Yarisworld Archive

Why does everyone compare the Yaris vs Fit...

68 posts · 24,502 views · page 1 of 2

b_hickman11Original postTyler, TX · Jan 7, 2009#1
Why does everyone compare the Yaris vs the Fit rather than the Civic?? The Civic gets better mpg's than the Fit and they are basically the same starting price. I think the Yaris Sedan is more like the base Civic than a base fit.

Replies 67

mikenacaratoBrentwood, TN · Jan 7, 2009#2
yaris hatch to fit maybe...idk why that comparison became standard.

why do they compare the evo to sti all the time?
JBIZZFort Lauderdale, FL · Jan 7, 2009#3
same size
PaidTimeOffHawaii · Jan 7, 2009#4
Because the Civic is categorized as a "compact" while both the Fit and Yaris are categorized as "sub-compacts?"
Kal-ElMassachusetts · Jan 7, 2009#5
People always compare models within intended segments. In this case, these two cars are the two entry level sub-compacts so that makes them automatic competitors. Problem is, Honda can't build a cheap car anymore so what we have is everyone screaming that the Fit is better while ignoring the actual prices.

Yes, the Fit's truest competitor is the xD. It matches up in just about every way: size, price, power, standard features, both 5-door hatches, available navi, ect.

But hey, Toyota simply offers many more car options than Honda. With Honda, you have the choice of the Fit or the Fit. While Toyota offers the Yaris sedan, 3 door LB, 5 door LB, Scion xD, Scion xB (still less than top line Fit).
puetato89orlando · Jan 7, 2009#6
yup
yaris/fit
corolla/civic
camry,accord
ECHOKnight2000Minnesota, US of A! · Jan 7, 2009#7
Granted there are other cars in this segment. The Fit is the closest competitor on size, price (depending on model) and features for the most part. Also mpg. And its Toyota's or one of Toyota's arch rival.👍
Kaotic LazagnaCentral Valley, CA · Jan 8, 2009#8
Can't really add anything here. What my answer is was already said. LOL.
blktiger60Washington · Jan 8, 2009#9
Honda still has no match for the MR2. . .
buchieboyPhilippines · Jan 8, 2009#10
yup
yaris/fit
corolla/civic
camry,accord

this is also the comparison in the Philippines.
Though the fit outnumber the yaris by a mile
ddongbaphay · Jan 8, 2009#11
Originally Posted by blktiger60 ↑
Honda still has no match for the MR2. . .
NSX?

S2K?
puetato89orlando · Jan 8, 2009#12
nsx/supra
s2k/celica (i guess)
eTiMaGoBangkok, Thailand · Jan 8, 2009#13
celica's "match" would be the integra/RSX

can't reaally compare S2K to MR2, they're quite different in many ways... MR2 to Mazda Miata/MX5 is a better comparison I would say
PaidTimeOffHawaii · Jan 8, 2009#14
Ok, quiz: If the celica's match is the integra, who was the direct competition for the prelude (when they were still manufacturing it)?
redyarisOrlando, FL · Jan 8, 2009#15
Originally Posted by b_hickman11 ↑
Why does everyone compare the Yaris vs the Fit rather than the Civic?? The Civic gets better mpg's than the Fit and they are basically the same starting price. I think the Yaris Sedan is more like the base Civic than a base fit.
Not me, before I purchased I compared the Yaris to a Kia Rio or Suzuki SX4. I even considered the Chevy Aveo5 for a split second until I came to my senses.
mackie421Philadelphia · Jan 8, 2009#16
Originally Posted by b_hickman11 ↑
Why does everyone compare the Yaris vs the Fit rather than the Civic??
I compared the Yaris to the Fit because I was looking for a hatch, and the Civic unfortunately no longer comes in hatch form in the US. I ended up w/ the Yaris because of the weak highway mpg w/ the manual tranny in the Fit.
PetersRedYarisThe Black Hills of South Dakota · Jan 8, 2009#17
Originally Posted by mackie421 ↑
...the Civic unfortunately no longer comes in hatch form in the US...
And that's to bad. 👎 A Civic (4 door) wagon or (2 door) hatch would probably be the coolest car made today (in it's own catagory of course). 🤤
nsmitchellRichmond, VA · Jan 9, 2009#18
I loved the Civic Si Hatchbacks! I wanted one so bad...

