Yarisworld Archive

Mobil-1 5W-30 does not meet SM/SL standards?

66 posts · 22,614 views · page 1 of 2

Replies 65

PetersRedYarisThe Black Hills of South Dakota · Jan 5, 2009#3
Interesting. I had already been planning to switch to SynPower simple because (at Walmart) it's $19 for a 5 quart jug vs. $26+ for Mobile 1.
Doug007California · Jan 5, 2009#4
Originally Posted by PetersRedYaris ↑
Interesting. I had already been planning to switch to SynPower simple because (at Walmart) it's $19 for a 5 quart jug vs. $26+ for Mobile 1.
Me too...I'm due for an oil change and was considering making the switch from Mobil 1; this cements the deal.
gidNortheast · Jan 5, 2009#6
Originally Posted by PetersRedYaris ↑
Interesting. I had already been planning to switch to SynPower simple because (at Walmart) it's $19 for a 5 quart jug vs. $26+ for Mobile 1.
used it for 4,500 mile stint in the '08 Liftback . You'll find good U.O.A.s at http://www.bobistheoilguy.com/forums...Board=3&page=1 . I got 4 quarts of the SYNPOWER awhile ago at K-MART for $2.99 each . There's a $10 rebate for VALVOLINE as well . Go to http://www.bobistheoilguy.com/forums...266764&fpart=1 and click on VALVOLINE REBATE in 1st post which will take you to the rebate that has been extended to FEBRUARY 2nd of 2009 ( disregard the expiration date of DECEMBER 31 , 2008 ) . That'll make the 5 quart jug $9.99 , thus $2 a quart for the SYNPOWER synthetic .
TheSilkySmoothThread starterNew Hampshire · Jan 5, 2009#7
Gid being the bargain hunter:
$10 off coupon ( mial in rebate) at valvoline site on 5qts of Synpower - I saw this while watching a vid of their testing lab which is cool 🎉

now where do I buy synpower at the cheapest price???

I may not want it though - I still think synpower its a grpIII mix. I want the jet engine oil! polyol=ester or di=ester. This is the ONLY real stuff in my book and is the "old school syn people think about. Make GOBS of power and leaks out all over the place - gotta love it.

This is the real stuff HERE> http://www.kemopro.com/productinfo/engine.html

but I dont know if I trust the blender
TheSilkySmoothThread starterNew Hampshire · Jan 5, 2009#8
Crapo! I just fully read Gid's post above about the rebate too - I shoulda known he would be on this like a rabid dog on a red squirrel😛
TheSilkySmoothThread starterNew Hampshire · Jan 5, 2009#9
I hear ( and you UOA guys can confirm this) The Valvoline maxlife is better than the synpower - but does it have the API approval or does it have too much antiwear additive to meet SM? Back to the valvoline site ... ...
gidNortheast · Jan 6, 2009#10
these are the days it pays to be a tight. 😁
jambo101Montreal Canada · Jan 7, 2009#12
Now for the interesting part...

According to a letter Valvoline marketers received, the result from Valvoline's testing indicate:

Valvoline SynPower's 5W-30 wear performance is at least four times better than Mobil 1 5W-30
Mobil 1 5W-30 does not meet minimum API SM or ILSAC GF-4 specification because of its inferior performance in the Sequence IVA wear test

