Yarisworld Archive

3rd Gear grind

93 posts · 39,314 views · page 2 of 2

Replies continued

YodaFL · Mar 9, 2009#51
ok cool sounds good
marcustoronto, canada · Mar 9, 2009#52
Originally Posted by hatchbackkid82 ↑
When i dropped it off he asked if i had the gear oil changed. i told him that i did it myself a few months ago. He then said well if we find anything wrong with it by default we will let you know. I'm pretty sure they will try and dump this on me. Of course I'm going to raise hell if they do😠
you should have just lied about the oil change.. now they are gonna have to see a receipt and the type of oil you put in..otherwise hope you get lucky and get someone who wont care but to give you a better customer service. good luck
hatchbackkid82Thread starter. · Mar 9, 2009#53
I couldn't lie about it... well i could but, they have the transmission drain plug marked with ink. So they know when the drain bolts been removed. I have receipts... put the correct viscosity in there.
marcustoronto, canada · Mar 9, 2009#54
you got the receipt then they cant decline ur coverage.. ur good to go.
hatchbackkid82Thread starter. · Mar 9, 2009#55
yup have all that stuff... at least last time i checked before i moved😕 If not just talk to a manager raise a lil bit of hell or just write the bbb or call toyota corporate
tomatoSan Francisco Bay Area · Mar 9, 2009#56
hmm.. car in the shop is never fun. 🙁 good luck, and let us know how it turns out!
hatchbackkid82Thread starter. · Mar 10, 2009#57
still waiting....this sucks i thought they would at least give me a loaner. i hate catching the bus
hatchbackkid82Thread starter. · Mar 10, 2009#58
Just spoke to the dealer, they are ordering a few parts. Asked the manager if this would be covered by the warranty, said he couldn't tell me just yet. said that they would have to pull the transmission to find out for sure. This is really frustrating, doesn't the powertrain warranty cover the motor and tranny😠? Last time i checked i was pretty sure it did. Why not give me a straight answer? What else is there to find out? There is a grind in 3rd gear short and simple.
marcustoronto, canada · Mar 10, 2009#59
canadian power train is 5 years.. and bumper to bumper is 3 years.. i believe.
tomatoSan Francisco Bay Area · Mar 10, 2009#60
Originally Posted by hatchbackkid82 ↑
Just spoke to the dealer, they are ordering a few parts. Asked the manager if this would be covered by the warranty, said he couldn't tell me just yet. said that they would have to pull the transmission to find out for sure. This is really frustrating, doesn't the powertrain warranty cover the motor and tranny😠? Last time i checked i was pretty sure it did. Why not give me a straight answer? What else is there to find out? There is a grind in 3rd gear short and simple.
Who knows.

You know, I bought my car used, but "certified" which is supposed to mean that I have a bumper to bumper warranty identical to the factory warranty for 3 months post purchase. I wanted them to check something (I think my clutch is really stiff in the morning, then it gets better as you drive it), so I thought, hey the car is under warranty, let's go ask them if it's a big deal or maybe just the way that car is. Well, they said they might have to charge me $160 just to look at the car to find out what's going on and whether or not whatever is going on is under warranty or not. When I complained about that rip-off charge to "look at the car" they told me and I quote "that's why people buy new cars, you got a 2007, so.... which is 🙄🙄🙄 I mean cars don't start falling apart when they're a couple of years old!! or do they?!!! I don't think the stiffness of the clutch is that big of a deal, so I'm not too worried, but I didn't expect to be jerked around like that 😠

