Yarisworld Archive

Is the Yaris mostly for Urban Transportation?

69 posts · 13,089 views · page 1 of 2

DorkinheimerOriginal postCanada · Feb 15, 2009#1
The Yaris is a good city car, but is it just as good of a car for people who take long trips at higher speeds?

Wasn't the Yaris designed mostly for city driving at lower speeds? I think so, because the motor spins a little fast at highway speed.
Bigger cars with bigger motors don't spin as fast, so makes it more pleasant driving at highway speed, especially when taking long trips.

Replies 68

SailDesign. · Feb 15, 2009#2
Originally Posted by Dorkinheimer ↑
Wasn't the Yaris designed mostly for city driving at lower speeds? I think so, because the motor spins a little fast at highway speed.
Bigger cars with bigger motors don't spin as fast, so makes it more pleasant driving at highway speed, especially when taking long trips.
It sounds like your mind is already made up. Begging the question of why you asked in the first place, I would say that it is a great car for long-distance driving. The speed of the motor has nothing to do with the comfort of the car, believe me. It is a fun beast at spedd, and relaxing to drive. IMNSFHO
DorkinheimerThread starterCanada · Feb 15, 2009#3
Nope, I had a Yaris and loved it and now have a Corolla and love both cars, but I think that the Yaris is more of a city car simply because of its high RPM's on the highway, especially with the manual transmission.

I would love to get another Yaris, but the high RPM on the highway is the only thing that bothers me.
NJBobSouth Jersey · Feb 15, 2009#4
I don't find the Yaris that high. How fast are you driving and what rpms are you getting? At 60mph, I'm revving around 3k which isn't bad at all.
Uh Oh, Canada, eh....can you translate from metric? 🙂
DorkinheimerThread starterCanada · Feb 15, 2009#5
OK, with my 2007 manual Yaris on 14 inch wheels, I would take long road trips, like 4000 km's and I would drive at 120 km/h, and the motor was spinning at 3300 rpm. If it was only a short trip, I wouldn't mind but when you drive for 15 to 20 hours at 120-130 kmh and you hear the motor spinning from 3300 to 3500 constantly, it's makes you wonder what kind of punishment it's receiving...

The yaris is a wonderful car, but I thnk its mostly for city driving and a good car for taking trips under 110 kmh with the manual.

For a while I was thinking of buying a Honda Fit, but I heard that it spins at 3000 RPM at 100 km/h, so 200 RPM faster than the Yaris with a manual transmission.
They said that the Fit is very noisy over 3000 RPM or 100 km/h. So we can say the same with any car....over 3000 RPM it starts to become noisy, and noisy means wear and tear.
roxy1michigan · Feb 15, 2009#6
i traded my yaris for the corolla because i just wanted a more comfortable ride and i just couldnt take the absolute barren, cheap interior of the yaris, hated the driving position for any extended trips, and the engine drone was a bit tiresome at 70+ mph. i liked the yaris overall and got great gas mileage with it, but ive only given up 1-1.5 mpg's with the corolla on the same routes. the telescoping wheel makes a world of difference. the 5 speed 2009 corolla doesnt rev alot lower than the yaris at 70 mph, but is much quieter due to better sound insulation.

i really dont think 3100 rpms at 70 mph (which is about where i think the manual yaris is) is that bad for a little car like the yaris. my 89 civic hatch (base model) was a 4 speed manual and was much higher than that at 70 mph. i put 200k miles on that car and at least 80% of it was at 70 mph. no sweat. that 1.5 l engine used in the yaris is a very proven, fuel efficient, durable engine.
DorkinheimerThread starterCanada · Feb 15, 2009#7
The Echo didn't spin as fast as the Yaris, and the new Corolla spins faster than the previous one. It seems that Toyota is making their engines spin faster, probably for more power at lower speeds, but not as good at higher speeds.
SilverBackEl Monte, Ca · Feb 15, 2009#8
It's a stop-n-go city car for sure. And at only around 100 WHP, the shorter gears fit it well (although IMO it would get better gas mileage on the hwy with slightly taller final gear). If it was meant for long trips, they would've made it bigger, roomier, and even MORE comfortable to ride in. Think of RVs and tour buses.
SailDesign. · Feb 15, 2009#9
Originally Posted by Dorkinheimer ↑
The yaris is a wonderful car, but I thnk its mostly for city driving and a good car for taking trips under 110 kmh with the manual.

Dorkinheimer, forgive me for asking, but.....

