Yarisworld Archive

Mini v. sedan = injury. No duh. Is this news?

42 posts · 29,070 views

jessOriginal postca · Apr 14, 2009#1
The pimps and slime in the insurance industry rolled out a fresh round of propaganda veiled as science.

My 09 Yaris was on the losing end of their science so I'd thought I'd share with my comrades.

But before you peruse the April 13 press release, note how their bottom line agenda about the 55 MPH speed limit seems to drive their findings.

---

News Release | April 14, 2009


New crash tests demonstrate the influence of vehicle size and weight on safety in crashes; results are relevant to fuel economy policies

ARLINGTON, VA — Three front-to-front crash tests, each involving a microcar or minicar into a midsize model from the same manufacturer, show how extra vehicle size and weight enhance occupant protection in collisions. These Insurance Institute for Highway Safety tests are about the physics of car crashes, which dictate that very small cars generally can't protect people in crashes as well as bigger, heavier models.

"There are good reasons people buy minicars," says Institute president Adrian Lund. "They're more affordable, and they use less gas. But the safety trade-offs are clear from our new tests. Equally clear are the implications when it comes to fuel economy. If automakers downsize cars so their fleets use less fuel, occupant safety will be compromised. However, there are ways to serve fuel economy and safety at the same time."

The Institute didn't choose SUVs or pickup trucks, or even large cars, to pair with the micro and minis in the new crash tests. The choice of midsize cars reveals how much influence some extra size and weight can have on crash outcomes. The Institute chose pairs of 2009 models from Daimler, Honda, and Toyota because these automakers have micro and mini models that earn good frontal crashworthiness ratings, based on the Institute's offset test into a deformable barrier. Researchers rated performance in the 40 mph car-to-car tests, like the front-into-barrier tests, based on measured intrusion into the occupant compartment, forces recorded on the driver dummy, and movement of the dummy during the impact.

Laws of physics prevail: The Honda Fit, Smart Fortwo, and Toyota Yaris are good performers in the Institute's frontal offset barrier test, but all three are poor performers in the frontal collisions with midsize cars. These results reflect the laws of the physical universe, specifically principles related to force and distance.

Although the physics of frontal car crashes usually are described in terms of what happens to the vehicles, injuries depend on the forces that act on the occupants, and these forces are affected by two key physical factors. One is the weight of a crashing vehicle, which determines how much its velocity will change during impact. The greater the change, the greater the forces on the people inside and the higher the injury risk. The second factor is vehicle size, specifically the distance from the front of a vehicle to its occupant compartment. The longer this is, the lower the forces on the occupants.

Size and weight affect injury likelihood in all kinds of crashes. In a collision involving two vehicles that differ in size and weight, the people in the smaller, lighter vehicle will be at a disadvantage. The bigger, heavier vehicle will push the smaller, lighter one backward during the impact. This means there will be less force on the occupants of the heavier vehicle and more on the people in the lighter vehicle. Greater force means greater risk, so the likelihood of injury goes up in the smaller, lighter vehicle.

Crash statistics confirm this. The death rate in 1-3-year-old minicars in multiple-vehicle crashes during 2007 was almost twice as high as the rate in very large cars.

"Though much safer than they were a few years ago, minicars as a group do a comparatively poor job of protecting people in crashes, simply because they're smaller and lighter," Lund says. "In collisions with bigger vehicles, the forces acting on the smaller ones are higher, and there's less distance from the front of a small car to the occupant compartment to 'ride down' the impact. These and other factors increase injury likelihood."

The death rate per million 1-3-year-old minis in single-vehicle crashes during 2007 was 35 compared with 11 per million for very large cars. Even in midsize cars, the death rate in single-vehicle crashes was 17 percent lower than in minicars. The lower death rate is because many objects that vehicles hit aren't solid, and vehicles that are big and heavy have a better chance of moving or deforming the objects they strike. This dissipates some of the energy of the impact.

Some proponents of mini and small cars claim they're as safe as bigger, heavier cars. But the claims don't hold up. For example, there's a claim that the addition of safety features to the smallest cars in recent years reduces injury risk, and this is true as far as it goes. Airbags, advanced belts, electronic stability control, and other features are helping. They've been added to cars of all sizes, though, so the smallest cars still don't match the bigger cars in terms of occupant protection.

