Yarisworld Archive

excessive sulfur odor on 2007 model year Yaris

115 posts · 45,484 views · page 2 of 3

Replies continued

yuiedieCA · Apr 20, 2007#51
ive been experiencing a very strong "odor" that occasionally creeps up when changing the ac from hot/warm to cold/cool. In the morning its cold so i turn up the heat, and in the afternoon it gets hot, so i turn up the ac to cold. i figured that was what was causing the weird smell. kinda like coolant. once in a while a distinct sour smell but only sometimes, and this happens when starting the car up during warm weather with the ac on (cold).
IsLNdbOiLas Vegas, NV · Apr 20, 2007#52
I've had this problem since I got my LB back at the end of August. Some mornings when I startup and when I get on the highway, it gets really bad.

How long does it take them to change the part?
mygfdrivesayarisWest Des Moines, IA · Apr 20, 2007#53
This sulfur smell is caused by the honeycomb like material inside the catalytic converter getting too hot - this is usually caused by driving and economy car like a race car - ease up turbo and the smell will go away, otherwise drive fast and enjoy the fragrance. ALSO - For the guy who asked on page 3 - Your low fuel light starts to blink when it is about 9.5 gallons low so the mileage should be closer to 31.58 MPG - that being said you can technically go 47.36 more miles after that light comes on, but i would fill up instead.
jetaimejscBville, TN · Apr 20, 2007#54
i just got my yaris like 1month & 1/2 and everytime my girlfriend gets in she always complains abou the smell, shes like "man, it stinks in here" but when she says that i assure you i did not fart, maybe i did but i doubt it, but i got allergies year round, so i cant even smell my upper lip, can ya explain to me what it kind of smells like, and should i get it checked, once a while i can smell something and it stinks pretty bad after like i went pretty fast
the_bossMontreal Qc · Apr 20, 2007#55
I smell a little but I can't say if it's the car or the paper mill...😕 will have the car check just in case!
ChinoCharlesOH · Apr 20, 2007#56
There is no reason not to go in and have this change made on your vehicle. There is obviously a problem with the stock setup, as Toyota wouldn't bother putting out a TSB on the issue if they didn't see the need to fix things. In short, don't ask questions or wait to smell anything. Just go into the dealership and say I want my catalytic converter swapped out for the updated model according to TSB EG035-06. Your dealership might even be impressed that you pay such close attention! Note: This is for liftbacks only.
the_bossMontreal Qc · Apr 20, 2007#57
any one know if it's US model, North American model or?
I just remember my old echo (2001..) was smelling like sulfur🤷 maybe there where an issue with those model too
IsLNdbOiLas Vegas, NV · Apr 20, 2007#58
How long does it take them to make this change? Couple of hours?
YamilRSan Diego, CA · Apr 20, 2007#59
Originally Posted by IsLNdbOi ↑
How long does it take them to make this change? Couple of hours?
45 min. on mine
jousleeRowland Heights, CA · Apr 20, 2007#60
does it matter which dealership i goto or do i need to go to the dealership that i bought my car from?
IsLNdbOiLas Vegas, NV · Apr 20, 2007#61
I just called my dealer and they said I have to leave my car there for at least 3 hours so they can find out what is causing the sulfur odor. I told them I had a printout of the TSB, but they said just because there is a TSB it doesn't mean that the odor is not caused by something else.
ChinoCharlesOH · Apr 20, 2007#62
Originally Posted by IsLNdbOi ↑
I just called my dealer and they said I have to leave my car there for at least 3 hours so they can find out what is causing the sulfur odor. I told them I had a printout of the TSB, but they said just because there is a TSB it doesn't mean that the odor is not caused by something else.
Don't all dealers honor Toyota's standard warranty? If you're in it you should be able to go to any dealership you want until you find one that will change it without being dicks about it. My dealership did it no questions asked, as they all ought to.
BMGYarisSouth Carolina, USA · Apr 20, 2007#63
Yea, if yo usay that you smelled sulfur during heavy acceleration then they cant really say "no you didnt" also there is no way to prove that it wasnt the catalytic converter that did it. Thus it would surely fall under the "specific complaint" category and if you ask them to change it then they really can not deny you right? regardless of what they may think caused it. Unless they can prove it didnt:) can they do that?

