Yarisworld Archive

Yaris vs. Camry - Yaris looses

62 posts · 18,170 views · page 1 of 2

TheSilkySmoothOriginal postNew Hampshire · Jun 14, 2009#1
OMG I though our structure was a bit more robust than this, but, this is probably the worst type of offset head-on crash you could get into - only the DS front 1/3 engaged. I don't feel as safe as I did just seeing the standard offset barrier crash test viddy.

Check it:

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=vcTf78b8WfY

Replies 61

TinyGiantRochester, NH · Jun 14, 2009#2
poor yaris.. what a waste lol
john21031Castaic, CA · Jun 14, 2009#3
this has been discussed before many times... small cars dont do well against heavy ones in these kinds of crashes...
supmetSouthern California · Jun 14, 2009#4
Originally Posted by TinyGiant ↑
poor yaris.. what a waste lol
Exactly. Why waste money testing a one in a million accident. Both drivers would have to be asleep to not attempt ANY correction, and then still it is a slim chance to line up their forces perfectly opposite of each other. If either car had their course set 1 degree off of that test, the results would have been far less catastrophic.

Also, I don't feel like looking for camry vs 4000 lb vehicle collisions, but I don't think you're walking away from a head on with 7 series or a suburban with just a few bruises.
TheSilkySmoothThread starterNew Hampshire · Jun 14, 2009#5
Originally Posted by john21031 ↑
this has been discussed before many times... small cars dont do well against heavy ones in these kinds of crashes...
Camry isnt that heavy, maybe 3400lbs? Prob = a 50mph barrier crash.
Yaris HiltonBristol, Tennessee, USA · Jun 14, 2009#6
No. The cars were both going 40 MPH, so if they were of equal mass it would be like an 80 MPH single vehicle collision. But because the Camry is ~1000 lbs heavier than the Yaris, they don't stop equally quickly. The Yaris is driven backward instead of coming to a halt, and therefore it's like a considerably faster barrier collision. 100 MPH, say.

The same physics apply with the Camry vs. a big Toyota pickup, or that pickup against a larger truck...
roxy1michigan · Jun 14, 2009#7
Originally Posted by supmet ↑
Exactly. Why waste money testing a one in a million accident. Both drivers would have to be asleep to not attempt ANY correction.
sorry, but to call these types of crashes one in a million is a little ignorant.

drunk driving fatalities often occur very similar to this, where the drunk driver, without any notice to the oncoming car, veers across the center line. same goes for drowsy drivers, distracted drivers, etc...leaving the other driver little or no time to make any correction. those type of drunk driving fatalities were part of the impetus for these crash tests in europe. 100% identical. no, but these offset crash test come very close to simulating those types of crashes.

from the IIHS Status Report, 2007.

A disproportionate number of fatal
crashes occur on rural roads, and most
such crashes occur on two-lane roads. A
major problem on these roads involves
vehicles crossing the centerlines and striking
opposing traffic. Crashes like these
account for about 20 percent of all fatal
crashes on rural two-lane roads. Approximately
4,500 deaths occur annually in
such collisions.


we all have to face the fact if we are in a head on or offset collision at even a moderate speed we have a decent chance of either dying instantly or being crippled and/or brain damaged for life. there are very few cars we would collide with that would afford us the opportunity to fare better than that in a head on crash.

as a small car driver i have always been very cognizant of this and am very dilligent in driving with the attitude that every driver on the road could be an idiot.
supmetSouthern California · Jun 14, 2009#8
Originally Posted by roxy1 ↑
sorry, but to call these types of crashes one in a million is a little ignorant.
Wow a bunch of numbers that do nothing to show how often cars hit with exactly opposite forces, thanks!

