Yarisworld Archive

Considering Yaris vs. Elantra

64 posts · 24,905 views · page 1 of 2

businezguyOriginal postPennsylvania · Jun 12, 2009#1
The alternator on my Ford Focus ZTS (purchased by my wife prior to our marriage) has died, and was replaced by another dead alternator a couple of years ago. In addition, I had to do extensive repairs to fix an issue with the car overheating, and it's beginning to demonstrate the same issue as before. Needless to say, with only 98k on it, I'm fed up and need to replace this car ASAP (the next two the three weeks at the latest). I am forced to drive my wife's 1995 Ford Explorer getting 19 MPG driving 55 MPH.

I'm trying to decide between an Elantra and a Yaris, and I've pretty much made a decision to go with the Yaris. While the Elantra has by far the best interior of the two, and quite honestly is the better vehicle overall, I love the minimalism of the Yaris, and most importantly the better MPG I'll get from it. There is nothing I would love more then to spend less of my money overseas supporting terrorism and saving about $50 a month at $2.50 per gallon.

So I need your help! I would be getting the base Sedan with the convenience and power package, and added on Bluetooth. However, can somebody break down all of the storage compartments that come with this car? I do a lot of commuting (132 miles round trip 5 days a week) and need to have storage readily available for my MP3 player, toll money, cell phone, organizer (can put that in the glove compartment), etc. Also, I love a huge thing of coffee during my commute. How large of a cup could I fit in the cup holder that's in front of the air vent? Could I for example fit a 1 quart bottle of Gatorade in it as an example?

Sorry for all of the questions, I am going to be making me purchase soon, and this will be the first new car purchase I'll make (paying cash so I'll own it outright).

Thanks!

Replies 63

rningonfumesSoCal · Jun 12, 2009#2
Storage:
Non-locking glove box,
arm rest (small),
pockets behind the driver and passenger seats
coin box underneath the driver's cup holder.
and Valet locking Trunk-60/40 folding rear seats(they don't fold flat.

Cupholders:
two on dash-- under the vents-can hold up to a large/xltra large of Carl's Jr/Hardee's drink cup.
Driver's and front passenger has an indentation in the lower door pocket that can hold the standard water bottle.
Rear of the arm rest is one more cup holder that flips out.


It looks like you've done your homework. I would pick one or the other of the packages to save money. I hope you are thinking of the manual too-- more money saved. The advantage of the Yaris over the Elantra is the price.... don't option out the Yaris any where near the price of the Elantra. If we were talking Hyundai competitor for the Yaris, it would be the Accent.

When you say you're going to save 50 bucks a month, I'm going to assume you mean over the Focus and not the Explorer. I say you're gonna save a lot more than that if you drive it right.

How large a laptop do you have? Bare with no bag, it should fit with other things in the glove box.

I hope I addressed most of your concerns, Good luck on either car.

Feel free to ask more questions.
businezguyThread starterPennsylvania · Jun 12, 2009#3
Originally Posted by rningonfumes ↑
Storage:
Non-locking glove box,
arm rest (small),
pockets behind the driver and passenger seats
coin box underneath the driver's cup holder.
and Valet locking Trunk-60/40 folding rear seats(they don't fold flat.

Cupholders:
two on dash-- under the vents-can hold up to a large/xltra large of Carl's Jr/Hardee's drink cup.
Driver's and front passenger has an indentation in the lower door pocket that can hold the standard water bottle.
Rear of the arm rest is one more cup holder that flips out.


It looks like you've done your homework. I would pick one or the other of the packages to save money. I hope you are thinking of the manual too-- more money saved. The advantage of the Yaris over the Elantra is the price.... don't option out the Yaris any where near the price of the Elantra. If we were talking Hyundai competitor for the Yaris, it would be the Accent.

When you say you're going to save 50 bucks a month, I'm going to assume you mean over the Focus and not the Explorer. I say you're gonna save a lot more than that if you drive it right.

How large a laptop do you have? Bare with no bag, it should fit with other things in the glove box.

I hope I addressed most of your concerns, Good luck on either car.

Feel free to ask more questions.
Thanks for the information you've provided, much appreciated. I read on some threads that folks were losing coins that were going behind the dashboard when storing them somewhere. Does the coin holder you describe have that issue?

As for the price, I need to get the automatic transmission and power package. Since the Yaris has no incentives and the Elantra does, a comparably equipped Elantra with more features standard, actually costs a few hundred dollars less. However, I figured that I would save about $50 in gas per month with the Yaris vs. the Elantra because I drive so much. VS. the Explorer I'll be saving about $232 per month. VS the Focus I'll be saving about $78 per month. All of this is assuming $2.50 for gas of course. If gas goes up, the savings obviously go up as well.

