Yarisworld Archive

Stick or Auto ?

57 posts · 17,607 views · page 1 of 2

szookOriginal postbaltomore ohio · Jan 22, 2006#1
Which one should I get ?

Replies 56

OKJeeperOklahoma City, OK · Jan 23, 2006#2
Stick, always better to have more control over the car, get more power out of the engine.
wushumasterkuToronto · Jan 23, 2006#3
auto zaps some power.. no way for me.
birdydenton,tx · Jan 23, 2006#4
I am getting a 5speed, I think on this car it would be a given.
swngBC · Jan 23, 2006#5
Just voted for automatic. It is great for city driving.
as400g33kAustralia · Jan 23, 2006#6
either is ok, but auto is a 1.5k option so went for the manual.
p2filzlos angeles · Jan 23, 2006#7
wow 1.5 more damn for that reason alone i would choose manual although ive already chosen manual
swngBC · Jan 23, 2006#8
In an attempt to win you over to the automatic side, I want to say how about 1k or less in the US?
why?harnett county NC · Jan 23, 2006#9
A car this small can only be properly enjoyed with a manual transmission. Actually, any vehicle can only be properly enjoyed with a manual transmission.
ronbonzoFulton County, Illinois, USA · Jan 24, 2006#10
I'm an old fart who finds it difficult to lift that left leg anymore. I'm going with the automatic.🍻
p2filzlos angeles · Jan 26, 2006#11
how old a fart are we talkin bout, seein as its a wrx the said fart is takin bout... on another note how does the manual feel on the yaris? not rubbery or anything rite?
yaris3Gurabo, Puerto Rico!!! · Jan 26, 2006#12
5 speed manual of course. :)....I bought my Yaris in November 2005 at Caguas, Puerto Rico. You can see my car in http://www.cardomain.com/id/yaris3
kralmraxCanada · Jan 28, 2006#15
i opted for the automatic as a comprimise with the wife who cannot drive a stick, this way i may be able to get a bike come spring. i'm actually enjoying the automatic for the amount of start and stop city driving i do.
PeteramaMaple Ontario Canada · Jan 29, 2006#16
auto for me I wish I could get stick but my wife drives it as well and she refuses to learn stick.....but let me tell you the auto is fun I dont regret it at all
Kouki_TruenoFL · Jan 29, 2006#17
Manual...
fooberkalispell, montana · Jan 30, 2006#18
I have yet to get my yaris. So this is good information. I'm worried about the stop and go city driving. And of course getting stuck in traffic jams. Been through too many in L.A. and san diego when i lived there. But could go manual considering i live in montana now. THanks for the info..
ZivCanada · Feb 1, 2006#19
I liked the stick, until I have read quite a few review on the stick is not as smooth as auto. So I test drive both and decided to get the auto instead. At least for the Yaris.

