Yarisworld Archive

The "let's brainstorm how to make a piggyback work" thread

84 posts · 86,364 views · page 2 of 2

Replies continued

eTiMaGoThread starterBangkok, Thailand · Mar 27, 2009#51
Originally Posted by largeorangefont ↑
The Unichip turbo module will support a 5th injector, so that is not a big deal. Pretty standard
5th injector's a bit of a last resort solution/hack though, isn't it?
1nzBrunei · Mar 27, 2009#52
greedy F-manage
he Greddy F-Manage enables you to control the feedback to your ECU, opening a range of tuning possibilities.
Features

* Controls feedback of air/fuel ratio to the standard ECU
* Does not control air/fuel ratio, this is used in conjunction with fuel controllers
* Can be used simultaneously with e-Manage Ultimate data logger
* DIP switches enable control of maps and switch on/off
Picture not included in this copy
eTiMaGoThread starterBangkok, Thailand · Mar 27, 2009#53
well hellooooo there! *starts reading up instead of working* arrrrgh
eTiMaGoThread starterBangkok, Thailand · Mar 27, 2009#54
Doesn't seem to be officially released outside of Japan, though, so good luck getting instructions in English...

http://www.trust-power.com/03electric/fmanage.html

Seems to have a NCP91 harness already, nice.

But, the million dollar question, will it be able to dance around the ECU's emissions checks...
1nzBrunei · Mar 27, 2009#55
well i was told it was for new car with relearning issue, so any one got the $ and just order it already hehe because when reading this thread i think diz is the right gadget all of u been looking for
ChinoCharlesOH · Mar 27, 2009#56
Hi Charles

Thank you for sending us the specifications of your vehicle. We have managed to get a Toyota Yaris and we are going to do the installation next week. We would first like to see what the unit does on the vehicle and then we can take it from there and then talk about sending an unit out to you to try it out on your car. My manager is aware of this situation and would love to find a solution for you.

I will keep in touch and will definitely get back to you once we have done the installation and will let you know what the outcome was. What are the specification that you are after? Are you looking at fuel consumption, more power or timing?

Have a great weekend.

Kind Regards
Marcell Bruynius (Ms.)
Digital Data Systems (Pty) Ltd
Manufacturers of Perfect Power Automotive Systems
22 Arbeid Avenue, Strijdom Park, Randburg, Gauteng, South Africa, 2194
PO Box 35872, Northcliff, Gauteng, South Africa, 2115
Tel: +27 (0) 11 792 9805
Fax: +27 (0) 11 792 9818
Email: marcell@dtwebs.com
Website: www.perfectpower.com


Onwards!
tk-421Dagobah · Mar 27, 2009#57
Originally Posted by ChinoCharles ↑
Onwards![/left]
[/left]
That's great news indeed! Please specify "power" as a requirement! 😁
yaris-meAnaheim, CA · Mar 27, 2009#58
I believe the AT and MT have different operating parameters. Will that have an affect on the piggyback?🤷
dallasCanada · Mar 28, 2009#59
Vey promising, your the Man! Good work,

Now let's hope and prey it's not one of those African scams !

Originally Posted by ChinoCharles ↑
Onwards![/LEFT]
[/LEFT]
eTiMaGoThread starterBangkok, Thailand · Mar 28, 2009#60
OK, here's my first draft:

Marcell,

Thanks very much for your enthusiasm!

The interest in tuning our cars' fueling is primarily for use with turbo/supercharger systems. But, if there s enough flexibility and results, I am sure may would be interested in tuning for better fuel economy too.

I will quickly outline the progress and attempts at working with piggybacks fuel management systems on various US Yarii.

Some years back there was a company, Zero Point Industries, which has since gone out of business, offering a turbo kit for the car, and using an e-manage unit for fuel management. They were unable to overcome the car's closed-loop logic for tuning, and their solution was to have the car in a permanent CEL condition, where the fueling runs in an open loop, and the e-manage can have control over it. As you know, this is an extremely crude approach!

Other members of our community have tried using AEM's FIC device which is supposed to work very well, but have had many problems, usually in closed-loop mode when then ECU is fighting hard to keep the AFR in stoich. I do not have more specific details at the moment but I can ask them to provide more information if you need.

On the other hand, we have a handful of members who are using a supercharger kit manufactured by Blitz, that comes with its own fuel management piggyback unit. Not a lot is known about its exact operation, but those members who have dyno'ed their car, or have a wideband O2 sensor, have found that it is still running rather lean, even at WOT when the car is supposed to run in open loop mode.

Now, one of these members is moving to a full standalone management system, but this is really out of the skill and budget of most enthusiasts who just want a reliable way to add 30-50 horsepower to their car.