Would hazards be reduced if all passenger vehicles were as small as the smallest ones? This would help in vehicle-to-vehicle crashes, but occupants of smaller cars are at increased risk in all kinds of crashes, not just ones with heavier vehicles. Almost half of all crash deaths in minicars occur in single-vehicle crashes, and these deaths wouldn't be reduced if all cars became smaller and lighter. In fact, the result would be to afford less occupant protection fleetwide in single-vehicle crashes.

Yet another claim is that minicars are easier to maneuver, so their drivers can avoid crashes in the first place. Insurance claims experience says otherwise. The frequency of claims filed for crash damage is higher for mini 4-door cars than for midsize ones.

Here's how the pairs of cars fared in the Institute's new crash tests:

Honda Accord versus Fit: The structure of the Accord held up well in the crash test into the Fit, and all except one measure of injury likelihood recorded on the driver dummy's head, neck, chest, and both legs were good. In contrast, a number of injury measures on the dummy in the Fit were less than good. Forces on the left lower leg and right upper leg were in the marginal range, while the measure on the right tibia was poor. These indicate a high risk of leg injury in a real-world crash of similar severity. In addition, the dummy's head struck the steering wheel through the airbag. Intrusion into the Fit's occupant compartment was extensive. Overall, this minicar's rating is poor in the front-to-front crash, despite its good crashworthiness rating based on the Institute's frontal offset test into a deformable barrier. The Accord earns good ratings for performance in both tests.

Mercedes C class versus Smart Fortwo: After striking the front of the C class, the Smart went airborne and turned around 450 degrees. This contributed to excessive movement of the dummy during rebound — a dramatic indication of the Smart's poor performance but not the only one. There was extensive intrusion into the space around the dummy from head to feet. The instrument panel moved up and toward the dummy. The steering wheel was displaced upward. Multiple measures of injury likelihood, including those on the dummy's head, were poor, as were measures on both legs.

"The Smart is the smallest car we tested, so it's not surprising that its performance looked worse than the Fit's. Still both fall into the poor category, and it's hard to distinguish between poor and poorer," Lund says. "In both the Smart and Fit, occupants would be subject to high injury risk in crashes with heavier cars." In contrast, the C class held up well, with little to no intrusion into the occupant compartment. Nearly all measures of injury likelihood were in the good range.

Toyota Camry versus Yaris: There was far more intrusion into the occupant compartment of the Yaris than the Camry. The minicar's door was largely torn away. The driver seats in both cars tipped forward, but only in the Yaris did the steering wheel move excessively. Similar contrasts characterize the measures of injury likelihood recorded on the dummies. The heads of both struck the cars' steering wheels through the airbags, but only the head injury measure on the dummy in the Yaris rated poor. There was extensive force on the neck and right leg plus a deep gash at the right knee of the dummy in the minicar. Like the Smart and Fit, the Yaris earns an overall rating of poor in the car-to-car test. The Camry is acceptable.

Fuel economy implications: One reason people buy smaller cars is to conserve fuel. Gasoline prices skyrocketed last year, and there's no telling what the price at the pump might be next week. Meanwhile, the gears are turning to hike federal fuel economy requirements to address environmental concerns. The conflict is that smaller vehicles use less fuel but do a relatively poor job of protecting people in crashes, so fuel conservation policies have tended to conflict with motor vehicle safety policies.

A problem with the current structure of fuel economy standards for cars is that the target of 27.5 miles per gallon is applied to an automaker's whole fleet, no matter the mix of cars an individual automaker sells. This encourages manufacturers to sell more smaller, lighter cars to offset the fuel consumed by their bigger, heavier models. Sometimes automakers even sell the smaller — and less safe — cars at a loss to ensure compliance with fleetwide requirements.

In response, the Obama administration announced it is boosting the fuel economy standard for cars, beginning with 2011 models, and instituting a size-based system to set fuel economy targets like the one already in effect for SUVs, pickups, and vans. This system will mandate lower fuel consumption as cars get smaller and lighter, thus removing the incentive for automakers to downsize their lightest vehicles to comply. It also could mean that technology currently used to enhance horsepower would go instead to reduce gas consumption — a direct safety benefit because less powerful cars have lower crash rates.

