Yarisworld Archive

embarrassingly bad mileage... REALLY

81 posts · 29,266 views · page 1 of 2

XYarisOriginal postNYC · Jan 19, 2009#1
So I live in Brooklyn. Almost all of my driving consists of short trips within the city. I do spend a decent amount of time idling (when picking up the girl) and I also let the car warm up a bit. BUT STILL...

20mpg consistently. WTF?

Im frankly worried at this point. I check the oil, fine. I even took a trip north out of the city about thirty miles and considering I hit some traffic both directions, I was comforted by getting over 30 mpg on the trip.

I know the idling is a waste, and its cold out, and I make a lot of short trips. yadda yadda

Ive even drastically altered my driving habits by keeping the rpm below 3000 as much as possible. This engine is kinda tiny and frankly feels ridiculously underpowered at these rpms- do people get this great mileage (40+ in th city?!) by just farting around at 2000rpm?

Not looking to get grilled here, just curious if anyone thinks or knows of an issue I may have. Maybe I should get an ecu reflash, or is my youthful exuberance getting the best of my fuel economy?

(2009 LB 2500 miles, only mods are the 205/40/17 pnero zero m+s tires)

Replies 80

ChinoCharlesOH · Jan 19, 2009#2
It definitely sounds like a problem with the car. I don't know what I'd have to do to get under 30 MPG and I drive 90% city and ignore the RPM mileage rule. I would keep track of mileage on a couple of tanks and take that info to the dealership and see what they say.
Luna V 2.0Miami, FL · Jan 19, 2009#3
Idling is terrible, and I never warm up my car. I just go easy on it till the cool light goes off.

I spend a little bit of time idling too, because of red lights and such, I would try to coast to the lights and stops, and if your picking someone up and you know you'll wait awhile, just shut off the car. Although since its cold you might not want to.

My guess is that the car is just too new, your mileage might improve after you've been driving it a bit. The worse mileage I got was 25 or 28 mpg and that was because I got my windows tinted and could roll them down, so I had to use the AC 100% of the time. I couldn't go without AC and windows cause it was pretty hot when I had gotten them. D:
firemachine69Sudbury, On · Jan 19, 2009#4
Originally Posted by ChinoCharles ↑
It definitely sounds like a problem with the car. I don't know what I'd have to do to get under 30 MPG and I drive 90% city and ignore the RPM mileage rule. I would keep track of mileage on a couple of tanks and take that info to the dealership and see what they say.


I'm averaging about 23-25mpg with the use of my starter, idling waiting for people, the extreme cold, and driving around in city traffic and heavy-working roads (snow/salt/slush/sand). Your tires (and I'm assuming after-market wheels) likely doubled what you had stock. So it doesn't really count as an "only" type of mod, as it's one the worst for killing gas mileage.
ChinoCharlesOH · Jan 19, 2009#5
Do you have 30 pound wheels? I see you have 17's. That could cost you 4-5 mpg like firemachine said...
KCALB SIRAYVirginia · Jan 19, 2009#6
Are you driving in third with an auto or do you have a manual
TLyttleKeremeos BC · Jan 19, 2009#7
Slush + wide tires = lousy mileage. I am not a fan of wide tires to begin with, particularly with a small engine, but even heavy rain can slow you down and affect your FE.

Yes, check with the dealer, but I don't think you will accomplish much. Another check is to push the car for 10yds or so on dry, flat, pavement: if it pushes easily, then the brakes and alignment are fine.
XYarisThread starterNYC · Jan 19, 2009#8
The wheels are privat netz ( like 150 + a piece ) I think I gained a few pounds per wheel and tire setup, but not enough to explain the difference. I also installed a tach, and my first tank in the city consisted of very aggressive scooting about...that was my first really bad tank in terms of mileage. Is it possible that I taught my ecu to provide for that type of driving?

I bought the car in Mass....but Im planning on bringing to a dealer in NY this weekend. Ive been intentionally avoiding idling and my warm ups are short in that I dont sit and wait for the 'cool' light to go out, just until im satisfied the engine is well lubricated.

I start commuting to school tomorrow (~11 miles each way) and I will try to only drive that daily distance for the week. Ill report what mileage I get.

Will the first oil change help? should I go synthetic? What malfunction would cause this? Thanks by the way!
ChinoCharlesOH · Jan 19, 2009#9
There is no way your conventional factory oil is causing it. I would say yes if you were getting 30 MPG and wanted 35. 20 is just bad for this car. I'm thinking you may have a defunct MAF or O2 sensor... sounds like your AF mixture may be extremely rich. What does your exhaust look like? Blowing any smoke?
XYarisThread starterNYC · Jan 19, 2009#10
I have a manual. and the car pushes easily ( my girl got a complex after I asked her to push it a few feet the other day) and I had an alignment done after the wheel install.

