Yarisworld Archive

GM Govt. Bailout?

75 posts · 15,617 views · page 2 of 2

Replies continued

GeneWPennsylvania · Nov 16, 2008#51
Originally Posted by SailDesign ↑
I call 🙄
ford Europe has a higher (yup!) labour cost, and they keep up very well with the European and Japanese "small fuel efficient" markets.
Ford makes their smaller cars all over the globe. Wouldn't surprise me if the Focus were made in Europe and it would not surprise me if Ford got a subsidy or two for doing it there.

Originally Posted by SailDesign ↑
They just choose not to import the smaller cars and their technology here.... Look at the Ford Focus diesel that just came out - Ford won't import it because "Americans view diesel as a dirty fuel"
🙄
Also because of NOx emissions... some diesels are pretty bad that way.

Also, perhaps, because the Ford Focus diesel lacks the acceleration needed to compete in US markets. Perhaps the real cause is that the American consumer does not want a slow plodding car?

I'd have sprung for a Yaris diesel. No doubt about it.

Gene
stuffyontario, canada · Nov 16, 2008#52
Originally Posted by GeneW ↑
The oil is useless unless someone takes a risk to extract it, transport it and market it. That risk taking ought to be rewarded and not punished with ever higher taxes (Royalties). If I had my say there would be no Royalties.

However this is the real world. People will demand what they can get from whoever has more. That's how it is. The attitude of "Cost of Doing Business" to me is really the attitude that business exists at the sufferance of the State. "They'll manage". What happens when "they" can no longer manage to pay those Royalties or the marginal cost of the Royalties plus the costs of extraction exceed the income from the oil?


My point is, what happens when the Royalties get so large that one cannot do business?

The Tar Sands have been there a very long time. Extraction of the sands was not practical until recently because of market Will the Premier cut the Royalty rates if the market prices of oil continue to fall?

What of all of the new dependents who take that extra revenue? Will they manage without it too if the Rates fall? Perhaps the Government cannot lower the revenue from the Royalties because someone is now dependent upon it?

I see a lot of this problem where I live. When the Steel Mills were fully operational governments expanded to fully use the tax revenue. The Steel Mills are mostly gone now. Those local governments who grew fat on manufacturing taxes now run speed traps (speed limits are made artificially lower and then police entrap people who "speed" through the area). These governments have also raised property taxes and income taxes and go begging to the State Capital for money.

You have to focus on the long term, not take more money because businesses "are doing so well". So even if we disagree on the idea of Royalties it's still reasonable to set them at levels which do not endanger the businesses.



Lots of good paying jobs in the fields. To me that is reward enough for having a business nearby.

As far as "checks" go....Bastiat warned that once citizens of a Democracy can vote themselves money out of the Treasury hard times are not too far behind.

As best evidence let me offer the spectacle of the US Congress "bailing out" big banks and investment firms which followed the lead of US Home Loan agencies by chasing shaky borrowers and then "bundling" loans into "securities". The program to buy the "toxic debt" will no longer be taken, instead banks can just get the money. Welfare for the super rich, which to me is just as wrong as welfare for able bodied folk who would rather loaf than work.

Gene
a company that makes cakes does not get their raw material (let's say flour) for free because it's useless without them to make something edible out of it.
they have to pay for the flour just like an oil company has to pay for the raw material from whoever owns it, which in this case is the people of alberta.


sure, i agree that corporate welfare is wrong,
but the government got themselves into this trouble by deregulating the banking industry.
the only reason why canada's banks are in such good shape compare to those in the u.s. and europe was that our government resisted deregulating the banking sector in the mid 90's.
as far as i'm concerned, industry has proven that they cannot police themselves.
GeneWPennsylvania · Nov 16, 2008#53
Originally Posted by stuffy ↑
a company that makes cakes does not get their raw material (let's say flour) for free because it's useless without them to make something edible out of it.
If they raised their own wheat and ground it into flour would they owe the local government money because the wheat grew out of the land? How about the people in the local area, since it's on "their" land?

It's not the much of a difference... raising wheat requires land. So does mining tar sands.

Why does the farmer not pay by the bushel for raising corn or wheat but the oil company pays for mining tar sand? Maybe because there is enough money being made to "justify" the reasoning?


Originally Posted by stuffy ↑
but the government got themselves into this trouble by deregulating the banking industry. the only reason why canada's banks are in such good shape compare to those in the u.s. and europe was that our government resisted deregulating the banking sector in the mid 90's.

as far as i'm concerned, industry has proven that they cannot police themselves.
First of all, it was the US Mortgage industry that got into trouble, not the banks.

The cause of all of this was when two US agencies that loan money for mortgages, Fannie Mae and Freddy Mac, were told to loan money to minorities in order to curb "unfair lending practices". This was done by the Clinton Administration in the 1990s.

