Yarisworld Archive

Shifting (A/T)

55 posts · 16,922 views · page 2 of 2

Replies continued

eTiMaGoBangkok, Thailand · Apr 3, 2007#51
You have to admit auto boxes have evolved by leaps and bounds over the years, now Lexus has an 8-speed box, and even on our lowly car, there's advanced electronics controlling the whole thing. "Manumatics" are just the natural evolution of the automatic transmission, since a computer unit can tell the gearbox when to shift, why not let the driver give some input too? All it costs is a few extra wires and buttons.

To be honest, there is some use to having a manumatic, it's a lot easier to change gears when needed (when going up a hill, or wanting maximum acceleration, etc), at the press of a button rather than the chance of moving the gearstick down an extra notch by accident. It doesn't make the shifting any faster, there'll always be a lag, and to be honest, the main reason for the whole system is that it looks good and makes people think they're driving a Ferrari or F1 car. And a car that makes its driver feel cool is a car that gets sold.

In a car of our class, auto boxes in any shape and size are not meant for serious sports driving, period. They're all about ease of use, so that pretty much anybody can drive without needing the foot-hand coordination to change gears. And like PSU Yaris said, it lets you concentrate on more important things when you take that boring commute... 😆 And what is the result of having a system anyone can drive? More cars are sold.

It does not mean you can't have some fun with it, though! One time, with a friend, we rented a cheapass auto car and put it through the paces, so to speak. Twisty hilly roads, large expanses of packed dirt, etc. I learned a lot from it. You can manually downshift and get the same kind of results as with a manual gearbox, but you gotta move the lever a lot earlier than you think you want to. You can control the whole thing to shift when you want to, how you want to, but your timing has to be completely different to a manual. It can be done, but it just feels weird... And it most likely does shorten the lifespan of the gearbox... What did we care? We were young and dumb and eager to learn, and it wasn't even our car anyway 😁

The highlighted parts represent the way of thinking of the car companies, I think... Nowadays it doesn't really matter what is better, just what sells better. Sad but true.
Yaris RevengeMy own little world. · Apr 3, 2007#52
BIN-GO, eTiMaGo! That was exactly my point all along. 🎉

~YR
eTiMaGoBangkok, Thailand · Apr 3, 2007#53
woohoo someone agrees with me *gets tears in his eyes*
daq421Thread starterLivermore, CA · Apr 3, 2007#54
Originally Posted by Black Yaris ↑
I am also baffled by those of you with auto's that want to shift them, it is just silly, and hurting your trans..... you are going to do what you are going to do.... I just don't understand why one would damage such am expensive part of your car on purpose, it is like not ever changing your oil
Again.. This is not really a thread about using the A/T like a manual, It's a thread about dropping out of D and into 3rd entering into turns to bring up the RPM's to put power to the wheels when you need it. All I said was the little car seems to respond to this action very well (as opposed to say my old A/T Cutlass). Using the A/T in this fashion is much like using it to engine brake down a hill, or dropping out of O/D into 3rd to pass up a hill. I'm not starting in 1st and "up-shifting" as I pull away from lights, nor am I "down-shifting" as I come to a stop.

-Peter
Pavel OlavichOrange County, Calif · Apr 3, 2007#55
Originally Posted by Yaris Revenge ↑
I also stand by my belief that you're a retard. 😉

Time and again you are confusing my comments on a manumatic with a standard automatic transmission. I have yet to make ANY comment on a standard auto tranny, yet you insist on quoting scripture from manuals about downshifting standard autos, and how it's supposed to be done.

YES YES YES, automatic transmission are meant to be downshifted manually!!! We get that. It's original purpose is for driving situations that confuse the automatic shifting (such as semi-steep inclines), or for loaded towing, but hell, if you want, downshift the sucker all you want. I don't care, and I honestly don't think it will cause any problem. I routinely kick mine out of overdrive to assist braking all the time.

Now Pavel, let me lay this out for you one more time, so you can understand what I'm saying. In a MANUMANTIC transmission there is a separate shifter area marked with a "+" and a "-". When you move the lever to this area, it forces the automatic to behave more like a manual. To upshift, hit "+", to downshift, hit "-". WHAT I SAID EARLIER was that this style of shifting is pointless for sporty driving, because there is a time lag between hitting the "+" and the actual gear change. It can be done much faster and more efficiently in a manual transmission. SO, for SPORTY driving, a MANUMATIC doesn't make much sense, because the standard auto shifting program included is faster. Granted, I would expect the ones on luxury cars and race cars to be pretty good, but the run-of-the-mill manumatics SUCK.

*whew!* Now, before you reply, read this through at least twice and dwell on it, so you don't make yourself look stupid again. This makes at least twice now you've misread a post and argued about it.

Really, to call someone a "bumpkin", shouldn't you at least be able to spell it first? 😆 And "compensating"? Dude, we're in a Yaris forum, or haven't you noticed? 🙄

Answer me this: have you even hit your 20's yet? And be honest! I'm genuinely curious.

~YR
My true retarded friend, what YOU don't seem to understand is this:

(1) You don't know how to drive a A/T manually in the proper fashion.

(2) You'd rather blame the equipment then admit (1).

(3) When moving the selector + or - one often NEEDS to work the gas pedel in conjunction with dropping a gear, so that the lag is NOT THERE!!!!!

Do you need picture, or are you just slow minded? You idiot, I am 47! And talking to you is like talking to a 13 year old brat that lacks accountability, responsability, and whose knee jerk reaction is to blame the equipment instead of admiting that he is ignorant.