205/40/17 doesnt really seem that big, but I suppose with less than 100 hp hitting the ground it is.

for the record, I have gotten 38 mpg on the highway with the hatched loaded with 150 lbs of gear and my 140 lb brother and thats with the new wheels and not driving 60mph (not on 95 south)

so this seems to be a city thing. all the snow and idling must be the answer. i hope my new car is ok🙁
XYarisThread starterNYC · Jan 19, 2009#11
no smoke. the car seems to be running great otherwise. seems like a dealer visit is called for eh?
ChinoCharlesOH · Jan 19, 2009#12
Yeah, 20 MPG is a big outlier. Let us know what they say.
andriesSpain · Jan 19, 2009#13
Maybe you have a defective Lambda sensor.
Then you get a higher fuel consumption.

Ask your Toyota dealer for reading DTC Error Codes, perhaps he find the problem.
kounj · Jan 19, 2009#14
after a search i found that your wheel with tire are around 46pounds this would definetly hurt your fuel in stop and go traffic,factory weight is somthing like 32 pounds.
andriesSpain · Jan 19, 2009#15
Originally Posted by kou ↑
after a search i found that your wheel with tire are around 46pounds this would definetly hurt your fuel in stop and go traffic,factory weight is somthing like 32 pounds.

Really? My stock tyres and rims are about 42 pounds.
I drive average 32 mpg (1.8 TS)
kounj · Jan 19, 2009#16
Originally Posted by andries ↑
Really? My stock tyres and rims are about 42 pounds.
I drive average 32 mpg (1.8 TS)
you have a 1.8l 👍if you put some light 15'' wheels on your car it would be quicker and get a better mileage
andriesSpain · Jan 19, 2009#17
Originally Posted by kou ↑
you have a 1.8l 👍if you put some light 15'' wheels on your car it would be quicker and get a better mileage
At the moment i drive with 15" rims and winter tyres.
The mileage is almost the same as with the 17"
ROCKLAND TOYOTAROCKLAND COUNTY NY · Jan 19, 2009#18
even with the trd 18's on and my heavy foot i STILL got 30+ mpg..........
kounj · Jan 19, 2009#19
Originally Posted by andries ↑
At the moment i drive with 15" rims and winter tyres.
The mileage is almost the same as with the 17"
does your car feel any quicker.
gas mileage will decrease in the winter due to the temp change,winter tyres are heavy.try them in the warmer months.
firemachine69Sudbury, On · Jan 19, 2009#20
Keep in mind folks, that 1.8TS was NOT designed for fuel economy. It was designed for zippy fun. Add in some very cold city driving, with plenty of stops and starting of the engine, and it becomes exactly like my case.
XYarisThread starterNYC · Jan 19, 2009#21
Kou, privat netz 17 inch wheel weight is 17 lbs and the tires are 19.............17+19= 36

(stock wheels are 15, and eagle LS are 17) that indeed equals 32.

Im not sure why some folks hate on larger wheels. Investing in light and/or larger wheels and nice tires has handling benefits especially over the awful stock tires. Its not like im running dubs on the thing.

The temp, and conditions were taken into account already in the analysis. something is up other than my wheels and tires

ps, thanks for answering my PM's
ZINGLebanon, Middle East. · Jan 19, 2009#22
20MPG, woah. That sir is not normal. Going to uni everyday, getting stuck in the wort traffic imaginable every day as well, I still get 40+MPG, my best so far was around 52MPG.


Should definitely check with dealer.
kounj · Jan 19, 2009#23
Originally Posted by XYaris ↑
Kou, privat netz 17 inch wheel weight is 17 lbs and the tires are 19.............17+19= 36

(stock wheels are 15, and eagle LS are 17) that indeed equals 32.

Im not sure why some folks hate on larger wheels. Investing in light and/or larger wheels and nice tires has handling benefits especially over the awful stock tires. Its not like im running dubs on the thing.

The temp, and conditions were taken into account already in the analysis. something is up other than my wheels and tires

ps, thanks for answering my PM's
i did a search and found your rims 21lbs and you tires are 24.5lbs so i am off half a pound.

ps you have a pm.
firemachine69Sudbury, On · Jan 19, 2009#24
Originally Posted by ZING ↑
20MPG, woah. That sir is not normal. Going to uni everyday, getting stuck in the wort traffic imaginable every day as well, I still get 40+MPG, my best so far was around 52MPG.


