Yarisworld Archive

Reason versus Excuse...

19 posts · 5,577 views

SIPNGASOriginal postSoutheast Wisconsin · May 22, 2009#1
what IS the difference?

The two seem like they could be used in place of the other...but I think a reason given by someone could sound like an excuse to another. And an excuse isn't always a bad thing, but it sort of has the that feel.

Thoughts?

Replies 18

SailDesign. · May 22, 2009#2
A reason is the "Why did you do this?" thing. There is only one answer.
An excuse is the public front you put on the reason.

Teacher: Jimmy, why did you punch Pete?
Jimmy: 'Coz he called me a poopy-head (this is the "excuse")

The REASON was that Pete called him a poopy-head for stealing his lunch money.
mrbondIllinois · May 22, 2009#3
^ that is true.

I actually heard a discussion about this on NPR a few weeks ago. The difference is very subjective. Excuses aren't always a bad thing - it apparently depends on the context, the content, and what its goal is.
Whether something is viewed as an excuse as opposed to a reason would depend on who is getting the excuse/reason.
SIPNGASThread starterSoutheast Wisconsin · May 22, 2009#4
Originally Posted by mrbond ↑
^ that is true.

I actually heard a discussion about this on NPR a few weeks ago. The difference is very subjective. Excuses aren't always a bad thing - it apparently depends on the context, the content, and what its goal is.
Whether something is viewed as an excuse as opposed to a reason would depend on who is getting the excuse/reason.
That's what I think, too.

It's all about perception and the two sides could view a reason/excuse as one or the other.
ShroomsterOrlando · May 22, 2009#5
I always ask myself like this:

Do I have a reason or am I making an excuse?
GeneWPennsylvania · May 22, 2009#6
Originally Posted by SIPNGAS ↑
what IS the difference?

The two seem like they could be used in place of the other...but I think a reason given by someone could sound like an excuse to another. And an excuse isn't always a bad thing, but it sort of has the that feel.

Thoughts?
The difference is probably the sophistication of the explanation....

If Bill Clinton got busted with an Intern in the Oval Office his excuse was his "Alpha Male" status. His explanation is that he was a sex addict, if not "an appetite in a suit" (so said Jesse Jackson).

Gene
YarisOwnersDadWestern Kentucky · May 22, 2009#7
All reasons that sound good are not necessarily good, sound reasons.
supmetSouthern California · May 22, 2009#8
I have reasons, everyone else has excuses 😁
TamagoOff Grid · May 22, 2009#9
reasons are based on facts
excuses are based on feelings

for example:

why are you late?

reason: there was an accident on the 826
excuse: i wasn't certain what the traffic was going to be like, so i didn't leave as early as i should have
TLyttleKeremeos BC · May 22, 2009#10
Hey, Lisa, is there background to this question? Just asking....
jdinrcSouthern California · May 23, 2009#11
I like these definitions from Webster's

Reason: a statement offered in explanation or justification, a rational ground or motive, a sufficient ground of explanation or of logical defense ; especially : something (as a principle or law) that supports a conclusion or explains a fact

Excuse: : something offered as justification or as grounds for being excused, an expression of regret for failure to do something, to try to remove blame from

Therefore:
A reason is a factual, logical explanation of a rational motive and is based on facts.

An excuse is an expression of regret and request for being excused (not an apology, but a request that no blame be assigned).
TheRealEnthMiami, FL · May 23, 2009#12
Therefore:
A reason is a factual, logical explanation of a rational motive and is based on facts.

An excuse is an expression of regret and request for being excused (not an apology, but a request that no blame be assigned).
thats just what tamago said =D
GiobateraCoral Springs, FL · May 23, 2009#13
😁😁😁Come on now, what is the reason for all these excuses????????😁😁😁:biggrin :
FunctionSpec626, Southern California · May 23, 2009#14
An excuse is our reason for doing something "wrong". Whether if we are telling the truth or telling a lie, the end result is still the same, we did something "wrong".

"Katie was late for class"<~~What she did wrong
"I had to save a dying puppy"<~~the truth
"There was traffic on the freeway"<~~the lie

Whether she lied or told the truth, even if it's good or bad, in the end she still did something "wrong", being late for class, which makes her reason for doing something wrong an "excuse".

Now if Katie saved her neighbors dying puppy, would the neighbor ask her "What's your excuse for saving my dog?" Is Katie's reason for doing something "right" an excuse? Only if you do something "wrong" would it be considered an excuse.

To Katie's teacher she did something "wrong" since she came late to class and to her neighbor she did something "right" since she saved her puppy. So her reason to her teacher is an excuse and her reason to her neighbor is..........a reason......lol
SIPNGASThread starterSoutheast Wisconsin · May 23, 2009#15
ooo..this was VERY interesting!

And it comes from a question posed to me by a friend. He said I was making an excuse for something I didn't do....(and he thought I should have)...where I felt I was stating a reason. I still think I had a good REASON....and that's where my thinking is the two have a lot to do with perception.

Thanks guys for some interesting and insightful answers.
SailDesign. · May 23, 2009#16
Originally Posted by SIPNGAS ↑
ooo..this was VERY interesting!

And it comes from a question posed to me by a friend. He said I was making an excuse for something I didn't do....(and he thought I should have)...where I felt I was stating a reason. I still think I had a good REASON....and that's where my thinking is the two have a lot to do with perception.

Thanks guys for some interesting and insightful answers.
Now, Lisa - you're only adding fuel to the "curiosity" fire. 🙂
cdavidhessRochester, NY · May 23, 2009#17
Then there's the statement:

Everyone has two reasons for doing something--- a "good" reason and the "real" reason.
MadMaxSan Antonio, Texas! · May 23, 2009#18
A reason is an explanation of how something happened, and excuse is an explanation as to why it happened.

In the military, you can give a reason for something going wrong, but there had never be an excuse for it. The bottom line is that if it was your responsibility, then you will be held accountable for it no matter why it happened.
jdinrcSouthern California · May 23, 2009#19
Originally Posted by TheRealEnth ↑
thats just what tamago said =D
Not exactly, but similar. Anyway, I like mine better 😁