We collectively have done a lot of research into the way Toyota set up the ECU to monitor the various sensors (MAF, IAT, AF, O2) to calculate the correct injector duty cycle, and it really is a rather tight-knit system, which is great if you do not intend to tweak anything, but too smart for our own good! We have access to rather detailed technical reference (repair/service manuals) describing all of this, so please let me know if you would like a copy. Alternatively, you can check the "brainstorming" thread in our forum:

The "let's brainstorm how to make a piggyback work" thread
Feel free to add/remove/modify 🙂
eTiMaGoThread starterBangkok, Thailand · Mar 28, 2009#61
Originally Posted by yaris-me ↑
I believe the AT and MT have different operating parameters. Will that have an affect on the piggyback?🤷
The AT ECU is completely separate, and apart from the different idling speed, I don't believe there is any difference at all between the ECUs
dallasCanada · Mar 28, 2009#62
Very well written, cant get more accurate and on topic than that 👍

Originally Posted by eTiMaGo ↑
OK, here's my first draft:



Feel free to add/remove/modify 🙂
largeorangefontSo Cal, OC · Mar 29, 2009#63
Sounds like you got some good feedback Charles. I would be open to testing and tuning something like this.
eTiMaGoThread starterBangkok, Thailand · Mar 29, 2009#64
Well after some musing about this, there are two approaches to this whole fuelling debacle.

The first one is to try to tweak the closed loop operation to run richer on demand. This is rather difficult and would hinge on modification of the AF and O2 sensors to give the ECU the impression of running lean, causing it to make the AFR richer.

The second one, which according to Long's findings, seems to be the Blitz approach (and a far more refined version of ZPI's), is to just forget about closed loop operation and trigger open loop when extra richness is required. He noticed on his Scangauge that as soon as the SC clutch was engaged and producing boost, the ECU switched to open loop

Obviously the first method would be preferred, as it should keep the car completely OBD fault-free, so in theory have no problems with inspections.

Now, looking at the reference manuals, it seems there are 3 types of open loop modes (my comments in italics):

• OL (Open Loop): Has not yet satisfied conditions to go closed loop (i.e. warming up)
• OL DRIVE: Open loop due to driving conditions (fuel enrichment) (i.e. pedal to the metal)
• OL FAULT: Open loop due to detected system fault (i.e. CEL)
So Blitz's fuel controller would be triggering this OL DRIVE mode somehow. But how? I'll report back when I find more information 😁
eTiMaGoThread starterBangkok, Thailand · Mar 29, 2009#65
I'm looking again and again at the instructions and wiring diagram and the only input that the Blitz box has to the ECU is the MAF signal. So, the possibility is that OL DRIVE can be triggered by a MAF signal over a certain threshold. Long, does the SCII have any way to monitor MAF voltage?
eTiMaGoThread starterBangkok, Thailand · Mar 29, 2009#66
back on the topic of the more elegant idea of closed loop tuning, URD has some rather interesting devices that could quite possibly solve this:

AFR Sensor calibrator:
http://www.urdusa.com/product_info.p..._id=1230100028
Tweaks the AF sensor's signal, thus affecting the short term fuel trim for closed loop mode

MAF sensor calibrator:
http://www.urdusa.com/product_info.p..._id=1260198051
A regular piggyback style device to tweak the MAF signal to affect the fueling in open loop

MAF + Timing calibrator:
http://www.urdusa.com/product_info.p..._id=1260198051
This ought to be enough to cover open loop operation where the timing is maxed out by default.

These products should be universal enough to work with our cars too but I am writing to them just in case, to see what input they may have 🙂
eTiMaGoThread starterBangkok, Thailand · Mar 29, 2009#67
Thanks Pavel, some good info there... do you mind if I post the excel file here in case anyone wants to have a look at it?
eTiMaGoThread starterBangkok, Thailand · Mar 29, 2009#68
well here's PK's data log of a drive in various conditions... mostly gentle driving, and you'll see several apparently random points where it goes to open loop, but looking carefully you'll see that it corresponds to the car slowing down and minimum throttle.. thus, DFCO!

can't attach excel files here, but here's a download link:

http://dl.getdropbox.com/u/691356/Normal%20Run.xls
largeorangefontSo Cal, OC · Mar 29, 2009#69
Why do you guys want to do closed loop fueling adjustments? They are not needed. The car is self adjusting (to a point) in closed loop.
eTiMaGoThread starterBangkok, Thailand · Mar 29, 2009#70
Originally Posted by largeorangefont ↑
Why do you guys want to do closed loop fueling adjustments? They are not needed. The car is self adjusting (to a point) in closed loop.
well yes but it tries to stay at 14.7 AFR no matter what. And from looking at the data that Pavel posted, the car can stay in closed loop mode even up to quite high RPMs, as long as the gas pedal is not being mashed down.

On the other hand, it is something I am not so sure about in the first place, at three quarters throttle, 4000RPM, for example, is there enough pressure from a SC/turbo that it would require fuel enrichment? Or am I barking up the wrong tree?
eTiMaGoThread starterBangkok, Thailand · Mar 29, 2009#71
Pavel's newest run, equipped with a heavier foot:

http://dl.getdropbox.com/u/691356/1to3Run.xls

note the relation between throttle % and open loop in the initial acceleration phase. Red numbers are shift points (hence the spot of 20% throttle which could be ignored)
largeorangefontSo Cal, OC · Mar 29, 2009#72
Originally Posted by eTiMaGo ↑
well yes but it tries to stay at 14.7 AFR no matter what. And from looking at the data that Pavel posted, the car can stay in closed loop mode even up to quite high RPMs, as long as the gas pedal is not being mashed down.

