Yarisworld Archive

Just filled up the tank with 91 octane premium fuel

101 posts · 60,283 views · page 1 of 3

darkmoon87Original postVancouver, BC · May 7, 2009#1
Just to feel if there is any difference. (out of curiousity)

I didnt notice any power gain or anything like that, but one thing was quite noticable.


After installing my NST crank and waterpump pullies, the car became more sensitive to clutch and I had a little difficulty starting smoothly from 1st gear.
The car would shake more when I give the gas only as much as I used to give prior to the pulley install, so I had to be extra conscious with my clutch manuvering.

After filling the car up with 91, I can start from 1st gear with a relative ease. It starts noticably more smoothly.

Do u think this is just a placebo thing? Discuss.

Replies 100

AothachosLong Island, NY · May 7, 2009#2
Only time i used any gas under 91 octane is the day i got the car they filled it up with regular gas, after that day i filled my tank up with 91 octane ALL THE TIME NO MATTER WAT. It only costs like 20$ exact to fill up and lasts about a week the way i drive. My starts are usually instant no delay or anything, feels smoother ride for me, and i have an automatic but when i take off it feels so good like idk its weird but good

alot of ppl use 87 cause its a 'waste" of money to use 91 but idc im happy with my yaris on 91 hehe
DerFlosserUSA · May 7, 2009#3
Possibly placebo but a higher octane fuel should ignite better so a smoother start really is possible.
07WYarisRSRidgeway Ontario · May 8, 2009#4
Originally Posted by DerFlosser ↑
Possibly placebo but a higher octane fuel should ignite better so a smoother start really is possible.
Higher octane fuel had a higher flash point... That means its harder for higer octane to ignite thats why its only to be used in high compression engines to eliminate knock...

So many people know so little about fuels and its affects its enough to make your head spin. Why people will continue to argue the effects of running different octanes is beyond me...
Run only the octane needed to prevent detonation, anything higher is waisting $$$ and costing you performance as a higher octane with higher flash point is harder to ignite and can waist fuel...
If your engine is knocking on 87 octane it either because you have a problem, your buyin shitty ass gas or you ran high octane fuels for a time and have a carbon build up problem.
i've been building and rebuilding race engines and regular engines for many years and have done many tests on the dyno and using CHT/EGT guages.
Facts are facts people. running a higher octane in a n engine that was designed to run a lower octane is not doing ANY good.. in fact it does more harm then good
06vitzRSAlberta,Canada · May 8, 2009#5
Originally Posted by 07WYarisRS ↑
Higher octane fuel had a higher flash point... That means its harder for higer octane to ignite thats why its only to be used in high compression engines to eliminate knock...

So many people know so little about fuels and its affects its enough to make your head spin. Why people will continue to argue the effects of running different octanes is beyond me...
Run only the octane needed to prevent detonation, anything higher is waisting $$$ and costing you performance as a higher octane with higher flash point is harder to ignite and can waist fuel...
If your engine is knocking on 87 octane it either because you have a problem, your buyin shitty ass gas or you ran high octane fuels for a time and have a carbon build up problem.
i've been building and rebuilding race engines and regular engines for many years and have done many tests on the dyno and using CHT/EGT guages.
Facts are facts people. running a higher octane in a n engine that was designed to run a lower octane is not doing ANY good.. in fact it does more harm then good

+1

But i'm just a mechanic so what do i know.

It would be soooooo nice to put this topic to rest....probably not going to happen, oh well.
eric81Clarksville, IN · May 8, 2009#6
The book actually says to use 89 or better. Also, the better the octane, the better it will ignite on a more regular basis. I let my car warm up before driving it, and I find it helps all my components run smoother.
yaris-meAnaheim, CA · May 8, 2009#7
I don't thinks it's placebo effect. You may not gain power, but the engine timing can run a little more advanced. That can make it a little smoother. You can confirm this by switching back to 87 octane.🙂
jambo101Montreal Canada · May 8, 2009#8
On a recent trip from Tampa to Montreal i tried a tankful of the high octane just to see how/if it would show any difference on my Scangauge.Roads were through Georgia and the Carolinas so they were fairly consistant and cruise was set at 60mph
Average mpg on regular was 47.3mpg
Average mpg on high octane 47.3mpg
In fact all operating parameters according to Scangauge remained the same🤷
ddongbaphay · May 8, 2009#9
Oh, I usually put that green handled gas in my car. Runs really weird though.
SabretoothSt Cloud FL · May 8, 2009#10
Higher octane fuels are designed for high performance or just high compression engines.