For the Reader's digest version go here

http://www.lewrockwell.com/suprynowi...ynowicz95.html

The original New York Times Article about the disaster, nine years before it happened, go here...

link

In moving, even tentatively, into this new area of lending, Fannie Mae is taking on significantly more risk, which may not pose any difficulties during flush economic times. But the government-subsidized corporation may run into trouble in an economic downturn, prompting a government rescue similar to that of the savings and loan industry in the 1980's.

''From the perspective of many people, including me, this is another thrift industry growing up around us,'' said Peter Wallison a resident fellow at the American Enterprise Institute. ''If they fail, the government will have to step up and bail them out the way it stepped up and bailed out the thrift industry.''
Canada didn't play this shit and hence isn't in the shit today.

For a very long time Fannie Mae and Freddy Mac have also "bundled" securities. Much longer than the current period. Fannie Mae certificates were rock solid investments, before it became fashionable to Social Engineer via the Banks.

The US Mortgage Industry "followed" suit, a safe thing to do. Too bad that a few bad actors really did entice a few dummies to sign on the dotted line, because their over reach and foolishness is going to hurt an industry which has done nothing wrong except blindly follow the two leaders- Freddy Mac and Fannie Mae.

The people who deserve punishment are Bill Clinton, Andrew Cuomo, and both Dems and Reps who watched this train wreck and sat on their hands because they figured that the Housing Market was a "measure of prosperity".

Gene
jclo3313Woodstock, Ga · Nov 16, 2008#54
Gene,
What is the third letter in your name?
ShroomsterOrlando · Nov 17, 2008#55
Originally Posted by jclo3313 ↑
Gene,
What is the third letter in your name?
????
GeneWPennsylvania · Nov 17, 2008#56
Originally Posted by jclo3313 ↑
Gene,
What is the third letter in your name?
You can count. Right?

Gene
Bob_VTVermont · Nov 17, 2008#57
Originally Posted by SailDesign ↑
I call 🙄
ford Europe has a higher (yup!) labour cost, and they keep up very well with the European and Japanese "small fuel efficient" markets. They just choose not to import the smaller cars and their technology here.... Look at the Ford Focus diesel that just came out - Ford won't import it because "Americans view diesel as a dirty fuel"
🙄
Ford had a diesel Escort here in the USA (one upon a time!) and it was a failure.....🙄
stevedNear Montreal, Quebec, Canada · Nov 17, 2008#58
I would give the bailout money to them only if they used it to make new technology, such as hybrid cars and selling them at the same price of current non-hybrid cars, and push to create all electric cars.

Governments should abolish the Unions. This way non-working paid employees in the job banks can be fired, cut the salaries of the way over paid employees. All the heads and management should get a massive pay cuts, no more bonuses. In other words cut out all the fat.
SailDesign. · Nov 17, 2008#59
Originally Posted by Bob_VT ↑
Ford had a diesel Escort here in the USA (one upon a time!) and it was a failure.....🙄
Waaaay back then, I'm sure it was. No-one cared much abouyt saving fuel over here. And to be honest the US Escort bodies were frikkin' HIDEOUS compared to the UK versions.
jkuchtaL.A. · Nov 17, 2008#60
Anyone who says a diesel car is slow hasen't been in one in the last 5 years. I rented a 307 hatch last time I was in Europe (2004), and didn't know it was a diesel till I had to fill it up. The thing was quick, accelerated really well, had tones of torque, and didn't sound like a diesel. If I could buy a diesel Yaris (or even the focus) I'd have one right now!
PetersRedYarisThe Black Hills of South Dakota · Nov 17, 2008#61
Originally Posted by SailDesign ↑
I call 🙄
ford Europe has a higher (yup!) labour cost, and they keep up very well with the European and Japanese "small fuel efficient" markets. They just choose not to import the smaller cars and their technology here.... Look at the Ford Focus diesel that just came out - Ford won't import it because "Americans view diesel as a dirty fuel"
🙄
Actually, their main reason is production cost. The diesel engine is built in England where labor costs are very high. They claim if they were to sell the car in the US it would be priced over $25,000 (more than a Prius). And if they built a plant in Mexico to build the engine there (where our Fiesta's will be built) they would have to sell 350,000 engines/year to cover the cost which they claim isn't realistic. I claim BS on that... No wonder Ford is going down with the other big 2, stupid decisions one after the other.

Heres the article- http://articles.moneycentral.msn.com...ell-in-us.aspx
TLyttleKeremeos BC · Nov 17, 2008#62
Abolish the unions? Sure, go right ahead, put labour back 130 years, back to 14-hour work days (6 1/2 of 'em), your house is owned by the Company, and you buy your meagre groceries at the Company store, hell of a fine idea! Andrew Carnegie lives! He made so much money off the worker he had to put together a corporation to get rid of it. I'm all for that, alright...

