Yarisworld Archive

Yari vs. Honda Fit

72 posts · 33,879 views · page 1 of 2

nwdixieboyOriginal postseattle,wa · Feb 15, 2006#1
I really love my 2001 4 door Echo and am torn between buying a new Yari or the new Honda Fit, which looks very tempting. Has anyone ridden or sat in a Fit/Jazz in another country or auto show?

Replies 71

ZivCanada · Feb 15, 2006#2
Well, the Toronto Auto Show will start in few days, I will see if I could go and check it out.
vicpaiTorrance, CA · Feb 15, 2006#3
The YARIS LIFTBACK wins hands down against the Honda Fit. Generally speaking, I am a big Honda fan because of their Navigation Systems (have owned a 2000 Acura TL/NAVI and an '03 Acura MDX/NAVI/RES), but when it comes to these 2, the Honda is waaay behind. The Yaris is much SAFER than the Fit according to the Euro NCAP tests, and besides, this is the first Toyota to incorporate their breakthrough MICS (Minimal Intrusion Cabin Structure) body, which is supposed to be able to withstand a collision with a 2-tonne vehicle!!!!! 😳 .....Sadly, Honda has not used their proprietary ACE (Advanced Collision Engineering) body structure on the Fit (which, BTW, is just as good as Toyota's MICS). Secondly, the Yaris is simply better all round from it's ultra-tight turning radius, it's fabulous exterior dimensions, better fuel economy etc. etc.!! .......I will still end up buying the redesigned MDX, which is coming out this fall, but for my commuter vehicle, it's going to be the YARIS LIFTBACK!! 👍
nwdixieboyThread starterseattle,wa · Feb 15, 2006#4
Thanks for the info. I am strongly leaning towards the Yaris sedan as it is so much classier looking and I like having a trunk to hide things.
swngBC · Feb 16, 2006#5
One of the factors that will tempt me to buy a Fit instead of a Yaris is the availability of side and curtain air bags on the Fit. In Canada, the Yaris does not come with them, even as options. Since you are in the US Nwdixieboy, you can get side and curtain bags on a Yaris if you want them, so the Fit loses its advantage in the US in that respect. Therefore, I would urge you to consider the Yaris for its fuel economy and overall newer design(introduced only in 05, or 06 in the case of the sedan which has not even been put on sale here yet). At least you will not have to risk buying a car which may be redesigned and have its look and other things changed sooner than you may expect.
Moreover, if you are considering a sedan, I believe the more appropiate comparison from the Honda side should be the Civic, not the Fit.
corey415San Fran, CA · Feb 16, 2006#6
With respect to the Euro NCAP results, keep in mind that the Yaris they tested had front, side, and side curtain airbags. The Jazz/Fit tested only had the 2 front airbags.

Also, there seems to be a contention that there is a huge difference in fuel economy between the Fit and Yaris. Looking at the specsheets, I dont see the difference as being dramatic in my opinion.

But it is true that the Fit is an old design. I wonder when the new model is coming out...
echo_hrsTop Gear Test Track · Feb 19, 2006#7
Some good comparison photos, it really makes a difference seeing them side by side...

Picture not included in this copy
Picture not included in this copy
Picture not included in this copy
Picture not included in this copy
KarelToronto, ON. · Feb 19, 2006#8
Thanks..I prefer the Yaris..😆
hhcchenseattle · Feb 19, 2006#9
sorry... still don't like the "mini minivan"...🤣
hoahmaruCalgary AB. · Feb 19, 2006#10
I still prefer the Yaris. The curves on the Yaris makes it look so much better and for me I think toyota engines are better that honda engines, just by experience.
swngBC · Feb 19, 2006#11
Until I saw the pictures, I never knew the Fit was so much bigger. I have already bought the Yaris and will not change to another car soon, but I still enjoy reading posts discussing about which of the two is better.
hhcchenseattle · Feb 19, 2006#12
Originally Posted by swng
Until I saw the pictures, I never knew the Fit was so much bigger. I have already bought the Yaris and will not change to another car soon, but I still enjoy reading posts discussing about which of the two is better.
well, over here, everyone is bias toward yaris...
at honda forums, they are bias toward fit...
🤮
don't know what to say...
fooberkalispell, montana · Feb 19, 2006#13
thanks for the side by side camparison. The more I see of the yaris the more I wish it was the end of march and I was driving mine.
SpeedzBrisbane, Australia · Feb 20, 2006#14
Look at it this way...