You will feel a difference on a High HP engine, or even a Turbo application that is tuned specifically for 91/93+ octane fuels. I read somewhere that the Yaris is pretuned in the ECU to handle fuels with crappy octane levels (>87 Octane). So if anything 87 is enough.
scapeBeaufort, South Carolina · May 8, 2009#11
Originally Posted by eric81 ↑
The book actually says to use 89 or better. Also, the better the octane, the better it will ignite on a more regular basis. I let my car warm up before driving it, and I find it helps all my components run smoother.
in the manual it states not to do this, especially during break-in, and recommend to simply turn it on and drive away.

as for octane, unless 89 is knocking, 89 is what your are to use. and 89 would only knock if it's lower than 89 octane, which can happen at very cheap gas stations.

"Higher octane fuels are designed for high performance or just high compression engines."
+1
MUSKOKA800Chatham, Ontario, Canada · May 8, 2009#12
Do u think this is just a placebo thing?


Exactly,
Higher octane fuel burns slower to prohibit pre-ignition in high compression engines. Using higher than manufacturers minimum specification only subsidizes BIG GAS.
scapeBeaufort, South Carolina · May 8, 2009#13
Originally Posted by ddongbap ↑
Oh, I usually put that green handled gas in my car. Runs really weird though.
lol
nerpRockville, RI · May 8, 2009#14
The manual says to put in 89? Wha? Is that the Canadian 89?
scapeBeaufort, South Carolina · May 8, 2009#15
Canada might use RON, which is 91 equivalent to 87 Octane-- they also recommend use of fuel detergents to reduce buildup.
DerFlosserUSA · May 8, 2009#16
higher octane fuel is a cleaner ignition assuming you have a healthy ignition system (all components). Other than than...one would really be hard pressed to tell the difference between an 89 and a 91 in a Yaris. It's a low-mid compression motor with 100hp. I can possibly see smoother starts but as far as running and gas mileage....we all know that the higher octane provides no benefits.
hamMI U.S. · May 8, 2009#17
Originally Posted by darkmoon87 ↑
Just to feel if there is any difference. (out of curiousity)

I didnt notice any power gain or anything like that, but one thing was quite noticable.


After installing my NST crank and waterpump pullies, the car became more sensitive to clutch and I had a little difficulty starting smoothly from 1st gear.
The car would shake more when I give the gas only as much as I used to give prior to the pulley install, so I had to be extra conscious with my clutch manuvering.

After filling the car up with 91, I can start from 1st gear with a relative ease. It starts noticably more smoothly.

Do u think this is just a placebo thing? Discuss.
I experience a noticeable gain in MPGs from 87 to 93
AothachosLong Island, NY · May 8, 2009#18
My manual says use 87 octane then in parenthesis next to it it says (research 91 octane) what does that mean? But yea no matter what no one is convincing me to go lower than 91 lol been using it my whole yaris life and no problems at all
427chevCT. · May 8, 2009#19
Originally Posted by eric81 ↑
The book actually says to use 89 or better. Also, the better the octane, the better it will ignite on a more regular basis. I let my car warm up before driving it, and I find it helps all my components run smoother.

Show me where "the book" says that.

Gasoline octane in the US is measured by the R+M/2 method, known as the PON number.

You're referring to the RON (reserach) octane rating, which is still used in Europe.

There is absolutely, positively NO ADVANTAGE in using a gasoline with an PON number greater than 87 on a Yaris. It is a waste of money.
427chevCT. · May 8, 2009#20
Originally Posted by ham ↑
I experience a noticeable gain in MPGs from 87 to 93

No you don't...

You might think you do, but objectively speaking there is no difference at all.
BLAZINBLUEVITZNEW YORK · May 8, 2009#21
👍 different thread SAME opinions.......
The little red pillon my computer chair · May 8, 2009#22
I just like the fact that running 91 octane gives me that 50 extra horse power. In fact, I raced a Mustang the other day and blew it's doors off! At the next light he asked me how I beat him. My response, "91 Octane Baby"!