Now I know why people are complaining about the service they get at the dealership on Yelp.com 🙄
marcustoronto, canada · Mar 10, 2009#61
they should give you a loaner.. read your contract again...coz when they fixed my strut they gave me a loaner for 2 days..they gave me a rav 4..very sluggish car..dont like that one although its great on gas..meter didnt move for me using it for 2 days.. might be broken.
hatchbackkid82Thread starter. · Mar 10, 2009#62
I'll wait for his call, he said he would give me a call back this afternoon. I'll ask him then how much longer they expect to have my car. I really wont' need a loaner... i just realized have a friend that is going out of town said she would let me borrow her car from tonight until saturday, and then i leave town on sunday. so i should be ok it just sucked having to bus it the past few days
hatchbackkid82Thread starter. · Mar 10, 2009#63
It was the 3rd gear synchro, They are fixing it right now. No charge all under warranty. WOO HOO👍!!!!!!!! Should be done by tomorrow, just in time for when the exhaust comes in.
tomatoSan Francisco Bay Area · Mar 10, 2009#64
🍻
hatchbackkid82Thread starter. · Mar 10, 2009#65
Exactly tomato🍻
tk-421Dagobah · Mar 10, 2009#66
Originally Posted by hatchbackkid82 ↑
It was the 3rd gear synchro, They are fixing it right now. No charge all under warranty. WOO HOO👍!!!!!!!! Should be done by tomorrow, just in time for when the exhaust comes in.
Good to know... I just left the car at the dealer a few minutes ago for this same purpose. 🍻
hatchbackkid82Thread starter. · Mar 10, 2009#67
Good luck hope they take care of you
tk-421Dagobah · Mar 10, 2009#68
Originally Posted by hatchbackkid82 ↑
Good luck hope they take care of you
Yeah I hope so... The Toyota rep was already giving me sh!t about having an aftermarket clutch, and how it would probably affect the warranty. Even after the mechanic already told him that it had nothing to do with the clutch. 😆
hatchbackkid82Thread starter. · Mar 10, 2009#69
Awwwww man. The rep is trying to make some money off of you, hopefully the tech tells him that it didn't affect tranny
hatchbackkid82Thread starter. · Mar 12, 2009#70
Ok still no car yet👎
tk-421Dagobah · Mar 12, 2009#71
Originally Posted by hatchbackkid82 ↑
Ok still no car yet👎
Same here. 😠
Still waiting for the warranty verdict too.
hatchbackkid82Thread starter. · Mar 12, 2009#72
Oh i know that mine is covered they're just not done with it yet.🙁
tk-421Dagobah · Mar 13, 2009#73
I just called the dealership, and the news is not good in my case.

They're not covering my car under warranty, even when they KNOW that the clutch has nothing to do with the synchro. They want to charge around $200 just for taking the tranny apart, plus parts. Not only that, but it will take them at least until next Wednesday to get the car back together.

God I love my country.
hatchbackkid82Thread starter. · Mar 13, 2009#74
Damn man sorry to hear that TK🙁. Well I just got a call back from the dealer, they ended up getting me a whole new transmission, the rep told me that after they put they new parts in there it was still doing the same thing (3rd gear grind) so they put a new tranmission in there. Sorry TK
tomatoSan Francisco Bay Area · Mar 13, 2009#75
Originally Posted by tk-421 ↑
I just called the dealership, and the news is not good in my case.

They're not covering my car under warranty, even when they KNOW that the clutch has nothing to do with the synchro. They want to charge around $200 just for taking the tranny apart, plus parts. Not only that, but it will take them at least until next Wednesday to get the car back together.

God I love my country.
OK, I don't understand this. Can someone please explain or send me to the right thread please? 😕

What I don't understand is why the dealer picks and choose what is covered or not covered. You guys have practically new cars, or cars with much lower mileage than mine, therefore should be fully covered under the 3 y initial warranty, no? Isn't the initial warranty comprehensive, or does the dealership still get to pick and choose what's covered and what's not covered?