Another way to conserve fuel, and serve safety at the same time, is to set lower speed limits. Going slower uses less fuel to cover the same distance. The national maximum 55 mph speed limit, enacted in 1974, saved thousands of barrels of fuel per day. It also saved thousands of lives. Highway deaths declined about 20 percent the first year, from 55,511 in 1973 to 46,402 in 1974. The National Research Council estimated that most of the reduction was due to the lower speed limit, and the rest was because of reduced travel. By 1983 the national maximum 55 mph limit still was saving 2,000 to 4,000 lives annually.

"Fifty-five was adopted to save fuel, but it turned out to be one of the most dramatic safety successes in motor vehicle history," Lund concludes. "The political will to reinstate it probably is lacking, but if policymakers want a win-win approach, lowering the speed limit is it. It saves fuel and lives at the same time."

Replies 41

jambo101Montreal Canada · Apr 14, 2009#2
Originally Posted by jess ↑
. By 1983 the national maximum 55 mph limit still was saving 2,000 to 4,000 lives annually.

"Fifty-five was adopted to save fuel, but it turned out to be one of the most dramatic safety successes in motor vehicle history," Lund concludes. "The political will to reinstate it probably is lacking, but if policymakers want a win-win approach, lowering the speed limit is it. It saves fuel and lives at the same time."
Makes sense to me.
Yaris HiltonBristol, Tennessee, USA · Apr 14, 2009#3
Hah! I was just coming here to post a link to the same article, which the New York Times is highlighting this morning. What a revelation! Ram a big car into a little car headon, and you're worse off in the little car! Whodathunkit?
SailDesign. · Apr 14, 2009#4
JUst makes me realise that ALL big cars should be banned. They are obviously going to do more damage to people, and are therefore unsafe for the public at lasrge. Burn 'em all! 🙂
Yaris HiltonBristol, Tennessee, USA · Apr 14, 2009#5
BTW, I just looked up the nominal curb weight for a 2008 Camry. 1050 lbs more than my 2009 Yaris sedan.
Yaris HiltonBristol, Tennessee, USA · Apr 14, 2009#6
Now they're highlighting this on the CNNMoney site, too.
HTM Yarissouth Carolina · Apr 14, 2009#7
Somebody should address the REAL issue . People need more driver training ..................
cleongSingapore · Apr 14, 2009#8
When was the last time you saw a head-on accident compared to all other types of accidents?

I think head-on accidents are a small percentage of car accidents.
Yaris HiltonBristol, Tennessee, USA · Apr 14, 2009#9
Now foxnews.com has put this as their lead story and top video link.
SailDesign. · Apr 14, 2009#10
Time to mandate a Momentum Limit on the roads. Let's see, a Yaris at (say) 2500 lbs nominal, at 55 mph, gives a momentum of 137,500 lb.mph. Assume a Camry at 3500 lbs, then his max in a 55 zone would be 137,500 / 3500 = 39 mph.
An old Cadillac at around 5000 lbs would be limited to 27.5 mph, etc.
A semi, say consevatively 30 tons (60,000 lbs) would be limited to 2 or 3 mph. 😁
Time to give the semis their own road system, abnd make life safer for all of us.
Yaris HiltonBristol, Tennessee, USA · Apr 14, 2009#11
Originally Posted by SailDesign ↑
Time to give the semis their own road system, and make life safer for all of us.
I agree. But I really don't want to pay the taxes that would require. 😲
ddongbaphay · Apr 14, 2009#12
Originally Posted by HTM Yaris ↑
Somebody should address the REAL issue . People need more driver training ..................
OH GOD. Someone gets it.
nemelekArizona · Apr 14, 2009#13
23 years ago I was involved in a head on accident. I was driving a 73 camaro doing 45mph. A teenager driving a 69 valant crossed the center line at 70 mph. He died. I broke my left hand. Rather it was blind luck or the grace of god that I am alive today I don't know. When your time is up it's up. Live today to it's fullest.
Kaotic LazagnaCentral Valley, CA · Apr 14, 2009#14
hmmm, I guess we all should buy Mack semi trucks now...