Not sure i'd hang Mobil1 out to dry on the strength of 1 anonomous letter,probably from one of Mobil's competitors,probably Valvoline.
marcustoronto, canada · Jan 7, 2009#13
this could be why i dropped mpg when i switch to mobil1 synth...significant drop.. lost about 30 km on a 36 liter tank,..
ChupacabraCT · Jan 7, 2009#14
The trend around some of the communities I visit is that people are distancing themselves from Mobil synthetic oils especially the 5-30. People noted oil analysis (back to back) that showed higher metal contents. I am considering switching but am not totally sold on the fact yet.
TheSilkySmoothThread starterNew Hampshire · Jan 7, 2009#15
Originally Posted by jambo101 ↑
Not sure i'd hang Mobil1 out to dry on the strength of 1 anonomous letter,probably from one of Mobil's competitors,probably Valvoline.
They (Valvoline) have issued multiple official letters clearly stating that sampling of the 5W-30 M1 does not meet SL or SM minimum standards and is not appropriate for use in current motor vehicles under warranty. I'll look for letter ... . I am not taking any sides here - I've gotten rotten batches of oil from Valvoline AND Mobil. Could have be a EOM Management decision to release underperforming material - happens all the time in even the most stringent arenas ( medical, aerospace, communications tech, auto tech). Look at the Columbia disaster for an prime example of Management incompetence or carelessness😠
TheSilkySmoothThread starterNew Hampshire · Jan 7, 2009#16
open letter from valvoline:
valvol1.jpg
firemachine69Sudbury, On · Jan 7, 2009#17
Originally Posted by TheSilkySmooth ↑
I hear ( and you UOA guys can confirm this) The Valvoline maxlife is better than the synpower - but does it have the API approval or does it have too much antiwear additive to meet SM? Back to the valvoline site ... ...


It's SM-rated, but does not qualify for the energy-efficiency starburst.
ShroomsterOrlando · Jan 7, 2009#18
I currently have mobil-1 5w20 in the wife's yaris and Castrol Syntec 5w20 in my civic

both of those have this sm sl jargon on the bottles so I guess i'm fine using them still....
gidNortheast · Jan 8, 2009#19
wonder how SHELL Full synthetic and PENNZOIL Platinum compare to the SYNPOWER ? Do you ? I don't . 🤷
nsmitchellRichmond, VA · Jan 8, 2009#21
Originally Posted by PK198105 ↑
what about ELF, kim thinking of getting that one in my Yaris.

ELF TOTAL QUARTZ FUTURE 9000 5W30
I've heard it has elfen magic...
TheSilkySmoothThread starterNew Hampshire · Jan 8, 2009#23
Originally Posted by gid ↑
wonder how SHELL Full synthetic and PENNZOIL Platinum compare to the SYNPOWER ? Do you ? I don't . 🤷
I'm tired of this oil stuff too. But this Ali/Fraser battle was too good to pass up😉
TheSilkySmoothThread starterNew Hampshire · Jan 8, 2009#24
Originally Posted by Chupacabra ↑
....and M1 EP seems to be 2nd best 🙂
EOM supplies Amsoil their base stock?
TheSilkySmoothThread starterNew Hampshire · Jan 8, 2009#25
Originally Posted by Chupacabra ↑
....and M1 EP seems to be 2nd best 🙂
Run it, have engine failure, Warranty wont cover due to oil not meeting manufacturer\'s spec, Now you have to prove to E.O.M. that their oil is bad(ha!) and caused failure, wait 3 years maybe get some money if you are lucky. In the meantime you pay $4500. for engine repair. Sure I want to use that stuff!🤘
TheSilkySmoothThread starterNew Hampshire · Jan 8, 2009#26
Originally Posted by TheSilkySmooth ↑
Run it, have engine failure, Warranty wont cover due to oil not meeting manufacturer\'s spec, Now you have to prove to E.O.M. that their oil is bad(ha!) and caused failure, wait 3 years maybe get some money if you are lucky. In the meantime you pay $4500. for engine repair. Sure I want to use that stuff!🤘
What am I sayin?! It's gonna be a pissing contest ANYTIME you have an engine failure. Probably the same outcome too.
ChupacabraCT · Jan 9, 2009#27
Originally Posted by TheSilkySmooth ↑
Run it, have engine failure, Warranty wont cover due to oil not meeting manufacturer\'s spec, Now you have to prove to E.O.M. that their oil is bad(ha!) and caused failure, wait 3 years maybe get some money if you are lucky. In the meantime you pay $4500. for engine repair. Sure I want to use that stuff!🤘
Bullshit. When I went to Toyota....they have a whole entire shelf full of Mobil 1 5-30 and that is what they use when a customer requires synthetic oil. There is no way that if there were an engine failure, they would not honor the warranty due to the use of Mobil 1. They can only check to see the viscosity is correct and the level is correct.
TheSilkySmoothThread starterNew Hampshire · Jan 9, 2009#28
Originally Posted by Chupacabra ↑
Bullshit. When I went to Toyota....they have a whole entire shelf full of Mobil 1 5-30 and that is what they use when a customer requires synthetic oil. There is no way that if there were an engine failure, they would not honor the warranty due to the use of Mobil 1. They can only check to see the viscosity is correct and the level is correct.
The Center Having and selling M1 is irrelevant to this argument, the centere is UNAWARE of the oil being out of specification as are 99.999% of drivers and 90% service managers. If the oil is at fault, the Oil MFG will have to pay and there may be BIG delays in recuping uyour losses. Naturally, Toyota WOULD have to prove that the oil was out of spec and not you, but if they are ShArKs they may give you the ould "run around" if you are ill informed and dont have a lawyer standing next to you. Now, typ they would only perform a viscosity at temp and TBN to certify the oil as OK. But if there is "proof" out there that M1 does not meet sl/sm then Toyota has the upper hand and they can deny warranty claim - IF it is proven a given MFG run of that the oil is NFG. In our world, I would hope MY toyota service centre would just fix the motor if the oil level is good and I have proof of last OC.
ps: I would also not expect to see any failures with this sequence iva test being not met. You may just see some higher wear numbers thru the OCI, if any.