Here is something from wiki that's actually useful:

# Head-on collision (123,000 crashes, only 2.0% of all US crashes, but 10.1% of US fatal crashes)

2% is low, but how many of those are exactly opposite vectors of each other?? 1% maybe? Probably less? I used 1 in a million before as an idiom, but it may not be far off.
TheSilkySmoothThread starterNew Hampshire · Jun 14, 2009#9
Originally Posted by Yaris Hilton ↑
No. The cars were both going 40 MPH, so if they were of equal mass it would be like an 80 MPH single vehicle collision.
You are incorrect here, Mr. Hilton. Simple physics, Newton's third law/conservation of momentum. If both vehicles weighed the same (Mass a=b) and they were traveling the same velocity and collided head on - this situation would be equivalent to a single vehicle collision into an immovable barrier (the Dozer in Vanishing Point?). What added to the structural damage is the 1/3 offset and the 1/2 tonne extra mass of the Camry. Without going through the calculus, I estimate a 50mph barrier collision. The Yaris damage in this trial isnt that much worse than vehicle structures 10 years ago; survivable but with injuries. Still ugly.
cleongSingapore · Jun 14, 2009#10
In this case, the Yaris wins.

It handles better, and can get you out of a dangerous situation instead of relying on its crash stars. Note how the Camry loses control, the Yaris is on the inside line of the Camry, and still retains enough control to brake in the same distance it takes the Camry to spin to a halt.
texkidSugar Land, TX · Jun 14, 2009#11
Originally Posted by supmet ↑
Wow a bunch of numbers that do nothing to show how often cars hit with exactly opposite forces, thanks!

Here is something from wiki that's actually useful:

# Head-on collision (123,000 crashes, only 2.0% of all US crashes, but 10.1% of US fatal crashes)

2% is low, but how many of those are exactly opposite vectors of each other?? 1% maybe? Probably less? I used 1 in a million before as an idiom, but it may not be far off.
Well, look at the rate of crashed Yaris owners on this forum. We're up to 7, I believe? One of them ended up in the ICU. The number of yaris owners that post on this forum is a just a SMALL fraction of the total number of Yaris owners in the US from '06 to '09 models. Therefore, I bet there is some Yaris owner out there that did get into a really bad head on collision that we don't know about.

Besides, I would like for you to keep up that smug attitude if you were to have to explain to a mother how her child was the "1 in a million" that died in the collision.

Another thing is that when they test these types of accidents, they want to see how the car will handle in an absolute worst case scenario (e.g. head on collisions and t-bones).
TheSilkySmoothThread starterNew Hampshire · Jun 14, 2009#13
I am not promoting heavier cars, I have driven sub-compacts for most of my life. They are maneuverable and can help a good driver AVOID an accident. Down with H2's, no Trailblaizers, No Yukons, No Ford Explorers, Expeditions, Excursions. etc! (I dont want them to hit me!)
leasaunceSydney, Australia · Jun 14, 2009#14
check out the headlight! weeee!
SilverBackEl Monte, Ca · Jun 14, 2009#15
See my comment on the first vid
SailDesign. · Jun 14, 2009#16
Originally Posted by supmet ↑
Here is something from wiki that's actually useful:

# Head-on collision (123,000 crashes, only 2.0% of all US crashes, but 10.1% of US fatal crashes)
So, using those numbers at face value, you are 5 times more likely to die in a head-on crash than in any other. Which is about what you would expect from the carnage in the video. One of the drivers, at least, would have died.
SandwashSo. Arizona, USA · Jun 14, 2009#17
Originally Posted by supmet ↑
Exactly. Why waste money testing a one in a million accident. Both drivers would have to be asleep to not attempt ANY correction, and then still it is a slim chance to line up their forces perfectly opposite of each other. If either car had their course set 1 degree off of that test, the results would have been far less catastrophic.

Also, I don't feel like looking for camry vs 4000 lb vehicle collisions, but I don't think you're walking away from a head on with 7 series or a suburban with just a few bruises.
Yes - thank you; there is risk to driving/living, and good news is that risk can be reduced via consciousness and action. Drive well/alert and chances are we'll likely live to life expectancy, at least.
Red HorseCosta mesa, California · Jun 15, 2009#18
Toyota should move the Yaris driver seat in the center :)
roxy1michigan · Jun 15, 2009#19
Originally Posted by supmet ↑
Wow a bunch of numbers that do nothing to show how often cars hit with exactly opposite forces, thanks!