If your mind is already made up, why ask the question? Maybe you and caveatipse should get together.....
YAR1SRaleigh, NC · Feb 15, 2009#10
I drive about 1.5 hours a day on the highway 5 days a week.... I have driven a grand marquis before my yaris... and yes the yaris isnt a great highway car compared to a big v8... but with a few changes to stop the swaying, im comfortable with my yaris...

that being said.... the seats are only so comfy... I would drive more than 200 or 300 miles unless I had to.
DorkinheimerThread starterCanada · Feb 15, 2009#11
Originally Posted by SailDesign ↑
Dorkinheimer, forgive me for asking, but.....

If your mind is already made up, why ask the question? Maybe you and caveatipse should get together.....

Well my mind is NOT made up, so stop saying things I didn't say.
DorkinheimerThread starterCanada · Feb 15, 2009#12
Is it wrong to say that this is basically a city car. NO
It's a dam good city car.

Is it a good highway car? It depends, with the manual transmission at 125 km/h, heck NO.
With that automatic at the same speed speed, it,s borderline.
SailDesign. · Feb 15, 2009#13
Originally Posted by Dorkinheimer ↑
Well my mind is NOT made up, so stop saying things I didn't say.
Ummm.... look below.

Originally Posted by Dorkinheimer ↑
Is it a good highway car? It depends, with the manual transmission at 125 km/h, heck NO.
Did you see that? You said it was not a good highway car! Oh, noes......

Tag - You're It!
DorkinheimerThread starterCanada · Feb 15, 2009#14
Originally Posted by k r a y z e e . j o j o ↑
It's a stop-n-go city car for sure. And at only around 100 WHP, the shorter gears fit it well (although IMO it would get better gas mileage on the hwy with slightly taller final gear). If it was meant for long trips, they would've made it bigger, roomier, and even MORE comfortable to ride in. Think of RVs and tour buses.
Exactly

It's mostly a city car, and I drive 95% city and that's why I love this car and would buy it again.

But on the other hand the other 5% of driving I do on the highway at high speeds, the manual transmission isn't appropriate because it spins way too fast, which boils down to wear and tear.

But I would buy this car again since I do mostly city driving.

Sorry guys for being honest.
enobmort42Denver, CO · Feb 15, 2009#15
it's a great city car, but imo, an even better highway car. ya can't beat going from NYC to orlando on $75 worth of gas. after a state or two, you don't even hear the engine anymore.

...this compared to my last car: '96 concorde that got MAYBE 15 mpg highway! =P
jambo101Montreal Canada · Feb 15, 2009#16
I drove from Montreal to Vancouver and back last summer and had no problems at speed with the Yaris..Not sure what you are expecting to hear from a Yaris forum as we all like the car.If you find small fuel efficient cars to noisy,buzzy or lacking in some other respect there are lots of larger automotive options available to you.
Driving at 120-130kph is not punishing the car they were designed to operate under those parameters.
DorkinheimerThread starterCanada · Feb 15, 2009#17
There is nothing contradicting in what I'm saying SelfDesign.

A) It's a good city car
B) It,s a good highway car below 110 kmh with the manual and 120 with the automatic
SailDesign. · Feb 15, 2009#18
Tomayto, tomahto.

Whichever. I like the car on the highway - you don't. Be happy!
DorkinheimerThread starterCanada · Feb 15, 2009#19
Originally Posted by enobmort42 ↑
it's a great city car, but imo, an even better highway car. ya can't beat going from NYC to orlando on $75 worth of gas. after a state or two, you don't even hear the engine anymore.

...this compared to my last car: '96 concorde that got MAYBE 15 mpg highway! =P
At a certain speed you don't hear the engine as much because of harmonics. You'll hear the engine alot at 3000 rpm and hear it less at 3500 for example, but it's still spinning too fast.

As for being easy on gas, it is, but that's not what I'm talking about here. IM talking about the RPM at highway speeds, which is too high for comfort, and for the engine's life.

