AlexKOriginal postSparks, NV, USA · Jul 29, 2006#1Even though on paper the Versa is the clear winner (in terms of what you get for the money), I chose the Yaris sedan. Here is why:
The Fit was very nice but it is impossible to get a manual transmission. The dealers said there are no more 2007 manuals available. The auto version was very slow off the line and not fun. The rear seats of the FIT are awesome but since I also have a pickup I won't be hauling huge loads with my commuter car. Also it has a timing belt instead of a chain which is like a little bomb waiting to go off at the worst possible moment (maybe I exaggerate a little here).
The Versa CVT SL (continuously variable transmission) model I drove was very nice. It was also slow off the line but once revved it accelerated very nicely. Too bad the price was $16900 for that model! The 6 speed manual was $13900 so I drove that one also. With a 6 speed transmission I was expecting a low first gear and a high 6th gear. Wrong on both counts! First gear is very high, and also the engine has very little low rpm torque (our Yaris engines are so much better in that dept). In 6th gear at 3000 rpm the Versa was doing 66 mph. My Toyota Tacoma truck is higher geared than that in 4th gear! Also the shifter was clunky feeling with obvious vibration from the engine. It made a hollow sounding noise with each shift. I work for a supplier for Nissan and could have gotten the car at below invoice price, but it still wasn't worth it. It is a POS in my opinion. It's such a shame too because it comes so well equipped and reasonably priced too (for the S trim level anyway).
The Yaris comes with few standard features but it felt like the smoothest, highest quality vehicle of the three makes I tried. The manual transmission and clutch are perfect. I do hate the annoying throttle-by-wire which causes the engine to rev up between shifts if I don't let off the gas a second earlier than I'm used to, but the Nissan Versa did that also (and I assume the manual Fit does the same). The ride quality is better than the Fit's and equal to the Versa's. The resale value of a Toyota is better than Nissan. The Yaris body also looks better than the Versa's.
I ended up buying a 5 speed manual Yaris Sedan in green. No options except tinted windows, bumper protector, and floor mats (not even a radio!). Interior color is black. The dealer knocked $300 off the MSRP for me, price was $12800 before tax.
I already ordered a in-dash DVD/MP3 player so I won't be without tunes for long. So far I've logged 200 miles and it's great! I bet I'm one of the few Yaris buyers who will be getting worse gas mileage than in their last car ('92 Geo Metro - I got 47 city, 52 hwy).
Replies 48
riceboyCAN · Jul 29, 2006#2LOL.. those Geo Metro's did take mileage to the limit...
tomjaszLost Wages · Jul 29, 2006#3😈 😈 😈 and in Nevada conditions to boot!!😈 😈 😈
TRD_YarisAustin, Texas · Jul 29, 2006#4"annoying throttle-by-wire which causes the engine to rev up between shifts if I don't let off the gas a second earlier than I'm used to"
word.. i hate HEARING the engine rev up JUST A BIT when i pop the clutch..it sucks for rev-matching since you must wait an extra couple .1's of a second 😠 😠
Good comparison. i haven't had the opportunity to drive the Versa, yet, but you couldn't have described the Fit and yaris better!
and, btw..why the hell isn't the yaris getting better gas mileage than a Geo Metro????!!! heck, civic CX/VX's (92-95 base models, one having longer gearing AND a rear diffuser under the rear bumper that helps gas mileage by about 2-4 on the highway!!!) got 35-40 MPG and they didn't weight much less and ALSO had 1.5L motors!!! they were a bit slower, but not by much..especially not 15 years of technology and an extra $5000 difference..
tomjaszLost Wages · Jul 30, 2006#5[QUOTE=TRD_Yaris]"annoying throttle-by-wire which causes the engine to rev up between shifts if I don't let off the gas a second earlier than I'm used to"
How does throttle by wire work?🤷
My layman's understanding is that unlike the mechanical system with a cable linking between the pedal and the throttle, the electrical system (by wire) uses the pedal as a controlling switch to send signals to a servo which opens or closes the throttle which controls the supply of fuel to the engine.