Fit is more than a few years old and Yaris is new...

I dont want to sink my $$ in a older model even though I'm buying it brand new...

And I also test drove the Fit... there is alot higher cabin noise than the newer Yaris... but the Honda V-Tec engine is a gem even though it is only a 1.5 SOHC...
ZivCanada · Feb 20, 2006#15
Wow, looking at it side by side, I am glad I did brought a Yaris instead of waiting for Fit or Versa. ha ha.
nwdixieboyThread starterseattle,wa · Feb 20, 2006#16
I have decided that since I LOVED my Echo so much, I am going to stick with the Yaris, as it is a known product and it is a newer design than the Fit.
jazzerindonesia · Feb 25, 2006#17
i drive 2005 honda Fit 1.5T, and my wife's 2006 yaris s limited is already at home. i think this 2 cars have its own fanatic fans, because the driving caracter is different, the yaris is more comfortable and solid than Fit (my wife and my daughter love it soo much), but for driving enthusiast who loved spirited driving... go for honda fit, .. believe me it has sportier performance and better driving experience in my opinion
jdgriswaldBellingham, WA · Feb 25, 2006#18
Looks rather familiar.
Attachment 145
While the above is not mine, I do have the rebadged Isuzu Oasis, don't think I need a mini version too.

1 attachment not included in this copy

swngBC · Feb 28, 2006#19
Better fuel economy than the Yaris and 5-speed auto? I almost want to deflect to Honda immediately! I will try to calm myself down and wait a while to see if the Fit will be due for a redesign soon as predicted by some fellow members. I also speculate that future Yaris models will be better equipped to match the competitions.
SmellyTofuSydney · Feb 28, 2006#21
I own a Fit and driven a few Yaris but both in different transmission (CVT vs 5 speed) but I find the Yaris to be fairly sluggish and the Fit to be quite flexible and more willing to go places. Most of this I think comes down to the transmission I think but handling-wise, the Yaris comes up trumps.
heybaiSheffield UK · Mar 9, 2006#22
I own a Fit and driven a few Yaris but both in different transmission (CVT vs 5 speed) but I find the Yaris to be fairly sluggish and the Fit to be quite flexible and more willing to go places. Most of this I think comes down to the transmission I think but handling-wise, the Yaris comes up trumps.

How did you like the interior of the Fit compared to the Yaris? I am concerned about headroom. I am not that tall, but somehow my head almost always touches the roof in a small car -- and thus my interest in the Yaris and its superior roominess (as far as I have seen). I haven't bought anything yet but am looking.
SmellyTofuSydney · Mar 9, 2006#23
The Yaris has hard plastics on the door handles and dash relative to the Fit. The tops of the door trim is softer on the Yaris. The roof I find has plenty of room and there's a height adjustable seat should you need it on both vehicles. I find the Yaris wider but not as long as the Fit. The seats in the Fit is better as it has more side support when you're going around corners.
hoahmaruCalgary AB. · Mar 19, 2006#24
Is the Fit cheaper in price than the Yaris? I believe in Canada it is cheaper, but I'am not too sure, gotta wait until the Fit hits show rooms in early April.
ZivCanada · Mar 20, 2006#25
I think the base is a little bit more expensive. However, Toyota's feature is known for expensive. So added with the feature, Fit could probably be cheaper.
corey415San Fran, CA · Mar 20, 2006#26
Here are the US FIT PRICES:

Base manual - $13850
Base Auto - $14650
Sport Manual- $15170
Sport Auto - $15970

For all levels add $550 destination charge
benfal2001Montreal · May 14, 2006#27
Originally Posted by nwdixieboy
Thanks for the info. I am strongly leaning towards the Yaris sedan as it is so much classier looking and I like having a trunk to hide things.
but trunk is always to small... 😆
benfal2001Montreal · May 14, 2006#28
Originally Posted by swng
Until I saw the pictures, I never knew the Fit was so much bigger. I have already bought the Yaris and will not change to another car soon, but I still enjoy reading posts discussing about which of the two is better.
Fit won the 1st place in Japan in 2002 and won the first place in www.CARandDRIVER.com over 6 others...