-Papa
PetersRedYarisThe Black Hills of South Dakota · Jan 9, 2009#29
Wow, some of you actually think your engine is going to sustain damage due to this? Anyone who thinks their engine is going to crap out due to Mobile 1 use is crazy. I don't care if a bad batch got out onto store shelves, it's a Toyota and can handle it. Use a different oil next change if it makes you feel better, but your Yaris is fine in the meantime...
ChupacabraCT · Jan 9, 2009#30
Originally Posted by PetersRedYaris ↑
Wow, some of you actually think your engine is going to sustain damage due to this? Anyone who thinks their engine is going to crap out due to Mobile 1 use is crazy. I don't care if a bad batch got out onto store shelves, it's a Toyota and can handle it. Use a different oil next change if it makes you feel better, but your Yaris is fine in the meantime...

I don't think that but SilkySmooth was saying that the dealer might deny your warranty due to the usage of M1 if one were to walk in with a blown motor which is definitely not the case.
TheSilkySmoothThread starterNew Hampshire · Jan 11, 2009#31
Originally Posted by Chupacabra ↑
I don't think that but SilkySmooth was saying that the dealer might deny your warranty due to the usage of M1 if one were to walk in with a blown motor which is definitely not the case.
I think it all depends on you Service managers temperment at the time - but they typically would have to call in a zone rep to approve. Andyotas arent magic and repeal the laws of material science - in fact 1nzfe utilise a camshaft that is VERY prone to wear in this exact circumstance - cold start wear - just like the Nissan test engine used in the sequence iva test. This whole thing Smacks of the Quakerstate disaster a decade or so ago, though for porbably differing circumstance. YOUR ENGINE MAY NOT FAIL - BUT YOU ARE RISKING A CAM REPLACEMENT POST-WARRANTY FOR A CONSIERABLE OUT OF POCKET CASH OUTLAY. I you wish to argue my points - lets talk about the seq iva a test that M1 fails to pass and go on form there. You cannot argue that a significant sample of M1 failed over a 2 year period - Ashland wouldnt state this if it could not be backe d by hard data. They would be risking losing their Co to the GIANT EOM. - Papa
TheSilkySmoothThread starterNew Hampshire · Jan 11, 2009#32
Originally Posted by Chupacabra ↑
I don't think that but SilkySmooth was saying that the dealer might deny your warranty due to the usage of M1 if one were to walk in with a blown motor which is definitely not the case.
Call your service manager and ask him/her; I intend to do this just to hear if they have received a bulletin on this issue - or have read this is an industrial publication. You wont read it in Road and Track or Motor trend they are in bed with the advertisers.
TheSilkySmoothThread starterNew Hampshire · Jan 11, 2009#33
Originally Posted by Chupacabra ↑
I don't think that but SilkySmooth was saying that the dealer might deny your warranty due to the usage of M1 if one were to walk in with a blown motor which is definitely not the case.
So if I follow your argument - that the oil you install does not have to meet Sl/Sm ILSAC GF3/4, then I can use John Deere 5w-30 SJ? Why deos my oil cap say: USE 5W-30 API SL APPROVED OIL?
auxmikeLI, New Yawk · Jan 11, 2009#34
This stuff gives me a headache.....🙁
I never gave this a thought ever on any of the cars I used to drive and they were all fine. Bought the PepBoys house brand for years.....
My Dad gets the synth change at the Toyo dealer on the '04 Tacoma and the '06 Corolla, and I believe it IS M1. They give him a reciept so it IS warr. covered if something goes wrong....
Face it, this engine sounds screwed up straight off the lot with that scary idle the sounds like bad valves. Notice how many people ask the same ? about the engine sound?🤷
I'm hoping since these cars are made in JAPAN that the engines might be a bit closer to spec. tolerances. As for turning into a rust bucket in the future, who knows!
AltitudeColorado · Jan 11, 2009#35
Surprise! An 'independant' study commissioned and paid for by Valvoline proves their oil is better! Wow, shocking!