P.S. I also have a AEM sticker on my car which throws in another 5 horsepower, but that's just our little secret! 😎
TheSilkySmoothNew Hampshire · May 8, 2009#23
if you have a CAI and open exhaust the ECU might retune over time for the higher octane and you might get some more torque, but I never found the need to add more than 2 gals to the rest of the tank in a mix to get all the octane the engine needs. try mixing in just 2 gals of 93 at a fill up of 87. Our engines are High compression and the eCU can start to retard timing when you get carbon buildup over time. A littel more octane can help. MAy car is starting to ping/knock at starting off in 1st gear at 20K miles on the odo. You dont drive hard enough to clean out this carbon, unless you run the car at WOT 3rd and 4th gear on the highway more than a couple minutes a day. That can clean it out. An melt your 2 layer exhaust pipe too!
07WYarisRSRidgeway Ontario · May 8, 2009#24
Originally Posted by DerFlosser ↑
higher octane fuel is a cleaner ignition assuming you have a healthy ignition system (all components). Other than than...one would really be hard pressed to tell the difference between an 89 and a 91 in a Yaris. It's a low-mid compression motor with 100hp. I can possibly see smoother starts but as far as running and gas mileage....we all know that the higher octane provides no benefits.
Higher octane does NOT have a cleaner ignition
Unless the compression is high enough to take ad vantage of the fuels flash point, burn rates and flame front speeds the engine will not burn as efficiently a a low octane and you end up with carbon deposits.
Lower octane fuels burn cleaner and more efficiently in ANY lower compression engines.
but I just build performance engines for a living and actually test them using the proper equipment..WTF would I know about fuels and the affects right?

Don't confuse RON and PON people
A 89 RON octane rating is PON (pump octane rating) of 86
when you look in the manual and see a research octane rating of 91 that does not mean to use 91 pumop octane... 91 RON = 87 PON.
Toyota, Honda and most other companies build thier econo engine to run on RON 89 (pump octane 86) because thats whats all thats available in some counties for low octane and it makes these engines most cost effective...

I'll never understand people that buy one of the cheapest econo boxes on the market and then run it on high octane ... you guys are nuts lol
you guys much know more then the dudes in white lab coats at toyota
07WYarisRSRidgeway Ontario · May 8, 2009#25
Originally Posted by TheSilkySmooth ↑
if you have a CAI and open exhaust the ECU might retune over time for the higher octane and you might get some more torque, but I never found the need to add more than 2 gals to the rest of the tank in a mix to get all the octane the engine needs. try mixing in just 2 gals of 93 at a fill up of 87. Our engines are High compression and the eCU can start to retard timing when you get carbon buildup over time. A littel more octane can help. MAy car is starting to ping/knock at starting off in 1st gear at 20K miles on the odo. You dont drive hard enough to clean out this carbon, unless you run the car at WOT 3rd and 4th gear on the highway more than a couple minutes a day. That can clean it out. An melt your 2 layer exhaust pipe too!
our engines are NOT high compression... my street bikes run 200psi plug per cylinder and run on 87 octane... guess what they have less then 10:1 compression ration.

The ECU will not re-tune for higher octane...
The only time it will make a difference is if the engine is knocking... then the knock sesor will pick up the engine knock and retard the timing.. it won't change the fuel maps to compensate.

Spark knock AKA PING is completely normal and just means the engine is running efficiently...

running a lower octane fuel will reduce carbon built up as it has a lower flash point and will burn more efficiently and completely... Also start running a TRUE synthetic like Amsoil or Redline with no mineral oil or by products that cause deposits to form and after 10 years you engine will still be 95% carbon free
highwaypassJakarta · May 8, 2009#26
Originally Posted by ham ↑
I experience a noticeable gain in MPGs from 87 to 93
i agree with you
jambo101Montreal Canada · May 8, 2009#27
Originally Posted by ham ↑
I experience a noticeable gain in MPGs from 87 to 93
Guess your car is different than mine as i see no difference Either through electronic measure or pencil and paper calculation but i guess if you are seeing noticeable gas mpg by paying the extra $$$ for higher octane then go for it , you will be happy with the extra mpg and the gas companies will be happy with the extra $$$$ Win win all around.
AothachosLong Island, NY · May 8, 2009#28
Originally Posted by ham ↑
I experience a noticeable gain in MPGs from 87 to 93
+2 lol 👍 i used to get 60 miles before the first bar went, now i use 91 it goes up to 75-80 on the first bar =), i wasn't satisfied with 60 miles on the first bar

also i had about half a tank of 91and i filled up with 87 and my car ran like crap like i felt it, it was horrible hard to explain but you feel it, like the car is "wtf is this crap your putting in me"



P.S. do you mean 91 or 93 lol
BLAZINBLUEVITZNEW YORK · May 8, 2009#29
^^ the naysayers will NEVER believe you.....
supmetSouthern California · May 8, 2009#30
I run 91 every once in a while, and it does feel smoother starting, accelerating, and idling.