Also, will this improve heat flow? I found over the winter that the heat sucks. They are so far away that by the time the actual flow of air hits me its not warm. That means in the winter I cant drive with my windows down and heat on full and stay warm:) which i love to do
JerkrattFair Lawn, NJ · May 21, 2007#64
you know my mom used to have an 01 camry.. and it had this problem and everytime i went and asked about this smell they said it could eb the type of gas im putting in. needless to say i know it was not but anyway im going to see if i can get this done
IsLNdbOiLas Vegas, NV · May 21, 2007#65
I finally brought mine in today for this. They're going to keep my Yaris at least overnight. They had to order the part(s).
the_bossMontreal Qc · May 24, 2007#66
just called my dealer...they said the don't check tech service bulletin untill they have a complaint😲
I guess Ill take care of the maintnance by myself😢
ShroomsterOrlando · Jun 3, 2007#67
so this tsb is still relevant for those of us with a lb produced after january of 2007?
IsLNdbOiLas Vegas, NV · Jun 3, 2007#68
It's been almost two weeks since I brought mine in for this. The sulfur smell is gone, but now there's this really strong smell that's similar to a chemical cleanser. Not sure what it is, but it only happens in the morning when I first start up or the first time I get on the highway on a day.
SabretoothSt Cloud FL · Jun 3, 2007#69
Will the dealership have a fit if you have modded your Yaris? Example: CAI?
Dont know if they will honor the TSB, seeing that it effects a complete opposite end of the car, but in-advertantly is effected by it. More in = more needing to go out?
YamilRSan Diego, CA · Jun 3, 2007#70
Originally Posted by IsLNdbOi ↑
It's been almost two weeks since I brought mine in for this. The sulfur smell is gone, but now there's this really strong smell that's similar to a chemical cleanser. Not sure what it is, but it only happens in the morning when I first start up or the first time I get on the highway on a day.
Is that smell comes when you turn the A/C on? I had a bad smell after I changed my cat and took it to the dealer, they said it was mold on the a/c ducts, they put some kind of foam cleanser and it worked pretty good
JerkrattFair Lawn, NJ · Jun 3, 2007#71
Originally Posted by Sabretooth ↑
Will the dealership have a fit if you have modded your Yaris? Example: CAI?
Dont know if they will honor the TSB, seeing that it effects a complete opposite end of the car, but in-advertantly is effected by it. More in = more needing to go out?
+1
the_bossMontreal Qc · Jun 4, 2007#72
had mine done today...30 minutes.....0$👍
ToyotechOak Ridge, NJ · Jun 4, 2007#73
Originally Posted by Jerkratt ↑
+1
they won't have a fit... the only issue they may have if your throwing a P0171 lean code with the intake and its due to an incorrect install. if its a good dealer...they will never even take it into consideration
squibbyNorCAL · Jun 5, 2007#74
hey i've been reading a lot on these forums and do also get the sulfur smell in my car. I took it in today and complained about it, but the dealership said that Toyota dosen't honor the tsb in California anymore because of something in the gas. Is this true? Has anyone recently gotten theirs changed in CA?
jliftLos Angeles, CA · Jun 5, 2007#75
Originally Posted by squibby ↑
hey i've been reading a lot on these forums and do also get the sulfur smell in my car. I took it in today and complained about it, but the dealership said that Toyota dosen't honor the tsb in California anymore because of something in the gas. Is this true? Has anyone recently gotten theirs changed in CA?
Have not heard this yet. Sounds pretty suspicious. Which dealer? Where/how did he get this info? Ask to see it in writing. Calll Toyota Corporate. At this point I would not believe him. Possibly Toyota is losing $$ on this big time and now doing an about face and "blaming" it on the gas addititives?
squibbyNorCAL · Jun 5, 2007#76
It was at Elk Grove Toyota up near Sac. He said they got an email from Toyota saying not to change anymore cats for the sulfur smell. I thought it was strange too, but the service manager wasn't in yet so I just got his number and left. I've already emailed Toyota, but I'll call Toyota Corp after work if I don't get a response by then.
jliftLos Angeles, CA · Jun 5, 2007#77
Originally Posted by squibby ↑
It was at Elk Grove Toyota up near Sac. He said they got an email from Toyota saying not to change anymore cats for the sulfur smell. I thought it was strange too, but the service manager wasn't in yet so I just got his number and left. I've already emailed Toyota, but I'll call Toyota Corp after work if I don't get a response by then.
I was very interested in this and had a few minutes so I called Toyota Corporate. They researched it for me and assured me that they are still replacing catalytic converters as stated in TSB EG035-06 (Revised). Your dealer who told you that he received an email from Toyota stating not to change it is probably making that up. I would go with what Toyota says. You can call for yourself. If in fact the dealer is being less than honest with you, I would raise some hell and let his "bosses" know about it. Good luck!
mushrmboyCalifornia · Jun 5, 2007#78
does this apply to recently purchased yarii too? i just got mine 2 weeks ago and i'm wondering if they would have replaced the part on their own by now. and how bad is the smell? so far i haven't been able to smell anything, but i haven't been in any real stop and go traffic yet. 🤷
squibbyNorCAL · Jun 5, 2007#79
Originally Posted by mushrmboy ↑
does this apply to recently purchased yarii too? i just got mine 2 weeks ago and i'm wondering if they would have replaced the part on their own by now. and how bad is the smell? so far i haven't been able to smell anything, but i haven't been in any real stop and go traffic yet. 🤷
I'm pretty sure it applies to new ones because I just got my yaris about a month or so ago and it's got the problem.