I tried my friends Echo, and his motor spins 400 RPM slower than my Yaris. He has the automatic transmission and the 2005 Echo was geared to spin slower and it was a charm driving it at highway speeds.
roxy1michigan · Feb 15, 2009#20
while the higher rpm's on the highway may be irritating, the notion that it is too much wear and tear on the engine is silly. i am certain that many yaris owners with the 5 speed will pile up 200k highway miles on this engine with no ill effects as long as they maintain it properly. 3200 rpms for long periods of time is not going to ruin this engine.
churpTropical Minnesota · Feb 15, 2009#21
It's great for both....but if you really feel it's aimed more for one or the other, change your tire diameter. Changing diameter will change the compromise to favor one at the expense of the other.
ChinoCharlesOH · Feb 15, 2009#23
^^ I was just about to post that. 😆 No reason to wonder how much "punishment" the engine takes @ highway speed. The answer is not much.
frownonfunRGV, Texas · Feb 15, 2009#24
wow this thread makes like no sense.
SilverBackEl Monte, Ca · Feb 15, 2009#25
Well I guess it's safe to say this thread is now dead😆
33OHDover, Ohio · Feb 15, 2009#26
I do 95% highway driving and don't see anything wrong with it. My motorcycle revs at about 7,500-8,000 RPMs on the highway and that's with 6 gears.

What, do you want to have to drop into 2nd gear in order to accelerate a few MPH on the highway?
JBIZZFort Lauderdale, FL · Feb 15, 2009#27
It is Ideally a city driving car, but has no problems cruising at 80 on the highway, & will last at least 2X longer than a bigger U.S. built car under harsh driving conditions (i.e. flooring it at every light).
SilverBackEl Monte, Ca · Feb 15, 2009#28
True. As long as it stays around 3K RPM, there should be no overheating and excessive wear-n-tear on the engine or tranny. Now if you were to do something like push it to 80MPH in 4th (or maybe even 3rd if the limiter doesn't get you), you're asking for trouble way down the road
SailDesign. · Feb 15, 2009#29
Originally Posted by k r a y z e e . j o j o ↑
True. As long as it stays around 3K RPM, there should be no overheating and excessive wear-n-tear on the engine or tranny. Now if you were to do something like push it to 80MPH in 4th (or maybe even 3rd if the limiter doesn't get you), you're asking for trouble way down the road
I dunno, krayzee - 80 in 4th is only 4100 rpm, and in 3rd it is still way below redline at 5500 rpm. Not recommended for long, but you shouldn't do any damage to the engine just getting there temporarily. 👍
cali yarisCanoga Park, CA · Feb 15, 2009#30
I read this thread and I want my four minutes back.

the OP has a fixed point of view on this (as we all do, I'm sure). If there were a hundred posts saying the car is great for highway and long distance driving, he would still have the same view, which of course he's entitled to. -- so, are we discussing something?
SailDesign. · Feb 15, 2009#31
Originally Posted by cali yaris ↑
-- so, are we discussing something?
Yes, or No. It is either a viciuos circle or a circle jerk, and no way to tell which. 😳

And No, you can't have your four minutes back.
SilverBackEl Monte, Ca · Feb 15, 2009#32
Let's all just agree to disagree, ..whatever the hell that means...
SailDesign. · Feb 15, 2009#33
Originally Posted by k r a y z e e . j o j o ↑
Let's all just agree to disagree, ..whatever the hell that means...
OK. 🙂
DorkinheimerThread starterCanada · Feb 15, 2009#34
If there could be a 6th speed to the manual Yaris, wouldn't you guys go for it, or would you say, nah, we prefer a 5 speed that revs 3500 rpm at 130 kmh.

I would say, heck, bring it on.

And yes it would be a good idea to put bigger wheels on the car to lose 200 rpm or so on the highway.

Maybe if I had 15 inch tires instead of my 14, that there would have been a 100 rpm difference.
DorkinheimerThread starterCanada · Feb 15, 2009#35
Originally Posted by frownonfun ↑
wow this thread makes like no sense.
Oh it does for someone thinking of buying a manual Yaris and not used to having rpm's up in the mid 3000's.

They will probably go for the automatic which spins 200 rpm slower ;)

I would have done that if I would have known back then.
Kal-ElMassachusetts · Feb 15, 2009#36
The OP is suggesting that 68 mph (110 kph) is the comfort limit for the manual?

That's ridiculous.

I have a MT and it only rev's at about 3300 at 80 mph (129 kph). About 3000 at 68 mph.
That's pretty relaxed. The member with 305,000 miles posted a top speed run of 115mph with no problem.

Point is, this is a great highway car. Why do people consider small cars only city cars??? You can drive the Yaris 85 mph all day long.

I'm also boggled at why the MT is said to rev higher than the auto? The MT gets even better highway mileage than the auto. My MT is very calm and smooth on the highway.