Could it be a placebo affect? Maybe
Is it only a 2 dollar placebo, if it is? Yes


With the octane specific argument aside, aren't their cleaners and additives in 91 that aren't found in 87 at some gas stations??
427chevCT. · May 8, 2009#31
Originally Posted by supmet ↑
I run 91 every once in a while, and it does feel smoother starting, accelerating, and idling.

Could it be a placebo affect? Maybe
Is it only a 2 dollar placebo, if it is? Yes
Not only could it be, it is.🙄

"CAR AND DRIVER" ran an article on this that included some objective testing of several vehicles. There was absolutely NO difference between regular and premium gasoline in vehicles that recommended regular (e.g. 87 octane).

There was a difference in vehicles that recommended premium, since running regular in them retards the spark and changes the engine mapping to the lower octane map.
427chevCT. · May 8, 2009#32
Originally Posted by Aothachos ↑
+2 lol 👍 i used to get 60 miles before the first bar went, now i use 91 it goes up to 75-80 on the first bar =)
So you're saying that running 91 octane in lieu of 87 octane increases fuel economy by about 30%..

Wouldn't Toyota simply recommend premium if that were the case? Premium only costs roughly 10% more, yet according to you it improves fuel economy by 30%. That means that running premium is a FAR more economical choice than running regular.

Honestly, anyone can claim anything on these forums. The fact of the matter is that I hold a mechanical engineering degree, have been employed in the profession for 23 years and have read quite a bit about the combustion process and fuel.

Scientifically speaking, your claim is baseless.
BLAZINBLUEVITZNEW YORK · May 8, 2009#33
Originally Posted by 427chev ↑
Honestly, anyone can claim anything on these forums.

and this is your claim:

I hold a mechanical engineering degree, have been employed in the profession for 23 years and have read quite a bit about the combustion process and fuel.
.
😆 🙄
427chevCT. · May 8, 2009#34
Originally Posted by BLAZINBLUEVITZ ↑
😆 🙄
I've aleady won my argument with you, based solely on that fact that you resorted to (baseless) insults in lieu of a credible response that included objective evidence to back your "opinion."

Time and time again, objective evidence proves my point. In fact, the article below noted that the car designed to run on 87 octane actually ran WORSE on premium. That is not the first time I've seen that happen. I suspect that premium's slightly slower burn time might result in compromised combustion in some engines that are designed for regular fuel.

http://www.caranddriver.com/reviews/...ature/(page)/1

http://www.consumerreports.org/cro/c...l-dollars-406/

"Don't use premium fuel if you don't have to. If your car specifies regular fuel, don't buy premium under the mistaken belief that your engine will run better. The only difference you'll see is about 20 cents more per gallon. Most cars are designed to run just fine on regular gasoline. Even many cars for which premium is recommended will run well on regular. We have found that the differences are imperceptible during normal driving. Check your owner's manual to find out if your engine really requires premium or if you can run on other grades."
BLAZINBLUEVITZNEW YORK · May 8, 2009#35
Originally Posted by 427chev ↑
I've aleady won my argument with you, based solely on that fact that you resorted to (baseless) insults in lieu of a credible response that included objective evidence to back your "opinion."
NO, your just a latecomer who thinks their gonna teach someone something with their knowledge. Maybe if this wasn't the 56th thread of the same topic id be a bit more receptive......
427chevCT. · May 8, 2009#36
Originally Posted by BLAZINBLUEVITZ ↑
NO, your just a latecomer who thinks their gonna teach someone something with their knowledge. Maybe if this wasn't the 56th thread of the same topic id be a bit more receptive......
I have nothing to "Teach" anyone on this board.