It smells really bad like rotten eggs. I don't even think you need to be in real bad stop and go traffic for it to happen. The first time I noticed the smell was after driving back to Sac from SF with pretty light traffic. I started my car after dropping off my brother and it was rotten egg smell all over.
squibbyNorCAL · Jun 5, 2007#80
Originally Posted by jlift ↑
I was very interested in this and had a few minutes so I called Toyota Corporate. They researched it for me and assured me that they are still replacing catalytic converters as stated in TSB EG035-06 (Revised). Your dealer who told you that he received an email from Toyota stating not to change it is probably making that up. I would go with what Toyota says. You can call for yourself. If in fact the dealer is being less than honest with you, I would raise some hell and let his "bosses" know about it. Good luck!
Thanks jlift. I'm going back there tomorrow to let them know I've talked to Toyota Corporate and got confirmation that the TSB is still in effect. If they still won't change it, then I'll be raising hell with the managers. 😈
jliftLos Angeles, CA · Jun 5, 2007#81
Originally Posted by mushrmboy ↑
does this apply to recently purchased yarii too? i just got mine 2 weeks ago and i'm wondering if they would have replaced the part on their own by now. and how bad is the smell? so far i haven't been able to smell anything, but i haven't been in any real stop and go traffic yet. 🤷
Yes. They are actually NOT putting the replacement Cat. on newly manufactured Yarii as they roll out of the factory. But, if you are aware of the TSB and print it out and take it in to them (you'll find it in a .pdf at the beginning of this thread), then they must honor it. Only if you are aware of it and ask for it, then they will replace it. I think that Toyota is trying to be "cost effective" here. i.e., what you don't know won't hurt you. (believe me, a majority of car owners do not know about these technical service bulletins!) It's best to have a copy of the TSB so that they can't say, "well, maybe you got some bad gas or are smelling something else" or something else like that. When I got my work done, I went in with a stack of 4 TSB's! The service rep. told me that I was not his "average" customer.👍
hans_fhUtah · Jun 5, 2007#82
Okay. The sedan doesn't have this problem, right?
jliftLos Angeles, CA · Jun 5, 2007#83
Originally Posted by hans_fh ↑
Okay. The sedan doesn't have this problem, right?
No. The TSB states:

"TSB REVISION NOTICE: August 4, 2006. This TSB applies ONLY to Yaris liftback models."


So we are talking about the liftback here. Sorry for any confusion. The TSB's state exactly which models are affected on any specific upgrade. Which begs the question, "why are the sedans unaffected? Perhaps they have the newer part on them?" hmmmmm....
hans_fhUtah · Jun 5, 2007#84
Originally Posted by jlift ↑
No. The TSB states:

"TSB REVISION NOTICE: August 4, 2006. This TSB applies ONLY to Yaris liftback models."