There is inevitably some over simplification in what I have said, of course.
ECHOKnight2000Minnesota, US of A! · Jul 30, 2006#7Congrats AlexK! You made the right choice! Hope you have many years of happy motoring!👍
Chaad32USA · Jul 30, 2006#8Congradulations.....you made the right choice. You will not regret it.
HenshinNorthern Virginia · Jul 30, 2006#9is it just me, or is the agreed upon "enemy" of the Yaris the FIT? or is this something we all know, but never mention???
when I see one on the road I feel such emnity for it, as if it has less of a right to be on the road and should make room for my Yaris.
I'm like... "Fit, GO! Get outta here! This is Yaris territory!"
when I was searching for my Yaris, I rememeber going to a dealer and seeing a Fit across from the Toyota dealer and thinking, "I could always just get a Fit... but... ewwwww. I don't want to be that type of guy."
Andrew ChalmersNA · Jul 31, 2006#10 Originally Posted by Henshin
is it just me, or is the agreed upon "enemy" of the Yaris the FIT? or is this something we all know, but never mention???
when I see one on the road I feel such emnity for it, as if it has less of a right to be on the road and should make room for my Yaris.
I'm like... "Fit, GO! Get outta here! This is Yaris territory!"
when I was searching for my Yaris, I rememeber going to a dealer and seeing a Fit across from the Toyota dealer and thinking, "I could always just get a Fit... but... ewwwww. I don't want to be that type of guy."
Awww - I think just some insecure folks go mad over trying to justify their purchase of a Yaris. It is pretty simple psychology - a person is more inclined to increase the positive affect they have for something after investing/paying for it (so they feel more rational and better abotu themselves in return - it is why you never listen to specific car forums for positive reviews but use them to look for potential problems).
The fit & yaris are both good vehicles - I wish more people would adopt smaller vehicles with better mileage. I would be happy with either vehicles because they work well enough to get around (not one of those folks who drive karts on public roads).
oktarenwestern ny · Jul 31, 2006#11 Originally Posted by Andrew Chalmers
Awww - I think just some insecure folks go mad over trying to justify their purchase of a Yaris. It is pretty simple psychology - a person is more inclined to increase the positive affect they have for something after investing/paying for it (so they feel more rational and better abotu themselves in return - it is why you never listen to specific car forums for positive reviews but use them to look for potential problems).
The fit & yaris are both good vehicles - I wish more people would adopt smaller vehicles with better mileage. I would be happy with either vehicles because they work well enough to get around (not one of those folks who drive karts on public roads).
what about the fact that people bought the yaris in the first place AFTER checking out other vehicles like the fit? that doesn't really jive with your psychological statement...
Chris07LBNew Jersey · Jul 31, 2006#12I never got the chance to test a FIT or a Versa..
Being you tested both, if you had to choose between JUST those two, which would it be?
Andrew ChalmersNA · Aug 1, 2006#13 Originally Posted by oktaren
what about the fact that people bought the yaris in the first place AFTER checking out other vehicles like the fit? that doesn't really jive with your psychological statement...
There are people who checked out the Yaris and bought other vehicles too. I think both vehicles are great and each has its own advantages and weaknesses. But some Yaris fanboys go nuts and essentially wish the Honda dealer would blow up and engulf all the Fits in flames or something.
oktarenwestern ny · Aug 1, 2006#14 Originally Posted by Andrew Chalmers
There are people who checked out the Yaris and bought other vehicles too. I think both vehicles are great and each has its own advantages and weaknesses. But some Yaris fanboys go nuts and essentially wish the Honda dealer would blow up and engulf all the Fits in flames or something.
i don't really care if they blow up or not. in fact, i would rather people buy those other cars and not fill the road with yaris'. i can see why someone would buy a versa because it does have a bigger engine or even an aveo or something because they are so cheap, but the fit is ugly and overpriced for what it offers, at least in my opinion. but again, i didn't drive it, i didnt' want to be caught it something so ugly.