Rather, I prefer to ignore children who have no understanding of the related science and will therefore remove myself from this thread.
DerFlosserUSA · May 8, 2009#37
Originally Posted by 07WYarisRS ↑
Higher octane does NOT have a cleaner ignition
Unless the compression is high enough to take ad vantage of the fuels flash point, burn rates and flame front speeds the engine will not burn as efficiently a a low octane and you end up with carbon deposits.
Lower octane fuels burn cleaner and more efficiently in ANY lower compression engines.
but I just build performance engines for a living and actually test them using the proper equipment..WTF would I know about fuels and the affects right?

Don't confuse RON and PON people
A 89 RON octane rating is PON (pump octane rating) of 86
when you look in the manual and see a research octane rating of 91 that does not mean to use 91 pumop octane... 91 RON = 87 PON.
Toyota, Honda and most other companies build thier econo engine to run on RON 89 (pump octane 86) because thats whats all thats available in some counties for low octane and it makes these engines most cost effective...

I'll never understand people that buy one of the cheapest econo boxes on the market and then run it on high octane ... you guys are nuts lol
you guys much know more then the dudes in white lab coats at toyota

I am not disagreeing with what you are saying. My point is that it's possible for the car to start smoother due to the higher octane fuel because, even though you may build engines and see drastically higher compression motors, 10.5:1 is still a "high enough" compression ratio to see benefits at start and idle condition utilizing a better grade fuel. I am not saying to run the car with the higher octane fuel...I am merely saying that it is a good possibility that the feeling is real in regards to the smoother start.
AothachosLong Island, NY · May 8, 2009#38
DAMMIT DARKMOON87 look wat you started lol, this is going to be the hot topic of arguments, like i said I know what i feel with 91 octane and I'm not changing, i don't mind putting in extra couple dollars for better fuel =)

*better fuel* watch someone say something about that lol

but yea im not convinced to switch to 87 so =) LET THE DEBATE CONTINUE!
nerpRockville, RI · May 8, 2009#39
All octanes have detergent in them. It's a bit of a misnomer to say that using 93 octane will "clean out" an engine that normally requires 87.
07WYarisRSRidgeway Ontario · May 8, 2009#40
Originally Posted by DerFlosser ↑
I am not disagreeing with what you are saying. My point is that it's possible for the car to start smoother due to the higher octane fuel because, even though you may build engines and see drastically higher compression motors, 10.5:1 is still a "high enough" compression ratio to see benefits at start and idle condition utilizing a better grade fuel. I am not saying to run the car with the higher octane fuel...I am merely saying that it is a good possibility that the feeling is real in regards to the smoother start.
DETONATION...look it up
thats the ONLY reason to use a higher octane fuel...
thats why we have higher octane fuels, not because they can give better mileage or make the car run smoother or start easier... Fuels DONT WORK THAT WAY
Higher octane is available at the pumps because some engines are forced induction, some engines run high compression ratios like todays modern Super sport bikes and off road bikes. Even some of these engines running 12.5:1 compression only require 87 octane

I hear what your sayin...
I'm just sayin NO, its not possible to start easier. Besided the compression ratio there is compression rates and HEAT... you need to calculate the HEAT of combustion into that mix... sure the lil yota engine may be a higher compression ratio then many other auto engines but at 10.5:1 there is not enough heat and compression at start up to take advantage of the higher octanes higher flash point..
My cammed Suzuki GSX750F pushes 100 hp runs 11:1 compression and redline of 12,000rpm and only needs 87 octane... Do you really think the Yaris needs better fuel then my crotch rocket?

Like i said it all has to do with the fuels flash point, the lower the flash point the easier it will ignite, the higher the flash point the harder it is to ignite.
Thats why many bio deisel set up have a deisel start because the biomixtures like used engine oil of veggie oil often has a much higher flashpoint and is harder for the engines to start on them. they start on the diesel and then switch over to run on bio once warmed up.

With higher octane fuels they not only have a higher flash point making it harder to ignite but they also contain additives that eliminate or remove free radicals in the fuel that can promote detonation. While the actual burnt temp of the fuel may not be changed the flame front speeds can be altered or slowed to help eliminate detonation. If you engine has no detonation, then there is NO benifit to running higher octane fuel... NONE

people often think higher octane fuels burn hotter and faster then lower octane fuels... this is a myth, actualy the lower the octane the faster it ignites and can burn faster depending on the additive and free radicals in the fuel..
If you were to take a carbed engine with fixed timing and diid two runs on a dyno one with 87 and one with 91 octane fuels. the 87 will always produce more HP and higher EGT (exhaust gas temps) then higher octane fuels...