I have a large laptop bag, so I'll just put my laptop in the rear of the car while commuting and obviously if I stop that the market or something on the way home, throw it in the trunk. I'm more concerned with what to do with my toll money, MP3 player, and cell phone. Believe me, when it comes to toll money especially, I feel like I risk life and limb just to get the correct change for the toll.
scapeBeaufort, South Carolina · Jun 12, 2009#4
like you said, the elantra is better build quality; tbh the corolla might be a closer match of comparison shopping-- notwithstanding, i still like my yaris ;D
but highway driving does get a bit hairy sometimes, this car is so light (and the hatchback is so tall!)
scapeBeaufort, South Carolina · Jun 12, 2009#5
oh, and yes the cup holders are awesome in this car! haha
businezguyThread starterPennsylvania · Jun 12, 2009#6
Originally Posted by voodoo22 ↑
One thing to consider if you do a lot of highway driving at higher speeds is the handling of the two cars.

You will find the Yaris does not handle so well at highway speeds, on uneven surfaces or crosswinds. Although it's better for the sedan vs the hatch, this is definitely an important thing to compare between the two cars before you buy. I never go over 55 mph and find the handling good enough, but a couple times a crosswind has nearly blown me out of my lane.

If you stick at 55mph; like you state; you will get about 45-50 MPG in the Yaris auto. I am unfamiliar with the Hyundai, but can guarantee you will not come close to that with the Elantra AT.
I'm sure this is the case, and I'm sure the Elantra would not be effected nearly as much as the Yaris, so I'll keep that in mind. But it also occurs to me that having had to drive the Ford Explorer for the past couple of weeks I ran into that issue once. Nothing like driving a tall, huge box. It's quite possible the Ford Explorer would be worse in that respect then the Yaris.

When I do a test drive, I'll have to try going 65 MPH on the highway. It's not like I plan to stick to 55 MPH ALL of the time.
businezguyThread starterPennsylvania · Jun 12, 2009#7
Originally Posted by scape ↑
like you said, the elantra is better build quality; tbh the corolla might be a closer match of comparison shopping-- notwithstanding, i still like my yaris ;D
but highway driving does get a bit hairy sometimes, this car is so light (and the hatchback is so tall!)
I've basically decided that saving $50 per month on gas is more important then the significantly better interior/design of the Elantra. I believe the Elantra would be about 20% less efficient in gas then would be the Yaris (despite EPA estimates stating only a 10% difference).

I really want to be hitting the high 40's to low 50's in this vehicle. I'm looking forward to saving some serious $$$ so I have more money to spend on myself. 👍
businezguyThread starterPennsylvania · Jun 12, 2009#8
So I just sent in a counter offer on a 2008 Yaris sedan this dealer still has in their lot. Obviously I'll get a better deal for that car then I would a '09 model, and my last attempt at getting more from the dealer is to have free bluetooth installed.

Anyway, I am expecting the offer to be accepted, and I just looked everywhere and realized that I have lost my driver's license after coming back from vacation in Florida. I'm so pissed! I have no idea where my birth certificate and marriage license are, and I doubt I'll find them over the next couple of days.

Now I'm trying to figure out, do I need to have my driver's license to buy a new car? This is so ridiculous!
GooseOhio cornfields · Jun 12, 2009#9
I'm not sure if you'll get in "the high 40's to low 50's" on the highway with the Yaris. Although people have posted that they've gotten above 40MPG highway, you'll be happier if you set your expectations at around 40MPG.

The Yaris is one of the best values on the market. Although Hyundai has been making great strides lately, their lower resale value tends to wipe out any savings up front. I recently dumped a new Genesis Coupe for another Yaris due to poor customer service from Hyundai - although your experience with Hyundai might be better. Based on my experience, I think Toyota has more advanced powertrains than Hyundai, too.

Based on your storage requirements, you may have to create some storage for change, etc because the Yaris sedan doesn't have many storage areas in the dash. Check the storage gadget section of your local auto parts store - you can find many things (like ashtrays) that can be used to store change for the commute.

EDIT: I'm not sure about needing a driver's license to buy in PA, but I'll bet you'll need to have it (especially if you're going to finance).
businezguyThread starterPennsylvania · Jun 12, 2009#10
I'm actually going to pay cash, so I'm not sure I'll need it. Obviously I'll need it so when/if I get pulled over I don't get a ticket, but I don't want to let it hold me back from making a purchase.