AlexKThread starterSparks, NV, USA · Aug 3, 2006#15Wow you think the Fit is ugly? I think it's nicer looking than the Yaris and would have maybe bought one if I could have gotten a manual transmission model. It supposedly handles better too but I know for a fact the ride is stiffer than Yaris or Versa.
I got 41.9 mpg (90% highway miles) on my first tank of gas in the Yaris which is pretty respectable considering I was doing 70-80mph and some stop-and-go traffic (Reno to San Francisco).
KatanaUnder the hood! · Aug 6, 2006#16I have tested a Fit and the Yaris is the better car!
corey415San Fran, CA · Aug 7, 2006#17 Originally Posted by AlexK
...
The rear seats of the FIT are awesome but since I also have a pickup I won't be hauling huge loads with my commuter car. Also it has a timing belt instead of a chain which is like a little bomb waiting to go off at the worst possible moment (maybe I exaggerate a little here).
FYI the Honda Fit has a low friction timing chain, not a timing belt.
featherzLake Arrowhead, CA · Aug 7, 2006#18I bought the Yaris for the simple reason that I thought it was cuter than the other econoboxes. Each to his/her own! :) I have nothing against Honda at all.
AlexKThread starterSparks, NV, USA · Aug 8, 2006#19The Honda Fit has a timing chain???? That Honda salesman is such a dumbass. Thanks for the info. Anyone want a cheap Yaris? Just kidding, I'm loving it.
paultyler_82USA · Aug 9, 2006#20To answer one person's question, the Metro got better mileage because the only availiable engines were a Suzuki 1.0 Liter I-3 and a Suzuki 1.3 Liter I-4. The 1.0 I-3 was available in two versions, the base engine, which made 55 hp and about 45 mpg as well as the detuned XFi version which made 49 hp and made approx 58 mpg. The 1.3L I-4 made 70 hp and got about 35 mpg. Me personally, I'm awaiting a 6-speed Versa SL in Magnetic Grey, Midnight Black, or Blue Onyx to arrive at my local Nissan dealership, mostly because I'm a Nissan person and I want the options that are availiable on the Versa, my significant other drives the Yaris, and I love it, but the important thing in a daily driver is that you drive what you want. I have no use at all for the Fit, but then I'm not a fan of Honda, the only Hondas I've ever cared for were the delSol, the s2000, and the NSX
tomjaszLost Wages · Aug 9, 2006#21I have yet to buy a car based on looks, Honda and Toyota have been consistently the most reliable cars. Nissan has joined the ranks of american manufacturers ans reliability is a thing of the past, especially when compared to Toyota and Honda.😲
KitelessUnion City, CA - U.S.A. · Aug 9, 2006#22 Originally Posted by AlexK
The dealer knocked $300 off the MSRP for me, price was $12800 before tax.
I already ordered a in-dash DVD/MP3 player so I won't be without tunes for long. So far I've logged 200 miles and it's great!
Good review man! And you got a super great price for the Sedan with those options. I bought a base hatch, and paid 11,400 or so after destination charge.
I too went sans radio and am waiting for a company like Metra to come out with a proper desh kit for my single DIN head unit out of my last car.
👍
- Kiteless
why?harnett county NC · Aug 9, 2006#23The Honda Civic CX/VX's were meant for gas mileage. The gearing was way higher to promote this.
Also realize Toyota was shooting for about 40 mpg, not better. They have smaller cars in other markets that get higher mpg.
paultyler_82USA · Aug 12, 2006#24 Originally Posted by tomjasz
I have yet to buy a car based on looks, Honda and Toyota have been consistently the most reliable cars. Nissan has joined the ranks of american manufacturers ans reliability is a thing of the past, especially when compared to Toyota and Honda.😲
Um... What? My Infiniti has 170000 miles and is still going strong... that's like saying Toyota isn't reliable because they partnered with GM! But last time I checked, Nissan still hasn't "joined the ranks" of American manufacturers, their only current partners are Renault (French) and Samsung (Korean)... and both my I30 and my mother's Altima were built in Japan. Check your facts first man.
