $2.99 see through fuel filter and installed it in the PCV line. When/If it fills up its cheap to change and saves valuable space in the tiny engine bay. Here's a picture:

Picture not included in this copy