As for MPG, I was able to average 34 MPG in a 2002 Ford Focus ZTS. This is a car that is supposed to only get 29 MPG highway, and only 25 MPG combined, and believe me with today's EPA estimates, the MPG should really be lower then that. I should also add that this car has had issues with overheating, and really needed a tune up lately (I was getting more like 36 MPG last year around this time).

I have very high expectations for the Yaris, and would be very disappointed if I got less then 45 MPG. I am willing to drive very conservatively to get the best milage I can.
AlexNet0Rockland, ME · Jun 12, 2009#11
I have very high expectations for the Yaris, and would be very disappointed if I got less then 45 MPG. I am willing to drive very conservatively to get the best milage I can.
if you are willing to follow the fuel economy forum and hypermiling tips to the letter, then expect 45+.

Drive normally, and expect 35-42.

Try to drive fast, get 30.

All are better than most vehicles
businezguyThread starterPennsylvania · Jun 12, 2009#12
Originally Posted by AlexNet0 ↑
if you are willing to follow the fuel economy forum and hypermiling tips to the letter, then expect 45+.

Drive normally, and expect 35-42.

Try to drive fast, get 30.

All are better than most vehicles
I'm wondering what I can expect by setting the cruise control to 55 MPH and leaving it at that. I really hope I can get well over 45 MPG by doing that.
rbellWalworth, NY · Jun 12, 2009#13
Gald to see you're picking the Toyota. I just purchased a Yaris 3dr hb 3 weeks ago. I don't have any issues tooling around between 70-75 mph. I think it handles fine. Previous vehicle was a 2004 Tacoma. It now has 225,000 on it. I only had to replace the front brakes and change oils and fluids. Toyota quality is fantastic. Hate to be harsh, but I wouldn't consider buying a Hyundai or KIA piece of crap.
id3379Jun 12, 2009#14
Originally Posted by voodoo22 ↑
One thing to consider if you do a lot of highway driving at higher speeds is the handling of the two cars.

You will find the Yaris does not handle so well at highway speeds, on uneven surfaces or crosswinds. Although it's better for the sedan vs the hatch, this is definitely an important thing to compare between the two cars before you buy. I never go over 55 mph and find the handling good enough, but a couple times a crosswind has nearly blown me out of my lane.

If you stick at 55mph; like you state; you will get about 45-50 MPG in the Yaris auto. I am unfamiliar with the Hyundai, but can guarantee you will not come close to that with the Elantra AT.
The sedan does not do well when there's alot of wind on the highway too, it gets scary at some points with stock sus/wheels.
supmetSouthern California · Jun 12, 2009#15
Originally Posted by scape ↑
the elantra is better build quality
🙄

Look up some resale values on similar toyotas and hyundais with similar miles. Hyundai doesn't know the meaning of the word quality.
businezguyThread starterPennsylvania · Jun 12, 2009#16
Basically all but 4 miles of my commute is highway miles. I'll run into problems many times with traffic jams for a few of those miles, however. Still, if I leave early enough, that doesn't happen that often, and I almost never hit a traffic jam at all on my way home. That is one of the reasons why I have high expectations for my MPG.

I realize this is a forum for the Toyota Yaris, and I obviously am steering towards that as my choice. However, I will give accolades where they are due. The Elantra has a longer record then most cars on the road today, and it is proven very reliable, and equaled the Yaris in reliability. It also has a much better quality interior, and actually has more space then even a Yaris.

Somebody above stated that the drive train in the Yaris is more advanced then the Elantra, and that is very accurate. The other major advantage the Yaris has is MPG.

As a personal opinion, the Elantra is SO smooth, comfortable, and refined that it makes me feel like I'm driving a large luxury sedan to an extent, whereas the Yaris makes me feel like I have a basic commuting car that is more fun to drive, and handles better on country roads. This is all based on having test drove both a couple of times.
rbellWalworth, NY · Jun 12, 2009#17
Hyundai has made a great deal of progress since the late 80s early 90s. I just don't think they're there yet. I looked at the sedan before deciding on the hatchback. I thought the sedan was descent. It all depends on how much you want to spend. There is a big difference between a base model and a model with packaged equipment. My Yaris is a base model so I realize its going to ride a little bumpy, it's not going to have a great sound system, and maybe it's going to be a bit noisy. But for what I need it for, it's fine. If ride and style were important to me, I would have looked at a Camry, or even a Volkswagen Jetta.
businezguyThread starterPennsylvania · Jun 12, 2009#18
I agree that Hyundai has made a lot of progress, but they have yet to match Toyota. For instance the Elantra is a very solid vehicle, and it's reliability would certainly compete with the Yaris. But the Entourage is an unreliable piece of crap, and the Sonata is behind in reliability standards compared to the Camry and Accord.