BooMadison, WI · Aug 12, 2006#25Paul... you may get a lucky one.
Toyota still the best! 🍻
Picture not included in this copy
KatanaUnder the hood! · Aug 12, 2006#26Yeap still going on strong!!!
tomjaszLost Wages · Aug 12, 2006#27 Originally Posted by paultyler_82
Um... What? My Infiniti has 170000 miles and is still going strong... that's like saying Toyota isn't reliable because they partnered with GM! But last time I checked, Nissan still hasn't "joined the ranks" of American manufacturers, their only current partners are Renault (French) and Samsung (Korean)... and both my I30 and my mother's Altima were built in Japan. Check your facts first man.
Joined the ranks of poor repair records is what I meant to imply. Nissan has lost their edge. Try taking a look at reports Consumer Reports has gotten from member Nissan buyers. THEY HAVE GONE BACKWARDS JOINING THE RANKS OF AMERICAN MANUFACTURERS!
tca4Delta,BC · Aug 12, 2006#28Subraru not on the list?
fooberkalispell, montana · Aug 12, 2006#29I read an article months ago that rated the toyota echo the best built car in the last decade. The least amount of repairs. Supposedly the yaris is the echo with just a better look to it.
BooMadison, WI · Aug 12, 2006#30 Originally Posted by tca4
Subraru not on the list?
Subaru is 3 below avg.
stuffyontario, canada · Aug 12, 2006#31i read an article that rated the echo the most cost-effecient car to own and operate,
good on gas, stingy on service.
ECHOKnight2000Minnesota, US of A! · Aug 12, 2006#32 Originally Posted by stuffy
i read an article that rated the echo the most cost-effecient car to own and operate,
good on gas, stingy on service.
You are right! The ECHO has been noted to be the most or one of the most low cost cars on the market (when it was produced), cause its "simplistic" its basic transportation, less stuff to break and also its a reliable Toyota, with one of the most reliable engines in its class, the ass kickin' 1.5ltr!🤘 🤘 🤘
Jem_hadarCollingwood, ON · Aug 13, 2006#33 Originally Posted by foober
I read an article months ago that rated the toyota echo the best built car in the last decade. The least amount of repairs. Supposedly the yaris is the echo with just a better look to it.
Originally Posted by TRD_Yaris
"annoying throttle-by-wire which causes the engine to rev up between shifts if I don't let off the gas a second earlier than I'm used to"
word.. i hate HEARING the engine rev up JUST A BIT when i pop the clutch..it sucks for rev-matching since you must wait an extra couple .1's of a second 😠 😠
I just learned to drive stick proppa when I got my Yaris back in May. Its a piece of piss now to do 😉
But I guess I'm still not up on all the lingo or concepts... can you explain the engine revving up business?
I know when I drive my buddy's 94 Mazda MX-3, its shifts much more smoothly than my Yaris (though I absolutely HATE the gearbox looseness/feel), you can barely tell I'm changing gears AT ALL in the MX-3... but I cant seem to get that level of smoothness out of my Yaris, even though I drive it day and day out.
And yea, re: the first post, the backseats of the Fit are fucking UNBELIEVABLE! So wonderful! That (for me) was the single most impressive thing about the Fit (that and the 60/40 standard split I believe, or at least w/ the model I was looking one (not the sport though).)
Toyota needs to find a way to duplicate those "Magic Seats". They're freaking incredible! LOVE THEM.
Jem
Jem_hadarCollingwood, ON · Aug 13, 2006#34 Originally Posted by foober
I read an article months ago that rated the toyota echo the best built car in the last decade. The least amount of repairs. Supposedly the yaris is the echo with just a better look to it.