TheSilkySmoothThread starterNew Hampshire · Jan 11, 2009#36
Originally Posted by Altitude ↑
Surprise! An 'independant' study commissioned and paid for by Valvoline proves their oil is better! Wow, shocking!
Oh, another EOM stooge enters the argument, He he. You Men in Silver are everywhere. LOOK OUT! OK. Valvoline states the MOBIL 1 5W-30, available (where'd it go??) on the shelves, does not meet API SM/SL specification on samples submitted to their own lab and independent lab. NO ONE can argue this point. Now, this results from a pissing contest EOM started: Mobil said their oil was the best, Valvoline said their oil was better, Mobil said prove it, and along the way M1 was found to be deficient. Tough Cookie - take your lumps. I am a fan of NEITHER. The fist time i got improperly formulated oil it came out of a Valvioline bottle. Poured like kerosene and smelled the same.
TheSilkySmoothThread starterNew Hampshire · Jan 11, 2009#37
[QUOTE=auxmike;216723]This stuff gives me a headache.....🙁
My Dad gets the synth change at the Toyo dealer on the '04 Tacoma and the '06 Corolla, and I believe it IS M1. They give him a reciept so it IS warr. covered if something goes wrong....
QUOTE]Ha ha, NOPE! Dealer changes the oil, you change the oil , doesn’t matter to Toyota regional.. MOBIL is at fault and the ball would be in their court IF the oil was found to be deficient and caused the failure. And YOU are stuck in the middle, pal. Don’t be naive. Toyota won’t take the blame for it or pay the bill. Mobil1 is not a Toyota warranteed part. Call you dealer.
AltitudeColorado · Jan 11, 2009#38
EOM stooge? I don't give a crap whose oil is better. I treat most all studies with suspicion - especially those where the competition pays someone else to test the other's product. The only ones worth paying attention to are those performed by people with no skin in the game.

Money talks - that's all this is - and it's how the world works.

Companies that perform a service for a fee are far more likely to come out in favor of the servicee's desired result. Why? Because if they want to stay in business and get future business from a given company they will give positive results. It wouldn't make sense to keep paying a company that says your product is crap.
TheSilkySmoothThread starterNew Hampshire · Jan 12, 2009#39
Originally Posted by Altitude ↑
EOM stooge? I don't give a crap whose oil is better. I treat most all studies with suspicion - especially those where the competition pays someone else to test the other's product. The only ones worth paying attention to are those performed by people with no skin in the game.

Money talks - that's all this is - and it's how the world works.

Companies that perform a service for a fee are far more likely to come out in favor of the servicee's desired result. Why? Because if they want to stay in business and get future business from a given company they will give positive results. It wouldn't make sense to keep paying a company that says your product is crap.
I understand this have worked for an ISO 9001 certifications, and having a house pre-purchase "inspected". Now, Do you believe the samples Failed this "expensive" sequence iva test or they are lying outright? I believe that the product sampled DID fail. Its a tough test. I think Ashland had the independent lab VERIFIY the result they found in their own lab. Ashland has in-house capabilities to perform a number these API/ ISLAC tests.
auxmikeLI, New Yawk · Jan 12, 2009#40
"I understand this have worked for an ISO 9001 certifications, and having a house pre-purchase "inspected". "

Huh?
SilverGlowSouthern California · Jan 12, 2009#41
Originally Posted by TheSilkySmooth ↑
Run it, have engine failure, Warranty wont cover due to oil not meeting manufacturer\'s spec, Now you have to prove to E.O.M. that their oil is bad(ha!) and caused failure, wait 3 years maybe get some money if you are lucky. In the meantime you pay $4500. for engine repair. Sure I want to use that stuff!🤘
You continue to bolding speak lies, nonesense, and your bravado proves your ignorance.