I would go for the base model with the roll down windows and the manual transmission, but my wife has some medical issues that would preclude her from driving the car if I didn't go with those options. Also, I will never buy a new car that does not have an aux jack. That simply isn't an option for me.
roxy1michigan · Jun 13, 2009#19
Originally Posted by businezguy ↑
I agree that Hyundai has made a lot of progress, but they have yet to match Toyota. For instance the Elantra is a very solid vehicle, and it's reliability would certainly compete with the Yaris. .
we'll see about that, but i doubt it. when i switched from my yaris to the new corolla, i test drove the elantra quite a bit. i actually felt it has a nicer interior than the corolla. but, the corolla was quieter on the road and just felt smoother. epa mileage was higher for the corolla, though i beat those numbers easily anyway. i was disappointed to find alot of elantra drivers getting disappointing mileage. i think hyundai doesnt quite compete with their engines as far as fuel efficiency and overall refinement goes.

my minimum expectation for any car in the class of the corolla/elantra or below is that 40 mpg is easily achieved with mostly highway driving. with the yaris and corolla, this criteria was easily met in real world driving for me.
jambo101Montreal Canada · Jun 13, 2009#20
You'll be happy you bought the Toyota when it comes to trading it in or selling it some years in the future as the resale value on the Toyota will be double what it would be on the Hyundai.
auxmikeLI, New Yawk · Jun 13, 2009#21
Comparing a base level Yaris to an Elantra is like apples and oranges.
Seems like Corolla vs. Elantra is more like it.
Perhaps Hyundai has gotten better, but it's still a ...Hyundai!
Resale value drops like a rock.Sorry, but I love telling folks I drive a TOYOTA.
Also, I know three people who had TRanny failures (A/T) , one at under 36k!
😲
businezguyThread starterPennsylvania · Jun 13, 2009#22
Originally Posted by auxmike ↑
Comparing a base level Yaris to an Elantra is like apples and oranges.
Seems like Corolla vs. Elantra is more like it.
Perhaps Hyundai has gotten better, but it's still a ...Hyundai!
Resale value drops like a rock.Sorry, but I love telling folks I drive a TOYOTA.
Also, I know three people who had TRanny failures (A/T) , one at under 36k!
😲
The reason I'm comparing the two is because the Elantra comes with $2k in rebates. Currently I was quoted $15,183 for an Elantra compared to $16,520 for a Yaris with everything I want. The Yaris costs $1,400 more then the Elantra!

What I'm getting at is that I'm comparing the two due to the price. I'm finding it hard to justify the extra cost of the Yaris, but I'm still seriously considering it. I'm just disappointed by the higher pricing of the Yaris right now.

If you want me to compare the pricing of the Elantra with the Corolla I think we know where that would go. Ironically, I'm pretty sure I could get a Corolla for a bit more then the quotes I'm getting for the Yaris. It's a frustrating experience right now.
TinyGiantRochester, NH · Jun 13, 2009#23
i paid less than that on my yaris and i added the paint/interior protection, spoiler, and some other stuff

wait till the last day of the month like 4 hours from closing and then go talk price. the dealers have quotas they need to fill.. play hardball. there are people on the forums paying 12-13k for a brand new yaris
TinyGiantRochester, NH · Jun 13, 2009#24
bring quotes from out of state dealers too.. you can always tell them "look i could drive two states over and pay $X. But i would rather buy local ..so what are you going to do for me?"
scapeBeaufort, South Carolina · Jun 13, 2009#25
i waited til july 4th or 5th, expecting some kind of deal... no such thing with toyota haha.
either way, corolla is much more comparable to an elantra, and the corolla will get awesome gas mileage as well, and much, much better resale (it appeals to new families as well as singles of almost all ages). i still like my yaris though ;D

if you're so uncertain about buying, lease for 2 years, a yaris lease is like 100$/mo or something silly...it's a complete waste of money, but hey if you really like the car you can always pay it off to keep it.
businezguyThread starterPennsylvania · Jun 13, 2009#26
For the record, I wouldn't be frustrated if it wasn't for the fact that I loved the Yaris. I love the car, it's just that in the current environment the car is actually costing more then other cars, and is actually appearing to cost almost as much as the Corolla.

I'm really not concerned about resale or trade in value. I will drive the car into the ground. I want to have this car for at least 200k miles, and would love to get 250k to 300k out of it. Even with all I've stated, I'm STILL considering the Yaris.

I think that those who are getting these cars for 12 to 13k are getting less features then I am.

I don't remember if I mentioned this or not and I don't feel like reading everything I wrote, but my wife has MS and she doesn't always have the best motor function as a result. So I need a car with automatic door locks/windows, and an automatic transmission. If it wasn't for that, I'd be considering a manual transmission to save on the price.