Believe it. My buddy Cale who is a phenomenally massive car enthusiast to the extreme said to me:
"Echo's just don't breakdown. They just don't. Its uncanny"
Having him say that was impressive. It really helped and was a large factor when I decided to by the Yaris (basically just a better looking version of the Echo).
Jem_hadarCollingwood, ON · Sep 24, 2006#35Saw (IN PERSON) today the Yaris at the dealership after hours, and I looked them all up and down for a good 1/2 hour, I swear.
... and I must say, I think I *may* like the Versa better than the Yaris now... but not 100% sure yet. :S Need to reflect on the matter more.
Interior wise, its more typical and less "unique/different/strange" like the Yaris's is... overall just pretty fucking nice! Outside, in person, its not as ugly as I thought it was when I was pics of it online. Its quite fine!
And it has over twice the storage space or the Yaris, plus an extra 16 horsepower! Both those features REALLY freakin' appeal to me. Esp since the cost is literally like SPOT ON for comparably equipped Versa to my LE 4 door!
If I were buying now and we had both a Toyota and Nissan dealership in Collingwood, I dont know which I would buy anymore. :S
Jem
paultyler_82USA · Sep 24, 2006#36 Originally Posted by Jem_hadar
Saw (IN PERSON) today the Yaris at the dealership after hours, and I looked them all up and down for a good 1/2 hour, I swear.
... and I must say, I think I *may* like the Versa better than the Yaris now... but not 100% sure yet. :S Need to reflect on the matter more.
Interior wise, its more typical and less "unique/different/strange" like the Yaris's is... overall just pretty fucking nice! Outside, in person, its not as ugly as I thought it was when I was pics of it online. Its quite fine!
And it has over twice the storage space or the Yaris, plus an extra 16 horsepower! Both those features REALLY freakin' appeal to me. Esp since the cost is literally like SPOT ON for comparably equipped Versa to my LE 4 door!
If I were buying now and we had both a Toyota and Nissan dealership in Collingwood, I dont know which I would buy anymore. :S
Jem
So you can see where the extra features like iKey, Bluetooth, 6-speaker system with 6-disc in-dash MP3/WMA changer, and CVT (on the SL trim model only) seals the deal for someone like me who really wants them.
Yaris DickSoutheastern USA · Sep 24, 2006#37 Originally Posted by paultyler_82
Um... What? My Infiniti has 170000 miles and is still going strong... that's like saying Toyota isn't reliable because they partnered with GM! But last time I checked, Nissan still hasn't "joined the ranks" of American manufacturers, their only current partners are Renault (French) and Samsung (Korean)... and both my I30 and my mother's Altima were built in Japan. Check your facts first man.
Judging from the JD Powers survey, it looks like it would be a GOOD thing for Nissan to "joint the ranks" of the American manufacturers...eh?😆
jeff_oCedar Knolls, Morris County, New Jersey · Sep 24, 2006#38alexK nice choice. i'm just curious... did you get the sedan with the power package? or just the base? because you said you don't have stereo but i dunno if you have power windows/side mirrors/locks etc.
i find toyota packages weird because once you get a yaris with power package, then you get an integrated HU which is hard to get replaced with an better aftermarket one.
Jem_hadarCollingwood, ON · Sep 24, 2006#39 Originally Posted by paultyler_82
So you can see where the extra features like iKey, Bluetooth, 6-speaker system with 6-disc in-dash MP3/WMA changer, and CVT (on the SL trim model only) seals the deal for someone like me who really wants them.
Oh, yea I can see that, but I was even just referring to an 1.8 S model, comparing it to my LE hatchback Package B
Jem_hadarCollingwood, ON · Sep 24, 2006#40Actually, was just looking at the Versa brochure.
Unless you go get the 1.8SL, you caht get a MP3 CD-player, and you dont have the option to add a centre arm rest either.