So we are talking about the liftback here. Sorry for any confusion. The TSB's state exactly which models are affected on any specific upgrade. Which begs the question, "why are the sedans unaffected? Perhaps they have the newer part on them?" hmmmmm....
Thanks a lot! It seems there is no any TSB talks about Yaris Sedan except the Rattle in Reverse. Am I right?
jliftLos Angeles, CA · Jun 5, 2007#85
Originally Posted by hans_fh ↑
Thanks a lot! It seems there is no any TSB talks about Yaris Sedan except the Rattle in Reverse. Am I right?

Well, there is TSB NV009-06 which deals with Upper/lower windshield tick noise which I posted on this forum.
But this applies to 2003-2007 model year Toyota vehicles and 2004-2007 Scion so I think that the 07 sedan would be included.

That's about the only other one I am aware of that would be for the Sedan. Search on "TSB" on this forum and you will find it. The dealer will let you know what specific TSB's are out there for your car if you ask him. It might be worthwhile thing to do next time you are there. You could also search on a website that has them for a fee and you can get the TSB numbers as a reference. I think that tundrasolutions.com/forums will let you see all the way up to the title of the TSB, in their knowledge base in the yaris forum.
eTiMaGoBangkok, Thailand · Aug 9, 2007#86
As for the cause of this bad smell, I though I had posted thins before, but this is what I noticed, as I have a basic AFR (air-fuel ratio) meter.

When you drive normally, the ECU keeps the AFR oscillating around the standard 14.7:1, going lean-rich-lean-rich... This, apparently, is to enhance the efficiency of the catalyser.

But, when you step on it, the ECU seems to make the AFR very rich, I've seen it go up to 11:1, and stay there, which is a lot of fuel, a lot of which will go unburned, and this seems to mess with the stock catalyser, hence causing this smell. The theory behind this extra fuel is that it will help in keeping the engine cool and prevent detonation, as would be done when you have a turbo, so it's really a safety measure for engine longevity.

I guess the new catalyser is better able to contain or process this extra fuel so that it does not cause the stink...

I don't know if this TSB is also available here, never bothered to check... I just let off the accelerator a little when I see this extra-rich AFR...
death is my giftdallas · Aug 9, 2007#87
I am having the same problem (didn't know this thread existed cuz i'm a dumbass). I just called the services department of my dealer. I specifically said, "excessive sulfur odor" and right away the dude said, "Bring it in tomorrow so we can have a look at it." I didn't say I had a print out of the TSB so I'm sort of curious on how they will handle this. If they give me ANY crap I'm going to whip out the print out and be all, "SUCKAH!"

So, I'll let you guys know.
sherryberryIllinois · Aug 9, 2007#88
i think there is a strange sulfur smell on mine but i don't sniff sulfur on a regular basis so cannot be completely sure. Just that there is a strange smell. so do I just go to the dealer to fix this?
eTiMaGoBangkok, Thailand · Aug 9, 2007#89
Originally Posted by sherryberry ↑
i think there is a strange sulfur smell on mine but i don't sniff sulfur on a regular basis so cannot be completely sure. Just that there is a strange smell. so do I just go to the dealer to fix this?
no, you stop eating so many baked beans and prunes...

😆
ChristopherCleveland, OH. · Aug 9, 2007#90
'07 Hatch here. No smells, 36-38mpg driving 50/50 highway/city (well over posted limits-lol) with the A/C pumping. So far so good. About 7 months old and 5100 miles on it. Chris
azncharmMO, USA · Aug 12, 2007#91
Went to the dealer last month with TSB print-out and they ordered the part. No questions asked. Called me back after a week and replaced the catalytic converter in less than an hour. However, I can still smell it sometimes. Less often than usual but it still happens. Before, it usually occurs in the first 3 minutes when I start the car. Now it smells less often and when Im about 10 minutes driving. Still observing. If it doesn't go away completely I will go back to my dealer.
death is my giftdallas · Aug 12, 2007#92
So I went to the dealer and dude crawled under my car and said it was a plastic bag that had melted to my whatever-it's-called. I didn't believe him so I crawled under there with him and told him to show it to me. Sure enough, he was able to scrap a bit of it off with his ink pen. I asked him what I should do and he said either let it burn off by itself or take it to a "car wash" to have them scrap it off for me.