Correct me if I'm wrong, but with a manual transmission wouldn't I expect even better gas milage?
supmetSouthern California · Jun 13, 2009#27
Originally Posted by businezguy ↑
I'm really not concerned about resale or trade in value. I will drive the car into the ground. I want to have this car for at least 200k miles, and would love to get 250k to 300k out of it.
Well you just made a decision on a yaris then. Elantras WILL NOT make it to 200k without rebuilding the entire thing. A yaris will.
GooseOhio cornfields · Jun 13, 2009#28
I've owned both manual and auto versions of the Yaris and I don't think there's much mileage difference between the two.

If trade-in value makes no difference (such as driving it into the ground), the Toyota product still wins against the Hyundai. While I'm sure the Hyundai product is solid, Toyota has probably the best proven track record for reliability. Add a huge dealer network compared to Hyundai, and Toyota wins if you would ever need service.

You're right about not being able to get a Yaris sedan with power windows/locks for $13K. It would be interesting to see what price difference there is between a somewhat loaded Yaris sedan and a bare-bones Corolla. Depending on the dealer, it may be a toss-up as to which of these options would be cheaper. If mileage is your top priority, though, the Yaris beats the Corolla.

EDIT: A quick search of Cars.com listings in my area yielded interesting info on the auto+pwr Yaris sedan/basic Corolla price difference. Both examples are advertised at $16,500! If I had to guess, I'll bet the margin is bigger on the Corolla and you might be able to score a better deal. The mileage caveat still applies to the Corolla - the mileage won't be as good.

Actually, if you're willing to drive to central Ohio, this '09 looks like a very good deal: http://www.cars.com/go/search/detail...eadExists=true
businezguyThread starterPennsylvania · Jun 13, 2009#29
Originally Posted by supmet ↑
Well you just made a decision on a yaris then. Elantras WILL NOT make it to 200k without rebuilding the entire thing. A yaris will.
That's really a generalization, but for the most part you're right, I'm close to making my decision and strongly favoring the Yaris. I love the car, I love the ride, I love the set up, and most importantly I love the awesome MPG I'll be able to get from this car without the need to dole out extra money for a hybrid.
roxy1michigan · Jun 13, 2009#30
Originally Posted by businezguy ↑

Correct me if I'm wrong, but with a manual transmission wouldn't I expect even better gas milage?
IMO, you are absolutely correct. back in 07 when i was shopping for my yaris, i made a crude spreadsheet from every forum i could find discussing real world mileage from yaris owners. i tried to compare apples to apples as far as driving conditions with the manual vs the auto. the vast majority (88%) of the highest mileage (identified as non hypermilers based on their posts) drivers were driving manual transmissions.

here is another site comparing a pretty good sampling of drivers of the 2007 yaris (which is identical as far as engine/transmission to the 09 yaris). you will see the manual transmission has an average of 38.8 mpg vs the auto transmission at 34.8 mpg.

http://www.fueleconomy.gov/feg/calcu...ta&model=Yaris

additionally, id have to say if you can get a corolla for the same price as a yaris, it would be a no brainer to go with the corolla. but, it you really want a hatchback, then the yaris is a no brainer, unless a base model fit appeals to you (which would already be equiped with power windows/locks.
businezguyThread starterPennsylvania · Jun 13, 2009#31
Originally Posted by roxy1 ↑
IMO, you are absolutely correct. back in 07 when i was shopping for my yaris, i made a crude spreadsheet from every forum i could find discussing real world mileage from yaris owners. i tried to compare apples to apples as far as driving conditions with the manual vs the auto. the vast majority (88%) of the highest mileage (identified as non hypermilers based on their posts) drivers were driving manual transmissions.

here is another site comparing a pretty good sampling of drivers of the 2007 yaris (which is identical as far as engine/transmission to the 09 yaris). you will see the manual transmission has an average of 38.8 mpg vs the auto transmission at 34.8 mpg.

http://www.fueleconomy.gov/feg/calcu...ta&model=Yaris

additionally, id have to say if you can get a corolla for the same price as a yaris, it would be a no brainer to go with the corolla. but, it you really want a hatchback, then the yaris is a no brainer, unless a base model fit appeals to you (which would already be equiped with power windows/locks.
To put it simply, I don't like the Corolla. It's a boring ride, with a plain interior that is...well, boring. The Yaris has a more basic interior, but somehow the overall experience is a fun/high MPG.

I have to admit it, part of the fun is going to be seeing how high I can get my MPG up to, and to me the Yaris is the most affordable route to do that. Unless I change my mind, once I gather all of the cash I need, I'll be going ahead and purchasing a Yaris. That's pretty much my decision.