Do you know why it feels smoother on higher octane fuel... they call this soggy. When an engine is jetted too rich or running too rich it has a soggy feel to it. An engine that is running a little to rich will run awesome, but it lacks power. the richer it is the less power it makes. And ebgine running leaner produces more power, too lean and you start to run the risk of overheating and detonation and pre-ignition ( not even close to the same thing bTW)
When an engine is running efficiently it can have what is known as spark knock or PING under heavy loads, this is normal but the more efficiently the engine is burning the fuel and the more power its making the less smooth it can feel.
Thats why racers often say the engine is a little lazy or soggy feeling when running rich or loading up. This is usually caused by an eninge that only needs high octane pump fuel but is being run on race gas.
The little red pillon my computer chair · May 8, 2009#41
. . . . . ouch . . .
427chevCT. · May 8, 2009#42
Originally Posted by DerFlosser ↑
I am not disagreeing with what you are saying. My point is that it's possible for the car to start smoother due to the higher octane fuel because, even though you may build engines and see drastically higher compression motors, 10.5:1 is still a "high enough" compression ratio to see benefits at start and idle condition utilizing a better grade fuel. I am not saying to run the car with the higher octane fuel...I am merely saying that it is a good possibility that the feeling is real in regards to the smoother start.
Nothing you said makes sense.

First of all, small chambers (inherent to a small displacement engine) are more efficient than larger ones because flame propagation occurs over a smaller area. That's the main reason that motorcycle engines are able to run such lofty compression ratios.

Secondly, the Yaris is one of the few engines that offers DIRECT INJECTION - which cools the intake charge and as discussed in the following link:

http://www.greencarcongress.com/2009...portfolio.html

10.5:1 is not a high compression ratio for a modern, direct injected, small displacement engine. The 2.4 liter, direct injected GM engine discussed in the link above runs an 11.4:1 CR!

Hence, the 10.5:1 compression ratio in the Yaris engine (where each cylinder represents a mere ~ 0.375 liters and where direct injection is involved) isn't comparable to an engine that utlizes port injection and larger cylinders (particularly the bore dimension).

What amazes me about these bulletin boards is that people voice opinions without having any REAL understanding of the subject matter, most of which boils down to advanced engineering principals.

There is absolutely, positively NO EMPIRICAL EVIDENCE supporting the notion that any modern engine that has a recommended fuel octane rating of 87 PON can, in any way, benefit from a gasoline of a higher octane rating. If anything, empirical evidence suggests the opposite, since the slightly lower burn rate of the higher octane fuel may adversely impact the intended timing of the complete combustion process, relative to the position of the piston and the valves.
jambo101Montreal Canada · May 8, 2009#43
Well said 427chev,i think most people fall into the marketing hype of naming the higher octanes with such colorful names (Super,deluxe,Premium,Gold etc)as to make 87 octane seem inferior,so they only fill up with that superior high octane and talk themselves into believing that they are somehow getting more power and better fuel economy without ever doing any meaningful measurements of whats really going on .
DerFlosserUSA · May 8, 2009#44
Originally Posted by 427chev ↑
Nothing you said makes sense.

First of all, small chambers (inherent to a small displacement engine) are more efficient than larger ones because flame propagation occurs over a smaller area. That's the main reason that motorcycle engines are able to run such lofty compression ratios.

Secondly, the Yaris is one of the few engines that offers DIRECT INJECTION - which cools the intake charge and as discussed in the following link:

http://www.greencarcongress.com/2009...portfolio.html

10.5:1 is not a high compression ratio for a modern, direct injected, small displacement engine. The 2.4 liter, direct injected GM engine discussed in the link above runs an 11.4:1 CR!

Hence, the 10.5:1 compression ratio in the Yaris engine (where each cylinder represents a mere ~ 0.375 liters and where direct injection is involved) isn't comparable to an engine that utlizes port injection and larger cylinders (particularly the bore dimension).

What amazes me about these bulletin boards is that people voice opinions without having any REAL understanding of the subject matter, most of which boils down to advanced engineering principals.