Are there any good thread on warranty issues that I might have missed in this forum? I'm really curious. (They wanted $160 to just look at my car even though it's technically under a comprehensive "bumper to bumper" warranty. 🙄

Why go to the dealership at all if they're going to pick and choose what's covered?!!! 😠
hatchbackkid82Thread starter. · Mar 13, 2009#76
If you have a bumper to bumper warranty they should cover anything that goes wrong. Unless you have mods done, some may still honor it. But if the problem can be traced back directly to the mod then your SOL. For example: if you throw a CAI on your car and drive through a puddle and it hydrolocks. Then you take to the dealer with the CAI on there, they probably won't honor your warranty. Dealers should never charge you to take a look at your car if your under the bumper to bumper warranty. In my case i got lucky, i was out of the bumper to bumper warranty, but i was still within the powertrain warranty (5yrs/60k miles). So there was no charge.
tomatoSan Francisco Bay Area · Mar 13, 2009#77
Originally Posted by hatchbackkid82 ↑
If you have a bumper to bumper warranty they should cover anything that goes wrong...
Well, they SAID I did, that's what that Certified program is supposed to be about. 😠 Actually, you gave me an idea. I think I'll call Toyota directly and see what they say about my warranty. Maybe the guy I spoke to on the phone didn't know any better.

Sorry about the rant. I hate it when people take advantage. I have a feeling if they could get away with grabbing people by the ankles and shaking them until money comes out of their pockets, they probably would!!! What are you gonna do, you need your car and they know it. Grrrr 😠
TamagoOff Grid · Mar 13, 2009#78
so the weak transmission debacle carries over from the old generation 5spd eh ?

shame :(
JerkrattFair Lawn, NJ · Mar 13, 2009#79
Originally Posted by tk-421 ↑
I just called the dealership, and the news is not good in my case.

They're not covering my car under warranty, even when they KNOW that the clutch has nothing to do with the synchro. They want to charge around $200 just for taking the tranny apart, plus parts. Not only that, but it will take them at least until next Wednesday to get the car back together.

God I love my country.
dude get in touch with toyota corp. or talk to there general mang. i think
cleongSingapore · Mar 14, 2009#80
Given that you'd changed the clutch, there might be sufficient grounds that the powertrain was altered to cause failure to the gearbox. A stock clutch with its associated slippage may have prevented the the gearbox having to deal with the power and torque from the engine fully. Because when it bites better, it also transmits that shock through the gearbox.
tk-421Dagobah · Mar 14, 2009#81
Originally Posted by cleong ↑
Given that you'd changed the clutch, there might be sufficient grounds that the powertrain was altered to cause failure to the gearbox. A stock clutch with its associated slippage may have prevented the the gearbox having to deal with the power and torque from the engine fully. Because when it bites better, it also transmits that shock through the gearbox.
Sounds reasonable, although I had the grinding problem even before I changed my OEM clutch. That was actually one of the reasons I swapped the clutch in the end, thinking that it would fix the problem.
cleongSingapore · Mar 14, 2009#82
Unless you had reported this to the dealer back then, you can't prove that the grind was already there prior to the clutch swap.

Right now all they are focused on is the labour cost that would have to come out of their shop time, even if Toyota does honor warranty, which is probably why they are trying to get you to pay for labor.

But looking at your mod list, you have 3 items related to gearbox (NST SSK, bushings, ACT clutch) which aren't factory standard. I find that the easiest way to claim warranty without a quibble is to have a bog-stock standard car presented for the dealer's scrutiny, even if it means you have to spend on labor to demod it.

In Singapore, for some brands, warranty becomes void if you so much as skip a scheduled service with the authorized service workshop network. Modding a single item on a car causes the entire car's warranty to be voided, even if the failed part has nothing to do with what was modified, so take heart that there's dealers worse than the one you're dealing with right now.
MorganPCB, FL · Apr 8, 2009#83
I'm getting a whole new transmission!

I think the key is to just ride with one of the service technicians from your local dealer and make sure they can replicate the noise, I've been complaining since Jan 08 about this but only now (that third is practically useless) do I get a new transmission...

Ehhh, whatever

my car sans the 3rd gear > slushbox belta
tk-421Dagobah · Apr 8, 2009#84
Originally Posted by Morgan ↑
I think the key is to just ride with one of the service technicians from your local dealer and make sure they can replicate the noise
That's what I did too. The tech actually said that it had nothing to do with the clutch swap or the SSK, but later said that they wouldn't cover my warranty anyway.