Thanks for taking the time to answer all of my prices. I can't wait until I own my new car!
Yaris HiltonBristol, Tennessee, USA · Jun 14, 2009#32
I certainly could've bought a Corolla (or two.) I wanted a Yaris. (Got two.)
guzziknightAtlanta, GA · Jun 14, 2009#33
Just out of curiosity, have you thought about buying a used one? there's some good deals to be had.
roxy1michigan · Jun 14, 2009#34
Originally Posted by businezguy ↑
To put it simply, I don't like the Corolla. It's a boring ride, with a plain interior that is...well, boring. The Yaris has a more basic interior, but somehow the overall experience is a fun/high MPG.
!
id agree the yaris hatchback has a more fun overall appearance, at least on the outside. the yaris sedan is even more plain looking on the outside than the new corolla. on mostly highway driving, i easily pull similar mpg's as i did in my yaris. the yaris had a slight advantage in more stop and go situations. i just dont see the value in a yaris sedan unless it can have some type of price advantge over a corolla (or even the Elantra).
businezguyThread starterPennsylvania · Jun 14, 2009#35
Originally Posted by guzziknight ↑
Just out of curiosity, have you thought about buying a used one? there's some good deals to be had.
I actually have. I've been looking at some Yaris's that are 2007 models but have only 25k or so on them, and are selling for $8k. I doubt I would be able to do a trade in, or get much for the Focus, but that would still be a fantastic deal. I like the idea of buying new, but those deals are very compelling and I might go that route.
businezguyThread starterPennsylvania · Jun 14, 2009#36
Originally Posted by roxy1 ↑
id agree the yaris hatchback has a more fun overall appearance, at least on the outside. the yaris sedan is even more plain looking on the outside than the new corolla. on mostly highway driving, i easily pull similar mpg's as i did in my yaris. the yaris had a slight advantage in more stop and go situations. i just dont see the value in a yaris sedan unless it can have some type of price advantge over a corolla (or even the Elantra).
I love the Sedan. To me it's more fun then either the Corolla or the Elantra. The 5-door hatchback is an awesome vehicle but it actually costs more, and my wife doesn't like hatchbacks.
roxy1michigan · Jun 14, 2009#37
Originally Posted by businezguy ↑
I actually have. I've been looking at some Yaris's that are 2007 models but have only 25k or so on them, and are selling for $8k..
that would be a very good deal with that little mileage.
businezguyThread starterPennsylvania · Jun 17, 2009#38
Well I have been of many minds about my purchase, and I'm sure part of it is the fact that I'm able to pay cash and own my car outright, so I'm really focusing on making the right decision on my purchase. That and I'm enjoying the purchase process.

Between considering the Elantra and toying with purchasing a Ford Focus (don't worry, it aint gonna happen), it's very likely I'll be buying my new Yaris on either Friday or Saturday. I'm so excited, and greatly anticipating this potential purchase!
businezguyThread starterPennsylvania · Jun 17, 2009#39
Okay so here's my question. For those of you who went with a manual Yaris, have you had any regrets? I'm seriously considering the manual for the fun factor, to save money on the purchase price, and to save fuel economy.

How is the manual transmission on the Yaris, is it nice and smooth? Does anybody ever get tired of driving one?
roxy1michigan · Jun 18, 2009#40
Originally Posted by voodoo22 ↑
For your mostly highway driving, you will in fact get worse fuel economy with a MT unless you do pulse and glide, which involves putting the car in neutral, shutting off the engine and coasting down to a certain speed before you start up the engine again.
.

you will get better mileage with the manual transmission overall, and based on every shred of information i collected when shopping you will still get better mpg's on the highway (the difference in rpm's is little and the auto transmission will still have more parasitic losses than the manual transmission).

ill just repost what i wrote before:
back in 07 when i was shopping for my yaris, i made a crude spreadsheet from every forum i could find discussing real world mileage from yaris owners. i tried to compare apples to apples as far as driving conditions with the manual vs the auto. the vast majority (88%) of the highest mileage (identified as non hypermilers based on their posts) drivers were driving manual transmissions.

here is another site comparing a pretty good sampling of drivers of the 2007 yaris (which is identical as far as engine/transmission to the 09 yaris). you will see the manual transmission has an average of 38.8 mpg vs the auto transmission at 34.8 mpg.

http://www.fueleconomy.gov/feg/calcu...ta&model=Yaris

additionally, id have to say if you can get a corolla for the same price as a yaris, it would be a no brainer to go with the corolla. but, it you really want a hatchback, then the yaris is a no brainer, unless a base model fit appeals to you (which would already be equiped with power windows/locks.


if you really want to up the fun factor, try to talk your wife into a hatchback yaris. there is nothing fun looking or unique about the sedan. i rented the yaris sedan before i bought my hatchback and i had a lady at the bank ask me "is that a new Tercel?"🙁
kimonaHuntington Bch, CA · Jun 18, 2009#41
This issue has been flogged to death here and elsewhere. Most drivers will get better gas mileage with the automatic transmission.
businezguyThread starterPennsylvania · Jun 18, 2009#42
I'm surprised that the manual transmission doesn't rev at lower RPMs because it is a 5-speed. I would be going around 55 to 60 MPH so I would think the 5-speed would run at lower RPMs for me.