I've owned 2 Civic Hatchbacks: 1988 Civic and a 1993 Civic VX. I loved them both very much!
I also owned a 1996 Civic HX CVT. I loved that car too.

I would say the answer to an MR2 would be the Del Sol VTech. I had a 1993 Del Sol Si and it was just the best car I've ever driven. In the summer it was that much better as I could go topless in less than 30 seconds. I would love it if Honda would remake the Del Sol as a hybrid.

The Fit and Yaris LB is a good comparison, but you can't compare a Civic to a Yaris Sedan. The Civic will mop the floor with a Yaris sedan, plus the Civic costs more and basically outclasses the Yaris.
mackie421Philadelphia · Jan 9, 2009#19
Originally Posted by PetersRedYaris ↑
And that's to bad. 👎 A Civic (4 door) wagon or (2 door) hatch would probably be the coolest car made today (in it's own catagory of course). 🤤

Agreed. My friends went to Greece last summer and were ready to become diplomats so they could bring over a Civic hatch.
blktiger60Washington · Jan 9, 2009#20
Originally Posted by nsmitchell ↑
I loved the Civic Si Hatchbacks! I wanted one so bad...

I've owned 2 Civic Hatchbacks: 1988 Civic and a 1993 Civic VX. I loved them both very much!
I also owned a 1996 Civic HX CVT. I loved that car too.

I would say the answer to an MR2 would be the Del Sol VTech. I had a 1993 Del Sol Si and it was just the best car I've ever driven. In the summer it was that much better as I could go topless in less than 30 seconds. I would love it if Honda would remake the Del Sol as a hybrid.

The Fit and Yaris LB is a good comparison, but you can't compare a Civic to a Yaris Sedan. The Civic will mop the floor with a Yaris sedan, plus the Civic costs more and basically outclasses the Yaris.
I agree, the Del Sol is a good match for the MR2. I recently sold my `85 CRX Si but I still have my `85 MR2.
Jem_hadarCollingwood, ON · Jan 10, 2009#21
Originally Posted by nsmitchell ↑
I loved the Civic Si Hatchbacks!
OH YEA... I'd kill two babies for an 03 civic hatchback!!! Fucking hot as hell cars!! LOVE THEM TOO!




Originally Posted by mackie421 ↑
I compared the Yaris to the Fit because I was looking for a hatch
Ditto.

And similar in price (note: i was never looking at the yaris RS or the fit sport topline models; and i was only ever looking at the 5door yaris too).

Plus them being in the same class (sub-compact) and all, with nearly same HP, torque, fuel efficiency, etc. etc. (even more so back in 07, before the new 09 fits came up w/ beefed up specs and offerings standard/available on it)

Jem
tomatoSan Francisco Bay Area · Feb 26, 2009#22
Originally Posted by b_hickman11 ↑
Why does everyone compare the Yaris vs the Fit rather than the Civic?? The Civic gets better mpg's than the Fit and they are basically the same starting price. I think the Yaris Sedan is more like the base Civic than a base fit.
Because they don't make a civic hatchback anymore, the FIT is its replacement. In fact, I think it's the smallest Honda in the US.
tomatoSan Francisco Bay Area · Feb 26, 2009#23
Originally Posted by nsmitchell ↑
I loved the Civic Si Hatchbacks! I wanted one so bad...
So did I!!! 😢

I've owned 2 Civic Hatchbacks: 1988 Civic and a 1993 Civic VX. I loved them both very much!
I also owned a 1996 Civic HX CVT. I loved that car too.

I almost bought a used Civic SI, but at the last minute I opted for the Yaris instead because the SI owner wanted as much money for his 9 year old Civic as the dealer for a couple years old Yaris, so I went with the newer car.

I owned a Honda Civic first gen. for a while, then got a 1987 CRX which I kept for a long time, until about 2 weeks ago. Hondas are good cars!!! 🤘
yaris-meAnaheim, CA · Feb 26, 2009#24
I've never owned a Honda, just Toyota's and Nissan's. When I needed a car I didn't consider the Fit as equivalent to the Yaris. I never thought to compare. After I bought the Yaris, I became aware of the comparison. They are both great cars, but....................the Yaris is better!👍
DorkinheimerCanada · Feb 26, 2009#25
Be glad that people comare the Yaris to another good car, and not a Hundai or Kia...
beaglemobileGreensboro, NC · Feb 26, 2009#26
Another Civic hatchback lover here. I looked at several used ones before getting a new Yaris, in fact.