Here is something from wiki that's actually useful:

# Head-on collision................but 10.1% of US fatal crashes)

2% is low, but how many of those are exactly opposite vectors of each other?? .
sarcastic and smug all at once...are you sure you dont drive a prius?

so, one out of every 50 crashes is a head on collision. head on crashes are going to be quite often opposite vectors of each other.

you just cited information that contradicts your "1 in a million" idea. then you ask a question that my useless statistics already gave you the answer to. the head on crashes are precisely the crashes that make up a good chunk of the fatalities.

head on crashes may make up 2% of all crashes in the u.s. but the fact that head on crashes make up for 10% of fatal crashes is very disproportionate.

so, of the 40,000 fatal crashes per year in the U.S., 4000 of them are due to head on collisions.

trees make up another 8% of all fatal crashes, and certainly many of those are of the head on variety.

so, clearly more than 1 in 50 crashes are of the head on variety. to argue about how precisely offset the crashes are is not productive. a head on crash in any car has a disproportionate chance of ending in a fatality compared to all crashes, and having it happen in a yaris wont make those odds better.

however, the point that driving a smaller, more nimble car can help one avoid crashes in the first place is valid, so there are advantages to a car like the yaris that crash tests, of course, cannot measure.
roxy1michigan · Jun 15, 2009#20
Originally Posted by Red Horse ↑
Toyota should move the Yaris driver seat in the center :)
...and to the back seat. just need a steering wheel that telescopes 4 feet.
supmetSouthern California · Jun 15, 2009#21
Originally Posted by roxy1 ↑

so, one out of every 50 crashes is a head on collision.

so, clearly more than 1 in 50 crashes are of the head on variety.
I don't argue with people that forget where they are going by the end of their own paragraph.(or people that consider trees head on collisions)
TamagoOff Grid · Jun 15, 2009#22
driving lessons are a better way to spend your money than buying a heavier car :)

a majority of accidents happen when the driver of one or both vehicles is screwing around "not" driving.. radio, makeup, smoking, reading, talking on the phone.... it's just a shame when the irresponsible driver takes out the guy who was paying attention but couldn't react quickly enough
POORSHANE CT · Jun 15, 2009#23
Hate to mention it, but there was a video of a smart vs mercedes. The smart did ok.
TamagoOff Grid · Jun 15, 2009#24
Originally Posted by POORSHA ↑
Hate to mention it, but there was a video of a smart vs mercedes. The smart did ok.
the smart has always done well. no surprise there.
supmetSouthern California · Jun 15, 2009#25
Originally Posted by Tamago ↑
the smart has always done well. no surprise there.
The smart did ok. What about the passengers? I'm still a firm believer in the necessity of crumple zones.

There's a video of the smart running into a concrete barrier, and then the guy is like "oh look how well built the smart is! the passenger door still opens!". Everyone would have died in that car.
TamagoOff Grid · Jun 15, 2009#26
Originally Posted by supmet ↑
The smart

There's a video of the smart running into a concrete barrier, and then the guy is like "oh look how well built the smart is! the passenger door still opens!". Everyone would have died in that car.
please name ANY car where the passengers would survive an 70mph head on impact. and don't take that video out of context. the commentator stated in the video that no one would have made it out alive.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=KJnWSUhjp0g
supmetSouthern California · Jun 15, 2009#27
Originally Posted by Tamago ↑
please name ANY car where the passengers would survive an 70mph head on impact.
I googled 70 mph collision, and this was the first link that wasn't about the smart test 😲

http://news.sky.com/skynews/Home/Str...00811315153872
roxy1michigan · Jun 15, 2009#28
Originally Posted by supmet ↑
I don't argue with people that forget where they are going by the end of their own paragraph.(or people that consider trees head on collisions)
reading is a skill. since some frontal collisions with trees and other solid barriers are obviously head on collisions, and car on car head on collisions make up for 1 in 50 of crashes, then obviously more than 1 in 50 crashes are of the head on variety.

physics will clearly show that hitting a tree head on will impart more damage than two cars hitting each other going 25 mph.