Thanks for the clarification! I do not plan on "pulsing and gliding". I would certainly be very conservative with shifting, and intentionally leave the car at very low RPMs however.
roxy1michigan · Jun 18, 2009#43
Originally Posted by kimona ↑
This issue has been flogged to death here and elsewhere. Most drivers will get better gas mileage with the automatic transmission.

flat out false. (odd that the epa highway estimate is worse for the automatic transmission)

if you want to...

-get the best mileage (not really debatable, IMO)
-save money on your purchase price (not in question)
-have a more fun driving experience when the mood hits you (hard to debate this)

...then get the manual transmission.

drivers of the automatic might have come to that conclusion in their own heads. a vast majority of the highest mileage yaris drivers are the manual drivers. auto transmission drivers can try to rationalize their choice of an auto transmission all they want. just admit you got the auto tranny for the convenience. the epa estimates and real life data bears out better mileage in the manual transmission.

i dont know how big of a sample you want:

68 automatic transmission drivers and 44 manual transmission drivers.
not only does the manual transmission yaris fare better in mileage, its not even that close. 38.8 mpg vs 34.8 mpg in favor of the manual transmission.

this forum is made up of a majority of auto transmission drivers (natural since there arent that many 5 speeds being made). it is natural they will want to believe the auto tranny can achieve equal mileage with the manual transmission. the facts wont show this to be so. the lower rpm argument doesnt cut it with this car as the rpm differences are minimal. the small rpm advantage cannot make up for the parasitic losses inherent in driving an auto (yes, even todays automatics). there is also a weight advantage, though it is not great.

now, taking the civic or fit as an example where the rpm differences between the auto are extremely different (something around 800+ rpm's at highway speeds) and you could see where that would make a difference.

the only argument to be had is someone who cant drive a manual transmision and doesnt understand efficient shift points might as well drive the auto.

i dont fault anyone for getting the auto transmission. it is more convenient (there are occasions where i widh i had one, such as traffic tie ups) and it still gets very good mileage, but not quite what the manual transmission will achieve.
auxmikeLI, New Yawk · Jun 18, 2009#44
I bought the A/T because I could no way no how find a 5speed with a power pkg last March.😠 All they had was ONE red "bare bones" model in stock. And I did check three dealers that day.
I was in DESPERATE need of a car and could not wait for the dealer to search around.
In the long run I'm glad I got what I did.....😁
businezguyThread starterPennsylvania · Jun 18, 2009#45
This is an interesting debate, and it seems that if I was doing a lot of local/city driving the manual transmission would be superior for me. If I'm going to be doing a lot of highway driving the automatic will actually have the advantage, and will actually run at lower RPMs then does the manual (which is still surprising to me since the manual has 5 gears).

Do I have that information correct?
roxy1michigan · Jun 19, 2009#46
Originally Posted by businezguy ↑
This is an interesting debate, and it seems that if I was doing a lot of local/city driving the manual transmission would be superior for me. If I'm going to be doing a lot of highway driving the automatic will actually have the advantage, and will actually run at lower RPMs then does the manual (which is still surprising to me since the manual has 5 gears).

Do I have that information correct?
the reason the honda fit automatic does better than the manaul transmission fit on the highway is because their is a huge discrepancy in rpm's at highway speed. the fit manual is geared ridicuously high such that it cant make up the drivetrain advantages vs the automatic fit.


in the case of the yaris, the auto will come close to the manual on the highway. the rpm difference on the highway is only about 200 rpm's. i collected data from cleanmpg, toyotanation, edmunds car space forums, fueleconomy.gov, and this forum before i bought my yaris. 88% of the highest mileage yaris were manual transmissions, and many of these were long distance commuters. the auto was commonly 1-2 mpg's behind. clean mpg is slanted toward hypermiling, but most drivers arent utilyzing many of those techniques. of course, someone who hypermiles a yaris automatic on a long highway jaunt should easily beat the mileage of the average person driving either a manual or auto yaris. on a raw numbers basis, a large majority of the hypermilers i found with the best highway mileages across all the forums were driving manual transmissions.