Anyone remember the Honda Accord station wagon? Or for that matter, the Accord hatchback? I saw a guy a few weeks ago with one of the HBs in mint condition.
tomatoSan Francisco Bay Area · Feb 26, 2009#27
Originally Posted by beaglemobile ↑
Another Civic hatchback lover here. I looked at several used ones before getting a new Yaris, in fact.

Anyone remember the Honda Accord station wagon? Or for that matter, the Accord hatchback? I saw a guy a few weeks ago with one of the HBs in mint condition.
I sure do! We had a Honda Accord HB before I got my first Honda, a used Civic first gen. I drove that thing to the ground. I saw an old Accord HB on Craigslist about a month ago, also mint condition, despite a lot of miles. 🙌
beaglemobileGreensboro, NC · Feb 26, 2009#28
CVCC represent! 😁
Kal-ElMassachusetts · Feb 26, 2009#29
Originally Posted by Dorkinheimer ↑
Be glad that people comare the Yaris to another good car, and not a Hundai or Kia...
Yeah, Hyundai stinks. 🙄

Dude, welcome to 2009. Hyundai is now among the best.

1 attachment not included in this copy

eTiMaGoBangkok, Thailand · Feb 26, 2009#30
Originally Posted by Kal-El ↑
Yeah, Hyundai stinks. 🙄

Dude, welcome to 2009. Hyundai is now among the best.
Agreed... and by all accounts that new Genesis coupe is looking to become one heck of an enthusiast car... Nissan and Toyota/Subaru couldn't get off their asses to build the next-gen cheap RWD coupe, now Hyundai's beat them to it!
TamagoOff Grid · Feb 27, 2009#31
why does everyone compare the yaris to the suzuki swift, that's the one i want to know..
eTiMaGoBangkok, Thailand · Feb 27, 2009#32
true, it's a well known fact that the old swift is a luxury car in disguise...
TamagoOff Grid · Feb 27, 2009#33
Originally Posted by eTiMaGo ↑
true, it's a well known fact that the old swift is a luxury car in disguise...
what is the terminal velocity of an unladen african swallow, now THAT is one i'm curious about.
YarisSedanCalifornia - Bay Area · Feb 27, 2009#34
subcompact to subcompact. civic is to corolla cause compact to compact
ddongbaphay · Feb 27, 2009#35
Lol. That Hyundai has the same door handle/lock combo as the Yaris.
ddongbaphay · Feb 27, 2009#36
Originally Posted by eTiMaGo ↑
Agreed... and by all accounts that new Genesis coupe is looking to become one heck of an enthusiast car... Nissan and Toyota/Subaru couldn't get off their asses to build the next-gen cheap RWD coupe, now Hyundai's beat them to it!
I don't think Subaru has anything except AWD.

Nissan's top stuff is AWD. And I think they have the 370z to compete in that Genesis segment. Even though the 370z costs more. Its much more car. You should be comparing it to the higher end Genesis Coupes anyways.

Ford's Mustang is pretty cheap. Starts at 20.

BMW's 128 is pretty close. I'd much rather get one of these. 135 would go up against the higher model Coupes.

Dodge has that challenger that starts at the same 22k price range.

Mazda has the RX-8 that starts at 26.

Toyota... they're Nascar now. Son. Idk wtf they're doing.

Soo, I think companies have been doing it. There's just another sparkle about the new Genesis.
ddongbaphay · Feb 27, 2009#37
Originally Posted by Tamago ↑
what is the terminal velocity of an unladen african swallow, now THAT is one i'm curious about.
As fast as a penny? lol.
DorkinheimerCanada · Feb 27, 2009#38
Originally Posted by Kal-El ↑
Yeah, Hyundai stinks. 🙄

Dude, welcome to 2009. Hyundai is now among the best.
Yeah, they went up in quality, but price for price, I prefer a Japanese car, and you did buy a Toyota !
And when you trade both cars in a few years later, you'll lose less with a Japanese, I'm pretty sure.
derickveliz2Central, MA · Feb 27, 2009#39
Fit owners always stair at my car all the time, the sport ones try to race me at the highway.
bobbyNortheast · Feb 27, 2009#40
I own a 2007 Yaris hatch, and a 2009 Phit with Navi. Having driven both, I can tell you that unquestionably the Phit is a better, safer, roomier, better handling car...by far.

