Does doing this at stoplights really help mpg on an automatic transmission, or is that just a myth? We have a difference of opinion on it among my friends.
😕
😕
22 posts · 13,836 views
so youre saying i shouldnt shift into neutral in my ATX aveo? lolOriginally Posted by BailOut ↑It does save gas because it decreases drag on the engine but it is nowhere near as efficient as just turning off the engine.
The wear on the transmission from going between N and D is negligible, and represents much less forces than even moderate acceleration. Prior to the mid 1990's some American makes did indeed have issues with frequent manual gear selections on an AT, and one South Korean manufacturer still does (Daewoo, makers of the Chevy Aveo), but it is nothing to worry about in the Yaris.
I would not do it often. I was "educated" by the GM dealership my rental Aveo was serviced at after I threw a CEL for using neutral like that. Let's just say that they are not fans of the transmission used in the Aveo. 😉Originally Posted by thebarber ↑so youre saying i shouldnt shift into neutral in my ATX aveo? lol
Does it save gas? Sometimes, but very, very little...Originally Posted by otterhere ↑Does doing this at stoplights really help mpg on an automatic transmission, or is that just a myth? We have a difference of opinion on it among my friends.
😕
can you load up your car the same (w/ ppl and a full trunk, say?) or what about for towing (assuming a 1000lbs w/ trailer and junk)?Originally Posted by voodoo22 ↑I agree you need to do what you are comfortable with and everyone is different, but the only compromise of inflating your tires to max sidewall over the suggested psi from your car manufacturer is ride comfort. The other downsides you list are false.
Sorry, I disagree. An overinflated tire does not grip/provide traction as well as one that has lower pressure...but most hypermilers don't realize that as they accelerate/deccelerate/travel at much slower rates than most folks...Originally Posted by voodoo22 ↑I agree you need to do what you are comfortable with and everyone is different, but the only compromise of inflating your tires to max sidewall over the suggested psi from your car manufacturer is ride comfort. The other downsides you list are false.
My Scangage shows such a tiny gain that it's not worth the bother. I think that the Yaris actually adjusts for the tranny when it's idling. Then there is the "I forgot to shift it back into drive and got the motor to over rev" situation.Originally Posted by otterhere ↑Does doing this at stoplights really help mpg on an automatic transmission, or is that just a myth? We have a difference of opinion on it among my friends.
😕
GM in my experience has this tendency to slap something together sometimes, especially their drive train components, and more so lately.Originally Posted by BailOut ↑I would not do it often. I was "educated" by the GM dealership my rental Aveo was serviced at after I threw a CEL for using neutral like that. Let's just say that they are not fans of the transmission used in the Aveo. 😉
You will be just fine as long as you leave the engine running while coasting in neutral.Originally Posted by YenOfIrrelevent ↑So it will be safe for a Yaris sedan to switch into neutral right? I have been doing it for the past two weeks and nothing happened yet but if there is something I should know that may occur please reply. Thanks.
Thank you Bailout. Yeah that's what I usually do, I switch it to neutral when I come close to a light and I always thought it's good because when you brake, it's not fighting against the engine when you are on D.Originally Posted by BailOut ↑You will be just fine as long as you leave the engine running while coasting in neutral.
you mean sitting at a stop not coasting right?Originally Posted by BailOut ↑You will be just fine as long as you leave the engine running while coasting in neutral.
Hmmm I don't switch on 50. More like in the 20-35. Sometimes I caught myself close to the 40 mark. Is that still bad?Originally Posted by Shroomster ↑you mean sitting at a stop not coasting right?
coasting from 50 or so to a light while shifting from drive to neutral affects gear mesh. essentially will strip clutch packs and teeth...
Originally Posted by voodoo22 ↑From what I've read and my own experience, it's best to coast in neutral when you aren't planning on slowing down and coasting in D will decelerate you too quickly. Like going down a hill or decline on the hwy.
You should stay in D and coast when coming to a stop so your engine is slowing you down and you can benefit from DFCO, where as long as the rpms are above 1200 or so, fuel to the engine is cut off and you're using no gas.
DFCO is best in all circumstances unless it greatly shortens the length of your coast. There's one spot I can coast in N for 3 kms some days, but in D I could only coast for 1/2 a km. In those cases I think it's best to coast in N for a long distance and use less fuel, than coast in D for a short distance and use no fuel.