And I dont think you can add at all the compass/outside temp feature I added to my Yaris (on the reivew view mirror) 😎
thewifesyarisReno, NV · Sep 24, 2006#41nice to see a fellow yaris on this forum from sparks, keep a look out for my wife she wont be hard to miss, with the pink stripes and all.
paultyler_82USA · Sep 25, 2006#42 Originally Posted by Jem_hadar
Actually, was just looking at the Versa brochure.
Unless you go get the 1.8SL, you had get a MP3 CD-player, and you dont have the option to add a centre arm rest either.
And I dont think you can add the compass/outside temp feature I added to my Yaris (on the reivew view mirror) 😎
That's what I want is the SL, CVT's not available on the S trim either. My local dealership quoted me 17,018 for a SL CVT with Convienience package (ikey, bluetooth) after Destination fee and before tax and title, pretty good price in my eyes.
Jem_hadarCollingwood, ON · Sep 25, 2006#43 Originally Posted by paultyler_82
with Convienience package (ikey, bluetooth) .
I love how the package names differ in the US from Canada, and even between somes states in teh US.
Up here, on the 1.8SL, there is only one package u can add (the one you mention)l, but its called the "Technology Package" not the Convenience package
paultyler_82USA · Sep 26, 2006#44Here, on the S you can only add the power package and can't get the CVT (6-speed manual or 4-speed auto only) or the 6 disc indash changer. The SL comes standard with all power and the changer, You get the CVT if you opt for the non manual, and you can add the Convenience (iKey and Bluetooth), Audio (upgraded speakers and subwoofer), Sunroof, and Satellite packages... unfortunately, the Audio, Sunroof, and Satellite packages are all linked, can't get one without the other... so I figure, I'll just upgrade the speakers and put a sub in myself, then add in the XM Tuner (standard Nissan part used on ALL Nissans and Infinitis with XM) I never really have used the sunroof on my I30... so I don't figure I need it on the Versa, besides, that's just one more complication if I attempt a Carbon Fibre roof.
Jem_hadarCollingwood, ON · Sep 26, 2006#45 Originally Posted by paultyler_82
Here, on the S you can only add the power package and can't get the CVT (6-speed manual or 4-speed auto only) or the 6 disc indash changer. The SL comes standard with all power and the changer, You get the CVT if you opt for the non manual, and you can add the Convenience (iKey and Bluetooth), Audio (upgraded speakers and subwoofer), Sunroof, and Satellite packages... unfortunately, the Audio, Sunroof, and Satellite packages are all linked, can't get one without the other... so I figure, I'll just upgrade the speakers and put a sub in myself, then add in the XM Tuner (standard Nissan part used on ALL Nissans and Infinitis with XM) I never really have used the sunroof on my I30... so I don't figure I need it on the Versa, besides, that's just one more complication if I attempt a Carbon Fibre roof.
Here neither.
I cant get the CVT on an 1.8S.
Or the 6-CD player. Nor MP3 capability.
You need to get the 1.8 SL "Technology" package to get those features.
paultyler_82USA · Sep 27, 2006#46 Originally Posted by Jem_hadar
Here neither.
I cant get the CVT on an 1.8S.
Or the 6-CD player. Nor MP3 capability.
You need to get the 1.8 SL "Technology" package to get those features.
That's funny, all three are standard on the US SL Auto.
Jem_hadarCollingwood, ON · Sep 27, 2006#47 Originally Posted by paultyler_82
That's funny, all three are standard on the US SL Auto.
the CVT is standard on the 1.8SL auto, but the other two require the tech pacakge.
JBIZZFort Lauderdale, FL · Sep 9, 2007#48Versa is built in Mexico, =s POS!
Sweet MercuryNew Jersey · Sep 10, 2007#49 Originally Posted by
Boo ↑ Paul... you may get a lucky one.
Toyota still the best! 🍻
Picture not included in this copy
Wow.
Land Rovers are pieces of crap.
And Mercuries have a higher rating than Toyota? WTF?