But yeah, people need to learn how to drive better and safer, as was mentioned earlier.
SailDesign. · Apr 14, 2009#15
Originally Posted by ddongbap ↑
OH GOD. Someone gets it.
+1
mr. poopyheadMississauga, ON · Apr 14, 2009#16
this is the stupidest crap ever...

you could do the same experiment and replace the "minicars" vs. sedans with sedans vs. SUVs... you'd get the same results and then have a "scientific" evidence that people should ditch their sedans and all move to SUVs... which will just accelerate the arms race that has been going on for years now... people moving into bigger cars and trucks to save themselves from the other people driving big cars and trucks... it's ridiculous...

take a look at the cars from the 80s... they were like the "minicars" we have now... the current corolla is bigger than an 80s camry... and have you seen the new ford F150? it's twice the size as an F-150 from 20 years ago... are traffic fatalities any lower now than then? (that's an honest question... i have no stats on it)

god bless america... the land of the fearful...
LambpastyMassachusetts · Apr 14, 2009#18
Wait so you mean to tell me that If I drive my Yaris into a head-on collision with a ford F-350 that there's an increased chance I'll be hurt?!😲🙄 So that means that if I get into a head-on driving an F-350 into a dump truck I might get hurt too?! I guess everyone should just start driving school buses and dump trucks around everywhere.

So is this really about the Yarii and economy cars being (obviously) on the losing side of a head-on or is it a way to persuade people into buying huge SUVs they don't need so they can be "safe" (and boost sales)...👎
Yaris HiltonBristol, Tennessee, USA · Apr 14, 2009#20
Originally Posted by mr. poopyhead ↑
the current corolla is bigger than an 80s camry...
The current Yaris sedan is bigger than an 80s Camry, and weighs the same. Toyota's been playing in the upsizing game, too.
jambo101Montreal Canada · Apr 14, 2009#21
This is a plot by the oil companies to get us all back into gas guzzling SUV's😉
DaveToronto · Apr 14, 2009#22
Same article was published in today's Toronto Star, and I was going to post about it here as well.

Seems this article doesn't mention the point in the Star that got me so riled up this afternoon:

"There are good reasons people buy mini cars. They're more affordable, and they use less gas. But the safety trade-offs are clear from our new tests," said Adrian Lund, the institute's president.

Automakers who manufacture the small cars said the tests simulated a high-speed crash that rarely happens on the road. They also said the tests rehashed past insurance industry arguments against tougher fuel efficiency requirements. The institute has raised questions about whether stricter gas mileage rules, which are being developed by the government, might lead to smaller, lighter vehicles that could be less safe.
http://www.wheels.ca/reviews/article/533297

In my humble opinion, this is absolute bullshit and nothing more than an attempt at using fear mongering to push people into larger and less efficient vehicles. The biases of the group who released this study is as clear as day. Leave it to insurance and oil companies to sensationalize 300 year old physics laws. This study could only mean less if it was published directly by the oil tycoon from The Simpsons.
auxmikeLI, New Yawk · Apr 14, 2009#23
Why did'nt they try the HB Yaris vs. the Camry?
That's the showdown I wanna see!😎
MorganPCB, FL · Apr 14, 2009#24
Originally Posted by Yaris Hilton ↑
BTW, I just looked up the nominal curb weight for a 2008 Camry. 1050 lbs more than my 2009 Yaris sedan.
I'm glad the iihs did the test small car vs small car + 1000lbs....

Originally Posted by mr. poopyhead ↑
this is the stupidest crap ever...

you could do the same experiment and replace the "minicars" vs. sedans with sedans vs. SUVs... you'd get the same results and then have a "scientific" evidence that people should ditch their sedans and all move to SUVs... which will just accelerate the arms race that has been going on for years now... people moving into bigger cars and trucks to save themselves from the other people driving big cars and trucks... it's ridiculous...

take a look at the cars from the 80s... they were like the "minicars" we have now... the current corolla is bigger than an 80s camry... and have you seen the new ford F150? it's twice the size as an F-150 from 20 years ago... are traffic fatalities any lower now than then? (that's an honest question... i have no stats on it)

god bless america... the land of the fearful...
+190238498791209852
Kal-ElMassachusetts · Apr 14, 2009#25
Geez, this is equivalent to crashing into the edge of a solid wall (with all impact force on the left half of the car) at 80 mph! What do these idiots think is going to happen??