On the other hand, it is something I am not so sure about in the first place, at three quarters throttle, 4000RPM, for example, is there enough pressure from a SC/turbo that it would require fuel enrichment? Or am I barking up the wrong tree?
That log has great info, but he is just putting around. Have him datalog a pull in a gear. Do one in 2nd from 2000 RPM and full throttle to redline, and the same in third gear. What is done to the car?

You are thinking correctly. Generally forced induction cars go into open loop sooner than NA cars. Some NA cars don't hit open loop until you go WOT. My guess is that this is one reason the Blitz SC is clutch driven, so you are not getting boost at lower load areas.

We can't see the actual AFR, but we can see his timing, which will be helpful.
Can he graph injector latency or duty cycle too? If so get that on there.

You can't hope to tune closed loop, no piggyback I have ever seen can do it. It just causes problems.
eTiMaGoThread starterBangkok, Thailand · Mar 29, 2009#73
LOF, I posted a second excel file just before your post with more spirited acceleration, Open Loop seems to kick in at 75% throttle and above, though this should require some more testing 🙂

I'm not sure you can get injector info off the OBD bus?

But what do you think of that URF AF sensor device I posted earlier? By tweaking the response from the sensor it would have the ability to affect the short term fuel trim and thus richen it up a little as needed. I'm just not sure how the rear O2 sensor will react to that and cause trouble...
largeorangefontSo Cal, OC · Mar 29, 2009#74
Originally Posted by eTiMaGo ↑
LOF, I posted a second excel file just before your post with more spirited acceleration, Open Loop seems to kick in at 75% throttle and above, though this should require some more testing 🙂

I'm not sure you can get injector info off the OBD bus?

But what do you think of that URF AF sensor device I posted earlier? By tweaking the response from the sensor it would have the ability to affect the short term fuel trim and thus richen it up a little as needed. I'm just not sure how the rear O2 sensor will react to that and cause trouble...
I saw that log, he is going too slow. We need long WOT pulls in a single gear, like you would do on a dyno.

Injector info is there on the OBD, the software just needs to be able to read it.

The problem with adjusting the fuel trim is that the car will readjust it back. The car can adjust fuel trims around +/- 25% before a CEL is thrown. Like I said, I have never really seen one that truly works. The car is constantly learing around your changes.

The rear 02 does nothing in relation to fueling. It is only there to insure the pre cats are functioning.
eTiMaGoThread starterBangkok, Thailand · Mar 29, 2009#75
hmmm i believe those are stored values when you have a CEL, not the dynamic values like you've logged so far...
eTiMaGoThread starterBangkok, Thailand · Mar 29, 2009#76
right right gotcha... well this is way over my head, and I need to get to bed, so I won't be much help 🙁
largeorangefontSo Cal, OC · Mar 29, 2009#78
Originally Posted by PK198105 ↑
LOF i got no engine mods so far and i need a longer straight with no one in front of me to do it safely and properly. ill try and do a run like you said from 2000k and up in each gear.
That would be great. Even seeing what a stock car does will be very helpful. Is there anything on the PID list relating to the fuel injectors?

Your list for that other pull had all the stuff we need, except for injector duty cycle or pulse width.
aucoriumSouth Africa · Mar 30, 2009#79
hey Guys

FYI , i chatted to a few guys with the SMT6 chip here in RSA, and they werent all that happy with the chip and have since changed to UNICHIP , im not sure if this is isolated senario's but just thought i'd give you guys the heads up.Problems reported are fueling and idiling , but like i said , could just be the cars that were tuned , i will keep an eye out for more info.
eTiMaGoThread starterBangkok, Thailand · Mar 30, 2009#80
thanks for the heads up, aucorium...

Today I tested something... As you might know I have a basic AF gauge hooked in to the factory sensor, it's not all that useful, but can show me when the car goes to open loop (in closed loop the AF ratio keeps oscillation rich-lean-rich-lean, as this is the most efficient way for the catalyser to work, wile in open loop the needle stays still). So, leaving the house, I shifted up to third at a rather low speed and put the throttle down. The engine was too low in RPMs to gain any sensible speed, but sure enough, AF needle pegged itself at 14:1 after a second, and stayed there until I let my foot off the gas.

I should have a chance to get on the highway late tonight and repeat the experiment in other gears/conditions, but this is quite promising!
aucoriumSouth Africa · Mar 30, 2009#81
mmm , that seems to show some promise , nice one!! let us know how the test goes.
aucoriumSouth Africa · Mar 30, 2009#82
FYI

i am busy researching us a Dastek Uni - Q chip , apparently this works on the yaris , it worked on my buddies honda fit 1.5 , so im gonna see if i can get a plug and play setup , as the guys here claim to have one for the yaris , i will keep you posted.

here is the chip:

http://www.dastek.co.uk/features_unichip.htm

it can control VVT aswell !
lammy29Nottingham, UK · Aug 17, 2011#84
any updates after all these years?