There is absolutely, positively NO EMPIRICAL EVIDENCE supporting the notion that any modern engine that has a recommended fuel octane rating of 87 PON can, in any way, benefit from a gasoline of a higher octane rating. If anything, empirical evidence suggests the opposite, since the slightly lower burn rate of the higher octane fuel may adversely impact the intended timing of the complete combustion process, relative to the position of the piston and the valves.
What amazes me about bulletin boards is that they somehow produce these attitudes where people assume that other people are oblivious and what they say is the gospel. As cool as you might be, I also have an engineering degree to my credit...and 2 other degrees to boot but that doesn't mean shit. Engine dynamics are pretty involved but fuel is a fairly easy thing to understand. Octane, as you know, refers to a fuel's tendancy to explode rather than burn. A low octane fuel will will burn more violently, releasing it's power/energy sooner than a higher octane fuel while a high octane fuel is more stable, and burns more slowly or energizes at a slower rate. Higher octane fuel can result in a smoother start and idle(more stable and efficient energy). As far as gas mileage goes....there are thousands of opinions and real life proof that higher octane fuels can deliver better mpg's. For example....here is a blurb from good ol' Tony...

http://www.fuelsaving.info/fuels.htm
darkmoon87Thread starterVancouver, BC · May 9, 2009#45
I love how I started the thread asking about the "smoothness" and the thread turned into a gongshow arguements about MPG and power gains...sigh lol
CrazedEpidemicNew York City · May 9, 2009#46
Originally Posted by ham ↑
I experience a noticeable gain in MPGs from 87 to 93
Thats what happened to me when I went to a Shell station that only had 93. I noticed more MPG.
DerFlosserUSA · May 9, 2009#47
Originally Posted by darkmoon87 ↑
I love how I started the thread asking about the "smoothness" and the thread turned into a gongshow arguements about MPG and power gains...sigh lol
I agree....and the only point that I ever really "tried" to make is that it's definitely possible and not "placebo" that it starts and idles smoother. 🤷
dybbukFredericton · May 9, 2009#48
And 427 seemed to be agreeing with you. However, he also said that smoothness was actually bad for the vehicle. Personally, I don't know much about engines (I am NOT a mechanic), but, I can read. It seems you guys aren't reading each other's arguments. It comes down to that it seems; yes, on higher octane fuels it will run 'smoother', but, it will also generate less power.
2009ToyotoadCalifornia · May 9, 2009#49
Originally Posted by supmet ↑
I run 91 every once in a while, and it does feel smoother starting, accelerating, and idling.

Could it be a placebo affect? Maybe
Is it only a 2 dollar placebo, if it is? Yes


With the octane specific argument aside, aren't their cleaners and additives in 91 that aren't found in 87 at some gas stations??

Bingo! We have a winner. Big oil figured out a long time ago that to charge a premium price you need to create a positive preception that the vehicle "just seem to" run smother or more powerful when spending the extra $.10 to $.20 a gallon.

Some oil companies even figured out that they can package the stuff and give it fancy names like "Octane boost, Techron, or fuel system cleaner."

Now there is nothing wrong with buying or using these products. These products do clean the system of carbon crud. However, you can get almost the same effect from running WOT on 50 miles of back country road.

Since some of us don't have 50 miles of WOT roads nearby, these additives are a reasonable substitute.

Just don't fool yourself!
427chevCT. · May 9, 2009#50
Originally Posted by dybbuk ↑
And 427 seemed to be agreeing with you. However, he also said that smoothness was actually bad for the vehicle.
Show me where I stated that "smoothness is bad for the vehicle."

I NEVER stated that. Please don't put words in my mouth again.

Originally Posted by dybbuk ↑
... It comes down to that it seems; yes, on higher octane fuels it will run 'smoother'...
Please produce third-party empirical evidence to support your claim that higher octane gasoline will cause a modern engine that's designed to run on regular gasoline to "run smoother."

Good luck finding that.

Have you ever heard of the "power of suggestion?" That's what's responsible for any "improvements" that are being claimed in using premium fuel in a Yaris. Objectively and empirically speaking, there are no ACTUAL improvements.

Medicine routinely demonstrates this phenomenon in what's known as "the placebo effect." People "feel better" when they eat a pill that made of compressed flour, for example, as long as the researchers tell the study group that it will make them feel better.