That's all. 🙂
specialeducatorHarrisonburg, VA · Feb 27, 2009#41
Given the price difference, it creates an unequal comparison. I quickly moved away from considering the Fit because of it's expense.
blktiger60Washington · Feb 27, 2009#42
Originally Posted by bobby ↑
I own a 2007 Yaris hatch, and a 2009 Phit with Navi. Having driven both, I can tell you that unquestionably the Phit is a better, safer, roomier, better handling car...by far.

That's all. 🙂
Not to mention a whole lot uglier.
ddongbaphay · Feb 28, 2009#43
Originally Posted by specialeducator ↑
Given the price difference, it creates an unequal comparison. I quickly moved away from considering the Fit because of it's expense.
Toyota 5D LB: $13,300.

Honda Fit: $14,700.
roxy1michigan · Feb 28, 2009#44
Originally Posted by ddongbap ↑
Toyota 5D LB: $13,300.

Honda Fit: $14,700.

not the proper comparison, since that is an automatic yaris 5 dr liftback.
automatic fit starts at $15,550
Kal-ElMassachusetts · Feb 28, 2009#45
Originally Posted by Dorkinheimer ↑
Yeah, they went up in quality, but price for price, I prefer a Japanese car, and you did buy a Toyota !
And when you trade both cars in a few years later, you'll lose less with a Japanese, I'm pretty sure.
I'll give you that much. 🙂 Yes, I still prefer my Japanese cars but was just defending Hyundai as you basically stated that Hyundai and Kia aren't good cars.
Kal-ElMassachusetts · Feb 28, 2009#46
Originally Posted by bobby ↑
I own a 2007 Yaris hatch, and a 2009 Phit with Navi. Having driven both, I can tell you that unquestionably the Phit is a better, safer, roomier, better handling car...by far.

That's all. 🙂
You paid approximately $19,500 for your Fit (auto?). How much was your Yaris again?

😉
RyuSurrey, BC · Feb 28, 2009#47
Yaris and Fit are both subcompact and both are from well known reliable Toyota and Honda, I guess that why is people always comparing Yaris to Fit, and not other subcompact.
SplitEdmonton · Feb 28, 2009#48
You can't cross compare years.

Yaris 5dr Hatchback - $15,065
Scion xD - $14,650
Honda Fit - $14,750

Yaris 5dr in the USA for some reason only comes in Automatic, so that explains the price difference.
I'm not really sure why Toyota makes its own competitor, Yaris 5dr vs Scion xD. GM has been doing this same stupidity for so long. Cobalt vs Pursuit, Solstice vs Sky, Sunfire vs Cavalier, Tahoe vs Yukon, etc. I don't really understand why.

Damn the Scion xD is a good deal btw, If we were in the states, we would have bought that instead for sure. The only reason I can see wanting a Yaris is for the 3dr or the sedan, i'm not sure why anyone would buy a 5dr yaris (no offensive to 5dr yaris owners, please enlighten me!). I'd love to have a Scion xD with that 1.8L motor.. its like a 5dr Yaris TS!
supmetSouthern California · Feb 28, 2009#49
Originally Posted by Kal-El ↑
Yeah, Hyundai stinks. 🙄

Dude, welcome to 2009. Hyundai is now among the best.
Originally Posted by eTiMaGo ↑
Agreed... and by all accounts that new Genesis coupe is looking to become one heck of an enthusiast car... Nissan and Toyota/Subaru couldn't get off their asses to build the next-gen cheap RWD coupe, now Hyundai's beat them to it!
Am I missing some running joke or something? You guys seriously think hyundais are nice? I realize not everyone reads consumer reports, but - I've asked this before, and I guess I'll keep asking - when was the last time you saw a hyundai driving around that was 5 years old or older? I see one a month tops, and invariably its making some god awful screeching/whining/hissing/"broken car" noise. Compare that with the 50 old hondas/toyotas that I see, and each one sounds like it still has 100k+ left in it.

Welcome to 2009, where your hyundai still sucks.
specialeducatorHarrisonburg, VA · Feb 28, 2009#50
I was using real life data- cars on the lots.