Need to say more ? 🤷
benfal2001Montreal · May 14, 2006#29
Originally Posted by jazzer
i drive 2005 honda Fit 1.5T, and my wife's 2006 yaris s limited is already at home. i think this 2 cars have its own fanatic fans, because the driving caracter is different, the yaris is more comfortable and solid than Fit (my wife and my daughter love it soo much), but for driving enthusiast who loved spirited driving... go for honda fit, .. believe me it has sportier performance and better driving experience in my opinion
I agree.
😳
The Yaris is:
Too much body roll, cramped rear seat, falls short on directional stability. 👎
plushDJRed Deer, AB · May 14, 2006#30
The back seat isnt too cramped, I'm six foot and I have lots of room
why?harnett county NC · May 14, 2006#31
Originally Posted by benfal2001
I agree.
😳
The Yaris is:
Too much body roll, cramped rear seat, falls short on directional stability. 👎

No, you can leave now, no one wants you here.

The Yaris is the ONLY CAR IN HISTORY to win both COY awards for EUROPE and JAPAN in the same year.

Now go take your pitiful temper tantrum and leave. Go justify your horrid purchase somewhere else, we are sick of you trying to justify your mistake to us.
RonVancouver · May 14, 2006#32
i've heard that of the honda fit too, more of a 'lively' fun drive. but if i was looking for something fun and quick to drive, it wouldnt be an econobox. the joys of the yaris for me are: comfortable, versatile, good on gas, civil, and adequately peppy; perfect for a daily to/from work vehicle. i have yet to drive a fit, and i dont really care to. its just ugly IMO.
stuffyontario, canada · May 14, 2006#33
No, you can leave now, no one wants you here.

The Yaris is the ONLY CAR IN HISTORY to win both COY awards for EUROPE and JAPAN in the same year.

Now go take your pitiful temper tantrum and leave. Go justify your horrid purchase somewhere else, we are sick of you trying to justify your mistake to us.
lol why? !
w1ngzer0Phoenix,AZ · May 14, 2006#34
Originally Posted by benfal2001
I agree.
😳
The Yaris is:
Too much body roll, cramped rear seat, falls short on directional stability. 👎
has more room then my impreza and its a 4 door.
RobbIA · May 14, 2006#35
I don't know why everybody is comparing the Fit vs. Yaris. They are completely different cars IMHO. They should be comparing the Fit againist the Suzuki Aerio SX.
corey415San Fran, CA · May 14, 2006#36
The Suzuki Aerio is in a different class. It has a 2.3L w/ 155hp.

I think a more apt comparison with the Fit would be the Scion xA.
AestheticalFilmU.S. Florida · May 16, 2006#37
saw a fit today, looks like a mini van for the guy who doesnt want to admit that he drives a mini van
Yaris RevengeMy own little world. · May 17, 2006#38
Originally Posted by AestheticalFilm
saw a fit today, looks like a mini van for the guy who doesnt want to admit that he drives a mini van
I realize I'm coming into this discussion a little late, but I have to agree here. Those pics at the beginning really close the deal. How on earth is Honda promoting the Fit as a sporty little economy car??? I think the public's reaction to it may be the same as to the Scion xB:

"Oh, look! That's a cool commercial! It must be a cool car! Sure it is! Look how cool it is on TV!"