I then showed him the printed out TSB and he said that wasn't on "all" 2007 Liftbacks, just some. I told him I wanted it changed anyway and he said they could evaluate it (whatever that means) and if they don't find a reason to change it they would charge me 70 bucks for the evaluation. But, if they did find a cause to change it they would do it for free. I told him I would wait and see if the smell went away.

What do you guys think? Are they obligated to change it even though he said, "Not all '07 Liftbacks were affected?"
JerkrattFair Lawn, NJ · Aug 12, 2007#93
get a car wash and have them clean it then go to a diff dealership they will do what ever they can to not do the tsb cause they lose money. there "eval" is bs but thats just me.. id say if u lived closer i can get one of my friends at the dealer by me to just be like yeah blah blah blah and order the part but ur kinda far
YamilRSan Diego, CA · Aug 12, 2007#94
Originally Posted by death is my gift ↑
So I went to the dealer and dude crawled under my car and said it was a plastic bag that had melted to my whatever-it's-called. I didn't believe him so I crawled under there with him and told him to show it to me. Sure enough, he was able to scrap a bit of it off with his ink pen. I asked him what I should do and he said either let it burn off by itself or take it to a "car wash" to have them scrap it off for me.

I then showed him the printed out TSB and he said that wasn't on "all" 2007 Liftbacks, just some. I told him I wanted it changed anyway and he said they could evaluate it (whatever that means) and if they don't find a reason to change it they would charge me 70 bucks for the evaluation. But, if they did find a cause to change it they would do it for free. I told him I would wait and see if the smell went away.

What do you guys think? Are they obligated to change it even though he said, "Not all '07 Liftbacks were affected?"
Yeah, that sounds like a BS excuse. The TSB says Liftback, NOT some of them
xerophinityGTA (Whitby) · Aug 20, 2007#95
Oh man, where would I be without this forum. I was in a crash in my friends Honda once, and it's the same smell as when the Airbags deployed. At least now I have a chance to make it go away, hopefully Whitby Toyota aren't dicks and they won't try to jerk me around.

edit: Okay so I gave Toyota Canada a call and they want me to take it into the dealer to take a look at it first. I have a feeling I'm going to get inroduced to that evaluaton fee you guys were talking about... Here I was hoping for just a take-it-in-have-it-replaced-no-questions-asked kinda deal, but I guess they're just not going to let this go without a fight.
Pavel OlavichOrange County, Calif · Aug 20, 2007#96
Strong Sulfur smell?

Eat. More. Fiber.
pennyracergrants pass · Mar 1, 2009#97
i had mine replaced 6 months ago left the dealed got it on the fhy wide open still smells like shit and toyota says there is no problem this has had the bad smell from day one mine is a 08 model year but built in 07 im lost on what to do next ? from what i have heard is the smell comes from the cat when its working not when its not working they say that the car is dumping to much fuel in the motor i need the ecu reflashed with some changes but toyota does not have a program for the 07 model year anyone have the true info on this matter
detroiterMetro Detroit · Mar 1, 2009#98
Don't feel bad. Mine does the same thing when I nail the gas at wide open. Mine is an 08 LB that's white colored too :)

The dealer pretty much told me the same as they did to you, that it's just all the extra fuel being dumped in running rich, then burning off. Told me that it's a "Toyota smell".
I guess I can see where there coming from, kind of like how Fords at WOT smells like eggs and fruit punch lol.
silver_echoSpokane, WA · Mar 1, 2009#99
what i noticed when i had my 01 on the dyno is that the factory fuel map makes it too rich at WOT... i get the same smell as well...
pennyracergrants pass · Mar 2, 2009#100
thats wild the same problem did you get your cat replaced detroiter
? my concern about this one am i getting worse gas millage then normall ? if so its costing me extra money witch would be b.s. in my book 2nd thing is this going to lead to major build up on the valves and plugs down the road ? yes toyota was zero help on this deal wish i could get some answers someware