the abilities of a car to withstand these types of crash tests has relevance in the context of any type of head on collision regardless of the object.

they are not "wasting their money testing a 1 in a million accident"

sorry you dont consider these types of crashes as head on collisions. i do:

Picture not included in this copy
TamagoOff Grid · Jun 15, 2009#29
Originally Posted by roxy1 ↑
reading is a skill. since some frontal collisions with trees and other solid barriers are obviously head on collisions, and car on car head on collisions make up for 1 in 50 of crashes, then obviously more than 1 in 50 crashes are of the head on variety.
why are you two arguing about this?
TheRealEnthMiami, FL · Jun 15, 2009#30
cars crash.. people die.... dont worry about statistics.... just try to be a good driver.... if someone else was the bad driver and u got f**ked over.. then thats life.... end it
roxy1michigan · Jun 15, 2009#31
Originally Posted by Tamago ↑
why are you two arguing about this?
you are right. i wasted a good six minutes of my life rebutting a statement that was ludicrous in the first place. from now on i will let ignorant statements stand on their own.

i should have known better then to get dragged down.

shame on me
TamagoOff Grid · Jun 15, 2009#32
Originally Posted by roxy1 ↑
you are right. i wasted a good six minutes of my life rebutting a statement that was ludicrous in the first place. from now on i will let ignorant statements stand on their own.

i should have known better then to get dragged down.

shame on me
the shame is all yours! (by the way i do this too, all the time 😢)
roxy1michigan · Jun 15, 2009#33
Originally Posted by supmet ↑
The smart did ok. What about the passengers? I'm still a firm believer in the necessity of crumple zones.

There's a video of the smart running into a concrete barrier, and then the guy is like "oh look how well built the smart is! the passenger door still opens!". Everyone would have died in that car.
ill make nice and agree with supmet on this. deceleration plays havoc with internal organs of the body and head. while the cage of the smart might keep the interior of the car intact, the deceleration would have to be made worse by lack of much in the way of a crumple zone.
TamagoOff Grid · Jun 15, 2009#34
Originally Posted by roxy1 ↑
ill make nice and agree with supmet on this. deceleration plays havoc with internal organs of the body and head. while the cage of the smart might keep the interior of the car intact, the deceleration would have to be made worse by lack of much in the way of a crumple zone.
i'd rather die with my legs intact than live with my lower body crushed by the dash/steering column.

living without legs is not living.
Yaris HiltonBristol, Tennessee, USA · Jun 15, 2009#35
Originally Posted by TheSilkySmooth ↑
You are incorrect here, Mr. Hilton. Simple physics, Newton's third law/conservation of momentum. If both vehicles weighed the same (Mass a=b) and they were traveling the same velocity and collided head on - this situation would be equivalent to a single vehicle collision into an immovable barrier (the Dozer in Vanishing Point?). What added to the structural damage is the 1/3 offset and the 1/2 tonne extra mass of the Camry. Without going through the calculus, I estimate a 50mph barrier collision. The Yaris damage in this trial isnt that much worse than vehicle structures 10 years ago; survivable but with injuries. Still ugly.
You are totally incorrect, from start to finish.
TamagoOff Grid · Jun 15, 2009#36
Originally Posted by Yaris Hilton ↑
You are totally incorrect, from start to finish.
hahahahaha PWND

silkysmooth, give this a try. run into a wall at 10mph

then run into a buddy who's also running 10mph at you

let us know which one hurts more
supmetSouthern California · Jun 15, 2009#37
Originally Posted by roxy1 ↑
reading is a skill. since some frontal collisions with trees and other solid barriers are obviously head on collisions, and car on car head on collisions make up for 1 in 50 of crashes, then obviously more than 1 in 50 crashes are of the head on variety.
And that has what context to me talking about 2 cars hitting head on, with perfectly oppositely aligned forces. That is the ONLY thing my original post was about - any real world situation, someone will attempt correction, giving a tangent to the force, rather than having it crumple the entire vehicle from being perfectly aligned. You chose to start talking about trees and crap, which is pretty much when I stopped trying to understand what you were talking about.