If Management was fair, there would be no reason for unions.

BTW, just heard on the news: a long-term employee of GM said that, 25 years ago, there was one supervisor for every 120 workers, now it is one supervisor for every 18 workers. Gee, could that be the problem???
Bob_VTVermont · Nov 17, 2008#63
Listened to a talk show on NPR and it was an interview with the UAW President...... according to him .......... GM Ford and Chrysler are all pointing at the UAW for the high prices...... the UAW has the view that they have been saving the economy....... I nearly ran off the road while laughing. The UAW said that the big 3 are "owed" the bailout money!

This..... he said...... they said...... she said ........ is all BS
SailDesign. · Nov 18, 2008#64
Doesn't really matter WHOSE fault it is (this is called "BlameStorming", IIRC), the thing is that they do not deserve the bailout. Period.
bobbyNortheast · Nov 18, 2008#65
American cars are HORRIBLE. I would be embarrassed to be seen driving one. Ugh! 👎
SailDesign. · Nov 18, 2008#67
Quote of the day from the Senate hearings:

"Survival of the auto companies is imperative for America to remain the global leader in innovation," said Sen. Charles Schumer, D-N.Y. "We should not drop out of the race before we have a chance to compete."

Hah! Where TF has HE been hiding these last 20 years or so? There is no innovation in Detroit at present, and the US auto industry has been "competing" longer than any other country.
Bob_VTVermont · Nov 18, 2008#68
Originally Posted by bobby ↑
American cars are HORRIBLE. I would be embarrassed to be seen driving one. Ugh! 👎
Remember that when you need a policeman in NYC...... they drive American cars...... the ambulances are American too.......😳
KCALB SIRAYVirginia · Nov 18, 2008#69
Originally Posted by bobby ↑
American cars are HORRIBLE. I would be embarrassed to be seen driving one. Ugh! 👎
I'd be embarrassesd to be seen with you in an American city. Hey, I hear Canada is giving people a rebate of $1,000 for owning a Fit and living there... go get it😁
Bob_VTVermont · Nov 18, 2008#70
Picture not included in this copy
TinyGiantRochester, NH · Nov 18, 2008#71
Free Market Economy.. let them be responsible for their own issues.. start making electric cars cheap and get the consumers rushing to the door to buy new cars.. get creative or get out!
anonymous userwindward oahu · Nov 18, 2008#72
Originally Posted by SailDesign ↑
I think if we keep bailing them out, they will keep producing cars that the American public don't want.
For those who still want to argue that we DO want these vehicles, I ask them to explain why GM is giong broke if their cars are so great..... It ain't rocket science!
Do you want to know why the automakers are going broke? There are people out there who had their factory close down 5-10+ years ago. They keep getting paid by going in to a building at collecting a check, as long as they stay in this room and read, do whatever for 8 hrs, then go home. It's bullcrap, but it's America's heartland at it's best.
anonymous userwindward oahu · Nov 18, 2008#73
You know, sometimes it's hard being the worlds top economic powerhouse year in and year out. I mean we bailout all these countries in their times of need.
But when we need it, very few nations can help us, monetarily at least.
Well, when the dollar is worth jack squat, i hope we can still all go on vacation and buy a $10 ice cream cone, or a $10 cup of starbucks coffee.
GeneWPennsylvania · Nov 19, 2008#74
Originally Posted by TLyttle ↑
Abolish the unions? Sure, go right ahead, put labour back 130 years, back to 14-hour work days (6 1/2 of 'em), your house is owned by the Company, and you buy your meagre groceries at the Company store, hell of a fine idea! Andrew Carnegie lives! He made so much money off the worker he had to put together a corporation to get rid of it. I'm all for that, alright...
Kind of doubt it, especially in western Countries. In the US, at least, Union workers do not necessarily make more money than non-Union workers in the same field. They also don't necessarily enjoy more job security.

Might interest you to know that Carnegie had to import workers from Central and Eastern Europe. Native born Americans refused to work in his mills. Probably because they were unsafe and because of the "turns system", where you showed up for work every twelve hours and if the Foreman liked you he let you work for a turn.


Originally Posted by TLyttle ↑
If Management was fair, there would be no reason for unions.
Unions, no doubt, are great bogeymen for the average worker. Each time that my employer was almost organized they ended up giving the Rank 'n File either more vacation days or better wages.