Hell, if you took a Hummer and did the same test with an 18-wheeler, do you think the Hummer is going to keep you safe? No chance.

🙄
Yaris HiltonBristol, Tennessee, USA · Apr 14, 2009#26
Originally Posted by Kal-El ↑
Geez, this is equivalent to crashing into the edge of a solid wall (with all impact force on the left half of the car) at 80 mph! What do these idiots think is going to happen??
It's even worse than that, because the car with the smaller mass is driven backward on impact.
RHDVIPbBLouisville, KY · Apr 14, 2009#27
Nobody has a higher chance of survival in a head on crash. Too many variables.

I do however think that there needs to be more testing when renewing your driver license.
mr. poopyheadMississauga, ON · Apr 15, 2009#28
Originally Posted by Dave ↑
This study could only mean less if it was published directly by the oil tycoon from The Simpsons.
"i'm gonna build the rootin'est, tootin'est, pollutin'est SUV for ya'll safety minded americans! yee-haw!!!"

Picture not included in this copy
DefStarYarisWaltham, MA · Apr 15, 2009#29
I guess I should ditch my Yaris for a Hummer inside a larger Hummer wrapped in armor plating so I'll be safe.
nsmitchellRichmond, VA · Apr 15, 2009#30
Originally Posted by Yaris Hilton ↑
Now foxnews.com has put this as their lead story and top video link.
/sarchasm/ Not Fox News! 😲/endsarchasm/
nsmitchellRichmond, VA · Apr 15, 2009#31
I think fear is what drives a lot of Americans to big cars/SUVs. Plain and simple. Fear, and keeping up with the Jones'/materialism.
SailDesign. · Apr 15, 2009#32
Originally Posted by Thirty-Nine ↑
<snip>
It's kind of a movement, I guess—one I'm proud to be a part of.
+1 🙂
ddongbaphay · Apr 15, 2009#33
Seriously guys, we need to get out of the sterotype that SUVs are everywhere. They aren't anymore.

On a side note. The MBenz C-Class was introduced after the E-Class became larger. MBenz needed another entry level segment in the US. Back in the 80s, the E-Class (190E, aka w201), was small.
slothman86Savannah, GA · Apr 15, 2009#34
And how many people have really gotten hurt on this site while driving their Yaris? ?
tomatoSan Francisco Bay Area · Apr 15, 2009#36
Originally Posted by Yaris Hilton ↑
What a revelation! Ram a big car into a little car headon, and you're worse off in the little car! Whodathunkit?
👍

For real!
BailOutReno, Nevada, USA · Apr 15, 2009#37
Originally Posted by slothman86 ↑
And how many people have really gotten hurt on this site while driving their Yaris? ?
I am curious about this as well. Between all the members on this site, past and present, and the real-world Yaris owners that I know, none of us has been significantly hurt in a collision, let alone dying from it.

In fact, the only helicopter ride I can recall wasn't even a collision but came from a teenage member that fully admitted he was driving like an ass and rolled his LB a few times on a deserted stretch of road.
SailDesign. · Apr 15, 2009#38
Originally Posted by slothman86 ↑
And how many people have really gotten hurt on this site while driving their Yaris? ?
I dunno - my side is still stiff in the morning after my crunch a couple of weeks ago. 🙂
OTOH, I have been getting used to the new 09 seats for the last week, and that could be helping.....
Kal-ElMassachusetts · Apr 15, 2009#39
If they want me in a mid-size or bigger car, then they better build me one that get's at least 40 mpg and costs under $16K. Yeah, that will happen! 🙄

Point is, there's a reason we want or have to buy small cars - cheap and efficient are two of the main reasons!
tomatoSan Francisco Bay Area · Apr 16, 2009#40
Originally Posted by Kal-El ↑

Point is, there's a reason we want or have to buy small cars - cheap and efficient are two of the main reasons!
+1
Easy to park, and easy/fun to drive are also right up there IMO.