Originally Posted by roxy1 ↑
physics will clearly show that hitting a tree head on will impart more damage than two cars hitting each other going 25 mph.
A car going how fast hitting the tree? And lets just pull some more random numbers out of nowhere to confuse the situation more.
Originally Posted by roxy1 ↑
the abilities of a car to withstand these types of crash tests has relevance in the context of any type of head on collision regardless of the object.
Sort of true, but more useful data could be obtained from more realistic tests.

Originally Posted by tamago
why are you two arguing about this?
are you new to the idea of internet forums?
ZaphodSomewhere in the vacinity of Betelgeuse · Jun 15, 2009#38
Originally Posted by TheRealEnth ↑
cars crash.. people die.... dont worry about statistics.... just try to be a good driver.... if someone else was the bad driver and u got f**ked over.. then thats life.... end it
Neverway! You should embrace the roadrage and play chicken with oncoming traffic on the highway like there's no tomorrow.
TheSilkySmoothThread starterNew Hampshire · Jun 15, 2009#39
Originally Posted by Yaris Hilton ↑
You are totally incorrect, from start to finish.
Back to school, the whole lot of you! You guys probably think a ten pound weight falls faster than a 3 pound weight. Flat-earthers ...
SailDesign. · Jun 15, 2009#40
Originally Posted by TheSilkySmooth ↑
Back to school, the whole lot of you! You guys probably think a ten pound weight falls faster than a 3 pound weight. Flat-earthers ...
I'll bet my 10-pound cannon ball falls faster than your 3-pound pillow. 😁
TamagoOff Grid · Jun 15, 2009#41
Originally Posted by TheSilkySmooth ↑
Back to school, the whole lot of you! You guys probably think a ten pound weight falls faster than a 3 pound weight. Flat-earthers ...
we're not talking about acceleration here dude, just simple math
TheSilkySmoothThread starterNew Hampshire · Jun 15, 2009#42
Maybe there is ONE eductaed individual out there.
Q: Given the Law of conservation of Energy(And the First law of Thermodynamics), when two cars collide head on and stop moving, what happens to the Kinetic Energy?
supmetSouthern California · Jun 15, 2009#43
Originally Posted by TheSilkySmooth ↑
eductaed
I'm gonna pee my pants 🤣
TheSilkySmoothThread starterNew Hampshire · Jun 15, 2009#44
Originally Posted by Tamago ↑
we're not talking about acceleration here dude, just simple math
Math? We are solving a physics Equation, you must know the Physical Laws of Nature before you can proceed.

I have no hope for the World anymore; Idiocracy Rules!
TheSilkySmoothThread starterNew Hampshire · Jun 15, 2009#45
Originally Posted by supmet ↑
I'm gonna pee my pants 🤣
Hey, that's LATIN😳
TheSilkySmoothThread starterNew Hampshire · Jun 15, 2009#46
Originally Posted by SailDesign ↑
I'll bet my 10-pound cannon ball falls faster than your 3-pound pillow. 😁
Wont bet you on that one😉
mikenacaratoBrentwood, TN · Jun 15, 2009#47
you know...to this day...i dont think ive seen silkysmooth post one thing that makes sense and is a correct statement
1NZYaris1New Zealand · Jun 15, 2009#48
Originally Posted by Tamago ↑
hahahahaha PWND

silkysmooth, give this a try. run into a wall at 10mph

then run into a buddy who's also running 10mph at you

let us know which one hurts more

I can answer that one , 😁 i suffered a serious head injury 2.5yr's ago
from doing just that , except it was a steel beam 😳, and accordding to the doctors , and speacialist's it's worse than a 100mph crash.
three contusion's and neck and shoulder damage , 3 operations
last one 8 weeks ago and another in 5 weeks .
if you are worried about getting hurt stay of the roads 👍
and i am yet to return too work
Twistoffate0817Voorhees, NJ · Jun 16, 2009#49
Of course the yaris would get more damaged...
highwaypassJakarta · Jun 16, 2009#50
brother vs bigger brother 😁