Replies continued
newyarSoCal · Apr 27, 2009#51 Originally Posted by
Ace ↑ This is what I’m sick of. People assuming things that they have nothing to back it up with. I never say that higher octane is better for the yaris engine, just show me some proof that is not if you're going to make that claim. I did show where some would say it is better but did not state my opinion. If you’re going state your opinion then show me some facts.
I spent half my life working in the labs and offices of the world largest gasoline and oil companies here in Houston, would love to read some facts and not opinions.
Well if you worked half your life in the labs and offices of the gas and oil companies as you claim then you wouldn't be asking for facts; you'd already know. How about you just contact Toyota, you know the people who DESIGNED THE ENGINE and ask them what they meant when they PUT IT IN THE MANUAL? Since you don't seem willing to accept the owner's manual as "facts" it won't matter what I or anyone else on this forum says.
Oh and keep in mind that the gas and oil companies WANT you spending more money on the higher octane fuels so they aren't about to tell you otherwise. Ask people who rebuild engines for a living; who service fuel and ignition systems; who make spark plugs, valves, rings, pistons. Ask the people who deal with the consequences of tens of thousands of miles of fuel usage in engines; they'll give you some "facts".
If you're "sick and tired" then relieve your symptoms by doing some research yourself instead of demanding others do it for you. I stated what I know based on decades of experience with cars. If you don't like it or disagree with it; fine. Everybody is entitled to their opinion. Why don't you just fill your tank with 87; run it out, measure your gas mileage. Then fill up with 92 and see if you can tell any difference other than the cost. If you can't, then there's your "facts". But it's your car; spend your money on whatever grade fuel you want to.
AceHouston · Apr 27, 2009#52 Originally Posted by
newyar ↑ doing some research yourself... Everybody is entitled to their opinion.
Thank you for admitting that you have no proof and it’s just an opinion.
keesueThe back streets of San Fran · Apr 27, 2009#53The Yaris was desgined to run on regular. Toyota states 87 octane as the minimun recommended fuel (nothing lower) in the owner's manual. Save the money for beverages and a turbo charger. 😁
Toyota designed the car with computer controls to enable it to run a relatively high compression on 87 octane by dynamically retarding ignition timing based on feedback from the knock sensor; further, they designed variable valve timing to scavenge exhaust from the cylinders more efficiently at higher rpm, lowering cylinder temperatures for the incoming charge. Without this technology, the engine would require higher octane fuel to avoid fuel detonation. Temperature, the by-product of compression, is the determinate factor for octane. The higher the compression, the higher the temperature and the higher the octane requirement. By old school standards, the Yaris is a very sophisiticated little engine.
The Yaris' timing does not advance to account for higher octane fuel. Without higher compression, it would be pointless. It only retards from its set point to account for higher temperatures from engine load that would result in knock. The set point can be adjusted if this is out of spec or objectionable, but a little pinging under load especially in high ambient temperature is normal and is a sign that the engine is squeaking the last bit of energy out of the charge.
Unfortunately, the Yaris doesn't dynamically raise its compression ratio without the assistance of forced induction. Using a higher grade fuel isn't required. Without higher compression, higher octance fuel in and of itself, won't improve the Yaris' peformance or extend its mpg to justify the expense; but, if you want to spend the cash....🤷
BLAZINBLUEVITZNEW YORK · Apr 27, 2009#54LOL at the constant argument between gas grades.......
keesueThe back streets of San Fran · Apr 27, 2009#55Yeah, its fun. Kinda like the efficacy of 0-20 v. 5-20 and whether its recommended or not. Heh...
1stToyotaOklahoma · Apr 27, 2009#56 Originally Posted by
Ace ↑ Someone please show me where Toyota indicates that the U.S. Yaris or the NZ series engines were designed for 87-octane gas. Or that it runs better on 87-octane gas.
The Smart requires premium gas; Yaris has a higher compression engine.
Simple. Factory tuning. Ever heard of canned tuners like Diablo, SuperChip...? Even they can be tuned for what octane you want to use. The Smart is tuned for premium and performance will fall off if lower octane is used, sort of like my GTO...I could get by on less than 91, but car was tuned for 91. Unlike the Smart, the Yaris isn't tuned for 91
And on page 384 ('08 manual) it says **87 octane
or higher**
so I might try mid-grade for a while and see
360cubesOntario · Apr 27, 2009#57Just to note here that I operated and managed two service stations for six years. Companies advertise "may contain up to 10% ethanol" on the pumps to make you, the consumer feel better that you're somewhat helping the environment. However, go back a few years and millions of vehicles on the road can only run up to 5% ethanol content, safely.
Most loads of fuel that were delivered never contained more than 6% ethanol - ever. The most ethanol content was found during the winter months, to increase the freezing properties of the fuel (hence, "winter gas"). In the summer, ethanol content was around 4-5% average per load delivered. In reality, we have 'winter gas' all year round! It amazes me how people run out and buy gas line antifreeze bottles for $1/ea when even 2% ethanol content in the fuel means you'll still be able to start the vehicle in -40C weather without trouble. 5-6% means it'd have to be below 55C before you'd even think about having to add anything special to the tank.
E-85 is 85% ethanol, 15% petrol (gasoline) mix. This fuel is meant for E85 compatible engines only. It'll stall and gum up engines that aren't meant for this fuel.
As for the "87 octane or higher" label, this is meant to cover Toyota's rear end should you live in the mountains, for example. A difference in elevation (even as much as 2500ft above sea level) can lead to engine ping due to lack of oxygen, which will require you to run a higher octane. The engine will automatically compensate for the octane difference (hence, knock sensors). Knock sensors can only control the engine so much. If you drove 10,000ft up a long hill at a steady speed, chances are you'll notice engine pinging around 5,000ft if you had a tank of 87 octane.
Running a higher octane fuel on a regular basis won't harm the engine. On some low grounded areas you can find octane as low as 85 at the pump! Keep in mind the high-ish compression ratio of these cars at 10.5:1). Turbocharged or supercharged cars need not worry about elevation changes, due to the lower compression engines (8.5:1) and the need to run 91 octane fuel irregardless. You can run 87 octane fuel in a modern turbocharged vehicle, but performance will go down the tubes as the PCM is designed for it to operate most efficiently on 91 octane.
As mentioned, a tuner can be used to change the PCM mapping a bit if you wanted to run 91 octane on a regular basis...you might even gain 1hp out of the deal. If you were going to do a few engine modifications, a custom tune would be the way to go to better squeeze out every HP possible from your particular setup. Otherwise, just to tune an engine on 91 octane isn't worth while. Stick with what the factory said unless you live on a mountain top.
My '00 Durango R/T came from the factory to run on 91 octane. However, it doesn't have knock sensors and I cannot run a lower octane without severe ping even at part throttle. I've added performance mods to it anyway that require 91 octane, but if I had left it stock I'm sure I would've found a way for it to run on 87 like 01+ Durango models.