Yarisworld Archive

HDR - PhotoMatix vs Dynamic Photo

18 posts · 9,158 views

Kaotic LazagnaOriginal postCentral Valley, CA · Dec 15, 2008#1
Tired as heck from my finals today, but I still wanted to play around with my new HDR software. These are using older pics of my car, but I wanted to make a new background for my laptop. Let me know which one you guys like better. Sorry if they're a little too big, let me know if you want them resized.

Dynamic Photo version:
Picture not included in this copy



PhotoMatix version:
Picture not included in this copy

Replies 17

YAR1SRaleigh, NC · Dec 15, 2008#2
I like the first one better... the second one looks blurry and a little less intriguing... IMO.
jinxorSydney, Australia · Dec 15, 2008#3
1st one is definately looking better
TheUnGroomedMD · Dec 16, 2008#4
The color of the Yaris in the Dynamic Photo picture seems to be a little better. But I had to vote for the PhotoMatix because of the compression.
tuckevalastinDelaware/Connecticut · Dec 16, 2008#5
neither's perfect but neither is bad... I vote Dynamic
Kaotic LazagnaThread starterCentral Valley, CA · Dec 16, 2008#6
Originally Posted by PK198105 ↑
Photomatix because it doesn't compress the color range as Dynamic Photo, look at the sky and you will notice compression in DYnamic Photo.
Yeah, I noticed that, but I figured since I've only played around with it a couple of times, I still have lots to learn about the settings. May be I can get it to the point where the picture doesn't have those compression areas.
Kaotic LazagnaThread starterCentral Valley, CA · Dec 16, 2008#7
Originally Posted by TheUnGroomed ↑
The color of the Yaris in the Dynamic Photo picture seems to be a little better. But I had to vote for the PhotoMatix because of the compression.
I agree, and I think that's where Dynamic Photo is sort of a cheat. LOL. You can pick and choose which hue range(s) is more saturated individually. There's also manual aligning of the pictures in Dynamic Photo. But once again, I don't know as much about its settings as I do with PhotoMatix.
Kaotic LazagnaThread starterCentral Valley, CA · Dec 16, 2008#8
Originally Posted by tuckevalastin ↑
neither's perfect but neither is bad... I vote Dynamic
hahaha. Yeah, my HDR's are not as drastic as PK's (could be also due to the fact I don't have those crazy scenery and sky like he does). 😆
cali yarisCanoga Park, CA · Dec 16, 2008#9
Look at the sky in the first one. See the pixelation? It looks like it was saved as a GIF file (258 color maximum).

The second photo has smooth color gradients - more like a JPG file would.

You sure we're comparing apples to apples?
Kaotic LazagnaThread starterCentral Valley, CA · Dec 16, 2008#10
Yup, Garm, both are JPEG's. I'm still getting used to the program that was used for the first one. 😛
Kaotic LazagnaThread starterCentral Valley, CA · Dec 16, 2008#11
Another one using more recent pics:

Dynamic Photo:
Picture not included in this copy




PhotoMatix:
Picture not included in this copy
Kaotic LazagnaThread starterCentral Valley, CA · Dec 16, 2008#12
That one came out too vivid, and I still can't manage to rid of the pixels. I guess I might just stick with PhotoMatix for that reason.
NJBobSouth Jersey · Dec 16, 2008#13
Really it's "beauty is in the eye"...etc. Dynamic appeals to me more. Both are exaggerations of reality. And I also agree with Cali. 🙂
ruimondPerth, Australia · Dec 16, 2008#14
I think the Photomatix one looks better, the Dynamic Photo one looks like it has a high contrast. Photomatix one has better colour in my opinion.

I just tried to edit one of my old photos in Photoshop, by just adjusting the exposures from -5 to 5 and saving invidual Jpegs. I used Photomatix like you have. Sorry to post the photo in your thread, didn't wanna start a new thread with it. Haha.

Picture not included in this copy
Kaotic LazagnaThread starterCentral Valley, CA · Dec 16, 2008#15
That came out pretty good. Dang you guys and your clouds! LOL.
derickveliz2Central, MA · Dec 16, 2008#16
I vote for your car! LOL. 🎉

If only we could mix them together 🤷
yarisugiハワイ · Dec 17, 2008#17
Originally Posted by ruimond ↑
I just tried to edit one of my old photos in Photoshop, by just adjusting the exposures from -5 to 5 and saving invidual Jpegs.
Where in Photoshop can you adjust exposure? I might wanna try that.
ruimondPerth, Australia · Dec 17, 2008#18
Originally Posted by yarisugi ↑
Where in Photoshop can you adjust exposure? I might wanna try that.
Your can do it through Image > Adjustments > Exposure. I'm pretty sure only the newer versions of photoshop have it.