I think something like the Magnusson-Moss Act should be enforced around here. I'm gonna ask around and see if that is a possibility for us mexicanos. 🙂
MorganPCB, FL · Apr 8, 2009#85
The dealer just called and asked if I wanted my clutch replaced while the transmission was out, for a moment I thought -- hmm how nice of them to call and ask, considering that dropping the subframe, disconnecting the steering, manhandling the transmission and the headache of putting it all back in is rather tedious --

so then I asked, well is the transmission off the car? "Ohh yes, its off and the new one is about to go in."

so did you take the clutch off the check the wear? "No, but I'm guessing that since you had a bad 3rd gear synchro your clutch has 10,000 more miles left on it."

ok so you didn't take the clutch off the fly wheel or inspect it in any way, yet you KNOW it only has 10,000 miles left on it? "Well we thought we'd try to save you the trouble of replacing it later."

uh-huh, no you may not put a new oem clutch in my car for $500+labor, I think I'll continue to drive my car til the recommended service interval that is 70,000+ miles away, thanks!
redglare45Pomona / Pasadena, California · Sep 2, 2009#86
Well I know this is an old tread, but count me in on that 3rd gear grind too. Mine usually would come in on downshifts only. Usually downshifting from 4th to 3rd gear usually got it to grind. Only had 61,000 miles, what sucks is that my warranty was over. So now my car is in the shop.
az_saguaroU.S. AZ · Oct 10, 2010#87
Mine has also developed the third gear grind with 67,500. Out of powertrain warranty. I do have the "Toyota Platinum" extended warranty, so now it will be fun to see how they try to not pay the warranty claim. I am sure they will think of a reason.
firemachine69Sudbury, On · Oct 12, 2010#88
Originally Posted by hatchbackkid82 ↑
I don't rough shift. Always make sure the clutch is all the way down when shift. It's driving me nuts. Even if i shift slow at a certain speed it will grind. The grinding sound is faint but still audible, but i can feel it through the shifter. It's like something is spinning in there
Your synchronizer is likely pooched.


Go make an appointment with Toyota, I hope you have drivetrain warranty left!
az_saguaroU.S. AZ · Nov 1, 2010#89
Definitely know the synchro was gone, they also found 4th gear teeth chipped and some fried bearings. Took a lot of "discussion" on the phone, but did get it the VSA (extended warranty) to cover repairs. Whew!
hatchbackkid82Thread starter. · Nov 2, 2010#90
Got it taken care of, ended up with a new transmission👍

Originally Posted by firemachine69 ↑
Your synchronizer is likely pooched.


Go make an appointment with Toyota, I hope you have drivetrain warranty left!
2o6Central Ohio · Mar 16, 2012#91
Don't mean to be a super bump, but I have the same issue with 3rd.....
yarisman1974Edmonton, AB · Apr 24, 2012#92
Well looks like evryone on here is experiencing the same thing as me, downshift from 3rd to 2nd gear, and unless I am under 40KM/h the gear will grind, meaning to me it's a synchro. Only problem is at 70K I had this problem last year and under powertrain warranty the synchro was replaced. Fast forward to this year and 13 months after the repair the very same issue is happening, and after speaking with the dealer and Toyota Canada because my PT warranty has expired, I do still have ECP warranty....however I got 2 calls today from Toyota, one saying that they would do a ONE time shot and waive the fee to have the dealer rip apart the transmisson, but an hour ago Toyota called back and NOW they won't honour that whatsoever and will only waive the fee if they cam prove that I didn't cause the issue as they claim that a synchro is wear and tear...I'm not happy at all with how Toyota is handling this, and may consider taking this up a notch. Any thoughts on this? I would appreciate that. Thanks.
cylaptorSlovenia · Feb 15, 2019#93
Originally Posted by Tamago ↑
there's your problem

get rid of that mobil1

that's a synchro destroyer (ask me how i know)
omg, I see that now. I have the same problem after putting in a Mobil1 75W-90 gear oil. It started to grinding and very difficult shifting.