Originally Posted by TLyttle ↑
BTW, just heard on the news: a long-term employee of GM said that, 25 years ago, there was one supervisor for every 120 workers, now it is one supervisor for every 18 workers. Gee, could that be the problem???
You know, every business I ever heard of that was in distress hired more bosses. I don't know why - whether they expected a Strike or needed to "motivate" Staff or what it was the number of bosses increased. I saw this at my first job out of school, where the number of bosses were doubled. Six months later they shut down production. I also heard about this at one other manufacturing firm, they hired more "suits" and then a year later folded up.

I've heard a rumor that they're gonna do this where I work now.... uh oh!

The weird part about GM and their boss head count is that a lot of "Supervisory" tasks have been heavily automated out of existence by MIS and ERP systems. Paper pushers, for the most part. My first job out of school wouldn't exist today because your average Secretary with a bit of Visual Basic could have replaced me.

What are they doing there? Probably on the payroll in case of a strike or because of some silly re-organization or maybe because of the Effect I mentioned before.

Another reason, which is kind of sinister, is that GM may be abusing them by using their salary status to milk more hours out of them, while not treating them like Exempt employees. I saw this trick at my first job. The net result was that the "Bosses" got used for Fill In positions and because they were overworked made dumb decisions that gummed up the works.

When things are going to hell that's when you have to think the most and be the most deliberate. Panic will kill you.

Gene
GeneWPennsylvania · Nov 19, 2008#75
Originally Posted by Thirty-Nine ↑
I have nothing against American cars by any means. I KNOW America can build a decent car, but I think old-school thinking and poor management are contributing factors as to the poor choices that the Big Three have made as far as car production goes.
We always were a bit childish in America. Too trusting, too naive and too self absorbed. Guys like Henry Ford made a mint off of us. So did William Crapo Durant, the founder of GM. Ford once sent agents to go to junk yards and discover parts that were "too good". When he found out that Kingpins (a predecessor of the ball joint) on Ford cars were not wearing out he had them "cheapened up".

In my opinion Detroit started to accelerate down the bad path after the Tax Reform Act of 1986. The interest income deduction for car loans was repealed. For some it now made more seen to lease a car than to buy one.

Management, being opportunistic, decided to re-frame an Automobile from being a physical good to being a service. This encouraged more people to lease rather than purchase. Images of the Lease "experience" was what got advertised rather than this expensive, durable and concrete thing known as an automobile. Blonde girls with big boobs instead of technology and resale value, excitement instead of thrift and you can get a better one tomorrow.

Detroit engineered cars to be tougher for the average Mechanic to work on so that the Dealers would get the Lion's share of service. They first wanted them to be easier to make but they also made them so that mechanics would need special tools to do the work economically. They put easily worn out and broken shit in bizarre places.

Lesees would take the Company's car to the garage for its mandatory service, pay for the car by the mile, and once the term was up they'd lease another newer car. The Company took care of you, for a hefty fee.

If the car was a piece of crap you'd lease a newer one. If it was really bad the Dealer would replace it, sorta.

There was also this idiotic thing called "Planned Obsolescence". The Product was built to slowly disintegrate so that you'd HAVE to buy a new one. This concept is so against the idea of the Customer being in the driver's seat that it's not funny. Ford and his kingpins became the whole damn thing nickel and dimeing you at 200,000 miles so you had to buy another car - or if you leased you never saw this horror show.

The Japanese and Koreans kept to the old model. A car was an expensive purchase. You bought and kept it. So it had to be of good quality and the better the quality the more customer satisfaction that came from it. Japan was selling to the world and most of the world is too poor to buy cheap goods. Japanese were very poor after the war ended and understood how hard it was to earn enough to buy a car. So did the Koreans. When Japanese got rich they remembered the climb up and how it felt to buy good products that honored their hard work.

American manufacturers were selling to Americans, who were wealthy and did not have to be shrewd and careful with their money. We haven't seen hard times since the Great Depression and haven't had a war here since 1865. We've had it very easy and the world is an easy place.

There was no tomorrow, only today and it's all new and shiny.

Tomorrow finally came.

I know that there are other causes and reasons but these are what come to me right now.


Originally Posted by Thirty-Nine ↑
As far as bail out, I'm afraid that not bailing them out will be worse than bailing them out. I lost my job last week, and I was in the auto industry (I worked for a supplier of Ford among other aftermarket parts). If it's bad now, a collapse of the Big Three would (could) be catastrophic.
Sorry to hear that you were laid off. Keep busy and don't treat this as a vacation. I did back in the early 1990s and regret doing so to this day.

I was laid off in 2006. I had a new job two months later. I don't live in a wealthy part of the US, I'm over forty and I have a pretty diverse job history. So this was pretty damn quick. Motivation and a desire not to repeat the mistakes of the past where what drove me.

Good luck to you.

Gene