BTW, city driving is more wear and tear on the engine than 80 mph highway cruising.
ChinoCharlesOH · Feb 15, 2009#37
I honestly kind of agree with the OP on the gearbox, though. It seems to make sense that the Yaris would get better MPG's with a 6 speed, no?
DorkinheimerThread starterCanada · Feb 15, 2009#38
It says that it gets better mileage on the highway because they calculate the mpg at 55 mph when the rpm is at 2700.
ddongbaphay · Feb 15, 2009#39
Short gears?!! DUDE! The Yaris has gears as tall as... ME.


Btw, Its spinning that fast, AND getting a super high MPG. Especially since those other micro cars can't compete. So whats the dealio?
SilverBackEl Monte, Ca · Feb 15, 2009#40
No longer a dealio. It's now more of an eternally pointless thread. We're all gonna take turns sitting here and bickering about it til it kill us all. Might as well put up a poll and throw out a war cry...
41magmag41New hampshire · Feb 15, 2009#41
Been to Indiana and back to New Hampshire with my sedan and it drove nicely and rode nicely. My average speed with the auto was around 80 mph and the rpm was around 33 to 3500 turned in a respectable 38.5 mpg for the trip. Not to shabby
Kal-ElMassachusetts · Feb 15, 2009#42
Originally Posted by Dorkinheimer ↑
It says that it gets better mileage on the highway because they calculate the mpg at 55 mph when the rpm is at 2700.
Before 2007, yes, but they've since changed the rating system (at least in the US).

Pre-2008, the Yaris was rated 33/40 mpg for the auto and 33/41 for the MT.

For '08, the EPA switched to a "real world system" (higher speeds, AC, ect...) and the Yaris came back with 29/35 for the auto, 29/36 for the MT.

80 mph returns about 35-38 mpg for most people and is usually brought down by the city driving mixed in.

55 mph will get you over 45 mpg.
SailDesign. · Feb 15, 2009#43
Originally Posted by Dorkinheimer ↑
Maybe if I had 15 inch tires instead of my 14, that there would have been a 100 rpm difference.
I rest my case - the OP is correctly named.....
Over and out!
yarswissSunland, CA · Feb 15, 2009#44
I haven't noticed any significant difference in "strain" on the car when driving at much higher speeds. I've been driving 65-85 mph for the past couple of months, and it seems that my car actually likes that, because the engine just runs a lot smoother. I recently drove for over an hour at over 90mph (about 150kph) and I barely noticed the engine noise at all, although it was revving around 3500 rpm.

Needless to say, it's also a great little car about town. Most drivers on the road truly underestimate just how "chuckable" and go-karty this car really is, and if ever there is a duel for a parking spot, they will always lose to my light little egg. 😁
specialeducatorHarrisonburg, VA · Feb 15, 2009#45
My automatic sedan works well on the highway
the_bossMontreal Qc · Feb 15, 2009#46
@ 110km/h my car revs at 3300 and it cost more than when Im in town 🙁 I can do in summer with normal driving, 550km per tank and on the highway max 450km at 110kph

Can't wait for a 6 speed Yaris to lower the highway RPM!
DorkinheimerThread starterCanada · Feb 15, 2009#47
Originally Posted by SailDesign ↑
I rest my case - the OP is correctly named.....
Over and out!
And what's your case? Trying to influence my personal opinion on this issue?
This is a discussion board, and if you can't deal with other people's opinion, I guess you shouldn't even post here.

NO one should be trying to please others here because its a Yaris forum. Say what you like and hate about the car like I'M doing, without making personal childish remarks.
DorkinheimerThread starterCanada · Feb 15, 2009#48
Originally Posted by the_boss ↑
@ 110km/h my car revs at 3300 and it cost more than when Im in town 🙁 I can do in summer with normal driving, 550km per tank and on the highway max 450km at 110kph

Can't wait for a 6 speed Yaris to lower the highway RPM!

Becareful, Sail Design might ridiculize your post.
frownonfunRGV, Texas · Feb 15, 2009#49
the thing is though is you aren't really discussing anything... you are asking if the yaris is primarily an urban automobile and then answering yourself with definitive yes. since then the thread has become an argument over things of a very relative nature... imo.
DorkinheimerThread starterCanada · Feb 15, 2009#50
I asked an honest question and stated my opinion. What's wrong with that?
All you have to do is say, yes I love driving the Yaris at 3500 RPM and it doesnt bother me, or do like others and say, I find that it revs a little too fast and would definetely need a 6th speed.

This is what the discussion is all about !!!