Should definitely check with dealer.
And I'm guessing you don't see a day below 80F in sunlight, correct?

The Netherlands is a cold, cold place... And it would seem the Yaris is extremely sensitive to temperature. The hotter, the better!
kounj · Jan 19, 2009#25
the summer i average 40ish now in the winter its 32-35ish,but there is some extra get up and go in the cold.
RyuSurrey, BC · Jan 20, 2009#26
Are you sure that you do the right calculation to get that 20 MPG?
I am guessing that probably the way you calculate might not be accurate.
XYarisThread starterNYC · Jan 20, 2009#27
miles travelled divided by gallons it took to fill up...off to school, ill do a mini test for this trip.
ZINGLebanon, Middle East. · Jan 20, 2009#28
Originally Posted by firemachine69 ↑
And I'm guessing you don't see a day below 80F in sunlight, correct?

The Netherlands is a cold, cold place... And it would seem the Yaris is extremely sensitive to temperature. The hotter, the better!

That is indeed true. And I got a 1.3L 🙂
SilverBackEl Monte, Ca · Jan 20, 2009#29
Originally Posted by XYaris ↑
(2009 LB 2500 miles, only mods are the 205/40/17 pnero zero m+s tires)
Was your gas mileage better on stock 15"s?
thebarberGrand Rapids, MI · Jan 20, 2009#30
well, w/ 17's youre pushing all the weight to the outside of the wheel and tire....which increases the rotational mass....3lbs per corner is equaly to like 30lbs when you try to get it rolling....

i know crandall has 18lb 17's w/ 215-40-17's and he gets about 30miles less per tank than i do w/ 14's

also consider the cold weather....cold, thick oil is harder to get moving when you first start the car

and the idling....just burning gas sitting still

what also MAY be a case is if youre still trying to take off fast AND granny shifting at 2000 or 3000rpm.....wide open throttle is wide open throttle no matter what gear youre in

and what gear do you cruise at in the city....say at 30mph.....3rd? try 4th
XYarisThread starterNYC · Jan 20, 2009#31
39.8 miles, 1.6 gallons of fuel.

yeah, thats 24.8 mpg

spare me the wheel hating, thats just plain messed up. I keep reading folks comments that they drive hard and cant get below 30 mpg. I drove my impreza like i stole it (especially in the winter ) and got 25 mpg consistently.

I hear what yall are saying about WOT even if its only til 3000rpm. Im not gonna lie, I like to scoot around but i have been curbing my desires in the interest of not killing my car and seeing if the mileage improves. its strange that its running perfectly otherwise.

I can make it to a dealer until friday. hope the car lasts that long
gidNortheast · Jan 20, 2009#32
XYARIS , I take it that it's an automatic ? Do you possibly have it in 3rd GEAR instead of OVERDRIVE ? How's your tire pressure ?
kounj · Jan 21, 2009#33
noones hating on the wheels just put your stock ones on and see if you have a change in power and FE.
AltitudeColorado · Jan 22, 2009#34
Originally Posted by gid ↑
XYARIS , I take it that it's an automatic ? Do you possibly have it in 3rd GEAR instead of OVERDRIVE ? How's your tire pressure ?
Ya - bet this is it. I remember another poster drove the auto for months complaining about low mileage and it turned out to be the same issue - driving in 3 instead of D.
gidNortheast · Jan 22, 2009#35
or how about leaving the A.C. button on . Noticed I had somehow hit the A.C. button to the ON position ( GREEN lit up ) , is easy to miss , not very bright or large . Seldom use it for warm weather or the defrost mode for windshield , if windows fog up roll down window a bit , fresh air helps that . How long it was on I don't know 😳 . Sign of progressive aging 🙄 .
gidNortheast · Jan 22, 2009#36
or both A.C. on and O.D. off . 🤷 .
otterhereSoutheast · Jan 23, 2009#37
I wouldn't be TOO embarrassed... As Mark Twain said ("Reports of my death have been greatly exaggerated."), so -- methinks -- have the "great mileage" claims on the Yaris. Toyota advertises it at 29 city/34 highway, or maybe 36 (can't remember), and I imagine that's pretty close to the truth of the matter.
bzinn 1University Place,WA · Jan 23, 2009#38
I put my stockies back on for winter and get 2mpg more than I did with my 17s,which made me feel pretty good.

Heavier tires,stop and go traffic and cold winters take milage down.Also look at the vent setting,if it is in the defrost position your compressor will run to dry the air,using more fuel,and it will do it most notciable at stop lights.