Then once the ads have stopped airing, and the pretty people and the techno beats have faded into memory, they'll be left with one helluva ugly car. 😆

I hate marketing. It's all so hollow, always trying to sell an image.... 🙄

~YR

EDIT: Sorry Thirty-Nine, didn't mean to be dissin' yer ride... 😳
rickoGeorgian Triangle Ont. · May 17, 2006#39
Jeez "39", you into Zen or something????? That was almost profound! Hey, no joke intended ..... that was well said.
benfal2001Montreal · May 17, 2006#40
Originally Posted by echo_hrs
Some good comparison photos, it really makes a difference seeing them side by side...

Picture not included in this copy
Picture not included in this copy
Picture not included in this copy
Picture not included in this copy
Sorry but I don't like to drive while my feet are in the radiator... Yaris no thanks. 👎
benfal2001Montreal · May 17, 2006#41
Originally Posted by AestheticalFilm
saw a fit today, looks like a mini van for the guy who doesnt want to admit that he drives a mini van
Yaris liftback looks more like a female car than male. Cutie cutie but no room and praticaly no performance to deliver... sorry that's it.
benfal2001Montreal · May 17, 2006#42
Originally Posted by why?
No, you can leave now, no one wants you here.

The Yaris is the ONLY CAR IN HISTORY to win both COY awards for EUROPE and JAPAN in the same year.

Now go take your pitiful temper tantrum and leave. Go justify your horrid purchase somewhere else, we are sick of you trying to justify your mistake to us.
You now have an idea of kind of unclassy people driving yaris. 🙄
benfal2001Montreal · May 17, 2006#43
Originally Posted by AestheticalFilm
saw a fit today, looks like a mini van for the guy who doesnt want to admit that he drives a mini van
Yess a mini van for the price of a small car for those who need cargo room! 👍 and a peppy engine!

You understand everything! 👍
benfal2001Montreal · May 17, 2006#44
And can't understand those silly idiots who designed the centered dashboard... Trying to start a trend ? Why show your passenger at what speed you drive ?
Completely stupid idea.
AestheticalFilmU.S. Florida · May 17, 2006#45
Originally Posted by benfal2001
Yess a mini van for the price of a small car for those who need cargo room! 👍 and a peppy engine!

You understand everything! 👍
hang on a second, i never said that it looking like a mini van was a bad thing, under the circumstances you stated the fit could be a heck of a deal.

just not for me.
DylanbyGTA · May 17, 2006#46
Originally Posted by Thirty-Nine
Nope, not into Zen, but thanks for the compliment. I did some research studies in college on automotive marketing, though. :)
For a second I thought you were going to say you'd stayed at a Holiday Inn last night.
rickoGeorgian Triangle Ont. · May 17, 2006#47
No worries "39", he's obviously some loser "Canadiens" fan, lost because he has no Leafs or Sens websites to pollute. It never pays to attempt to reason with an idiot. When he is finished here, he'll probably flit over to the Nikonians website and badmouth the D200.
why?harnett county NC · May 18, 2006#48
Go mods!!!

Bring out that banning stick.
ZivCanada · May 18, 2006#49
Originally Posted by ricko
No worries "39", he's obviously some loser "Canadiens" fan, lost because he has no Leafs or Sens websites to pollute. It never pays to attempt to reason with an idiot. When he is finished here, he'll probably flit over to the Nikonians website and badmouth the D200.
Ouch. Take that!
MontrealerMontreal · May 18, 2006#50
Originally Posted by ricko
No worries "39", he's obviously some loser "Canadiens" fan, lost because he has no Leafs or Sens websites to pollute. It never pays to attempt to reason with an idiot. When he is finished here, he'll probably flit over to the Nikonians website and badmouth the D200.
Hey, I think the guy was trolling and deserved to be banned, but don't start painting all Montrealers/Habs fans with the same brush. You're just lowering yourself to his level.

Back to topic, I'm going Yaris for two reasons: I want the sedan, not a hatch, and I loved how incredibly dependable my Echo and my parents' Tercel have been. Plus, I like the look of the Yaris, while the Fit looks... mini-minivan is about right.