Using EP will not cause engine failure. It has never caused engine failure. It is too bad that there are many newbies to cars that could read your BS and think it is fact. I just hope that most of the people reading your flippant sarcastic comments see past your know-it-all attitude and lack of knowledge.

And I'm not even a M1 EP user....
auxmikeLI, New Yawk · Jan 12, 2009#42
I swear this must be "Grumpy in NH".
What ever happend to him?
Yeah, don't feed the trolls, boys.
1stToyotaOklahoma · Jan 13, 2009#43
Originally Posted by SilverGlow ↑
You continue to bolding speak lies, nonesense, and your bravado proves your ignorance.

Using EP will not cause engine failure. It has never caused engine failure. It is too bad that there are many newbies to cars that could read your BS and think it is fact. I just hope that most of the people reading your flippant sarcastic comments see past your know-it-all attitude and lack of knowledge.

And I'm not even a M1 EP user....
You got pretty close to speaking that same lie again. Engine failed due to an oil related issue in a late model chevy pickup that used nothing but M1, Mr know-it-all. 😛
TheSilkySmoothThread starterNew Hampshire · Jan 13, 2009#44
Originally Posted by SilverGlow ↑
You continue to bolding speak lies, nonesense, and your bravado proves your ignorance.

Using EP will not cause engine failure. It has never caused engine failure. It is too bad that there are many newbies to cars that could read your BS and think it is fact. I just hope that most of the people reading your flippant sarcastic comments see past your know-it-all attitude and lack of knowledge.

And I'm not even a M1 EP user....
I would respond, but you are too ignorant to formulate an argument using logic. So have a Bad day🙂
TheSilkySmoothThread starterNew Hampshire · Jan 13, 2009#45
Originally Posted by auxmike ↑
"I understand this have worked for an ISO 9001 certifications, and having a house pre-purchase "inspected". "

Huh?
Hey there's nothing really bad about being a moron. Its just your geneology and upbringing - It's not your fault Mr . Mikey 🙂
TheSilkySmoothThread starterNew Hampshire · Jan 13, 2009#46
MODERATER:
Close this thread - It been overtaken by haters who are not speaking to point and are just casting aspersions.
gidNortheast · Jan 13, 2009#47
someone got up and out the wrong side of their YARIS this morning . 😉
TheSilkySmoothThread starterNew Hampshire · Jan 13, 2009#48
Originally Posted by gid ↑
someone got up and out the wrong side of their YARIS this morning . 😉
Yeah, Silverglow and Auxmike - I'm not going to tolerate this kind of verbal abuse from a couple illogical dolts. How 'bout discussing the argument points instead of going on the personal attack? I guess they have no logical argument. 🤷
gidNortheast · Jan 13, 2009#49
Originally Posted by TheSilkySmooth ↑
Yeah, Silverglow and Auxmike - I'm not going to tolerate this kind of verbal abuse from a couple illogical dolts. How 'bout discussing the argument points instead of going on the personal attack? I guess they have no logical argument. 🤷
I was referring to you . You insulted me as well as of lately . What's up with the attacks ? 👎
AltitudeColorado · Jan 13, 2009#50
Silky(s) - no need to get all huffy about it. Just read that article you posted carefully.. Notice anything peculiar? Hint: Marketers...

The bottom line is that someone using Mobil 1, Valvoline or any other oil and who also does regular oil changes and doesn't beat the crap out of the car will be able to drive it until the thing falls apart. Who cares if my 200K engine has slightly more wear than someone else's 200k engine. The thing has served its purpose and it's time to get a new car!

And please... like you didn't know your post would stir things up?