After getting my car realigned last week I also have gained another mpg,and am back up to 35 mpg for highway travel.

when I drive all city travel,with defrost or AC on with the17s I average about 25mpg,i have a heavy foot at stop lights......

But coming from a gas guzzling hot rod to the yaris.......this thing is sipping gas......GTO ate up 15 gallons in 3 days,and that was only about 140 miles tops......much happier.
otterhereSoutheast · Jan 23, 2009#39
Originally Posted by bzinn 1 ↑
IAlso look at the vent setting,if it is in the defrost position your compressor will run to dry the air,using more fuel,and it will do it most notciable at stop lights.

Ah-ha! I've been wondering about that. Because I have to defrost it most mornings (ice on windshield), I generally just leave the vent open (in the recirculate position). I wasn't sure what effect this might have on mileage?
tetzyamisHI · Jan 23, 2009#40
With the previous car ('03 Corolla), I changed original 15" to 17" and did not affect fuel economy at all. It was 32 mpg before 17" rims and 32 mpg after rims. 17" was much heavier than 15". I had a lot harder time carrying 17" from my condo to the parking lot.

My friend had '07 LB, 90% city driving, lots of short trips and idling, and still was getting 25+ mpg.

20 mpg seems to have something wrong to me.
XYarisThread starterNYC · Jan 23, 2009#41
1. Its a manual (so no overdrive issue )
2. I do have to defrost a lot ( the yaris windows like to fog up and its winter )
3. I talked to a few local dealers. One cool one said he doesnt think anything is wrong. That if the car was throwing a code the check engine light would on. duh. So I would assume that if the lambda or other sensor was bad this would trigger a code. He also said that the engine not being broken in at all may make a difference as well. Im gonna drive it as is until the first oil change which is a new debate altogether.

Should I wait until 5k to change the oil for the first time? especially with these concerns?

I have recently pulled of almost 25 mpg so that makes me feel better.

Thanks yall for your advice and concern.
brendenr89Owensboro Ky · Jan 23, 2009#42
maybe, just maybe it's a bad fuel filter??
SpaceShotNH · Jan 26, 2009#43
1. Check your tires and set to 32psi or the average of 32 and max sidewall rating.
(mine were under inflated at dealer pickup, but not quite low enough to trip the TPS)
2. Change the oil (perhaps going to a lighter weight synthetic for the cold weather) and make certain not to overfill it. (between the lines on the dipstick, NOT over the top line)
3. Borrow a scanguage or get a passenger for a weekend to watch your shifting.

If you don't upshift quick enough, ride the clutch, or spend too much time in 3rd or 4th (even in the city) your Mpg will suffer. 20 or more years ago you often needed to get the revs high in lower gears to get an economy car moving well. You don't need to do that with a Yaris. Try it for a week or more and see what happens.
TLyttleKeremeos BC · Jan 26, 2009#44
Mmmm, maybe. I NEVER make ANY 4-holer pull hard below 2,000rpm, including my Yaris, and I seldom rev over 3500, but I still get excellent mileage. The first thing I did was run up the tire pressure to sidewall max -2lbs, and resumed my usual driving style, ie don't slow down for corners, never floor it, read traffic so that I don't have to slow down any more than absolutely necessary. Works for me.
AltitudeColorado · Jan 27, 2009#45
Lead foot. Get yourself a scangauge and get the lead out. You'd be surprised how much you can let up on the gas and still maintain speed.
firemachine69Sudbury, On · Jan 28, 2009#46
I'm currently doing about 50km (30 miles) to a bar right now. 😆
TLyttleKeremeos BC · Jan 28, 2009#47
I prefer 8 beats to the bar myself...

The accuracy of the fuel gauges was discussed awhile ago, and the consensus was, don't depend on them, use them as a rough guide only.
minicorollaOhio · Jan 28, 2009#48
And I'm bitchin' about 36 MPG
firemachine69Sudbury, On · Jan 28, 2009#49
Originally Posted by TLyttle ↑
I prefer 8 beats to the bar myself...

The accuracy of the fuel gauges was discussed awhile ago, and the consensus was, don't depend on them, use them as a rough guide only.
I was in that boat for a while... And while accurate in the testament, mine seems to now evenly spread mileage between the first and sixth bar.


I'm now averaging 25-27mpg. ALOT better. 🙄🆘🙄
jambo101Montreal Canada · Jan 29, 2009#50
My crappy mpg is due to the engine never getting to operating temperature during the winter,my Scangauge tells me that i need to drive at least 5-6 miles at highway speeds to attain temps in the 180's and most of my driving these days is all city driving for no more than 20 minutes at a time. I'll see how it improves on an upcoming trip to Florida.