i even broke 46 mpg with my manual yaris 4 times using few hypermiling techniques, but primarily by driving sensibly, and of course those were mostly highway tanks.

in 2008, the EPA decided to revise its testing methods. Tests will continue to use a dynamometer. Changes will include:
Higher speeds - up to 80 MPH on the highway cycle
Colder temperatures - tests will now start at 20 degrees Fahrenheit rather than 75
More rapid acceleration
Use of accessories - the air conditioner will be operated 13% of the time


this is what happens on the highway in real life. many drivers are going to have to speed up and slow down during their highway driving. very few people get a 50 mile run at one speed. out of 112 drivers on fueleconomy.gov, for example, very, very few have 90% or more of their overall driving consisting of highway mileage. the current testing methods resulted in the yaris being rated with a higher mpg on the highway. anecdotal evidence is nice for a forum debate, but in my view the raw numbers favor the manual transmission yaris in real world highway driving.

having said all of that, i dont think the difference is big enough (if all you do are highway commutes that are non stop) to justify buying a manual if you view the auto transmision as the more convenient choice.
roxy1michigan · Jun 19, 2009#47
Originally Posted by businezguy ↑
This is an interesting debate, and it seems that if I was doing a lot of local/city driving the manual transmission would be superior for me. If I'm going to be doing a lot of highway driving the automatic will actually have the advantage, and will actually run at lower RPMs then does the manual (which is still surprising to me since the manual has 5 gears).

Do I have that information correct?
the reason the honda fit automatic does better than the manaul transmission fit on the highway is because their is a huge discrepancy in rpm's at highway speed. the fit manual is geared ridicuously high such that it cant make up the drivetrain advantages vs the automatic fit.


in the case of the yaris, the auto will come close to the manual on the highway. the rpm difference on the highway is only about 200 rpm's. i collected data from cleanmpg, toyotanation, edmunds car space forums, fueleconomy.gov, and this forum before i bought my yaris. 88% of the highest mileage yaris were manual transmissions, and many of these were long distance commuters. the auto was commonly 1-2 mpg's behind. clean mpg is slanted toward hypermiling, but most drivers arent utilyzing many of those techniques. of course, someone who hypermiles a yaris automatic on a long highway jaunt should easily beat the mileage of the average person driving either a manual or auto yaris. on a raw numbers basis, a large majority of the hypermilers i found with the best highway mileages across all the forums were driving manual transmissions.

i even broke 46 mpg with my manual yaris 4 times using few hypermiling techniques, but primarily by driving sensibly, and of course those were mostly highway tanks.

in 2008, the EPA decided to revise its testing methods. Tests will continue to use a dynamometer. Changes will include:
Higher speeds - up to 80 MPH on the highway cycle
Colder temperatures - tests will now start at 20 degrees Fahrenheit rather than 75
More rapid acceleration
Use of accessories - the air conditioner will be operated 13% of the time


this is what happens on the highway in real life. many drivers are going to have to speed up and slow down during their highway driving. very few people get a 50 mile run at one speed. out of 112 drivers on fueleconomy.gov, for example very, very few have 90% or more of their overall driving consisting of highway mileage. the current testing methods resulted in the yaris being rated with a higher mpg on the highway. anecdotal evidence is nice for a forum debate, but in my view the raw numbers favor the manual transmission yaris in real world highway driving.

having said all of that, i dont think the difference is big enough (if all you do are highway commutes that are non stop) to justify buying a manual if you view the auto transmision as the more convenient choice. besides, when you get up around 35-40+ mpg's, the saving in a few mpg's gets to be rather small, and the higher you get, the more insignificant the savings from a few mpg's becomes. diminishing returns.
Yaris HiltonBristol, Tennessee, USA · Jun 19, 2009#48
How many angels can dance on a shift knob?
businezguyThread starterPennsylvania · Jun 19, 2009#49
Thanks for the information, Roxy. There are times when I get stuck in a jam and really do have to slow and and speed up for as much as 10 miles of my 62 mile commute to work (this rarely happens on the way home).

I still have a feeling that the manual transmission will be the better choice for me. Thanks for all of the information you've provided, it's been a lot of help.
kimonaHuntington Bch, CA · Jun 19, 2009#50
Originally Posted by voodoo22 ↑
If you can live with the MT, it's definitely the better choice based on initial cost alone. In Canada AT is a 1000$ option. Just don't be deterred from getting the AT based on FE fears for the kind of driving you do. The most important thing is to get what you want. It's much easier to deal with a choice you made versus one made for you, imo.
I like this advice.