Ziv on Vitz
swngBC · Feb 1, 2006#20
There is yet another good thing about the Yaris' auto which is worth mentioning - you only have to pay marginally more in terms of fuel cost to enjoy the comfort and convenience👍 .
why?harnett county NC · Feb 1, 2006#21
That is if you think of it as comfort and convenience. It is physically hard for me to drive an auto after driving my Viggen for so long.
swngBC · Feb 1, 2006#22
I certainly respect that why? What I was trying to say was that in the case of other cars, an auto would cost noticeably more(than marginally) in terms of fuel cost to run.
ZivCanada · Feb 2, 2006#23
I understand for those whom drive manual all their life would hardly consider auto, but I found Yaris's Electroic Controlled Transmission (S-ECT) is quite different then my last altima and accord(both Auto). Maybe just me, but I do found Automatic is smoother and quiet than the Manual.
I know people who find Manual more 'fun' to drive, but at least for myself, Auto certainly didn't take any 'fun' out of my drive on a Yaris.
why?harnett county NC · Feb 2, 2006#24
It is good to hear that the auto in the Yaris is a good one. Too long were the days when auto's in small cars were horrid.
AngryBusDriverPeterborough, Ontario · Feb 4, 2006#25
Originally Posted by kralmrax
i opted for the automatic as a comprimise with the wife who cannot drive a stick, this way i may be able to get a bike come spring. i'm actually enjoying the automatic for the amount of start and stop city driving i do.
I test drove both, but I have always found manual much more fun. It's funny kralmrax, I chose the manual transmission for the exact same reason you chose the automatic. Let the wife drive the Jimmy and the Yaris is all mine! 👍
guy_likewhoaVancouver · Feb 13, 2006#26
get stick. way more fun to drive. manual transmission for ever!!!....unless I lose my left leg lol
fooberkalispell, montana · Feb 13, 2006#27
I keep going back and forth on whether to get manual or auto. I guess i'll just wait till I see what they can offer me yaris wise and figure out the best option.
urazTurkey · Feb 28, 2006#28
always manual. see the red line and change the gear. it makes me happy
why?harnett county NC · Feb 28, 2006#29
Not to mention the manual transmission is lighter.
fooberkalispell, montana · Feb 28, 2006#30
Does anyone know if the manual transmission is the same as the corollas is now. I have no yaris around to see what kind of manual transmission they have. So I tested out the coralla yesterday to test out its manual. It wan't all that bad in making shifts.
jcoveBrampton, Ontario, Canada · Feb 28, 2006#31
Originally Posted by why?
A car this small can only be properly enjoyed with a manual transmission. Actually, any vehicle can only be properly enjoyed with a manual transmission.
I totally agree there !!!!👍 🍻 🎉
why?harnett county NC · Feb 28, 2006#32
Originally Posted by foober
Does anyone know if the manual transmission is the same as the corollas is now. I have no yaris around to see what kind of manual transmission they have. So I tested out the coralla yesterday to test out its manual. It wan't all that bad in making shifts.
It is not. The Yaris has gears that will accelerate faster than the corrola's. I don't know the technical term for it, I think gearing is lower, or numerically higher, but I might be mixing that up.
swngBC · Feb 28, 2006#33
Originally Posted by why?
It is not. The Yaris has gears that will accelerate faster than the corrola's. I don't know the technical term for it, I think gearing is lower, or numerically higher, but I might be mixing that up.
Do you mean shorter gear ratios😳? I am no expert either. Just enjoy chatting with you guys.
why?harnett county NC · Feb 28, 2006#34
I think so. Shorter and lower numerically gear ratios I think will accelerate faster, while longer and higher ones will go slower.
kevjef420Cambridge ON · Mar 21, 2006#35
I got a manual. I hate automatic transmissions, especially on small cars. But I must say that I am not that impressed with the transmission. I have owned 3 toyotas with manual and all of them didn't shift near as nice as any honda I have drove. I must say that this car really moves with a 5 speed and 106hp. The car is very light and has excellent throtle response. btw it smokes my brothers 98 Civic Si for lunch.
DJ_SpaRkyGroveland, FL (Near Orlando) · Mar 22, 2006#36
(coming from a Scion Driver) 1NZ-FE + Auto = Bad. MPG & the driving experience will both be better with a 5-speed
maoLos Angeles · Mar 22, 2006#37
maybe im still young but i prefer manual than auto. i like more power going those uphill streets. my parents suggest that i should go with 5 door auto. but i did not want that, since im paying for the car, mine as well get one you like. =P
Swissy_82Prince George, BC, Canada · Mar 23, 2006#38
I'm not going to vote. I don't know how to drive stick yet 😳 , so i will wait befor i cast my vote.
DJ_SpaRkyGroveland, FL (Near Orlando) · Mar 23, 2006#39
Originally Posted by Swissy_82
I'm not going to vote. I don't know how to drive stick yet 😳 , so i will wait befor i cast my vote.
if you get one, you will learn. it's not hard.
PeteaussiPerth, Australia · Apr 2, 2006#40
A stick allows you more control of the car I think. Also, it is a hell of a lot more fun. If you get the 1.5L engine then trust me, a stick is definitely worth it because you can throw the Yaris around a lot more.
stuffyontario, canada · Apr 2, 2006#41
yeah, manual is the only way to go, especially with a small car.

auto sucks the life out of a car. i havent' driven an auto yaris, but i have driven auto echos and they are not nearly as fun to drive as my car.
harvesCanberra, Australia · Apr 3, 2006#42
Manual deffinately. I would never buy an auto in a car less then 2lt
why?harnett county NC · Apr 3, 2006#43
I have driven the auto Yaris, and it is ok. I can't wait to get my manual.
swngBC · Apr 3, 2006#44
Why? says - I have driven the auto Yaris, and it is ok....
Yes, that is exactly the point. A manual gear box can of course give the driver a lot of fun and flexibility but as why? says, the auto is ok. There are valid reasons why some people have to buy the auto, paying about one thousand dollars more despite that it is not as good as the manual in a number of ways.
Of course the manual is very very good but I am so glad that why?, who is an abvious supporter of the manual, says that the auto is ok.
stuffyontario, canada · Apr 3, 2006#45
why did you opt for the auto, swng?

(i want some valid reasons, besides being able to drink coffee, talk on the phone and smoke a cigarette at the same time while driving)
swngBC · Apr 3, 2006#46
Originally Posted by stuffy
why did you opt for the auto, swng?

(i want some valid reasons, besides being able to drink coffee, talk on the phone and smoke a cigarette at the same time while driving)
Thanks for the question. It is partly due to that fact that I live in a very hilly area with a lot of stop and go traffic to get through before reaching the highway. However, it is largely due to the fact that my wife also drives the same car and she likes to have one that is easy to drive and easy to park. She ranks convenience above fun. She especially dislikes starting on steep slopes.
stuffyontario, canada · Apr 3, 2006#47
makes good sense,
luckily, my wife enjoys driving standard as well,
when we first got the yaris, we had to take turns driving, but now i get to drive the most- (i let her control the t.v. channel changer)
swngBC · Apr 3, 2006#48
Originally Posted by stuffy
makes good sense,
luckily, my wife enjoys driving standard as well,
when we first got the yaris, we had to take turns driving, but now i get to drive the most- (i let her control the t.v. channel changer)
Good humor! Enjoy(I mean, both of you)!
falkerArizona · Jun 11, 2006#49
IT DEPENDS HOW AND WHERE YOU DRIVE IT BUT I PREFER MANUAL
boxerboyNorth Carolina · Jun 11, 2006#50
I like a manual in most cars. I enjoy driving. The only exception is a luxury car.